Soldiers and soldiering in Britain, c.1750 to 1815

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: School of History

Abstract

Britain's relationship with its soldiers during the eighteenth century was a complex one. Georgians branded these men a danger to liberty, victims of oppression, and 'bloody backs', whilst also celebrating their victories and championing their generals, such as General Wolfe at Quebec in 1759. Britain's soldiers were both heroes and the 'scum of the earth', yet this dynamic and multifaceted connection has yet to be fully explored, largely because the scale of Britain's military mobilisation has not been recognised, nor its significance fully appreciated. This fraught relationship became more complicated with the increasing mobilisation of the male population into novel forms of military service beyond the full-time soldiering of the British Army. The militia, reformed during the Seven Years' War in 1757, and large-scale volunteer forces (part-time soldiers raised for home defence) in the American War of Independence and especially the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars created new types of soldier in Britain and new ways for men to be under arms. At its peak in the Napoleonic Wars, some 680,000 men were involved in some form of military service, yet the experiences of these men remains largely forgotten.

To better understand the concept of soldiering and explore the similarities and differences between the different forms of military service in Britain, this project will explore the language, broadly defined, in which the soldier was described by others and written about by themselves, thus contextualising shifts in attitudes towards soldiers and soldiering. Working from the premise that a 'soldier' was a particular category within society that was defined by contemporaries and by soldiers themselves, and therefore relational and contextual rather than being fixed, the project will be able to utilise methodological techniques more commonly seen in the social sciences and gender history when studying identity to create new knowledge on the topic. The project will involve extensive archival research and will form a network of scholars working in this period to cover the many different geographical, methodological and temporal angles to the topic. These will include regional differences, questions of citizenship and manliness, and the changes wrought by the almost permanent state of war against France between 1754 and 1815.

Alongside academic outputs, the project aims to make key documents available in an online repository for anyone interested in the subject of soldiers in this period. The aim is to distribute the findings of the project beyond academia, to users such as schools, local historians, military enthusiasts, and genealogists. A fundamental part of the project will be an interactive website allowing these interest groups not only to view what the network is doing, but to contribute their questions, expertise and knowledge. This will further assist us in our goal of promoting a better understanding of this crucial period in the making of the concept of 'soldiering' in Britain. Furthermore, these outputs will be well timed for the forthcoming 200th anniversary of the Battle of Waterloo.


Planned Impact

The impact of the grant will be based around three areas:

Education
The research will underpin elements of the PI's MA teaching on 'Defending a Nation: Britain at War, 1793-1815' (which is available to students on the MAs in Modern History, Military History and Eighteenth-Century Studies) and primary source material from the project held in the publicly accessible Leeds University Digital Object Service will be integrated into the teaching of this module. Furthermore, the PI aims to develop a new 'learning unit' for the undergraduate HIST2520 Sources and Approaches to British History course. Both will be developed during the project, as part of the network / KT activity allocated time. Similarly, the CI will bring the project findings and source materials to bear upon his final year module 'Citizenship and Gender in Britain' and his MA module 'Men of Arms: Masculinity and War in Britain, 1750-1918'. Beyond Higher Education, the project will work with the British Militia and Volunteer Study Group of the Napoleonic Association and one of the aims of this collaboration is to develop educational materials for schools, museums, and archives about mass mobilisation during this period. As such, the project will provide new educational material at a variety of levels in an area that is not currently well covered, and which promises to be an innovative and stimulating angle on local history. In this regard, the School of History's links with the Royal Armouries at Leeds should provide a suitable pathway for the dissemination of this material.

Dissemination of Expertise
The website will be a fundamental element of the project and will provide useful information for a wider audience about the topic. In particular, brief summaries of the militia and volunteers will provide contextual information to those who have come across records relating to soldiers in this period but would like to know more about what these documents tell them, for example amateur historians, people looking into their family history, or archivists. This is particularly the case for genealogists as soldier records and militia lists often form key components in their investigations. The interactive elements of the website will also permit them to become engaged with the project: the PI / project group will be able to respond to their questions or observations, with the further benefit that these discussions will be readable by other users. To ensure maximum benefit under this heading, the project will be actively promoted by the PI via web links at other relevant webpages.

Knowledge Exchange
As the website goes beyond a didactic model of knowledge transfer and will aim to embrace existing communities of interest, both online / virtual and real, the project has a significant opportunity for knowledge exchange. Crucially, the work of the PI in publicising the project to relevant groups and individuals beyond academia presents significant areas where the project can work with others, including: providing local knowledge of significant archives / repositories which are currently not well catalogued; local / amateur historians submitting material for the project, thus broadening the range of material available to the PI / CI in the timescale available; and bringing together others working in the field, both from academia and outside it.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Annette Jäckle (Author) (2012) Defining Soldiers workshop notes

publication icon
Linch K (2013) Defining Soldiers: Britain's Military, c .1740-1815 in War in History

publication icon
Orla Muldoon (Author) (2011) The Language of Soldiering

 
Description In focusing on Britain's experience of warfare, this project has demonstrated that historians' conventional definition of 'the soldier' is too simplistic. Soldiering in the period 1750-1815 was often part-time or a phase (or phases) in an individual's life. Furthermore, soldiering should also be considered as an identity and a model of conduct, which were to a large extent moulded by soldiers themselves as lived experiences. These identities and behavioural codes, in turn, had complex relationships with their civil counterparts: ideals such as gentility and politeness - quintessentially 'civil' models of masculinity - had important, and subtly different, roles to play in the military sphere.



As such, this project has demonstrated the value of an interdisciplinary approach to the history of war. The wide range of academic subjects represented within our online network, our workshops and our international conference allowed for stimulating cross-disciplinary discussion. As we demonstrate in our forthcoming methodological article in the journal War in History, military history can only benefit from this engagement. This article proposes that historians of the Georgian soldier can usefully engage with two agendas: greater use of the methodologies of social and cultural history to understand combat and the soldier's world; and a renewed concentration upon the place of soldiers within society and culture. This contrasts with the 'war and society' approach which, we argue, often focuses upon wartime civil society rather than soldiers themselves. We have endeavoured to put this ethos into practice in our collection of essays, Britain's Soldiers: Rethinking War and Society 1715-1815, which is forthcoming with Liverpool University Press.



Additionally, the project has demonstrated the possibilities of public engagement for an academic research project. As well as using 'conventional' media to reach other academics and research students - such as conferences, workshops and refereed publications - we have made extensive use of social networking, online resources, blogging and other media. Our Ning network http://redcoats.ning.com has demonstrated how a simple and inexpensive site from a commercial provider can develop into a participatory networking tool, and other projects have since modelled their websites on ours. Given the popularity of military history beyond academia, the subdiscipline is well placed to engage wider audiences: over half of the active members on our website describe themselves as non-academic, and the conference attendees included archivists, military re-enactors and independent scholars.
Exploitation Route As we describe above, the 'Britain's Soldiers' project has already been very successful at engaging non-academic audiences. The project therefore offers a model for how academics can engage people beyond academia.



Our work on historicising 'the soldier' is potentially relevant to contemporary policy, at a time when Britain is once more engaged in controversial overseas conflicts. Soldiers currently have a high profile in the media, which recently has been more prepared to employ the language of heroism, sacrifice and national pride than it has done for many years. Much of this has focused on wounded service personnel, focusing on charitable aid and often criticising state provision - concerns that would have been very familiar to a Georgian audience. Our work on the complex relationship between soldiers and British society, and on the challenges of reintegrating former soldiers back into it, have parallels with the contemporary situation.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy

URL http://redcoats.ning.com
 
Description The principal impact of the project was to bring together a wide community of those interested in the subject of Britain's soldiers in the Eighteenth Century through the project website, a conference, more immediate publication of knowledge, and communication through social media. The project brought together academics, current students, and those interested in the period and fostered an effective community of interest where knowledge and ideas could be exchanged. There were over 3,000 unique visits to the site (up to 3 January 2012), and visitors made significant use of the content, spending an average of 3 minutes on the site and viewing 4 pages each visit. 154 people registered to use the interactive tools on the site (a discussion forum, questions and answers, and a profile page), of which 47% were not academics or students and 46% were international. The project included a digital repository of primary source material, from which users had downloaded items 100 times. The website was designed to encourage engagement in preparation for the conference, which resulted in being attended by 39 people, with a mixture of academics, students, and non-academics. The different elements of the project were knitted together through the use of social media, such as twitter to advertise the publication of new resources or blog for more in-depth discussions, as well as the discussion generated by the community itself. Overall, participants rated the project very highly (3.7 out of 5, 5 = very useful). The networking features of the project, such as the online discussion forum and the conference, were particularly appreciated and successful. One comment from a retired museum curator, currently publishing in military history, sums up the experience of many of those involved: '[the project] brings together not only academic staff, but also independent researchers and 'amateurs' (in the best sense of the word) in a very fruitful exchange, both on the website and at the conference. A particular feature is that it gives confidence to non-academics to present their research, which is often of a high standard but is not necessarily normally given a forum in a university context.' Furthermore, the project had a significant impact on current students, who gave the project the highest ratings (4.6 / 5) and they especially welcomed access to other experts in the field, both academics and non-academics. The impact of the project will continue in the future too, as the project website and its resources have been secured for the future and new resources continued to be added to the site.
First Year Of Impact 2011
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description 33rd Regiment of Foot Reenactment Society 
Organisation His Majesty's 33rd Regiment of Foot
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Knowledge exchange - the society was present at the 'Britain's Soldiers' conference in July 2011. Their involvement was a process of exchanging knowledge and expertise between academics and re-enactors, through their presence at conference papers and the displays that they put on.
Start Year 2011
 
Description Castle Museum York 
Organisation York Castle Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Knowledge exchange - advice about militia / volunteers units for a potential event.
Start Year 2010
 
Description Hampshire Record Office 
Organisation Hampshire Record Office
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Knowledge exchange - discussion and promotion of material selected to be digitised in LUDOS relating to the project.
Start Year 2010
 
Description LUDOS digital archive service 
Organisation University of Leeds
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Technical advice on setting up the digital repository for the project.
Start Year 2009
 
Description Publishing records from East Sussex Record Office 
Organisation East Sussex Record Office
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Knowledge exchange - discussion and promotion of material selected to be digitised in LUDOS relating to the project.
Start Year 2011
 
Description Guest blog: Uncovering the Georgian Army 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Guest blog at Ancestry.co.uk based on a letter from a soldier discovered in Hampshire Record Office. The blog discusses how the letter challenges the view of Britain's soldiers in the period as 'scum of the earth', and also highlights resources available in local archives for the study of this period.

Although the end date has been set to the same day as it was article was released, the blog is still available on ancestry.co.uk's website.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Making New Soldiers: Britain's Military Culture 1740-1815 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A paper given at Leeds University Eighteenth Century Group seminar.

The paper was based on the forthcoming chapter in 'Britain's Soldiers: Rethinking War and Society 1715-1815'. The paper discussed the key research findings of my work, and offered a new way of thinking about the activities and status of Britain's soldiers
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description News article: Uncovering the Georgian army 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Article for the University Reporter magazine about the project.

This article led to an inquiry from the Yorkshire Post and a subsequent article in that publication.



The end date has been set to the same day that the articel was published, although it is still available on the University website.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
 
Description Research peers into minds of soldiers who fought Napoleon 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Article published in the Yorkshire Post about the project.

The article led to an enquiry from a member of the public about the project, including some details of a ancestor they had traced to the period.



The end date has been set to the day the article was published, however the article is still available on t
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
 
Description The soldier's body 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A blog post at the University of Northampton's 'Experts at Northampton' blog. http://blogs.northampton.ac.uk/expertsatnorthampton/category/war/

The 'Experts at Northampton' blog is hosted by the university's press office, and seeks to disseminate expert opinion from the university on topical issues.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
URL http://blogs.northampton.ac.uk/expertsatnorthampton/category/war/
 
Description Uncovering the experience of the soldiers who fought Napoleon 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Article describing the project in the University of Leeds' 2012 undergraduate prospectus.

The end date has been set to the end of the 2012 recruitment cycle, although the article may still be in circulation after that date.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011