Lyric Responses to the Crusades in Medieval France and Occitania

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: French Studies

Abstract

The crusades have left a profound and disturbing legacy in inter-cultural and inter-faith relations nationally and world-wide. They continue to be of compelling interest and relevance to students, scholars and the wider public, with crusading rhetoric alive in the global political discourse transmitted daily in the media. Ecclesiastical sources, written in Latin, provide official versions of the preaching, organisation and events of the medieval crusading movement, whereas vernacular literature offers an invaluable secular perspective, whether supporting the Church's agenda, replacing it with its own, or challenging it through ridicule or revolt. The lyric poet-musicians of medieval France, troubadours and trouvères, composing in Occitan and Old French (OF) respectively, present a rich diversity of immediate responses on the part of a secular public, in France, Occitania, Italy, the Iberian Peninsula, Syria and Greece. All this material will be made freely available online in high-quality editions, with translations into both English and Italian, along with professional readings and musical performances. An accompanying monograph, linked to the online texts, will place them in their historical and cultural context. A book publication in Italian is also anticipated, containing a new critical edition of the Old French texts.
The research will explore how these vernacular poet-musicians responded to medieval crusading movements. It will examine the extent to which their responses can enlighten us about the views of their public and contribute to, complement, differ or dissent from the Church's crusading propaganda, both in their concepts of crusade and crusading and in their rhetoric. It will identify the distinct attitudes towards the crusades that emerge from these sources, ways in which their responses vary geographically and chronologically, and the relationship, tense or otherwise, between crusading and secular ideals. It is anticipated that fresh information and insights will emerge from new critical editions of texts hitherto only available in out-of-date or defective editions, from the study of ways in which texts engage in dialogue with each other, and from research into historical circumstances alluded to in the texts, or discoverable from other vernacular or Latin sources and features of the manuscripts in which they have been transmitted. The monograph will provide the first comprehensive, modern analysis of OF and Occitan lyric texts relating to the crusades based on high-quality editions and up-to-date philological tools and historical information.
All outputs will be of a high scholarly standard and will be of interest to scholars and students of medieval history, literature and culture in the English- and Italian-reading world. The monograph with its links to the online collection of texts, translations and performances, will be relevant to teachers of history, music, and medieval culture in higher education institutions and perhaps schools, the online editions supplying a need for affordable (in this case free) access to high-quality, up-to-date editions with reliable translations. The Italian collection of Old French lyrics in book form will fill a gap in the teaching market there, though it may be too costly for the British one. The monograph and online publications will also be intended for the general reader, such as that of Paterson's 'The World of the Troubadours: Medieval Occitan Society c. 1100 - c. 1300', CUP, 1993, diffused in the UK and world-wide in English, with several paperback reprints and translations into Spanish, French, and Italian.
The research will impact on the academic, school and public community through a deeper and more nuanced understanding of the crusades. At the same time it will enhance understanding of medieval literature, particularly the interaction between Old French and and Occitan poet-singers on the one hand, and vernacular poets and ecclesiastical writers on the other.

Planned Impact

Potential beneficiaries of the research outside the investigators' professional academic circle include schoolteachers and their pupils, museums and galleries, and the general public, all likely to have heard of the famous trouvère Richard the Lionheart. Schoolteachers of history, French and current affairs will be able to use the online texts with translations, performances and commentaries, in conjunction with a library copy of the monograph, to broaden their own and their pupils' awareness of the crusades and the Middle Ages; to interest them in an important phenomenon that is not only engaging in its immediate appeal (knights and chivalry are a perennial attraction) but highly relevant to the political situation in the world today; to think about responses to contemporary events and diverse types of news-media and propaganda in different epochs; and to use high-quality and entertaining sources that would otherwise be difficult to access. Museums and galleries staging exhibitions concerning the crusades or other aspects of medieval culture, such as history of art, could use the free online material in order to enhance the context of the exhibition. The existence of the 'general reader' has been demonstrated by the dissemination of Paterson's book 'The World of the Troubadours' (CUP 1993) in French, Spanish and Italian and in several English paperback reprints, which has appeared on the shelves of, for example, Waterstones, the Sainte Chapelle in Paris, and the visitors' gift shop in Carcassonne. The benefit to such a reader is, above all, cultural and intercultural: the development of interest in and knowledge of the subject; the mind-broadening that comes from learning about other cultures, whether chronologically or geographically separate from one's own; appreciation of the artistic achievements of the medieval world; and a fuller and deeper knowledge and understanding of a past that resonates powerfully and often disturbingly in a modern multicultural environment. Feedback from readers of 'The World of the Troubadours' suggests that writing that is original and scholarly, but at the same time clear and accessible, can also occasionally be helpful to creative writers, or prompt journalists and television producers to ask for interviews or comment (an interview with Paterson for Channel 4 has been distributed worldwide, and she has been quoted on 'Have I Got News For You').
Methods of making these groups aware of the opportunity to benefit from the research will include book marketing, websites, and other means. As well as the websites at Warwick and Naples containing the online texts, there will be a site dedicated to the project, which will include podcasts of parts of performances accompanied by five-minute talks. Web surfers will have plenty of opportunity to discover these websites on the basis of their interests. University Open Day talks will aim to stimulate interest among UK schools, and talks will be offered to local schools. Warwick University supports a process of research dissemination which involves a full range of digitised materials including online video, audio, blogging and other channels which will be available for the project. Possibilities as yet undeveloped include a Warwick Arts Centre performance to coincide with the musical recordings of Old French lyrics, and the potential involvement of creative writing students and other Warwick students (see Impact Plan).
The research and professional skills developed by staff working on the project could apply to any employment sector that required intellectual acuity, flexibility, judgment and independence, linguistic knowledge, attention to precise detail, awareness of cultural difference, careful reading, interpretation and expression, organisational ability, teamwork, and IT skills.
All online material will be available by

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Research still underway so no key findings to report as yet.
Exploitation Route TBC
Sectors Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description 1. Medieval literature seminar at the Univesity of Neuch?tel, Switzerland, Autumn 2012, for the bachelor's degree in French Teaching Swiss students about the crusades, French crusading texts, and the project. 2. Radaelli has used the Old French texts she is involved in editing for our project to mount a taught course for musicologists, concentrating on the corpus of secular monodic repertoire of the 12th- and 13th-c. troubadours and trouv?res, particularly crusade songs. The c. 30 students ha
First Year Of Impact 2012
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Les troubadours autour des croisades orientales de Jacques le Conquérant: Olivier lo Templier 
Form Of Engagement Activity Scientific meeting (conference/symposium etc.)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation paper presentation
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact The paper introduces the AHRC-funded project and illustrates through a specific example the need for new critical editions of troubadour crusade lyrics and reconsideration of their historical cirumstances.

TBC
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Lyric responses to the crusades: parody and dissent 
Form Of Engagement Activity Scientific meeting (conference/symposium etc.)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Participants in your research or patient groups
Results and Impact Paper given at the 14th international congress of the International Courtly Literature Society, Lisbon 22-27 July 2013

The purpose of the paper was to introduce the AHRC-funded project, & consisted of an introduction, a view of the project website under construction, and discussion of a burlesque troubadour song about crusading.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
 
Description Workshop (The Crusades: History and Literature) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact 44 people attended an interdisciplinary one-day workshop organised in collaboration with the historian Prof. Jonathan Phillips of Royal Holloway College, held in London on 22/03/2014. This stimulated questions and lively discussions after each paper.

1) Katarina Stulrajterova wrote a report on the workshop for the Slovakian journal, THE CRUSADES: HISTORY AND LITERATURE (Križiacke výpravy: História a Literatúra, 22 Marca 2014, Londýn) in Historocký casopis, rocník 62, 2014, císlo 2, 379-380.
2) A proposal for a book based on the workshop is currently with Boydell.
3) While most attendees had academic affiliations, one wrote afterwards, 'I am not an academic nor a scholar and I never went to University but for me I have the next best thing, the wonderful events that are given to the public free of charge at various Universities and colleges and other establishments.
I particularly enjoyed your event and although I arrived late, as I had only just seen the posters clearly displayed at Senate House, I found the event to be very educational and informative and above all very enjoyable.
I knew very little about the Crusaders apart from what I learnt at school which was only that they went on a crusade and claimed to be 'Killing for Christ'. I learnt so much else on Saturday's event, all the intricate little bits that were never taught in my history lessons at school. I only wish our history lessons were so interesting and if they had been then I probably would have gone to school more often.'
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/french/research/crusades/activities/