Delectare et docere: A 17th-Century Marketing Tool for Showcasing the Lirone and its Repertoire

Lead Research Organisation: University of Southampton
Department Name: Faculty of Humanities

Abstract

My life was changed forever 35 years ago when, leafing through a 17th-century oratorio in the Vatican Library, I came to a recitative with the curious indication 'Cain con la lira'. Such a tantalising inscription would have meant very little to a musician or scholar in 1975, but today we know that the instrument referred to is the lirone, that plaintive-sounding multi string bowed intrument most often associated with grief and lamentation. That first encounter with Roman music inspired the rest of my musical life: I have made research trips to the main Italian cities, have collected, transcribed and performed much of the repertoire, and commissioned four copies of original lirones, yet in all my performing and touring as a professional musician in Europe, America and the Far East, I have been repeatedly disappointed that Roman music is still neglected by performers, promoters and recording companies.

The Roman composers of the generation after Monteverdi, led by Luigi Rossi and Marco Marazzoli, set the intense poetry of their contemporaries - of which martyrdom and death, extravagant repentance, lamenting and religious ecstasy played no small part - and intensified it to create a new musical experience that was sensual, passionate, even erotic. Both Christian and Classical narratives were exploited to put their message across. The new exaggerated and excessive musical style is what we have come to think of as 'Baroque'.

In 2007 I was awarded an AHRC fellowship which enabled me to research the lirone and its history, playing techniques, repertoire and cultural setting, and to develop projects that would promote the instrument and its remarkable repertoire. For that purpose I formed the ensemble Atalante to explore, rehearse, record, stage and film as much Roman music as possible. In 2009 I was awarded an AHRC small grant to assist with costs towards intensive rehearsal periods for two recordings to ensure optimum artistic results as well as to elucidate important performance-practice questions posed by the repertoire. The grant also supported our staged and filmed depictions of the musical narratives, with sumptuous Caravaggio-style costumes, evocative props and imaginative lighting in atmospheric settings. This made the repertoire far more accessible to the musical public, and worked to reinforce the marketing of the CDs, to promote my ensemble Atalante and to augment the effectiveness of my research and my lirone website. Our first recording (November 2009) was of Roman laments of Artemisia, Helen of Troy, Mary Magdalene and the Blessed Virgin by Rossi and Marazzoli. The second recording (July 2010) was of the Roman oratorio of Santa Caterina, whose original score we reconstructed since it had been damaged.

My current application for a further AHRC small grant is to showcase the lirone as an important member of the basso continuo family, to continue to expand its repertoire through recordings, concerts, presentations and performing editions, and to transcend language and cultural barriers for listeners through visually illustrated staged versions of the repertoire. A further objective would be to introduce large-scale Latin works for the lirone (Lamento di David by Domenico Mazzocchi) as well as laments from the generation after Rossi and Marazzoli (Alessandro Stradella, Alessandro Scarlatti and Bernardo Pasquini), including a recorded track of Cain's lament to finally enable that remarkable work to see the light of day.

My strategy in visually enhancing Roman music is modelled on the Counter-Reformation's own marketing tool for spreading their ideology far and wide. Their motto Delectare et docere - to delight while instructing - was created to attract the multitudes back to the Catholic church. The extravagant and erotic music and poetry must have had a powerful effect on its 17th-century listeners, and with visual enhancement, we endeavor to achieve a totally immersible experience for listeners today.

Planned Impact

The professional music business is discovering that creative programming with visual enhancement is necessary to make new repertoire accessible and to reach potential listeners. Atalante's staged performances and recordings lead the way; not only are they creating a market for 17th-century Roman music, but they are inspiring other musicians and ensembles to embrace this marvellous repertoire, to use the lirone's unique sonority to advantage and to explore new worlds of continuo sonorities. Ensembles who have commissioned me to build Roman programmes for their own series are the Academy of Ancient Music, the English Concert and Les Arts Florissants.

Professional, amateur and student musicians will have access to the repertoire and translations through my editions of all the Roman music that we perform and record. Likewise they will benefit from important performance-practice guidance. Techniques for accompanying vocal music, solving figured-bass problems, mixing the continuo palette, approaching 17th-century Italian poetry and more will also be available in my CD booklet notes, performing editions and prefaces, published articles, presentations and web materials.

There are literally 1000s of vocal manuscripts in the Vatican collections, and scattered amongst them are narrations and laments of ancient heroes and heroines, both secular (Greek, Roman, Persian, Turkish, Egyptian) and religious (Judeo-Christian, Muslim). Surveying and transcribing them has been an arduous but rewarding journey, much like that of the archaeologists who excavated the relics of ancient Rome. Undoubtedly this research will combine well with other arts and disciplines, particularly within academe and the museum and gallery sector.

Reaching musicians and audiences is also inevitably accomplished through the media. With the added benefit of filmed stagings, our narratives can be heard and seen through a variety of formats: radio and television broadcasts, internet sites (Internet 2.0/social networking e.g. YouTube, Facebook), on our record company website and on Atalante's, on downloads and on DVD.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Fully-staged production of Luigi Rossi's Orfeo 
Description In collaboration with Ireland's premier professional choir, Resurgam, we mounted a production of Luigi Rossi's Orfeo for the Galway International Arts Festival. This is the first time that any kind of opera has been presented here. Erin Headley was artistic and music director, international singers from Atalante took the major roles, and eight singers from Resurgam took the minor roles and choirs. The Italian stage director and designer Alessio Rosati managed the stage work, the costume and lighting design. This was an important work to show off the lirone by the composer who used the instrument considerably in his spiritual music as well. The production was filmed, and clips and extracts will eventually be available. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2014 
Impact The audience reaction was palpable, and the reviews most favourable. The experience particularly opened up new avenues and performance styles for the Irish singers. Enough enthusiasm was generated by promoters that Resurgam plan to either revive this production or produce a new work for 2016. 
 
Title Reliquie di Roma: IV Lamento di David: the Genius of Domenico Mazzocchi 
Description Lamento di David: the genius of Domenico Mazzocchi, his Latin and Italian Biblical and Classical texts with works specifically for the lirone Contents: Oratorios, Lament of David, and Dialogue of Mary Magdalene; Virgil's lament of Euryalis, a mother whose son was a victim of the Trojan war; a dramatic account of the errant Magdalene with Martha and Lazarus escaping Palestine by boat; inspiring and uplifting motets, all works in which Mazzocchi indicated the use of the lirone, dynamic and expressive indications and microtonal tuning. Lament of David; Dialogue of Mary Magdalene; Virgil?s lament of Euryalis, a mother whose son was a victim of the Trojan war; a dramatic account of the errant Magdalene with Martha and Lazarus escaping Palestine by boat; inspiring and uplifting motets, all works in which Mazzocchi indicated the use of the lirone, dynamic and expressive indications and microtonal tuning., Lamento di David The genius of Domenico Mazzocchi in Latin and Italian Biblical and Classical texts. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2014 
Impact Much of this music has never been recorded. The oratorios of Mazzocchi were unknown masterpieces that have finally seen the light of day. The lament of Euryalus is unusual on two counts; one that it is a Latin secular text, setting, and two, that it indicates microtonal tuning for expression specifically by the composer. Also extraordinary is the very long narrative cantata of Mary, Martha and Lazarus, unlike anything else from the period. The reviewers and public alike have come to realise how much this music is really worth hearing. 
 
Title Reliquie di Roma: Mortale, che pensi Carissimi, Mazzocchi, Marazzoli, Rossi, Stradella 
Description Themes of abandonment, crucifixion, loss, fire and war . Lament of Armida, Nero and the Fire of Rome, a Roman soldier's lament at the cross, Zaida's lament for Mustafa, the sacrifice of Jephte and a scene from the Aenied which includes a laments in enharmonic tuning. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2014 
Impact Particularly the enharmonic tuning in the laments of Euryalus and in the Lament of the Magdalene not only what this remarkable tuning system brings to ancient narratives and that the instructions on this difficult tuning are explained in the CD booklet. Listeners and scholars are now realising how bizarre and almost surreal this repertoire is, and how fascinating the period is. 
 
Title Ultime Lagrime 
Description Two staged concerts by my ensemble Atalante performing key repertoire for the lirone in Siena, Italy at the Teatro dei Rinovatti, and in Colle Val dElsa at the St Martial and Albert Cathedral, as part of the Festival Contemporaneamente Barocco in Tuscany. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2012 
Impact We might have been bringing coals to Newcastle since we were performing Italian music to Italian audiences, but they were thoroughly astonished at how extraordinary our repertoire was, and at the amazing continuo instruments that accompanied it. They were equally astonished that it was foreigners who rediscovered their music from the Vatican archives, transcribed it, and subsequently presented it in staged performances. 
 
Description The two main areas in which we came to a better understanding were how the how the lirone was specifically used in a musical work and how to cope with the difficult Italian poetry to make it meaningful to us as performers and to listeners.
Exploitation Route Through information disseminated on the internet and in CD booklet notes as well as through courses, and from listening to our performances, student performers may well benefit. Many such singers and continuo players have contacted me to express interest in working with me. As far as the repertoire goes, as more and more academics appreciate the extraordinary beauty of it, those not only in music but the other arts and in cultural studies will benefit.
Sectors Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other

URL http://www.atalante.co.uk
 
Description In addition to continuing concert appearances, we made two more CDs in our series, Reliquie di Roma which benefitted in every way from the research findings that go back to my original fellowship commences in 2007. These CDs and videos have been available on various media networks as well as on our website, so that sound tracks and video clips are readily available to the public. We also included our musical and stage work to promote the music and the ensemble on a Splash page and on social media outlets.
First Year Of Impact 2011
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Staged performances of Luigi Rossi's Orfeo for the Galway International Festival
Amount € 80,000 (EUR)
Organisation Arts Council of Ireland 
Sector Public
Country Ireland
Start 04/2014 
End 08/2014
 
Description Collaboration between Resurgam and Atalante 
Organisation Resurgam, Ireland's Premier Professional Choir
Country Ireland 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution My ensemble Atalante was invited by Resurgam in 2013 to put to put together an opera production which would involve the professional choir, Resurgam and our vocal chamber ensemble, Atalante. I was appointed artistic and music director of the whole project, and my ensemble Atalante supplied the main role singers and continuo. I appointed the Italian stage director and designer, Alessio Rosati to manage the staging, and to design the costumes and lighting. I also edited the score with cuts and corrections and wrote the surtitles.
Collaborator Contribution In addition to applying for the grant, Resurgam's administrator became production manager for the project, Mark Duley was a rehearsal keyboard player, and eight members of the choir took the minor roles. Resurgam also arranged practical matters like travel, accommodation, fees, and all the technical input needed for the performances.
Impact A number of outputs arose, and are listed with the relevant discipline: Musical/poetic - singers and continuo players made huge advances with the difficult Italian poetry and its rhetoric Acting - singers attained many new skills in movement, and with gesture relevant to the musical drama Opera company skills were learned by Resurgam's director/administrator and Atalante's musical and staging director Further plans to revive the production and/or create a new production for 2016 have been suggested
Start Year 2013
 
Description Il Lirone ed il suo Repertorio 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A lecture given in Italian to scholars and students at the Istituto Superiore di Studi Musicali Rinaldo Franci, Siena. As ever, I needed to provide basic information about the lirone and the period before going into detail. My main purpose in speaking here was to engage Italians in thinking about their own language, and how important it is to consider that vocal music from the 17th century is based on poetry, and not prose. This stirred up some lively discussion during question time, and it was gratifying that the Italians understood well my points about prosody and rhetoric.

The audience were graduate students and professors of music who brought up the point that in Italy, conservatories are not sympathetic to the early music movement, so that lectures and concerts of this kind are extremely welcome and more are needed to transform interest in high quality but little known repertoire.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Interview on Radio 4's Woman's Hour 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact In March 2012 I was interviewed by Jenni Murray about the release of Atalante's second recording, Caro Sposo: Oratorio di Santa Caterina by Marco Marazzoli. Excerpts from this CD and our previous one, Lamentarium were played, and I demonstrated the lirone live on air.

Much feedback came from listening colleagues and from those who had little musical understanding who were amazed of the rich artistic culture of the Roman papal court in the 17th century, particularly the impressive and voluminous repertoire enjoyed by the courtiers and cardinals that appears to be equally as appealing to listeners today.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description Research and performance residency at Villa I Tatti, Italy 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact There were many scholars at my presentation who were astonished by the quality of the repertoire that I had found in the Vatican LIbrary, and they greatly appreciated seeing the videos as well. There has been ample research done on 17th-century Roman culture by academics, but these listeners appreciated and realised the importance of actually presenting the music in context.

As part of my residency I was also engaged in research in Florence where I found further evidence for musical activity involving the lirone at the Scuola di San Raphaello and at the Monasterio di San Marco.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
 
Description The Lirone from Leonardo da Vinci to the Present 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact This lecture was given at the Pennsylvania State University (March, 2012) as part of a three-day residency there in which I also coached graduate string students in the art of bowing. In support of this lecture I presented slides of 16th and 17th-century paintings, as well as videos (from my recordings) with subtitles, made possible thanks to AHRC grants. I was gratified by the response that the students and faculty showed in their amazement and appreciation of the beauty of this lost Roman repertoire for the lirone.

A very important connection came from this visit in the form of collaboration with Prof. Marica Tacconi, a specialist in an earlier period of Italian music, but nevertheless most taken by the Roman repertoire that I lectured about and discussed with her. She was the person who contacted Harvard's Villi I Tatti about my work, and I was almost immediately offered the residency.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012