The Dialectics of Modernity: Modernism, Modernization, and the Arts Under European Dictatorships.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Arts Languages and Cultures

Abstract

The history of Italian Fascism has always attracted a substantial amount of academic and non-academic attention, but considerably less systematic attention has been paid to the aesthetic achievements promoted during the dictatorship. This project examines the relationship between arts and politics in the age of European totalitarian regimes and presents the first comprehensive view of the arts system during the Italian Fascist dictatorship from an interdisciplinary perspective. Hence, this research is relevant to exploring how the past and its uses have an impact on our understanding of the role of the humanities in shaping our perception of society and civic participation.

During the Ventennio, the Italian Fascist regime created totalitarian aesthetic apparatuses together with new forms of social and cultural patronage for the control of the individual/citizen in the social sphere, seeking mass consensus and the constitution of the 'new man/woman' as the foundation of a modern collective social identity. Specifically, by drawing on a wide-ranging set of modernist journals and artefacts, spanning public building, artworks and novels, this project explores how the Italian Fascist regime's participation in an aesthetic movement (modernism) and in its transformation into a social phenomenon (modernization) created a distinctive system of the arts, which, in the 1930s, also had a profound influence across the whole of Europe. In this research, we argue that these debates and artistic expressions were of key importance for the regime's existence, as they played a foundational role in shaping the aesthetics orientations of Italian culture, in creating its transnational profile, and strengthening the power of the arts during political repression. This project's distinctive contribution to knowledge consists in its sustained analysis of the unique synergy between artistic and political discourses on the modernist aesthetics and totalitarian politics it supports through a wealth of primary data. Such data will become available to both academic and non-academic beneficiaries via the database/website and the series of outreach activities planned.

The applicant has published extensively on the topic of early twentieth-century literary journals, modernism, translation and fascist cultural policies and is currently the co-Investigator in a major UK-based AHRC-funded project looking at intellectual, publishers and journals in post-WWII Italy. She is supervising postdoctoral fellows on Irish modernism and Italy as well as on the role of the PCI in the post-war intellectual debate. She has written a monograph on Fascist cultural policies on translation and published on literary journals and intellectual history from the early 20th century to the 1960s. This project builds on these works on fascist culture, literary journals, and intellectual history, and will result in a major, interdisciplinary monograph entitled Fascist Modernism: The Arts Under Dictatorship, an interactive database/website.

The proposed research programme of impact and dissemination activities will assure the engagement of a wide range of academic and non-academic audiences both in the U.K. and in Italy. Through a series of interconnected public events (e.g. radio conversations, events in bookshops, theatres, and museums, an exhibition, and a round table), designed to increase awareness of the arts' social dimension, the project will involve the broader community in discussions on the arts and humanities ethics of resistance and their social/cultural significance in times of political crisis and transitions.

Planned Impact

In view of our belief in the constant permeability between artistic practices and their transferable social value, this project's main impact strategy consists in demonstrating the importance of the arts both in shaping the public sphere and in promoting the role of the individual in intellectual debates features in literary journals which have championed democratic participation. Through a book, a database/website, an online academic journal, a Visiting professorship, an exhibition, and a series of interconnected public events, this project will engage academics and broader audiences, such as undergraduate students, families and the elderly, who might have an interest in the aesthetic and political dynamics of European integration as well as in the Fascist period. These audiences could benefit from discussions, which cover historical events in light of contemporary issues about the role of the arts in society. The main beneficiaries of the research fall within the following groups:

1. Individuals and bodies within the UK and EU public sector and organizations, interested in the relationships between arts and politics, e.g. museums, art galleries. The exhibition planned in Manchester will cover this aspect of the project. The exhibition will display a significant selection of the artefacts stored in the database/website and, through explanatory running texts, it will primarily dialogue with wider audiences, such as the public at large, local school children and library or gallery visitors (see Pathways). By proposing set of narratives comprising of a balanced mix of texts and images, a public lecture and some school visits, the exhibition will present the material accessibly. It will thus contribute to increasing the number of visitors and the library/gallery portfolio of activities.

2. Think tanks and interest grounds concerned with both a) the call for reconsidering the very limits of national sovereignty and centralised forms of control; and b) the humanities and the modern foreign language crisis of legitimation. These issues will be addressed during the public roundtable at the People's History Museum and will aim at developing collaborative conceptual frameworks, which Think-tanks and interest groups might also adopt to problematize these issues with audiences comprising non-experts. Experts will, instead, guarantee that the debate will make solid references to an extensive range of historical data, explored as part of the project's research agenda. The roundtable will be held in conjunction with similar events the PI will be involved as director of the Manchester-based Interdisciplinary Research Centre in the Arts and Languages (CIDRAL), thereby streamlining venues and maximizing impact on different audiences. The event will thus be part of both the Museum and CIDRAL programme of events and will guarantee visibility and outreach. The People's History Museum will also be able to attract visitors and publicize its own collections.

3. The broader British and Italian public interested in understanding not only the history of Fascist Italy but also its inner cultural workings. The project's outputs will be discussed in events focusing on how political crisis and aesthetic transformations have fostered the presence of the arts in the public sphere. To this end, results will be disseminated by way of conversations with Q&A session and pre-distributed questions and taking place at easily accessible museums, libraries, the radio, independent youth social spaces (Centro sociale occupato), private foundations and bookstore. Due to their dialogical and informal nature, the conversations will involve diverse audiences both in the U.K. and in Italy with varying degrees of specific knowledge on the topic and belonging to different age groups. Each institution will have the chance to attract the public and gain visibility in their own market share. The bookshops will also have the chance to promote their own book sales.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The project:
1) provided the first in-depth interdisciplinary assessment of the arts system under the Italian Fascist regime;
2) presented a comprehensive theoretical and empirical study of modernism not as a literary but as a socially-embedded aesthetic system related to a well-defined political phenomenon through a database/website;
3) drew conclusions on the crucial roles the arts and humanities played during the age of European totalitarianisms and on their ethics of resistance in the contemporary political situation. Finally, the research carried out for the project has generated a further major research question: What are the conditions, possibilities and effects of public intervention through artistic gesture? The project has placed new emphasis on how art shape public spaces and the relationship between citizens and the social sphere.
Exploitation Route When the database-website will be completed, it could function as a platform for other similar research projects. One of the key findings of the project is the use of Digital Technology. This project will therefore create a new set of online:
1) pathways and connections across the various individual artefacts stored in the database (a total of 180), which will better express the relations among the artefacts and the key ideas and arguments developed by the project. This addition will facilitate its use as an interactive tool for teaching purposes. Every artefact is described by an individual essay, and every essay has been tagged in such a way as to display the connections with other artefacts and the overall conceptual framing of the project. The structure of the website will remain flexible and thus of potential use to other colleagues interested in interdisciplinary teaching and research. The website will be linked to the monograph Architecture and the Novel Under the Fascist Regime which is Open Access.
2) permanent on-line exhibition on public art consisting of about 40 artefacts, which will then be used in the classroom to familiarise students with digital technologies and foster independent analysis and selection skills (for this feature we are also requesting further funding to clear the copyright of pictures of some of the artefacts).
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description This project has reached beyond academia. The PI has so far engaged with several dissemination activities both nationally and internationally. The PI has started new collaborations with international organisations, and she has written a chapter for the catalogue of the exhibtion on the arts during the Fascist dictatorship, which opened in Milan on 17th February 2018. The exhibition was curated by leading art critic Germano Celant and sponsored by the Fondazione Prada. The exhibition has been extensively reviewed by newspapers and art magazines in Italy, UK and the USA. The Prada exhibition is the largest ever staged in Italy on this particular topic. The exhibition has sparked debate on the status of the arts under repressive regimes and the chapter by the PI has addressed one of the key question the exhibition asked. The reviews in specialist and non-specialists journals and magazines have focused primarily on this aspect and challenged the understanding of the role of the arts in the public sphere. The PI has engaged so far in 5 events nationally and internationally in Naples, Milan, Rome, Cambridge and Warwick. The key findings presented in these talks centred on the use of digital technologies for research and teaching, the role of the arts in society and the significance of interdisciplinary research.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Title Website/database 
Description The website-database for storing the project's main data has been finalised. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact At present the existing website contains a database of 20 journals, 177 artefacts, described through a series of 400-word multi-lingual pieces jointly-written by a team of researchers, and about 2000 'agents' (authors of articles on the journals stored, and authors of the artefacts); and an on-line exhibition on the theme of public art. 
URL http://dialecticsofmodernity.manchester.ac.uk/
 
Description Crimini della bellezza. Un canone del romanzo fascista. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This talk took place at the bookshop Ubik (Naples). The PI with Professors Giancarlo Alfano and Francesco de Cristofaro (chair) and Dr Emanuele Canzaniello introduced to the general public a debate on the relationship between the novel and the Fascist period. The talk focused on the relationship between arts (the novel in this case) and politics during the European dictatorships. The focus was not only on Italy but also on France in the 1930s. The discussion offered a comparative and interdisciplinary perspective on the role of the arts in the public sphere.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Il sistema delle arti durante il Ventennio. Prospettive di studio interdisciplinare 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This talk took place in Rome at the Fondazione Caetani. The PI introduced the project and discussed its technical development. The discussion was about the relational of the project as well as the potential for adopting such technology to work on visual arts. One of the outcomes of the project was the potential for future collaborations.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Narrative dello spazio, architetture della nazione. Romanzo e architettura nell'Italia fascista. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact This was a lecture given at the University of Naples. Undergraduate and postgraduate students took part. The lecture introduced part of the research project to new audiences and adopted an interdisciplinary framework which sparkled debate. Discussion revolved also around the relationship between politics and aesthetics during times of political repression.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Presentation about the project in Milan at the Laboratorio Formentini per l'editoria 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact During the talk, I presented the project and contextualised its findings, especially the website-database. 20 people attended and there were questions about the key findings of the project as well as about the digital outputs. The discussion about digital outputs sparkled interests in other colleagues who were engaged in Digital projects.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Research paper at Cambridge 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This activity allowed me to present my work to an international audience of academics and postgraduate students. It was helpful in getting substantial feedback on the theoretical foundations of the book I am currently writing as part of the project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description The Dialectics of Modernity: Designing Cultural Landscapes with DH 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact During this talk I presented the findings of the whole project and especially the work carried out to construct the website-database. The debate was about the difficulties encountered when venturing into Digital outputs as opposed to more traditional ones. Colleagues were interested in the configuration and the conceptual mapping of the website-database as well as in the more general debate about the future of the printed book vis a vis the digital book.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/modernlanguages/academic/postgraduate/mancosu/identitiesinmotion4