Queer Theory in France

Lead Research Organisation: King's College London
Department Name: French

Abstract

Queer theory is an umbrella term describing a multi-disciplinary approach to the study of gender and sexuality that has grown in popularity since it first became established in the Anglo-American academic world in the early 1990s. Queer theory borrowed extensively from the work of leading French thinkers of the post-war period, in particular Foucault, Derrida and Lacan. However, in France itself queer theory has not only established itself relatively late in comparison with the UK and the US, but indeed is still fighting to gain a stronghold in academic institutions.

This project begins as an investigation into why such a discrepancy exists, and proposes to look into both the transformation of French post-war philosophy in the hands of Anglo-American queer theorists, as well as the more recent re-translation of queer theory back into the French context. What has been gained and lost in this intercultural traffic of ideas? We shall re-examine queer theory in the light of the different legal, social, political, and institutional contexts with a view to accounting for the striking belatedness of queer theory in France. In so doing, the project will foster the burgeoning dialogue between queer theorists from all three national contexts. The project will address the following questions:

- How did the first wave of Anglo-American queer theory make use of and transform its French influences?
- How, in turn, has queer theory been transformed as it has been reinscribed in the French national context?
- What specific features of French social, political, academic and legal institutions inform the extent to which queer theory is emabraced or rejected?
- How has psychoanalysis as discourse and institution influenced this process, bearing in mind its greater cultural weight in France?
- Why has queer theory been more easily absorbed in some French academic departments (history, sociology) than in others (literature)?
- What are the differences between the way grass-roots LGBTQ activism, and in particular HIV/AIDS activism, engages with theoretical debates in the UK, the US and France?
- How is the issue of gay separatism/assimilation treated differently in the UK, the US and France?
- Why is the debate around 'bareback' (unsafe) sex conducted differently in the UK, the US and France?
- What can be gained by examining such differences? Are they historically insurmountable? How would a dialogue between queer theorists and activists working in the three national contexts reinvigorate both queer theory and the cultures of LGBTQ communities across all three nations?

Planned Impact

We have identified four main groups of extra-academic beneficiaries of the research. They are:

- Public health workers and activists from HIV/AIDS prevention groups
- LGBTQ lawyers
- LGBTQ activists in general
- Psychoanalysts and psychotherapists working in the public and private sectors

The chief way in which these groups will benefit from the research is by their active participation and involvement in selected areas of the project. Representatives from each of the above groups will be invited to speak in workshops organized that will closely relate to their concerns. Thus, a workshop on the issue of 'bareback' (unsafe) sex will engage with health workers, HIV/AIDS prevention activists, LGBTQ lawyers and activists in general; another on the issue of 'gay separatism' will engage with LGBTQ lawyers and activists; a third on the influence of psychoanalysis will engage with psychoanalysts and psychotherapists. The aim of participation in all these cases is to allow selected public, private and voluntary sector groups, as well as the general LGBTQ public to benefit from academic research that directly speaks to their lives and work. By the same token, our aim is to allow academic research itself to be involved with the experiences and expertise of people from outside academia. In this way, public health policy will be brought into dialogue with both theoretical debates around 'bareback' sex as well as with the views and expreriences of grass-roots LGBTQ activists.

A second way in which the general LGBTQ public will benefit from the research is through the two public panel debates organized in Year 3 of the project in non-academic spaces with the aim of involving groups and individuals from outside academia. In keeping with the transnational interests and aims of the project, we shall hold one such debate in London and one in Paris. Participants in the workshops and in the international conference will also be invited from the UK, the US, and France alike.

The project's impact will be faccilitated by advertising in both the UK and the French mainstream LGBTQ media to ensure maximum involvement of non-academic interested parties. The website will further allow for the participation of members of LGBTQ groups and of the interested general public.
 
Description We have investigated the cross-cultural traffic of Ideas between the French and Anglo-American national contexts that gave rise to the theoretical discipline of Queer Theory in the UK and US from the 1990s onwards, and also the 'return' of Queer theory, belatedly, to France. We have discovered the manifold problems but also the imaginative solutions that were necessary in the work of translating queer texts and concepts from one national context to another, as well as the resistances and peculiarities of the French environment that necessitated a new approach that is at once both more and less polemical to the French institutions, at once more and less radical in relation to French academic expectations, at once more and less original and diverse in relation to the established discourses in the S and, to a lesser degree, the UK. We have also brought to light for the first time for UK audiences and readerships important traces and elements of the French queer archive, and we have fostered the emerging dialogue between queer academics and activists across the channel.
Exploitation Route We hope our findings may be taken forward by queer activists in the UK and France and also by the health and legal professions that work with HIV prevention and the gay sexual subculture of barebacking.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare,Other

 
Description The project findings have been used to foster a better understanding of the role and the history of queer activism and theory in France both in the UK and in France itself. To smaller extent, they have also contributed to producing a better informed and more just representation of some of the topics the project dealt with (e.g. the barebacking culture), especially among non-academic parties with an interest in those topics (health professionals, HIV activists, lawyers).
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description (Re)situating Queer Theory on the Critical Left 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact This exploratory workshop focused on James Penney's After Queer Theory (Pluto, 2014) and Razmig Keucheyan's Hemisphere Gauche (La Découverte, 2013) was intended principally for early-career academics and post-graduate researchers in French Studies, Sociology, Gender Studies, Queer Studies, Women's Studies and related areas. Participants were invited to offer a 5-10 minute paper, which could explore an aspect of either or both texts, in isolation or in relation to the speaker's own work.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/modernlanguages/research/french/currentprojects/queertheory/works...
 
Description Queer Theory and Academia: The Case of France in an International Frame 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Compared with Britain and the US there are strikingly few researchers based in France who would think of themselves as working in, or with, queer theory. This workshop seeks to investigate what can be hypothesized as a resistance to queer theory from within the French academic establishment. The workshop will ask why there has been relatively little progress to date in establishing LGBTQ studies on the kind of secure institutional footing in French academia which they have long enjoyed in other national contexts. The workshop will ask whether such resistance to queer theory can be accounted for, as some have suggested, in relation to other systemic resistances, in particular to interdisciplinarity and cultural studies. It will reflect upon the gains and losses which institutionalization within academia involves.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/modernlanguages/research/french/currentprojects/queertheory/works...
 
Description Research Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact The first workshop organised under the project, entitled 'queer theorisations of bareback in three national contexts', held at Warwick university on May 13, 2013. Participants included academics from France, the UK and the USA, as well as legal and healthcare professionals and activists. Publications arising from this symposium is forthcoming in 2015.

This symposium shed new light simultaneously on the phenomenon of bareback and the queer-theoretical discourses which would apprehend it, as well as kick-starting further collaborations across the three national contexts and across the disciplines represented.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/french/research/currentprojects/queertheory/workshops/bareback