New Engagements to enhance artists' livelihoods in East Africa: Art; Writing; Work

Lead Research Organisation: Newcastle University
Department Name: Sch of Arts and Cultures

Abstract

This impact and engagement project focusses on practical interventions that will support artists living and working in Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda build sustainable livelihoods and help build capacity in the creative industries in in East Africa, an international development priority. It will do this through engagements that respond to the needs, ambitions and priorities of visual art professionals as stated by themselves, the local organisations that support them and set out in government policy and development reports on the creative economy in East Africa commissioned by the British Council.

The planned engagements and impacts have been developed through the activities of the AHRC-GCRF funded research network 'Networking New Opportunities for Artists in East Africa' which draws together visual art professionals from diverse backgrounds in East Africa, including artists and art collectives living and working in deprived areas, to collaboratively scope interventions that will support the sustainable development of their livelihoods. The network's activities focus on identifying pragmatic approaches to shared problems, practical initiatives that will impact directly on real life experiences and and make definable contributions to building capacity for visual art activity in the creative economy, thus working towards EAC and international development goals.

Extended evidence-gathering has identified that a fundamental constraint to addressing many of the challenges artists face is a deficit in 'art writing' skills. This deficit is apparent at all levels in the visual art ecology and impacts in variety of ways, from a lack of confidence in preparing basic written material for self-promotion which can exclude or disadvantage many artists when trying to access professional opportunities, to the absence of a shared body of developed artistic critique. Not only does this inhibit artistic production, but it also constrains the role and capacity of the visual arts within the cultural economy. Balanced against this, new platforms including a new art magazine are struggling to emerge, and the enthusiasm, energy and demand for practical initiatives to assist development of artistic writing is evidence that the emergent generation of artistic writers and critics who are already identifying themselves as key future players in the creative economy, will respond enthusiastically to opportunities offered to assist their professional development and make their voices heard.

The project team: arts organisation 32 Degrees East, the British Council in East Africa, the BIEA, art publications Nairobi Contemporary, Art Monthly, and Newcastle University have worked collaboratively to develop plans for a set of engagements that will support specific types of art writing skills, equipping members of the visual art community with the key skills, knowledge and experience which are currently lacking and which will will assist them in the development of sustainable livelihoods.

The project develops four related strands: the development of a new art writing toolkit for essential promotional material; a pilot project developing entrepreneurial and business skills in artists through reflective writing, and an innovative approach to nurturing emergent critical voices in the visual arts, fostering a new generation of artistic writers and providing them a public platform by supporting, in a sustainable way, a new magazine for art writing. Structured around an activity programme that includes workshops, mentoring and the publication of two editions of the art magazine, the project develops its impacts within a context where the importance of supporting artists and growing the creative economy has been recognised through measures such as the passing of the Creative and Cultural Industries Bill (2015), but where government support remains minimal. The impacts that will derive from this project are therefore urgent and vital.

Planned Impact

Within the international development context, the project will impact on those communities identified in the reports and policies highlighted in the Case for Support. These are i) members of visual art communities in East Africa whose career opportunities and livelihoods will be enhanced ii) organisations and platforms supporting artists working in society and encouraging greater public engagement with the visual arts.
The project therefore aims to impact initially on individuals and on organisations. These impacts will in turn develop capacity within the creative industries, and through this pathway the project offers the potential for greater public benefit. Government policy and official reports confirm that the creative industries will have an increasingly important profile within the EAC over the next two decades. Their development is a priority both for their potential for positive economic impact on individual livelihoods but also for their capacity to bring less quantifiable benefits: to 'promote creativity, optimise skills and human resources...and express messages that foster understanding and peace' (Uganda National Culture Policy 2005).
Activities have been collaboratively designed to impact on those visual art professionals and arts organisations who engage directly with project activities; on other members of the visual art community in East Africa, and on stakeholders in the creative industries. There will be impacts on the public who engage with project outputs such or who consume art.
The focus is on pragmatic approaches, impacting on visual art professionals' writing skills, including those which will enhance artists' capacity for entrepreneurship with an emphasis on how these new skills can promote sustainable careers, including capacity for freelance work. These newly acquired skills will enhance art professionals' capacity to access opportunities and afford them greater visibility, building confidence, reputations and affording better market opportunities. The artists' mentoring programme will enable emerging East African writers to gain from the expertise of international and African mentors, offering them opportunities to publish their work in the public realm, developing a new cohort of East African art writers.
Partner Visual arts organisations will benefit through a deepened relationship with their stakeholders: through new knowledge and experience they gain about the value and use of online toolkits, mentoring and art publishing and an enhanced understanding of the relevance and importance of art critique within a developed art ecology. The project therefore contributes to their capacity to deliver their core objectives.
The published texts will give audiences an opportunity to engage with more developed discourses about contemporary art, stimulating future interest in and appreciation of the visual arts and their significance within the cultural economy in East African society.
Through making more widely visible and understood the work of artists and art writers, and by raising their profiles, the project will positively impact on the status of artists and writers within their communities, improving stakeholder perceptions of the role and value of creative practitioners. Within a political context where recognition of the value of growing the creative economy has been demonstrated through measures such as the Creative and Cultural Industries Bill (2015), but where there is still little evidence of governments providing significant support, the impacts which will derive from this project are vital.
This impacts of this project will be sustained in tangible ways: the continuing use of the toolkit on our Project Partner's website will help artists sustain their livelihoods, continuing art dialogues in future editions of Nairobi Contemporary will build capacity for visual art and aspiring visual art professionals will better understand how the sector can offer viable careers.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Njabala 
Description Curated exhibition of eight women artists in Uganda 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The exhibition opened on 8th March 2022, and whilst there was a terrific response from the audience, it is too early to tell what impacts will ensue 
 
Title contributions to Nairobi Contemporary and other art platforms 
Description The writers who participated in this project have each created a work of text, which may be a piece of art criticism, a review or a piece of creative writing for publication in one of the platforms supported by the project 
Type Of Art Creative Writing 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact In some cases, commissions for further writing 
 
Description A number of workshops have been held supporting the development of critical texts for publication in the art press. Many of these have been published. An art writers tool kit has been developed.

This project primarily addressed, within the ODA context, SDG8 (promoting inclusive and sustainable economic growth, full and productive employment and decent work for all). However, It also acknowledged the importance of SDG5 (achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls). While we were not able to find sex-disaggregated data on the creative industries workforce in Sub-Saharan Africa, there are some indicators of women's lesser employment as, for example, faculty members across the various creative arts departments within academia. At one of our partner universities, men outnumber women by a ratio of 2:1 (in fact this is comparable to some departments in UK universites), although they do not always dominate senior posts. A significant strength of the proposed project in terms of promoting gender, equality, diversity and inclusion lay in its provenance, with the network (Networking New Opportunities for Artists in East Africa) committed to ensuring diversity through collaborative working with a range of individuals and groups, including women's organisations.

We were clear about developing a research team which included women as leaders, including involving a diversity of participants in training and mentoring, as arts practitioners and trainers, not only for personal capacity-building and skills development but also to provide role-models to the next generation of arts practitioners.

A strategy of gender diversity informed and guided the team throughout the project. Whilst our partners reported that nationally there is gender imbalance at senior levels in the art world, where a majority of established artists are male, this is less the case amongst the younger generation of visual art professionals where the visual art ecology shows a more even balance of women and men. By nurturing this generation - most of our participants were under 35 - and being explicitly mindful about gender inclusivity, we aimed that the project would push forward on that particular direction of travel. However, careers in the creative industries, in East Africa as elsewhere, are widely regarded as insecure, unprotected and poorly remunerated, characteristics that typify careers with high numbers of women. Thus, one of driving principles of this project was to build sustainable livelihoods for all, for women as well as men, and we chose to work in collaboration with Project Partners who share that vision. For example, our lead PP, 32 Degrees East Ugandan Arts Trust state that they 'take measure to make sure we are more inclusive with regards to class, gender, ethnicity and tribe' and there is evidence that this policy is being successfully implemented. Similarly, one of our other partners, the British Council, state that, 'Our work involves developing relationships with people from a wide range of backgrounds and cultures. Working effectively with diversity and promoting equality of opportunity is therefore an essential part of our work'.

Participants and presenters in the various activities undertaken as part of the project were recruited by our partner 32 Degrees East: the gender balance of participants was 50:50 and 70:30 in favour of women presenters. Our initial open call for art writers for the project attracted 70 applications. Our final selection of 19 commissioned writers who attended project engagement workshops, comprised 9 participants identifying as female, 9 as male and 1 as non-binary. The project mentors we recruited to mentor this group comprised 11 mentors, 7 of whom identified as women and 4 as men, although the matching of mentors to mentees was undertaken without regard to specific gendered pairings, instead being based on aligning needs with expertise.
The academic colleagues who have contributed to the original research and the proposed project are five women (3 x Co-Is, 2 x RAs) and three men (PI, 2 x Co-Is).

The project aimed to enhance the livelihood and sustainability of visual arts practitioners, a community where the number of women has been increasing over the past decade in East Africa and, given our focus on gender equality in terms of the key stakeholders in the project - participants, artists, mentors - we expect the benefits of the project to be reaped by women and men alike.
Exploitation Route Through the publication of art writing
Sectors Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description This project aimed to develop art writing skills and practice in East Africa. Many of the participants in the project have now seen their work published, including in international journals such as Art Monthly. Participants in this project continue to report benefits, for example the exhibition curated by one of our project participants led directly to her representing Uganda at the Venice Biennale of contemporary art
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Economic

 
Description Art and Writing Workshops
Geographic Reach Africa 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact The participants in the workshops reported improvements in their capacity to contribute to the creative economy in Africa through their art writing activities. Stakeholders attending the workshops, such as museum curators noted the benefit of having better equipped writers within their field. Art Magazine editors reported an increase and improvements in the volume and quality of articles submitted for publication. Participants also reported that the formation of the network significantly benefited their professional practice.
 
Description Art and Work in East Africa: New Engagements in Art Curating
Amount £91,965 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/T007672/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2020 
End 01/2021
 
Description Follow-on Funding for Impact and Engagement
Amount £99,855 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/T007672/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2020 
End 01/2021
 
Description Art and Curating 
Organisation 32 Degrees East Ugandan Arts Trust
Country Uganda 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We work with Kampala Art Trust to develop curating skills in Uganda We work with 32 Degrees East, Uganda Arts Trust to develop curating skills in Uganda, and the development of the visual art ecology more broadly
Collaborator Contribution Kampala Art Trust work with us to develop curating skills. They make their gallery available for the project, together with staff time and expertise 32 Degrees East, Uganda Arts Trust work with us to develop curating skills. They make their resources, including their staff expertise available to the project
Impact exhibition plans curated exhibitions art writing artworks
Start Year 2015
 
Description Art and Curating 
Organisation Kampala Art Trust
Country Uganda 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We work with Kampala Art Trust to develop curating skills in Uganda We work with 32 Degrees East, Uganda Arts Trust to develop curating skills in Uganda, and the development of the visual art ecology more broadly
Collaborator Contribution Kampala Art Trust work with us to develop curating skills. They make their gallery available for the project, together with staff time and expertise 32 Degrees East, Uganda Arts Trust work with us to develop curating skills. They make their resources, including their staff expertise available to the project
Impact exhibition plans curated exhibitions art writing artworks
Start Year 2015
 
Description Art and Curating 
Organisation Makerere University
Department College of Engineering, Design, Art and Technology
Country Uganda 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We work with Kampala Art Trust to develop curating skills in Uganda We work with 32 Degrees East, Uganda Arts Trust to develop curating skills in Uganda, and the development of the visual art ecology more broadly
Collaborator Contribution Kampala Art Trust work with us to develop curating skills. They make their gallery available for the project, together with staff time and expertise 32 Degrees East, Uganda Arts Trust work with us to develop curating skills. They make their resources, including their staff expertise available to the project
Impact exhibition plans curated exhibitions art writing artworks
Start Year 2015
 
Description Collaboration with 32 Degrees East, Ugandan Arts Trust 
Organisation 32 Degrees East Ugandan Arts Trust
Country Uganda 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution 32 Degrees East, Ugandan Arts Trust are a key partner on this project. We aim to establish all our partnerships on an equitable and sustainable basis. This means that the project is designed so that each partner leads from their particular strengths. We worked with 32 Degrees on two strands in this project. 1) The development of an 'artists' writing toolkit'. This aims to support writers who feel less confident in writing the basic material they need to develop their careers in the public arena. This includes CV writing skills, writing artist statements, grant applications, descriptions of their work etc. Working with stakeholders in the visual art community, we developed a plan for the toolkit. 2) 32 Degrees organised a number of workshops to support art writing at a more developed level. Workshop participants were commissioned to write a piece for publication, and were supported through the process of developing their writing though mentoring and sessions designed to support critical art writing
Collaborator Contribution Our partnerships are established on an equitable and sustainable basis. Each partner contributes from their area of expertise. 32 Degrees are well networked within the visual art ecology in East Africa. They reach out to artists, applying their policy which is rooted in equality of opportunity irrespective of gender, tribe, race and other protected characteristics. Because of this policy, and the strength of their networks, we were able to reach a wide and diverse range of participants. Many of our events took place at the 32 Degrees base in Kampala. 32 Degrees organised the events, and invited many of the speakers.
Impact An Artists Writing toolkit. Writing for publication Workshops Exhibitions and artworks
Start Year 2016
 
Description Collaboration with the British Institute in Eastern Africa 
Organisation British Institute in Eastern Africa
Country Kenya 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We have worked with the BIEA over a period of years. As part of the current project, we secured funding to recruit an RA who would be based with the BIEA. Her role was to support the project across all its activities. A high level of interaction between the PI, the RA at the BIEA and our other project partners, all conducted on an equal footing enabled the project to proceed successfully. The project is well integrated, with events organised at the BIEA base in Nairobi featuring speakers invited by our other project partners.
Collaborator Contribution The RA based at the BIEA was a key member of the project team - the only person working on a substantive FTE contract (and with mentoring and supervision provided by other staff at Newcastle University and the BIEA). As such, the BIEA led on many of the administrative strands of the project: creating calls for expressions of interest, collating replies, helping devise criteria by which participants should be selected and finally, collecting feedback from our participants. The RA also monitored the gender balance of our participants and helped implement the necessary measures to ensure the the project was ODA compliant.
Impact Workshops Art writing for publication Artworks and exhibitions
Start Year 2017
 
Description Art & Writing Workshop - BIEA 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This, the first workshop of our project engaged with art writers, artists and other stakeholders including publishers and curators from across East Africa. It was held at the British Institute in Eastern Africa, our partner organisation and included contributions from speakers from Africa, the US and Europe.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Art and Writing Workshop # 3 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was the third and final workshop in the project. It took place at 32 Degrees East, Ugandan Arts Trust in Kampala, Uganda. The event was attended by the participating art writers in the project, the project mentors and other speakers and participants from Africa, the US and Europe.

The main participants at the workshops were those who had responded to our open call for art writers. We originally selected 12, as per our application, but because of the exceptional number of applicants (over 70), the quality of applications and some additional QR ODA compliant funding we received we were able to increase the number of participants to 19. All came from DAC countries, specifically: Kenya (8) Ethiopia (2) Uganda (6) Rwanda (1) Tanzania (2). In addition to these 'core' participants, the workshops were opened up to others, with a call made through the website and social media of our project partners. Numbers attending varied over the three days of the workshop. All attendees were East African nationals, most were Ugandans. Workshop presenters were from Kenya (2); South Africa (1). USA (1) UK (4) Uganda (4). The events were attended by team members from 32 Degrees (3, all Ugandan) and by the UK research team (2). The project also hired an RA from Kenya (1) who attended all events.

The workshop was concerned with developing sustainable careers for art professionals. The aim is to support the development of a cadre of professional art writers and support art magazines in East Africa. Participants were invited, through a competitive selection process, from across East Africa and included a diverse and representative group of art professionals. Anonymised data regarding the composition of the group has fed into further project activities and funding bids.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Art and Writing Workshop #2, Kampala 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Our second workshop took place, and was primarily organised by our partner 32 Degrees East, Ugandan Arts Trust. The event was attended by art writers, artists and art professionals from across East Africa. Participants also included speakers from Africa, the US and Europe. The art writers attending brought examples of their work for publication. These were discussed at one-to-one and group sessions. An aim was to improve the writing so that it would be ready for publication in forthcoming editions of the art magazine Nairobi Contemporary and other platforms.

The main participants at the workshops were those who had responded to our open call for art writers. We originally selected 12, as per our application, but because of the exceptional number of applicants (over 70), the quality of applications and some additional QR ODA compliant funding we received we were able to increase the number of participants to 19. All came from DAC countries, specifically: Kenya (8) Ethiopia (2) Uganda (6) Rwanda (1) Tanzania (2). In addition to these 'core' participants, the workshops were opened up to others, with a call made through the website and social media of our project partners. Numbers attending varied over the three days of the workshop. All attendees were East African nationals, most were Ugandans. Workshop presenters were from Kenya (2); South Africa (1). USA (1) UK (4) Uganda (4). The events were attended by team members from 32 Degrees (3, all Ugandan) and by the UK research team (2). The project also hired an RA from Kenya (1) who attended all events.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Exhibition Njabala: This is Not How 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This exhibition opened to the public on 8th March 2022, International Womens' Day. The exhibition presents work by eight women artists in Uganda reflecting on the themes of memory, love, womanhood and activism. Using art to speak to repressive roles of living for women, the exhibition seeks to re-enact a revised and contemporary function of Njabala, a legendary female figure in Ugandan folklore.

The following extract from the exhibition catalogue, written by the curator Martha Kazungu explains its aims

By suggesting the title , Njabala: This is Not How, the exhibition proposes not just one way of doing as suggested by Njabala's mother, but a diversity of choices and decision making for women. As a starting point, Martha Kazungu, the exhibition curator supported by the project is interested in interrogating the glorification of the silent suffering of women in many societies in Uganda. Silence is disguised and applauded as good conduct: how dare women talk about rape, gender violence without being blamed for inviting or inciting the violence. The exhibition subverts all tendencies of silence and silencing through bold installations, text, poetry, film photography, performance and painting.

The artists curated in the exhibition were Immy Mali, Bathsheba Okwenje, Miriam Watsemba, Sandra Suubi, Pamela Enonyu, Sarah Nansubugu, Lilian Nabulime (the project Co-I) and Esteri Tebandeke. The curator was Martha Kazungu who was mentored for the project by Yvette Mutumba

The exhibition was formally opened by the American ambassador to Uganda and was attended by several hundred people, including artists, students, academics and other professionals. There was a poetry reading by five Ugandan women poets.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Gender Equality in International Development workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A presentation on gender equality statements in the context of GCRF/ODA projects at Durham University
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Iwang Sawa at AfriArt. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Iwang Sawa at AfriArt was an exhibition curated by Acaye Kerunen. Acaye's goal in curating the project was to work with weavers from western Uganda to engage the multiple layers of culture and language forms on weaving patterns to generate fluency of meaning and the explore the language of these patterns and forms, bringing them to a wider audience and valorising the work of the women.

Acaye has reported to us that as a direct result of this project, she has been invited to represent Uganda in the 2022 Venice Biennale. The work funded by the project is already en-route to Venice. This is a significant outcome as this will be the first time Uganda has been represented at the Biennale, and the decision that Acaye should be the lead artist, showing the exhibition she curated is a major step in both her individual development, but also the visibility of Ugandan art internationally. The significance of the choice of a female artist for this prestigious function can also not be overstated.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://afriartgallery.org/exhibitions/iwang-sawa-acaye-e-pamela
 
Description KLA ART 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact KLA ART is Kampala's free contemporary art festival produced by 32° East | Ugandan Arts Trust. The festival centres art in the city, and transforms relationships between artist and audience
The theme of KLA ART 21 was "This is Ours", inviting artists and audience to reflect on questions of ownership and collectivity.

The 2021 edition is supported by the Prince Claus Fund for Culture and Development, Arts and Humanities Research Council (GCRF) and Arts Collaboratory.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://klaart.org/about/