Dementia in the minds of characters and readers

Lead Research Organisation: Queen's University Belfast
Department Name: Sch of Arts, English and Languages

Abstract

One of the most rewarding aspects of reading a novel is the experience of seeing the world through the eyes of a character, especially when it offers a new or unusual perspective, known as 'mind style' in literary linguistics. This is the first comprehensive mind style analysis of dementia narratives, including Elizabeth is Missing (Healey 2015), The Corrections (Franzen 2010), The Wilderness (Harvey 2010) and Still Alice (Genova 2007) amongst others. Because of the wide-ranging ways dementia can be experienced and depicted, this project will push the boundaries of the mind style model, developing its scope and analytical power.
However, this project also investigates how literary language depicting the minds of characters with dementia can provide a 'way in' to understanding a socially stigmatised condition associated with loss of personhood. Some might argue that fictional representations of dementia have little relevance to real experiences: our contention is that dementia is different for everyone, so there is no 'real' means of measuring representative accuracy, nor should fiction conform to 'reality'. Indeed, fiction is unique in the way that it lets us access the workings of other peoples' minds so closely. To illustrate, we offer a short vignette of how Jonathan Franzen, in his award-winning book The Corrections, uses mind style to take the reader inside the mind of Alfred, a character with dementia:
Alfred was standing in the master bedroom wondering why the drawers of his dresser were open, who had opened them, whether he had opened them himself. He couldn't help blaming Enid for his confusion. For witnessing it into existence. For existing, herself, as a person who could have opened these drawers.
Alfred's confusion and agitation is iconically represented in the listed questions 'wondering why...who...whether...'. The use of repetitive, speech-like, 'live' sentence constructions 'for-, 'for-', 'for-', involves us in Alfred's search for blame. In our pilot study (Lugea et al 2017), we asked participants in a Reading Group to listen to a longer version of this extract, underlining features of interest, completing a short questionnaire, and engaging in a group discussion. A participant living with dementia reported, 'this is my life' and other readers reported feeling as if they had access to Alfred's thoughts and experience. This vignette illustrates a major advantage of using literary representations of dementia: fictional mind styles allow us to show, rather than tell people what it is like to experience dementia.
Our project uses fictional extracts which display features of dementia mind styles to explore the potential of fiction to unlock deeper understanding and empathy towards people with dementia. The Reading Groups will include:
1. people in the early stages of dementia
2. caregivers
3. social work/policy students
4. the general public
The readers' responses will inform our analyses of the fictional texts, developing the mind style model itself and providing further empirical insight into how real readers interact with fictional characters.
The findings will be shared in academic, social policy and cultural settings. We will publish a booklet to be used in ongoing dementia training and support. The project will culminate in a Dementia Fiction Festival, celebrating the boom of fiction on the topic and contributing to the growing public awareness of the condition. The texts analysed, as well as works from local and international authors, will be showcased through live readings, performances and screenings. With the support of dementia charities, the events will be dementia-friendly, giving people living with dementia a rare chance to engage in directly-relevant cultural activities. Ultimately, we provide a method which could be replicated to improve cultural understandings and empathy towards dementia in other contexts, and similar illnesses in any context.

Planned Impact

This research engages key stakeholder groups in reading fiction depicting the world-view of characters with dementia, a method replicable in other contexts and with other cognitive impairments. Based in Northern Ireland, the findings will be relevant to any of the 46.8 million people living with dementia globally (Alzheimer's Disease International 2015). The impact is much wider when we consider that the disease effects family members, friends, carers and - socio-economically - society at large.

People living with dementia
People in the early stages of dementia, who are often less catered for in arts therapy (Beard 2012) will use the fiction to discuss their lived experiences in Reading Groups. As Canning shows (2017), Reading Groups give a voice to marginalised people, having a cathartic psychological impact. Like previous research (Billington et al 2013), our project can demonstrate the impact of literary interventions on people living with dementia in relation to their symptoms, quality of life and wellbeing. Addressing the 'social death' (Brannelly 2011) that people living with dementia have been said to suffer, the project's series of outreach events will be as inclusive as possible, thus positively impacting on the social inclusivity of the cultural scene in Northern Ireland.
Informal caregivers and health professionals
Given that there are 700,00 people in the UK caring for a loved one with dementia (Alzheimer's Research UK 2015), this research is highly relevant to those caring friends and family. Although carers are advised to put themselves 'in the shoes of' a person with dementia during training (Alzheimer's Society 2017a), there are no specific methods on how to do this. The Reading Groups' inclusion on the Training for Informal Caregivers (TrIC) programme will introduce carers to the fiction, encourage them to take the perspective of the characters and, in turn, facilitate empathy, impacting on their understanding and the quality and level of care they provide. The booklet will be available for dementia charities to use in supporting staff and service users into the future.
The Reading Groups with social work/policy students will use fiction to lay bare core symptoms of dementia and encourage empathetic and professional engagement. The research will inform the development of interdisciplinary teaching materials for Queen's University undergraduates, including programmes in Social Sciences and on a module 'New Questions for an Ageing World', as part of our new Liberal Arts degree.

Public/policy/third-sector
The research findings will be presented at a masterclass for British Society of Gerontology in Northern Ireland, which has mixed public/policy/third-sector audiences. Through ARK Research Updates and a Knowledge Exchange Seminar to the Northern Ireland Assembly, the research findings will also reach policy-makers in the region. To ensure long-lasting public benefit, these resources will be freely available on the ARK website for five years after the project start date.

General public
There is already a 'dementia boom' in popular culture, but this project develops that into deeper awareness through selection, analysis and dissemination of the fiction and the findings. Research findings will reach a public audience through events as part of local and international programmes, as well as our Dementia Fiction Festival. There is a high level of fear about dementia amongst the public, with very little accurate information about what the condition actually involves. Fiction will act as an important starting point for translating this fear into a more socially acceptable understanding of dementia.

Creative writers
The Dementia Fiction Festival is a means to promote the work of creative writers, local and international, having an impact on the artists' visibility. Moreover, the research findings will be shared through a workshop with creative writers, impacting on literary practices.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Lugea J (2022) Dementia mind styles in contemporary narrative fiction in Language and Literature: International Journal of Stylistics

publication icon
Lugea, J Dementia mind styles in contemporary narrative fiction in Language and Literature

 
Description This project has compiled a corpus of almost half a million words of contemporary fiction from the perspective of a character with dementia. By analysing the textual data qualitatively and quantitatively, we have been able to uncover the stylistic features used to represent dementia in the minds of characters. Some of these tally with previous studies of other kinds of 'mind styles' and include features such as the lack of a word for a concept (underlexicalisation), particular metaphor use and interactive tendencies. However, we have also found that dementia is represented on the narrative level (structurally, across whole novels) and by playing with different levels of knowledge (e.g. differences between what the characters know, the reader know and ironies that arise). We have also been able to pin down a more precise definition for 'mind style' which is based on iconicity i.e. texts represents minds by replicating, in the language, the way those minds experience the fictional world. This means readers get to 'try on minds' in fiction.

Since the reading groups have been held (May 2021), we have gathered, processed and begun to analyse the vast reader response data to extracts from dementia fiction. Although analysis is ongoing using Atlas.ti qualitative coding software, initial findings demonstrate that fiction can facilitate awareness and understanding towards the condition.
Exploitation Route The scholarly community can gain from the development of the dataset and the theoretical apparatus around 'mind style'.
Evidence is emerging for the power of fictional language to facilitate understanding and increased awareness around what it is like to experience dementia.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Healthcare,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-wno22Az1Y6X_b1clzmEdw/featured
 
Description This project's research has informed practice in writing about dementia imaginatively: - creative writing sessions with people living with dementia - a scoping event and workshops with creative writers who are writing about dementia In both cases, the stylistic features of existing fiction (in our dementia fiction corpus) laid bare in our research are used to facilitate the practice of future writers. The project's reading groups had an impact on participants by engaging them with fiction, facilitating social/shared reading and improved understanding of the condition. The dissemination of the research has impacted upon people the importance of societal and cultural ways of dealing with dementia, not just medical narratives.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Healthcare,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Creative Writing Workshops: dementia fiction
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Title Dementia Fiction Corpus 
Description This project compiled a corpus of 490,000 words of contemporary fiction from the perspective of a character with dementia. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This corpus constitutes the first of its kind and one of the largest of contemporary fiction in English. 
 
Title Dementia fiction reading group data 
Description The project carried out extensive reader response data collection, investigating the responses of readers to extracts of dementia fiction. A series of 6 weekly reading groups were held online (Zoom), audio-recorded and transcribed. This was repeated with 4 different groups (carers, people living with dementia, student social workers). The discussions are supplemented with pre-, post-study questionnaire data, as well as weekly reading questionnaires. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact possible impacts: benefits of social/shared reading for exploring health/social issues and developing awareness. 
 
Description Alzheimer's Society 
Organisation Alzheimer's Society
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution As part of our outreach programme, we have hosted two creative writing workshops with people living with dementia, recruited through the Alzheimer's Society. They were overwhelmed with the positive impact of this event on participants' wellbeing and confidence.
Collaborator Contribution Alzheimer's Society have a staff member on our Advisory Panel and have been feeding into research design and methodology. They are allowing us to recruit participants to the reading group of caregivers, using their existing channels.
Impact Two creative writing workshops with people living with dementia; their writing will be included in a published pamphlet.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Dementia NI 
Organisation Dementia NI
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Dementia NI (DNI) is a charity that helps to empower people living with dementia to have their voices heard and remain active members of society. We will be hosting reading groups and one of those groups will be made up of research participants living with dementia. Together, we will read extracts from fiction depicting dementia and their responses will feed into our understanding of the texts. In this way, the project gives people living with dementia a platform to respond to fictional representations of the condition. In our outreach programme, people living with dementia (recruited through DNI) are participating in creative writing workshops to narrate their lived experience of the condition.
Collaborator Contribution DNI members and Empowerment Officers are on the Advisory Panel of this project. They have been involved in the research design and feeding into the research methodology, based on their knowledge of the needs of people with dementia, and how they can be involved in the research. This has involved decisions around selecting the extracts and the procedure for the reading groups. Dementia NI are allowing us to recruit to the reading group of participants living with dementia through their membership channels.
Impact Multi-disciplinary: literary linguistics, creative writing, narratology, empirical literary studies and cultural gerontology.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Dementia Fiction Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A two-day hybrid online/in-person festival, celebrating the culmination of the project by exploring the range and richness of fiction about dementia. As well as research talks and discussions, the event heard from carers, writers and those living with dementia about how the experience can be narrativised. Networking events and cultural events took place in the evenings.

15-16th September 2021, in Accidental Theatre Belfast and online (live YouTube events).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL1FZgDLPzSTzk1Dkbjq1ZhNf86GL0Vya_
 
Description Dementia: Feel it through Fiction 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Has reading fiction ever made you laugh, cry, or feel something? How can words on a page create characters and represent fictional experiences to such an extent that we not only believe, but are moved by them?
This interactive talk explores how dementia is represented in fictional language, how readers respond to it, and why.
27 Mar 2021
Imagine! Festival of Ideas and Politics
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://youtu.be/jttqwKVgctE
 
Description Dr Jane Lugea and Jan Carson speak to Lynette Fay, BBC Radio Ulster about the Dementia Fiction Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Talking to Lynette Fay, Dr Jane Lugea outlines the research underpinning the Dementia Fiction Festival, 15th-16th September 2021. The research project's Outreach Officer Jan Carson describes the importance of engaging the community with the issues raised by the project.

Period 14 Sep 2021
Title: Lynette Fay show
Media name/outlet: BBC Radio Ulster
Media type: Radio
Duration/Length/Size: 10 minutes
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000zlpj
 
Description Dr Jane Lugea and Jan Carson speak to RTE Arena show about the Dementia Fiction Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Title: Dementia Fiction Festival - coverage on RTE's Arena show
Degree of recognition: International
Media name/outlet: RTE Radio 1
Media type: Radio
Duration/Length/Size: 14 minutes
Country/Territory: Ireland
Date13/09/2021

Description: Talking to Sean Rocks, Dr Jane Lugea outlines the research underpinning the Dementia Fiction Festival, 15th-16th September 2021. The research project's Outreach Officer Jan Carson describes the importance of engaging the community with the issues raised by the project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.rte.ie/radio/radio1/clips/22005029/
 
Description NI Science Festival: Somebody I used to Know with Wendy Mitchell 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Wendy Mitchell has written a memoir about her lived experience of early onset dementia. In this discussion for NI Science Festival, she and her ghost writer discuss the challenges of narrativising dementia and the PI on this project has input on how literary language and narrative can capture that experience, as well as the ethics of representation.
The talk was broadcast on 27th February 21 and has since had over 500 views from international attendees.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KpsiGcVS8hI
 
Description Scoping event: Creative Writers and Dementia 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 16 creative writers attended an online Zoom discussion about how to write about dementia with accuracy, sensitivity and ethically.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://blogs.qub.ac.uk/dementiafiction/outreach-impact/
 
Description See the world through another's eyes: reading fiction to understand dementia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Keynote talk delivered to Queen's University Belfast Women's Graduate Association.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Two creative writing workshops with people living with dementia (Alzheimer's Society, March 2021) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Patients, carers and/or patient groups
Results and Impact Approx 15 people living with dementia attended two separate creative writing workshops, hosted by author and arts facilitator Jan Carson, who is outreach officer on this project. Their narratives will be included in a future outcome of the project, a pamphlet of writings from people living with dementia.
The Alzheimer's Society staff member reported this feedback:

What can I say? A thank you genuinely doesn't seem adequate! The sessions were absolutely phenomenal - when you signed off yesterday, Pete was still on the Zoom and I have never seen him so excited! Jane phoned me as soon as the session ended, full of enthusiasm (she said that she felt like she'd been on holiday, and I know exactly what she meant!)
I've been getting some lovely comments, which I'll send on to you, but a highlight for me was seeing the participants leaving the session feeling ten feet tall. Obviously confidentiality prevents me from giving you personal details, but there was at least one participant who is having a really tough time and desperately needed a confidence boost, and my goodness did you provide it!
I'm sure sessions like these are very familiar territory for you, but it was an absolute joy and a privilege to be part of it all (and Jane says, and I quote, thankyouthankyouthankyouthankyou!!!)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://blogs.qub.ac.uk/dementiafiction/outreach-impact/