Next-Generation Modelling of Glacial Isostatic Adjustment
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Cambridge
Department Name: Earth Sciences
Abstract
Modern-day changes to sea level can be measured using either tide-gauges or with satellite altimetry, and these observations provide vital quantitative information about the effects of anthropogenic climate change. Similarly, satellite-based measurements of the Earth's gravitational field are used to monitor mass-loss from the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets. Such modern-day measurements cannot, however, be straightforwardly interpreted in terms of modern-day processes due to significant contributions from glacial isostatic adjustment (GIA); this being the on-going deformation of the solid Earth and concomitant sea level change caused by the last deglaciation. It is, therefore, necessary to model and correct for GIA within modern-day observations. Similarly, GIA contributions are also required when determining sea level projections, and hence for assessing and mitigating the risk of specific coastal locations to future sea level rise. At present, errors within GIA corrections constitute a significant, but poorly quantified, source of uncertainty within these various applications. Indeed, the magnitude of GIA corrections can sometimes be as large as the modern-day signals of interest, while the same can be true of the uncertainties on these corrections.
The process by which GIA corrections are obtained involves solution of the so-called GIA inverse problem. An essential step in solving this latter problem is the numerical simulation of GIA using (i) an assumed earth model and (ii) a model of ice sheet evolution back to the last glacial period. To date, most such studies have been based on the assumption that Earth structure (and in particular, mantle viscosity) varies only with depth. Given this assumption, the computational cost of simulating GIA is low, and this allows for simple methods to be applied in solving the inverse problem predicated on the ability to run very many simulations with different input parameters. Substantial 3D variations of viscosity within the Earth's mantle certainly do exist, however, though their specific form remains poorly known. Within the past 20 years or so, a range of studies have shown that such viscosity variations can have a significant effect on GIA. The cost of simulating GIA in 3D earth models is, however, dramatically increased over earlier 1D calculations, and this has rendered useless older methods for solving the inverse problem.
Within the foreseeable future, the only computationally viable approach to the GIA inverse problem that can take account of 3D viscosity variations is to apply gradient-based optimisation (GBO). This approach is widely used in other fields, including weather forecasting, oceanography, and seismic tomography. A key technical aspect of this approach is the application of the so-called adjoint method for calculating the derivatives required to iteratively update the model so as to better fit the data. Recently, the first application of GBO to the GIA inverse problem has been undertaken, and the initial results show great promise. This research has, however, made clear that future large-scale applications of this method are being held back by the computational tools available. The aim of this proposal is, therefore, the development of new and highly efficient numerical methods to facilitate the application of GBO to the GIA inverse problem. Such focused methodological work is necessary to enable future practical studies aimed at increasing the accuracy of GIA corrections, and hence improving our ability to monitor and understand the Earth's changing climate.
The process by which GIA corrections are obtained involves solution of the so-called GIA inverse problem. An essential step in solving this latter problem is the numerical simulation of GIA using (i) an assumed earth model and (ii) a model of ice sheet evolution back to the last glacial period. To date, most such studies have been based on the assumption that Earth structure (and in particular, mantle viscosity) varies only with depth. Given this assumption, the computational cost of simulating GIA is low, and this allows for simple methods to be applied in solving the inverse problem predicated on the ability to run very many simulations with different input parameters. Substantial 3D variations of viscosity within the Earth's mantle certainly do exist, however, though their specific form remains poorly known. Within the past 20 years or so, a range of studies have shown that such viscosity variations can have a significant effect on GIA. The cost of simulating GIA in 3D earth models is, however, dramatically increased over earlier 1D calculations, and this has rendered useless older methods for solving the inverse problem.
Within the foreseeable future, the only computationally viable approach to the GIA inverse problem that can take account of 3D viscosity variations is to apply gradient-based optimisation (GBO). This approach is widely used in other fields, including weather forecasting, oceanography, and seismic tomography. A key technical aspect of this approach is the application of the so-called adjoint method for calculating the derivatives required to iteratively update the model so as to better fit the data. Recently, the first application of GBO to the GIA inverse problem has been undertaken, and the initial results show great promise. This research has, however, made clear that future large-scale applications of this method are being held back by the computational tools available. The aim of this proposal is, therefore, the development of new and highly efficient numerical methods to facilitate the application of GBO to the GIA inverse problem. Such focused methodological work is necessary to enable future practical studies aimed at increasing the accuracy of GIA corrections, and hence improving our ability to monitor and understand the Earth's changing climate.
Publications
Yu Ziheng
(2024)
Application of first- and second-order adjoint methods to glacial isostatic adjustment incorporating rotational feedbacks
in GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL
Maitra M
(2024)
On the elastodynamics of rotating planets
in Geophysical Journal International
Al-Attar D
(2024)
Reciprocity and sensitivity kernels for sea level fingerprints
in Geophysical Journal International
| Description | Work with Mitrovica Group |
| Organisation | Harvard University |
| Department | Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences |
| Country | United States |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Linked to this grant, work has been ongoing with the group of Jerry Mitrovica in Harvard, USA. This group has been making direct use of the adjoint GIA methods and codes developed as part of the current grant. This includes the publication of a paper (Kim et al, 2022, JGR) this year on the dependence of GIA induced changes to the Earth's rotation rate to mantle viscosity. Prior studies had only consider the effect of 1D variations in viscosity, but we have shown the full 3D sensitivity. In this manner, what this datum can and cannot constrain has been clarified. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Prof Mitrovica's group have been primarly involved in terms of suggesting applications for the methods developed. Prof Mitrovica himself has been working closely with me on the devlopment of the adjoint theory within a rotation Earth model, and also in forming plans for future work. |
| Impact | Kim, A.J., Crawford, O., Al-Attar, D., Lau, H.C.P., Mitrovica, J.X. and Latychev, K., 2022. Ice age effects on the satellite-derived J? 2 datum: Mapping the sensitivity to 3D variations in mantle viscosity. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 581, p.117372. Al-Attar, D., Syvret, F., Crawford, O., Mitrovica, J.X. and Lloyd, A.J., 2024. Reciprocity and sensitivity kernels for sea level fingerprints. Geophysical Journal International, 236(1), pp.362-378. |
| Start Year | 2014 |
| Title | GSHTrans |
| Description | A C++ template library for fast generalised spherical harmonic transformations. |
| Type Of Technology | Software |
| Year Produced | 2023 |
| Open Source License? | Yes |
| Impact | This library provides tools for fast generalised spherical harmonic transformation along with related methods for fields defined in spherical geometries. This method is needed for a range of geophysical applications including in GIA modelling. |
| URL | https://github.com/da380/GSHTrans/tree/main |
| Title | pygeoinf |
| Description | A python library for the solution of inverse and inference problems in a function space setting. Currently, the focus has been on linarised of linear problems, but the development will later shift to non-linear problems such as the GIA inverse problem. |
| Type Of Technology | Software |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Open Source License? | Yes |
| Impact | This library provides a set of tools for formulating and solving the common aspects of inverse problems in a function-space setting. The user has, through class inhertience, to define their model space and forward operator (along with an adjoint implementation), but then the rest of the problem is handled internally. |
| URL | https://github.com/da380/pygeoinf |
| Title | pyslfp |
| Description | Python library for the solution of the sea level equation and its adjoint in an elastic Earth model. |
| Type Of Technology | Software |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Open Source License? | Yes |
| Impact | This library provides to the wider community a tool for efficiently computing sea level fingerprints in elastic Earth models and, crucially, sensitivity kernels for this problem via the adjoint method. These codes can be used within the solution of inverse problems linked to modern sea level. |
| URL | https://github.com/da380/pyslfp |
