Narrativising Dinosaurs: Science and Popular Culture from 1850 to the Present

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Department of English Literature

Abstract

Encountering dinosaurs is a routine experience for most of us. They tower over us in museums, entertain us in books and films, and peer out at us from our cereal boxes. Though increasingly well-understood from a scientific standpoint, dinosaurs are far less frequently considered by cultural historians: it may be enough for some people to understand how these animals lived (and died), but the reasons such understandings have become important in twenty-first century culture are in themselves worthy of investigation. What is it about dinosaurs that makes them so appealing? Why do we use them to tell stories to each other, and how do those stories work? Most importantly of all, how have those stories evolved since dinosaurs were first discovered, and what can their evolution teach us about the broader relationships between science and culture?
Dinosaurs are both a manifestation of and an ideal lens through which to view the apparent rift between literature and science which C. P. Snow infamously called 'The Two-Culture Divide' in 1959. Their very existence serves to demonstrate the interdependence of these disciplines: painstakingly reconstructed from scant fossil remains, dinosaurs are invariably the product of imaginative faculties as well as empirical data. They therefore embody a combination of storytelling and science; they are, so to speak, inherently interdisciplinary. By understanding dinosaurs as a focal point for the shifting conversations between literature and science over the last 160 years, this study therefore speaks to wider questions of interdisciplinary knowledge as well as to the specifics of our relationships with Mesozoic life.
This project will examine the ways in which dinosaurs are narrated to and by the public in the broadest possible sense. The materials of its study range from scientific documents written during the nineteenth century (such as the treatise in which Richard Owen coined the word 'dinosaur' in 1842) to contemporary science fiction (such as Stephen Baxter's 2002 novel Evolution). These categories are frequently less distinct than we might suppose - the 1995 novel Raptor Red, for instance, was written by acclaimed palaeontologist Robert T. Bakker explicitly to capitalise on his science's dramatic potential. It seems that dinosaurs often serve to collapse the spatial distances between kinds of writing, as well as the temporal distances between ancient animals, Victorian naturalists, and present-day consumers.
Dinosaurs do this kind of work beyond, as well as within, printed texts, so the Fellowship also takes account of the importance of institutions as sources of popular knowledge. Museums have always played a central role in the way dinosaurs are seen, and this importance is reflected in the RA's research focus. Key to the project is its partnership with the Lapworth Museum of Geology, a Victorian institution newly refurbished for the twenty-first century, located on UoB's main Edgbaston campus and recently nominated for the Art Fund's 2016 Museum of the Year award. By the time the Fellowship begins, Dr Tattersdill will already have collaborated with the Lapworth on a public exhibition about dinosaur images; working further with the museum, its staff, and its extensive archive will give Dr Tattersdill and the RA privileged access to both a source of valuable information about the past and an exciting means of engaging the wider, present-day public in their research.
During the Fellowship, Dr Tattersdill will consolidate his growing reputation as a research leader - not only in the studies which form the centrepiece of the project but in a two-day workshop which will benefit academics working in cognate areas and in a series of events designed to engage specialist educators and the general public. Through mentoring the RA and through teaching and impact activities associated with the project, he will also gain significant experience of collaboration, admin, and knowledge transfer.

Planned Impact

Beyond the academy, this project is designed to engage two groups in particular. The first is museum and education professionals, including community volunteers, who will be included in the project via a bespoke workshop and the creation of a teaching resource; the second is the general public, who will be engaged with via several different events designed to capture a range of audiences (a public lecture, a children's poetry workshop, and a movie night). In both cases, the Fellowship's events are envisaged as having at least as great an impact on the researchers as on their audiences: this project is fundamentally about public perceptions of dinosaurs, and exposure to a range of those perceptions will only enrich the academic work around which the project is focussed.
Taking place at the midpoint of the project, the workshop for museum and education professionals will be conducted at and with the assistance of Birmingham's thinktank museum. With the PI as facilitator, this workshop will provide a space for a diverse group of experts to exchange thoughts and current techniques regarding the role of dinosaurs in education, potentially inspiring new collaborations between the heritage, secondary, and higher education sectors. Its principal object, though, will be to encourage individual reflection on the role played by dinosaurs in today's teaching cultures. The workshop will benefit PI and RA by exposing them to current school and museum approaches to the subject; they aim, in turn, to change the way that these approaches are conceived and conducted, giving educators more tools with which to think through the pedagogies of the prehistoric. The involvement of thinktank extends the Fellowship's contact with the museum sector beyond the Lapworth, taking the project off campus and into the heart of the city.
The workshop will also feed the development of a teaching resource that the PI and RA will create in close collaboration with the Lapworth. Dinosaurs have recently been added to the Key Stage 2 curriculum and the Lapworth museum is already hosting school parties whose instructors would benefit from a set of suggested activities for before, during, and after visits. Creating the teaching resource will not only have a positive impact on local schools and the Lapworth museum, but will also give the PI and RA a new kind of contact with some of their main research questions, including a sharpened insight into the way dinosaurs are figured legally (ie. on a national curriculum, as a compulsory part of childhood).
Amongst the wider public, the Fellowship will seek to provoke thought and enhance knowledge about its subject with a small but diverse series of activities. The lecture, as the most summative performance of the Fellowship's research, is situated at its close; evenly spaced throughout the duration of the Fellowship, the other two events provide an opportunity for the PI and RA to be informed by public perspectives on their work. The film night provides an ideal means of engagement through the dinosaurs' rich screen history, and will give the PI an opportunity to converse with film buffs as well as cinema staff on the nature of this enduring association. The children's poetry workshop, capitalising upon an existing collaboration between the PI and the Emma Press, allows children to inform the project directly without excerpting them from a space - the Lapworth Museum - which has considerable experience entertaining them. In all three events, it is anticipated that framing dinosaurs through the lens of literary criticism will encourage attendees to consider more broadly the interactions between literature and science which feed public conversation. By placing literary criticism in spaces and contexts normally seen as 'scientific', each event serves to promote the value of the Arts and Humanities in wider culture.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The most significant achievements from the award were: our increased understanding of dinosaurs in popular culture (PI), especially in museum spaces (RA), on which academic and academic-related publications are out or in progress; a programme of events and talks, which has been successful in beginning to disseminate these findings to a diverse public audience and which has already begun generating invitations for further initiatives; employment for the RA on a two-year postdoc at the University of Stavanger - a project closely related to this one which is likely to spawn future international collaborations (and which testifies to the project's success in developing the career of the RA and giving the PI leadership and mentoring experience); and the consolidation of a strong working relationship between the Lapworth Museum and the PI - which is now starting to lead to future collaborations between the Earth Sciences department at UoB and the College of Arts.

This project was founded with 12 key goals, and I am happy to report that progress was made against all of them. Most are captured, or being captured, by the individual event and publication entries elsewhere in this submission. In addition to these, the grant funded travel (for the PI, the RA, or both) to Toronto, Edmonton, Paris, Berlin, Sheffield, London, and Oxford to participate in academic conferences, research, and professional meetings. The results of these journeys, the primary research we undertook, and the research and writing time which the award provided, have been diverse and universally positive.

Progress on the monograph which was to be the centrepiece of this funding bid has been interrupted by the coronavirus pandemic. It remains under contract to Bloomsbury, and my ambition now is to complete a larger and significantly expanded work in a few years' time.
Exploitation Route Evidence of increasing scholarly interest in our subject area is already visible, especially through increasing collaboration with the PopPalaeo network based at KCL (also AHRC-funded). We hope that this will increase as more of our publications come out. The models of public engagement which we have pioneered in this project have already been adopted or repeated by several cultural institutions. The PI's involvement in a new international network around cultural heritage in natural history museums - Symbiosis (https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/research/symbiosis/index.aspx) - will increase the dissemination of our attitudes and techniques.
Sectors Education

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

 
Description The temporary exhibition which I curated with the Lapworth museum was picked up by both the Dudley Museum and Erasmus Darwin house; in addition to other project goals I worked with those institutions to broaden the reach and impact of that exhibition. Neither the Dudley Museum nor Erasmus Darwin House had hosted a temporary exhibition before taking ours, and this change in their practice looked set to continue - the pandemic has, of course, complicated things. I am involved in new funding bids for further exhibition activities, both to the AHRC and the Leverhulme Trust. My work with the Lapworth was part of a REF Impact Case Study - though the specific outcome is not known, the overall REF results make it probable that the ICS was of at least 3* quality. Many of our impact activities - including the creation of a KS2 worksheet for the Lapworth museum, our children's poetry event, and our evening talks - are being repeated or adapted the institutions where they took place. I am currently working on new bids to both the Royal Society of Edinburgh and the AHRC, both of which build on impact work undertaken during this grant.
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Collaboration with the Lapworth Museum on Events Programming and Research 
Organisation University of Birmingham
Department Lapworth Museum of Geology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Verity Burke and I worked with the Lapworth throughout the year on many events (which see) and on their archives. As well as formal project outputs we have been involved informally in many of the Lapworth's other public endeavours - including recruitment and event programming as well as their own future funding applications (to ACE England among others). The relationship we built with the Lapworth during this period continues to result in collaborations: for example, I currently sit on the Project Board of their new archiving project, which was funded by the National Archive to help organise the documents about which Burke and I wrote during the Fellowship. Burke and I also created a KS2 worksheet on fossils for the museum to offer to school groups - this worksheet incorporates learning objectives from both the English and Science KS2 curricula. As the Lapworth plans another bold phase of expansion, I am happy to continue to be in touch with them as a representitve of the humanities, and I am optimistic for our future shared efforts.
Collaborator Contribution The Lapworth provided event space for a variety of project activities - including public- and academic-facing events. They granted access to their archives and support in primary research which will result in at least one publication (in press at the time of writing). Their director also agreed to be interviewed for our published work, and their communications staff have been useful in advertising our public events and in making connections with other regional museums.
Impact Burke's article 'It's Geology Time' was the main academic output from this collaboration. The collaboration also informs Kistler and Tattersdill's article about museums. See the publications section for full references to both. The Lapworth will play a role in Tattersdill's monograph about dinosaurs, which is still in progress at the time of writing. Many events took place in the Lapworth or with their support - see the 'events' section for full details.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Academic Workshop on 'Research Dinosaurs' 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This workshop was held in the Lapworth in July 2019. It included historians, palaeontologists, museum professionals, literary critics, an anatomist, a materials scientist, a primatologist, and many besides. The first day focussed on formal papers, object handling, and discussion; on the second day delegates designed an interdisciplinary module in a series of workshops (available on request). A particular highlight for many was the video plenary from John Acorn (University of Alberta). The event was scheduled to fit into and complement the existing run of 'Popularising Palaeontology' workshops (run by Chris Manias at KCL), also AHRC funded. Comments left by delegates included: "This event was wonderful, and I think the multidisciplinary approach is very stimulating"; "The discussion of teaching was fascinating throughout"; and "excellent - a really interesting variety of approaches".
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.poppalaeo.com/research-dinosaurs
 
Description Children's Poetry Event (Lapworth Museum) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We brought in Richard O'Brien, Birmingham's Poet Laureate and Creative Writing Lecturer, to run a workshop about dinosaur poetry for children aged 6-10 in the Lapworth museum space. This built upon Dr O'Brien's previous work with me on a book of children's dinosaur poetry (see link and publications). The event, which sold out within an hour of being posted online, drew many parents in as well. The Lapworth, which had never run a poetry event before, have indicated that they would like to repeat this event in the future.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://theemmapress.com/shop/dragons-of-the-prime/
 
Description Cinema Presentation + Talk (Lapworth Museum) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact With the Lapworth Museum, and as part of their efforts to widen public appear with evening activities, I gave a short talk prior to a screening of 'Jurassic Park' in the museum space. The attendees were mostly families from the local area, although there were also some university students in attendance (the Lapworth Museum is on campus). The event was a success and as a result, the museum are planning to do more cinema nights!
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Keynote Talk at the Earth Science Teachers Association (ESTA) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Thanks to my collaboration with the Lapworth, I was invited to give a keynote at the annual conference of the Earth Science Teachers Association. The other keynote speaker was Prof Alice Roberts. My talk was on Geology in Fantasy Writing, and was attended by a large group mostly consisting of active secondary-school geography and geology teachers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Poidcast appearance 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact An entire episode of the podcast 'Words to that Effect' was dedicated to the subject 'Dinosaurs: Palaeontology to Pyjamas' as a result of my research, and I was the main guest on this 25 minute episode.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://wttepodcast.com/2019/01/14/dinosaurs-in-fiction/
 
Description Talk to General Public (at Barber Institute, Birmingham) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of the Barber Institue's 'Lates' programme - on an evening dedicated to artistic depictions of animals - I gave a short talk about the lack of dinosaurs in the Barber's artistic space (why is artwork about dinosaurs always in science museums, when artwork about birds can be found in both spaces?). The talk was a casual one, repeated several times during the evening as participants in the programme drifted past.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Talk to General Public (at Erasmus Darwin House) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact After the success of 'Drawing Out the Dinosaurs' at the Lapworth Museum, Erasmus Darwin House (Lichfield) asked if they might hang the exhibition. As part of this, I delivered a Lunar Lecture in Lichfield entitled 'Beyond Brontosaurus: Dinosaurs, Science, and Fiction'. This was a sold out event to a mostly local group of museum devotees.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Talk to General Public (at King's College London) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of a series of public events associated with the Popularising Palaeontology programme, I appeared on a panel at an evening event about Palaeoart. The talk I gave was called 'Shakespeare and Dinosaurs', and I spoke alongside scientists and museum curators to a mixed London general public.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.poppalaeo.com/
 
Description Talks and workshops to General Public (at Oxford Museum of Natural History) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of this project and continuing, separate, work with the Oxford University Museum of Natural History, we put on an after-hours workshop in the museum space with talks and activites on the subject of artistic depictions of dinosaurs. As part of this event, I delivered a workshop on 'Drawing Dinosaurs' and Verity Burke gave a talk about staging dinosaurs in museum spaces. We also had a talk from David Button, a palaeontologist at London's Natural History Museum.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019