Creativity for Peace Festival: Creative Methodologies for Unearthing Hidden War Stories

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: School of Modern Languages

Abstract

Our Peace Festival project (PF) identified outstanding groups and initiatives that amplify the voices of marginalized peoples that challenge official histories in Peru and Colombia. It successfully facilitated the gathering of peace activists from these groups in Cartagena de Indias, Colombia, to discuss and produce art about the ways they use creative methodologies to tell stories about conflict and violence, their methodological challenges and possibilities, and the alternative narratives that subvert established accounts. Such creative spaces for dialogue and reflection contribute effectively to inclusive democracy and sustainable peace.

We produced a multi-authored article on the theoretical and methodological lessons of this novel approach to working with peace activists, currently under review for publication. A second paper, examining the achievements of creative methodologies, was presented at the Latin American Studies Association congress in Barcelona, May 2018.

In the follow-up Creativity for Peace Festival, we plan to expand the creative spaces further across academia and activist communities, building on three key insights of the original PF for other co-production initiatives across academic disciplines and with community based organisations:
1) That sharing and co-producing knowledge is enhanced by the embodiment created by active engagement with emotions.
2) There is a creative force inherent in embracing participants' own goals and strategies.
3) Tensions between participants around process and goals, once acknowledged, can be productive; these tensions can serve as a common act producing a collective focus on creating an affective community.

The Creativity for Peace Festival responds to participants' calls in the original PF to explicitly incorporate these lessons and bring in new participants with distinctive experiences of conflict and peacebuilding. Thus, participants working to effect change expressed the necessity of broader spaces for dialogue, exchange, and reflection to produce actionable knowledge and creative know-how that reinvigorates their practices given the complex realities in which they operate. They also stressed the need to find ways to connect with other actors in networks of solidarity and knowledge that create synergies to increase their impact. Thus, the follow-on Festival consolidates what was produced and opens new spaces for knowledge transfer and wider impact.

This project involves new participants from Cuba and Nicaragua to generate new pathways for collaborative engagement that greatly widen the impact of the original project. Including these two countries will further strengthen previous collaborative links with partner organisations, and build capacity for incorporating them into a research network for future projects.

The Creativity for Peace Festival builds on the findings of the first PF in order to achieve new and expanded impact with existing and new partners involved in peacebuilding efforts in Latin America. For this, we will:
a) Organise and facilitate the Creativity for Peace Festival as a four-day event with activists from the four countries, apply the fine-tuned methodology and create a space for exchange in-situ with community-based experiences in Cuba.
b) Re-connect with existing groups and initiatives (Peru/Colombia) and accompany their process of reflection on lessons and changes to produce materials to be shared in the Festival. Connect with new initiatives invited to the Festival (Nicaragua/Cuba).
c) Facilitate the building of a trans-national network of knowledge production, exchange and transfer between participants, non-academic and academic actors.
d) Design publicly accessible material detailing how to use the lessons and findings from the original project.
e) Co-produce artefacts and a short-film with participants during the Festival that will be made available in a public exhibition in UK and deposited in an open-access archive.

Planned Impact

Impact will be achieved in three areas: first, capacity-building amongst participant groups; second, network-building across national boundaries within the Latin American region; and third, knowledge exchange which raises the level of public discourse about post-conflict societies and the cultural and political legacies of armed conflict.

1. Capacity-building: The Creativity for Peace Festival aims to improve the capacities of actors to be better equipped to deal with the complex realities of the legacies of war and ongoing violence in the Latin American region and seek to create space for a more inclusive democracy with social justice. Participants in the original Peace Festival told us that they returned to their work reinvigorated and with new ideas to apply to their projects. The Creativity for Peace Festival will contribute to the specific countries' evolving situations by enhancing this process in Colombia and Peru, and expanding its impact to two new countries:

In Peru, participant activists are currently confronted with the backlash from conservative groups in power that are challenging the achievements of grass-root work for the country's institutional building and democratic transition. In Colombia, participants are closely involved with ongoing efforts to implement the peace process brought about by the Peace Accord, and with the transitional justice mechanisms, such as the Truth Commission, that are challenged by the recently-elected government.

In Nicaragua, the developing political crisis and the risks that the escalation of violence has created at the moment presents itself as a threat. There is therefore a pressing need for the invited participants, who are working to transform the crisis into an opportunity for sustainable change, to build their capacity through engagement with new methodologies and networks. In Cuba, our partner organisation is a key actor in the peacebuilding efforts as mediators of peace processes in the region through their networks with social movements. They also work closely with other community-based networks to enhance participatory democracy in their country. Their capacity will be strongly enhanced through involvement with the work of the Colombian, Peruvian and Nicaraguan participants.

2. Network-building: This is an important line of work, which we recognized was not achieved in the original project because we presumed these networks already existed. We learned that it would be an important contribution to strengthen the horizontal connections between groups and initiatives throughout the Latin American region, and between participants and their own networks with social movements. Furthermore, we became aware of the great, hitherto unrealised potential for networks between non-academic and academic actors for research in order to enhance solidarity and put to work actionable knowledge produced by the initiatives participating in this project which will enhance their impact to transform conflict and the understanding of its complex legacies.

3. Knowledge exchange: The project and its network of collaboration will strengthen its connection and contribution to national peacebuilding efforts through partnership with other ongoing projects (Bringing Memories from the Margins in Colombia, MEMPAZ with Newton Fund/Colciencias, and Digital platform for memory-work in Peru with ESRC Impact Acceleration Account) and key allies (Ruta Pacifica as part of the Colombian Truth Commission, Biblioteca Nacional Colombia holding the Truth Commission archive, and the Gender Justice Memory transnational network project AHRC/GCRF led by Jelke Boesten) raising the level of public and academic debate around this line of work. Projects like this raise awareness of innovative work going on away from traditional media sources, promoting cross-fertilization of knowledge within Latin America, and between Latin America and the rest of the world through academic and related networks.
 
Title Peace Festival artefacts/artworks 
Description Artefacts and artworks created by participants during the Peace Festival will be displayed in the public exhibition to be held in Bristol (planned for March 30th still under consideration given the current public health concerns). 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact Too early to say. Knowledge exchange between participants. Participants' awareness of each other's practices facilitated learning from each other, their different context settings, their different practices and challenges. 
 
Title Peace Festival short film and two micro videos for social media 
Description Peace Festival short film provides an account of the main event, the environment created, feelings shared, and what we produced together. An additional trailer for the short video was created to introduce the film. Peace Festival micro-videos: 1) A timelapse of the participatory mural painting experience in the outdoor wall of a school in Ayacucho Peru. 2) A short collection of fragments of the interviews with participants where they detail their work and views, their challenges and learnings. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Knowledge sharing. The short film and the timelapse are digital products that resulted from the work during the Creativity for Peace Festival and have been shared through a website. This provides glimpses of the methodology as well as the participant's views on their work and their collective learnings. Other organisations and practitioners can be inspired and learn from the film and videos. There was no event in the UK to share the outcomes of the festival, nor a launch event for the website which contains the two Peace Festival carried in Cartagena (2017) and Ayacucho. The website has the potential to improve participants' outreach by showing their work and also other organisations working on memory and peace by learning from the participants and the festivals themselves. This has not happened due first to covid-19 restrictions and other urgent arising problems that participants have had to deal with as a consequence of the pandemic and the crises in their countries. 
URL https://peace-festival.org/en/home/
 
Title Website for digital exhibition of Peace Festival events 
Description We created The Peace Festivals website as an alternative public exhibition due to the pandemic. We shifted from an in-person public exhibition to a website hosting a digital exhibition. The website contains two festivals, one in Cartagena de Indias, Colombia (2017) and the other in Ayacucho, Peru (2019), the festival experiences and the short films produced in each, as well as images of the artefacts created in each festival by participants. It also showcases the work of the participants' organisations in their communities and their forged relationships. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Knowledge exchange and knowledge sharing. The website provides glimpses of the methodology as well as the participant's views on their work and their collective learnings. Other organisations and practitioners can be inspired and learn from the resources on the website. There was no event in the UK to share the outcomes of the festival, nor a launch event for the website which contains the two Peace Festival carried in Cartagena (2017) and Ayacucho (2019). The website has the potential to improve participants' outreach by showing their work and also other organisations working on memory and peace by learning from the participants and the festivals methodologies in themselves. There is also potential for the website to strengthen the connections between participants' organisations and other actors working on historical memory and peace. This has not happened yet due first to covid-19 restrictions and other urgent arising problems that participants have had to deal with as a consequence of the pandemic and the unfolding crises in their countries. 
URL https://peace-festival.org/en/home/
 
Description The Peace Festival took place in Peru in October 2019 proving a successful methodology to gather memory and peace activists from Peru, Colombia, Nicaragua, Guatemala, and Cuba. The Festival methodology catalyzed the knowledge exchange and production through creative methodologies. It increased awareness of the violent contexts in which activists operate and re-energized activists to continue their work on memory and peace in the region. In addition it proved that the applied methodology of sharing and intimate space and exploring through the body and emotions allows activists to explore not only their shared ideas and vision but their differences as important elements to continue to build bridges of solidarity and collective action.
Exploitation Route Too early to say. The public exhibition and panel in Bristol to discuss the usefulness to others planned for 2020 and re-scheduled for 2021 has not taken place. We are drafting possible plans for the future. Now that the project has ended and colleagues' commitments are in other projects, we will have to think about what is possible at this stage to make the most of this project, including its continuity through other funding or alliances with other initiatives.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy,Other

URL https://peace-festival.org/en/home/
 
Description The Creativity for Peace Festival is already evidence of a scaling up of response, as it stemmed from an original Peace Festival in 2017 that included Peru and Colombia. It demonstrates scale and replicability by directly responding to participants' calls in the original project to bring in new participants with distinctive experiences of conflict and peacebuilding. Participants in the original project expressed the necessity of broader spaces for dialogue, exchange and reflection to produce working knowledge and creative know-how that reinvigorates their practices, given the complex realities in which they operate. They also stressed the need to find ways to connect with other actors in networks of solidarity. Thus, the follow-on Festival consolidated what was produced and opens new spaces for knowledge transfer and wider impact. The festival resulted in: catalysed knowledge exchange and production; increased awareness of the violent contexts in which activists operate; and re-energized activists to continue their work on memory and peace in the region. In addition, it proved that the applied creative methodology of sharing intimate space and exploring through the body and emotions allowed activists to invest in not only their shared ideas and vision, but in their differences too. By recognising both as important elements, it became easier to build bridges of solidarity and collective action. Such creative spaces for dialogue and reflection contribute to inclusive democracy and sustainable peace. The project improved the capacities of actors to be better equipped to deal with the complex realities of the legacies of war and ongoing violence in the Latin American region and to create space for a more inclusive democracy. An important impact was to strengthen the horizontal connections between groups and initiatives throughout the Latin American region, and between participants and their own networks with social movements. Furthermore, the project highlighted the hitherto unrealised potential for networks between non-academic and academic actors, in order to enhance solidarity and put to work actionable knowledge produced by the initiatives participating in this project. The project and its network of collaboration strengthened its connection and contribution to national peacebuilding efforts through other ongoing projects (Bringing Memories from the Margins in Colombia, MEMPAZ with Newton Fund/Colciencias, Truth on the Margins: Bringing Memories to Support Transitional Justice in Colombia (AHRC), Digital platform for memory-work in Peru (UoB-ESRC Impact Acceleration Account) and partnerships with key allies (Ruta Pacifica as part of the Colombian Truth Commission, Biblioteca Nacional Colombia holding the Truth Commission archive, and the Gender Justice Memory transnational network project). The project raised awareness of innovative work going on away from traditional media sources, promoting cross-fertilization of knowledge within Latin America, and between Latin America and the rest of the world through academic and related networks. The project features in a report by PRAXIS "Transforming Conflict and Displacement through Arts and Humanities" A Research Report by PRAXIS: Arts and Humanities for Global Development. It was part of 10 selected best practices from all AHRC projects contributing to conflict and displacement as part of the Sustainable Development Goals. The report shares the key learnings, outcomes and impacts of the project with other projects, scholars, and practitioners working in the field. It also highlights the contributions of arts based methods to the complex challenges presented in the field of conflict and peacebuilding. The findings have fed into the Bringing Memories in from the Margins, and Truth on the Margins projects, including in the collection of data and sharing of findings of the Colombian Truth Commission.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description PRAXIS Report Transforming Conflict and Displacement through Arts and Humanities
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or Improved professional practice
Impact These are all detailed in the PRAXIS report.
URL https://changingthestory.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/110/2021/12/University-of-Leeds-PRAXIS...
 
Description Peace Festival host organisation: ANFASEP 
Organisation ANFASEP
Country Peru 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Partnership with ANFASEP (National Association of Relatives of Kidnapped and Disappeared in Peru) to become the Host Organisation of the Peace Festival in Ayacucho. A community liaison worked closely with partner organisation to develop the activities they wanted to have and their role as hosts. They worked closely in drafting a plan and budget.
Collaborator Contribution Partnership with ANFASEP (National Association of Relatives of Kidnapped and Disappeared in Peru) to become the Host Organisation of the Peace Festival in Ayacucho. ANFASEP successfully hosted the Peace Festival and took an important role in the activities developed.
Impact Too early to say.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Peace Festival partner in Colombia: Ruta Pacifica de las Mujeres 
Organisation Peaceful Women's Route
Country Colombia 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Ruta Pacífica de las Mujeres facilitated the work with Colombian activists.
Collaborator Contribution Ruta Pacífica de las Mujeres facilitated the work with Colombian activists.
Impact Too early to say
Start Year 2019
 
Description Peace Festival partner in Cuba: CMMLK 
Organisation Centro Memorial Martin Luther King
Country Cuba 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Centro Memorial Martin Luther King, CMMLK, facilitated the work with activists in Cuba.
Collaborator Contribution Centro Memorial Martin Luther King, CMMLK, facilitated the work with activists in Cuba.
Impact Too early to say
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration activity: Bringing Experts Together on Emotions and Violence from Nicaragua, across space and academic boundaries. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A series of international collaborative events with activist researchers from Nicaragua. The 3 events took place in the Netherlands, in December 2019, taking advantage of a series of international events on related themes at the Institute of Social Studies, organised in collaboration with Dr Silke Heumann of the Civic Innovation Research Initiative and the Nicaragua-Netherlands Solidarity Network, as well as the Coloquio Internacional "Afectos y violencia en la cultura Latinoamericana" organised by the Digital Memories project (European Union's Horizon 2020), KU Leuven and Utrecht University.
The events created a unique space for critical reflection, network-building and capacity-strengthening for experts on emotions and violence in Nicaragua and beyond. The events were designed together with partners who are the main contributors with their expertise and their demands for a space to exchange and critically reflect with potential collaborators. 4 Activist researchers shared their experiences from Nicaragua, providing up to date knowledge on the conditions for researchers in the field, a reflection on methods, and the possibility of an institutional framework for ethical partnerships in violent conflict situations. The dialogue centred on violence, emotions and memory, the roles of activist researchers and universities, as well as how these lead into (and might shape) understandings of rights, duties justice and peace in the future.

Outcomes:
- improved capacity to design research and interventions as a result of sharing up to date research, information on the context, and best practices in Nicaragua;
- renewed critical thinking with regards to the role of universities and the third sector in conflicts shaped by political violence;
- a realistic assessment of the feasibility of a collaborative research project between the University of Bristol and activist-researchers on the ground.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Memories from the Margins week of public events in Bristol 20-24 March 2023 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This is a big week of events to engage the general public in Bristol and the south-west region with the findings of the Bringing Memories in from the Margins and the Truth on the Margins project.
It takes place just after the Researchfish submission deadline (20-24 March) so we will compete with full details in 2024. It includes 6 events - a gig, a theatre performance, a gala celebration, a film screening, a cookery workshop and a photographic exhibition - and the launch of 7 outputs - a photobook, a website, an interactive documentary, a comic book, a CD, an educational guide and an infographic. Details of all of these will be completed on Researchfish in 2024. At present (8 March 2023) we are finalising these events and outputs. We expect the impact of these events to the substantial in changing people's understanding of the impact of armed conflict in Colombia and around the world.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/bringing-memories-in-from-the-margins-tickets-566463988037
 
Description Peace Festival main event in Ayacucho, Peru, October 2019. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact 45 memory and peace activists from 20 organisations from Peru, Colombia, Nicaragua, Guatemala, and Cuba gathered during the week of the Peace Festival in Ayacucho, October 2019. They exchange knowledge on creative methodologies to work on memory and peace in violent contexts.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Peace Festival seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 20 people attended the seminar to discuss methodology and first findings after the Peace Festival. Seminar was held in Bristol end of 2019.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019