A Socio-Ecological Observatory for the Southern African Woodlands
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Geosciences
Abstract
* Context
The Earth's vegetation is changing in response to climate change, increased concentrations of CO2 in the atmosphere, and harvesting for fuel, food and building materials. These changes can accelerate or reduce climate change by altering the carbon cycle, and also affect the livelihoods of those who use natural resources in their day-to-day lives.
One of the most important ways to understand vegetation change and its impacts, is to make careful measurements of the same patches of vegetation ("plots") repeatedly. Networks of these plots have produced surprising findings, challenging theory and models of vegetation responses to climate change. E.g. in Latin America, a network of these plots has shown that tropical forests are not soaking up as much carbon as predicted.
Networks of these on-the-ground plot measurements are the only way to get a detailed view of how vegetation is currently changing. However at the moment, different researchers do not combine their data to understand regional patterns of change. This project will address this by bringing together researchers collecting plot data in southern African woodlands to share data and answer the big questions about what is happening to the vegetation in the region.
The southern African woodlands are the largest savanna in the world (3 million km2), and support the livelihoods of 160M people. Many of these people are poor and depend upon the woodlands for 25% of their income and to support their agriculture. Theory and models suggest that these woodlands will be sensitive to increased atmospheric CO2 and other environmental changes underway: this is because, unlike forests, woodlands maintain a balance in the competition between trees and grasses, allowing both types of plant to co-exist. Small changes that benefit trees (such as more CO2 in the atmosphere) might rapidly change woodlands into a tree-dominated system. This would mean that they store more carbon, but might reduce the diversity of plants on the ground. It is also possible that human use of these woodlands, particularly wood harvesting for fuel, is altering their diversity and reducing the "services" that they provide.
Currently we have no way to know if these changes are happening - satellite data and models can help, but need to be validated with plot measurements.
* Aims and objectives
Understanding the response of southern African woodlands to global change is the long-term goal of SEOSAW. It will do this by creating a regularly re-measured, systematic plot network. The stepping stones to this network are to:
1) develop an online data-sharing platform to exchange existing plot data so that we can look for signs of widespread change
2) combine NERC-funded data from 486 plots with data from 1,783 plots measured by others, to create a network that covers the whole region
3) use this new data set to better understand the processes that allow trees and grasses to co-exist, to allow modellers to make better predictions of future change
4) encourage researchers to make measurements in similar ways in the future, so that we can more easily detect changes
5) create a plan for future plot measurements that covers the whole region, and makes best use of the available time and money.
* Who will benefit?
SEOSAW will fill a large gap in the network of plots in tropical regions and benefit:
- modellers of the Earth's vegetation will be able to test their models against reality in one of the most difficult to model biomes
- scientists using satellite data to map vegetation will now be able to calibrate and validate their maps in all types of tropical vegetation
- Those modelling the carbon cycle, who need to know how much carbon is being taken up by the woodlands
Conservationists will also benefit, as SEOSAW will identify parts of the region that have unique or particularly diverse woodlands, helping to prioritise conservation efforts.
The Earth's vegetation is changing in response to climate change, increased concentrations of CO2 in the atmosphere, and harvesting for fuel, food and building materials. These changes can accelerate or reduce climate change by altering the carbon cycle, and also affect the livelihoods of those who use natural resources in their day-to-day lives.
One of the most important ways to understand vegetation change and its impacts, is to make careful measurements of the same patches of vegetation ("plots") repeatedly. Networks of these plots have produced surprising findings, challenging theory and models of vegetation responses to climate change. E.g. in Latin America, a network of these plots has shown that tropical forests are not soaking up as much carbon as predicted.
Networks of these on-the-ground plot measurements are the only way to get a detailed view of how vegetation is currently changing. However at the moment, different researchers do not combine their data to understand regional patterns of change. This project will address this by bringing together researchers collecting plot data in southern African woodlands to share data and answer the big questions about what is happening to the vegetation in the region.
The southern African woodlands are the largest savanna in the world (3 million km2), and support the livelihoods of 160M people. Many of these people are poor and depend upon the woodlands for 25% of their income and to support their agriculture. Theory and models suggest that these woodlands will be sensitive to increased atmospheric CO2 and other environmental changes underway: this is because, unlike forests, woodlands maintain a balance in the competition between trees and grasses, allowing both types of plant to co-exist. Small changes that benefit trees (such as more CO2 in the atmosphere) might rapidly change woodlands into a tree-dominated system. This would mean that they store more carbon, but might reduce the diversity of plants on the ground. It is also possible that human use of these woodlands, particularly wood harvesting for fuel, is altering their diversity and reducing the "services" that they provide.
Currently we have no way to know if these changes are happening - satellite data and models can help, but need to be validated with plot measurements.
* Aims and objectives
Understanding the response of southern African woodlands to global change is the long-term goal of SEOSAW. It will do this by creating a regularly re-measured, systematic plot network. The stepping stones to this network are to:
1) develop an online data-sharing platform to exchange existing plot data so that we can look for signs of widespread change
2) combine NERC-funded data from 486 plots with data from 1,783 plots measured by others, to create a network that covers the whole region
3) use this new data set to better understand the processes that allow trees and grasses to co-exist, to allow modellers to make better predictions of future change
4) encourage researchers to make measurements in similar ways in the future, so that we can more easily detect changes
5) create a plan for future plot measurements that covers the whole region, and makes best use of the available time and money.
* Who will benefit?
SEOSAW will fill a large gap in the network of plots in tropical regions and benefit:
- modellers of the Earth's vegetation will be able to test their models against reality in one of the most difficult to model biomes
- scientists using satellite data to map vegetation will now be able to calibrate and validate their maps in all types of tropical vegetation
- Those modelling the carbon cycle, who need to know how much carbon is being taken up by the woodlands
Conservationists will also benefit, as SEOSAW will identify parts of the region that have unique or particularly diverse woodlands, helping to prioritise conservation efforts.
Planned Impact
SEOSAW will have both economic and social benefits for the UK, for Africa, and for the global community. The medium term beneficiaries will include UK researchers and companies, the UK general public, African researchers and companies/individuals and African governments.
The grant will enhance UK leadership in the field of savanna carbon cycle science, ecosystem services and the human ecology of the tropics, assisting UK researchers and businesses in gaining income from research bodies (including EU and UN-linked funds), NGOs and private companies with interests in the region. We expect that, if our longer-term vision is successful, having the UK as a centre of savanna research could create 6-15 FTE jobs in the UK in 5-10 years, based in both Universities and SMEs (our previous work has led to new jobs in our partner SMEs, Ecometrica, Bioclimate Research and Development, and LTSi).
Scientists and researchers based in Universities, government forestry departments, NGOs and private consultancies in Africa will benefit from the increased activity and coordination of measurements in their woodlands. A combination of training, high-level publications, and exposure to top-level researchers from the UK, South Africa, the USA and elsewhere, will result in greater capacity to win funding and ecosystem monitoring contracts from government, NGOs and private companies. The impacts here could be long-lasting and multiplicative: we estimate the project will work with between 150 and 200 African researchers and field technicians, many of whom will pass on benefits to wider groups and future students throughout their future careers. There is probably the need for 20-30 FTE field scientists/technicians specialising in monitoring social and ecosystem factors in these countries by 2020, with actual numbers far lower than this currently: our project will help develop those already working in this field, and train new staff to fill these roles.
The research could have a wider long-term impact in Africa and globally. As the link between woodland resources and the global carbon cycle, and even local service provision, is currently under-researched, it is largely ignored in global climate discussions, and the value of the woodlands is often undersold locally. By enabling better quantification we believe resources for protection could flow from international bodies, and better enforcement and development of environmental protection laws and incentives could develop within African countries. This could lead to large social and economic benefits for the hundreds of millions of people living in these systems, in terms of greater food production, flood protection, rainfall generation and environmental stability, as well as producing global benefits in terms of climate stabilisation.
Finally, while the UK population is aware of the charismatic large mammals that inhabit these systems, they have little awareness of the extent or rate of change of savanna woodlands. The exciting science that will result from this network will be publicised, and will lead to an increased awareness of this large and interesting ecosystem in the UK. This will improve knowledge and understanding of environmental issues and science in the UK, with potential positive social and economic impacts as more people make positive environmental choices when buying goods and services, and potentially causing more children to consider taking STEM subjects.
The grant will enhance UK leadership in the field of savanna carbon cycle science, ecosystem services and the human ecology of the tropics, assisting UK researchers and businesses in gaining income from research bodies (including EU and UN-linked funds), NGOs and private companies with interests in the region. We expect that, if our longer-term vision is successful, having the UK as a centre of savanna research could create 6-15 FTE jobs in the UK in 5-10 years, based in both Universities and SMEs (our previous work has led to new jobs in our partner SMEs, Ecometrica, Bioclimate Research and Development, and LTSi).
Scientists and researchers based in Universities, government forestry departments, NGOs and private consultancies in Africa will benefit from the increased activity and coordination of measurements in their woodlands. A combination of training, high-level publications, and exposure to top-level researchers from the UK, South Africa, the USA and elsewhere, will result in greater capacity to win funding and ecosystem monitoring contracts from government, NGOs and private companies. The impacts here could be long-lasting and multiplicative: we estimate the project will work with between 150 and 200 African researchers and field technicians, many of whom will pass on benefits to wider groups and future students throughout their future careers. There is probably the need for 20-30 FTE field scientists/technicians specialising in monitoring social and ecosystem factors in these countries by 2020, with actual numbers far lower than this currently: our project will help develop those already working in this field, and train new staff to fill these roles.
The research could have a wider long-term impact in Africa and globally. As the link between woodland resources and the global carbon cycle, and even local service provision, is currently under-researched, it is largely ignored in global climate discussions, and the value of the woodlands is often undersold locally. By enabling better quantification we believe resources for protection could flow from international bodies, and better enforcement and development of environmental protection laws and incentives could develop within African countries. This could lead to large social and economic benefits for the hundreds of millions of people living in these systems, in terms of greater food production, flood protection, rainfall generation and environmental stability, as well as producing global benefits in terms of climate stabilisation.
Finally, while the UK population is aware of the charismatic large mammals that inhabit these systems, they have little awareness of the extent or rate of change of savanna woodlands. The exciting science that will result from this network will be publicised, and will lead to an increased awareness of this large and interesting ecosystem in the UK. This will improve knowledge and understanding of environmental issues and science in the UK, with potential positive social and economic impacts as more people make positive environmental choices when buying goods and services, and potentially causing more children to consider taking STEM subjects.
Organisations
- University of Edinburgh (Lead Research Organisation)
- Free University of Brussels (ULB) (Project Partner)
- South African Env Obs Network (SAEON) (Project Partner)
- University of Cape Town (Project Partner)
- Lubango Herbium (Project Partner)
- Copperbelt University (Project Partner)
- University of Missouri - Columbia (Project Partner)
- The Miombo Network (Project Partner)
- U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) (Project Partner)
- University of Zimbabwe (Project Partner)
- Centre for Int Forestry Research (CIFOR) (Project Partner)
- Lilongwe Uni of Agri and Nat Resources (Project Partner)
- Brown University (Project Partner)
- Makeni Savannah Research Project (Project Partner)
- University of the Witwatersrand (Project Partner)
- Eduardo Mondlane University (Project Partner)
- Yale University (Project Partner)
- Stellenbosch University (Project Partner)
- University of Hamburg (Project Partner)
Publications
McNicol IM
(2018)
Carbon losses from deforestation and widespread degradation offset by extensive growth in African woodlands.
in Nature communications
Nieto-Quintano P
(2018)
The mesic savannas of the Bateke Plateau: carbon stocks and floristic composition
in Biotropica
Fayolle A
(2018)
A sharp floristic discontinuity revealed by the biogeographic regionalization of African savannas
in Journal of Biogeography
Loubota Panzou G
(2020)
Pantropical variability in tree crown allometry
in Global Ecology and Biogeography
Godlee J
(2020)
Diversity and Structure of an Arid Woodland in Southwest Angola, with Comparison to the Wider Miombo Ecoregion
in Diversity
Aleman JC
(2020)
Floristic evidence for alternative biome states in tropical Africa.
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Pellegrini A
(2020)
Decadal changes in fire frequencies shift tree communities and functional traits
Ahrends A
(2021)
Detecting and predicting forest degradation: A comparison of ground surveys and remote sensing in Tanzanian forests
in PLANTS, PEOPLE, PLANET
Amy C. Bennett
(2021)
Resistance of African tropical forests to an extreme climate anomaly
Bennett AC
(2021)
Resistance of African tropical forests to an extreme climate anomaly.
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Godlee J
(2021)
Structural diversity and tree density drives variation in the biodiversity-ecosystem function relationship of woodlands and savannas
in New Phytologist
Cuni-Sanchez A
(2021)
High aboveground carbon stock of African tropical montane forests.
in Nature
Amy C. Bennett
(2021)
Resistance of African tropical forests to an extreme climate anomaly
Wood E
(2022)
Intentions behind common and risky fires in south-eastern Tanzania
in African Journal of Range & Forage Science
Meyfroidt P
(2022)
Ten facts about land systems for sustainability
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Rozendaal D
(2022)
Aboveground forest biomass varies across continents, ecological zones and successional stages: refined IPCC default values for tropical and subtropical forests
in Environmental Research Letters
Bennett A
(2023)
Sensitivity of South American tropical forests to an extreme climate anomaly
in Nature Climate Change
Davies R
(2023)
Precipitation gradients drive high tree species turnover in the woodlands of eastern and southern Africa
in Ecography
Amy C. Bennett
(2023)
Sensitivity of South American tropical forests to an extreme climate anomaly
Mogonong B
(2023)
Vegetation description around the savanna flux measurement site at Benfontein Nature Reserve, South Africa
in South African Journal of Botany
Rees M
(2023)
Testing White's Floristic Impoverishment Hypothesis in the Forest-Savanna Transition Zones of Africa
in Diversity
Amy C. Bennett
(2023)
Sensitivity of South American tropical forests to an extreme climate anomaly
Gotore T
(2023)
Woody biomass increases across three contrasting land uses in Hurungwe, mid-Zambezi valley, Zimbabwe
in Southern Forests: a Journal of Forest Science
McNicol IM
(2023)
Protected areas reduce deforestation and degradation and enhance woody growth across African woodlands.
in Communications earth & environment
| Description | - we have developed a set of protocols for measuring the structure of African Woodlands. These cover trees, grass, soil and plant traits, as well as a standardised format for describing the socio-ecological context of the measurements - we have synthesised a large data set of tree measurements from across Southern Africa |
| Exploitation Route | others are able to use the protocols to inform their work, and the associated data management tools |
| Sectors | Environment |
| URL | https://seosaw.github.io |
| Description | the methodological guidance that has been developed as part of SEOSAW has been contributed to the Mozambican government's task force on forest monitoring and is in use by the Zimbabwean Forestry Comission |
| First Year Of Impact | 2017 |
| Sector | Environment |
| Impact Types | Policy & public services |
| Description | A data science community of practice to support locally-led management of African natural resources (DataNRM) |
| Geographic Reach | Africa |
| Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
| Impact | DataNRM aimed to enhance capabilities in emerging frontiers of data science linked to locally-led natural resource management (NRM). This has led to new data science methods being embedded into ongoing research and teaching across the continent, with the longer term aim of supporting improved governance and management of natural resources. The inclusion of participants from national government departments has also facilitated skills and knowledge transfer within these realms. |
| Description | Field-based training in understorey protocols - Tanzanian workshop |
| Geographic Reach | Africa |
| Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
| Impact | The researchers from African universities and governmental institutions had understood the overlooked importance of the understorey, both in terms of it's contribution to biodiversity and to carbon dynamics. The groundlayer contains a far larger proportion of species diversity and carbon in arid systems. Furthermore, quantifying grass composition and biomass will aid in quantifying fire dynamics and subsequent GHG emissions. The participants with their newly-acquired skills will be able to share these within their institutions and communities of practice. |
| Description | GEOTrees Participation |
| Geographic Reach | Multiple continents/international |
| Policy Influence Type | Participation in a guidance/advisory committee |
| Impact | Through their successful promotion of the importance of the dry tropics to global carbon dynamics, Kyle Dexter and John Godlee have been key to GEOTrees consideration of long-term monitoring plots in Africa and South America. New monitoring plots were placed in Angola with further discussions on future sites in Tanzania. This improves the quality and representivity of global carbon monitoring. |
| Description | Improving Zimbabwe's National GHG emissions reporting |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
| Impact | David Milodowski engaged with the Zimbabwe Forestry Commission to explore modelling tools that ZFC could use to input the existing data they collect in the field into practicable reporting formats for national IPCC requirements. These discussions will form the basis for the tool development and roll-out at a subsequent workshop planned Q1 2026 which will improve Zimbabwe's reporting from Tier 1 to Tier 2, or possibly even Tier 3. |
| Description | SEOSAW-KEFRI Workshop: Monitoring carbon in the woodlands |
| Geographic Reach | Africa |
| Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
| Impact | This workshop brought together national (Kenyan) and international stakeholders in monitoring carbon in Africa. The aim was to share experiences and lessons learned in the carbon sector, with a focus on local and national needs and challenges. Representatives from other countries in Africa were present to exchange knowledge. We explored themes on measuring, monitoring and reporting carbon and the links between biodiversity-livelihoods-climate change with carbon monitoring. The engagement at the workshop challenged existing views on competing objectives for biodiversity-livelihoods-climate change-carbon and evoked constructive discussion about mitigating the trade-offs to maximise environmental and societal benefit. The workshop also served as a (rare) networking event between experts and practitioners within silo-ed institutions in Kenya as well as across national boundaries in Africa. |
| Description | Zimbabwe Forestry Commission Data Analysis Workshop |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
| Impact | This workshop developed the capacity of the Zimbabwe Forestry Commission to accurate collect, process and analyse the data from their forest inventories to meet national reporting requirements (e.g. UNFCCC, IPCC). Showcasing the data analysis results to the departental director also strengthened the importance of the work our ZFC colleagues are undertaking. |
| Description | NERC-FAPESP PhenoChange: Towards a Dry Tropics Global Phenological Monitoring Network |
| Amount | £83,554 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | NE/X002993/1 |
| Organisation | Natural Environment Research Council |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 11/2022 |
| End | 10/2024 |
| Description | Pathways of resilience and evasion of tipping in ecosystems |
| Amount | € 10,000,000 (EUR) |
| Organisation | European Research Council (ERC) |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | Belgium |
| Start | 08/2024 |
| End | 09/2029 |
| Description | Resolving the drivers of restoration effectiveness and leakage in wooded savannas |
| Amount | £845,456 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | NE/Z50404X/1 |
| Organisation | Natural Environment Research Council |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 02/2025 |
| End | 02/2029 |
| Description | SECO: Resolving the current and future carbon dynamics of the dry tropics |
| Amount | £2,130,387 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | NE/T01279X/1 |
| Organisation | Natural Environment Research Council |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 04/2021 |
| End | 10/2026 |
| Description | Tree2Globe |
| Amount | € 2,500,000 (EUR) |
| Organisation | European Research Council (ERC) |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | Belgium |
| Start | 09/2024 |
| End | 10/2029 |
| Title | Methods and protocols for plot data collection in southern African woodlands |
| Description | We have developed a set of linked protocols that will allow for data collected across the region to be compared, whilst retaining flexibility to suit the many different objectives of researchers in the region. The following protocols are iavailable: Plot design and tree measurements, including deadwood and saplings. Understory plants Soil Trees traits Seedling traits All the protocols are 'living documents', and we welcome input and suggestions from all. |
| Type Of Material | Improvements to research infrastructure |
| Year Produced | 2018 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | The protocols will help standardise data collection and improve regional compataibility of data sets. They have already been used in Angola, and by the Zimbabwean Forestry Commission. |
| URL | https://seosaw.github.io/manuals.html |
| Description | A data science community of practice to support locally-led management of African natural resources (DataNRM) |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | DataNRM aimed to enhance capabilities in emerging frontiers of data science linked to locally-led natural resource management (NRM). The format was a 6 month series of workshops and practice-based learning co-led by African and Global North practitioners will develop new knowledge and "train-the-trainers" at 15 African institutions. This has led to new data science methods being embedded into ongoing research and teaching across the continent, with the longer term aim of supporting improved governance and management of natural resources. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| Description | Field-based training in understorey protocols - Tanzanian workshop |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | The workshop had the following intentions: - Train early career African scientists and foresters in the collection of groundlayer (grasses and other non-woody herbaceous vegetation) data to help fill the critical need for groundlayer data in the region - Network early career African scientists and foresters across national, disciplinary and institutional boundaries - Field test the GGG groundlayer composition and functional attributes protocol in an African woodland system (previously tested in South America and Madagascar) - Field test the SEOSAW herbaceous biomass protocol (in conjunction with the GGG protocol) - Develop a prototype shrub protocol - Field test the integration between the suite of SEOSAW sampling protocols: plot design and tree stem measurements, coarse woody debris methods, small stem (regenerating stems) measurements, shrub measurements, herbaceous biomass measurements, plant functional traits measurements, soil sampling methods, and social-ecological surveys. - Collect groundlayer data with the aim of engaging an early career researcher to lead a publication and contribute to the GGG database - Increase the collaboration between SEOSAW, TAFORI and the GGG - Engage interest in SEOSAW and groundlayer data with graduate students at Sokoine University of Agriculture |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| Description | Improving Zimbabwe's National GHG emissions reporting |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | A SECO Post-doctoral Researcher (David Milodowski) presented the ways his carbon modelling framework could improve Zimbabwe's National GHG reporting to the IPCC. He engaged with the Zimbabwe Forestry Commission to explore tools that ZFC could use to input the existing data they collect in the field into practicable reporting formats. These discussions will form the basis for the tool development and roll-out at a subsequent workshop planned Q1 2026. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2025 |
| Description | SEOSAW-KEFRI Workshop: Monitoring carbon in the woodlands |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | This workshop brought together national (Kenyan) and international stakeholders in monitoring carbon in Africa. The aim was to share experiences and lessons learned in the carbon sector, with a focus on local and national needs and challenges. Representatives from other countries in Africa were present to exchange knowledge. We explored themes on measuring, monitoring and reporting carbon and the links between biodiversity-livelihoods-climate change with carbon monitoring. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
