📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

The Romantic Ridiculous

Lead Research Organisation: Edge Hill University
Department Name: English, History and Creative Writing

Abstract

This project aims to shift Romantic Studies from the sublime to the ridiculous. In asking 'Is Romanticism ridiculous?' I do not seek to dismiss either the period or its literature as meaningless or unimportant, but to ask instead whether an alternative approach to its aesthetics categories can shift the specialism from a still dominant focus on a narrow canon of individuals to a joyful celebration of collectivity and collaboration. Building on the work of German philosopher Jean Paul Richter, I define the ridiculous as a comic juxtaposition of perspectives, based on an initial failure of understanding. Richter argues that our sense of the ridiculous originates in early interactions with nature, triggering a kind of counter-sublime which reorients the relationship between individuals, imagination, and landscape, focusing on communal responses to the natural world above individual takes. For Richter, the ridiculous is most clearly seen in social interactions, provoking laughter, community, and collaboration between groups of people. This project adopts the ridiculous as a lens through which to read Romantic-period engagements with the natural and social worlds, shifting the emphasis away from encounters between an individual genius and sublime scene to an aesthetic perspective which privileges joyful group dynamics promising moral and spiritual rejuvenation, especially in relation to children and childhood. Throughout the project, Samuel Taylor Coleridge recurs as a philosopher responding to Richter's ideas in his own lecture on wit and humour; as a writer of the ridiculous in relation to nature, society, and childhood; and as a figure of the ridiculous in both Romantic-period and later satires. The project will draw on current debates about aesthetics, particularly Sianne Ngai's work on aesthetic experiences with a lesser affective charge than the sublime, to foreground the ridiculous as an alternative approach to Romantic Studies, originating within Romanticism itself, and reconfiguring it from individual genius to collective joy.
The project will lead to four types of output:
1. A co-authored book on The Romantic Ridiculous, drawing on the spirit of collaboration of Richter's ridiculous, and including work by me and the post-doctoral researcher.
2. A single-authored article (peer-reviewed) responding to Research Question 2, placing Jean Paul Richter's 'ridiculous' aesthetics in relation to 18th- and 19th-century philosophy, and aimed at publication in the leading international journal, Romanticism.
3. A collaborative article (peer-reviewed) responding to Research Question 5, on the legacies of Romanticism in children's literature, aimed at publication in Children's Literature Association Quarterly.
4. A project website, constructed using a free wordpress site, and hosted there for the duration of the project then stored in Edge Hill's Data Archive for the standard time of 10 years after the last request as detailed in the Data Mangagement Plan. The website will include a reflective blog on the development of the exhibition, providing a record of the collaborative activities on the project, as well as a record of the project's 'Table Talks'
Events on the project include:
1. An exhibition entitled 'We Are Not Amused: Laughter in the Nineteenth Century' at the Atkinson, Southport, in November 2019, based on collaborative work with Edge Hill Nineteen, my university's 19thC research group, which will launch 'The Romantic Ridiculous' as a project. This exhibition is scheduled to take place before the start of the AHRC fellowship, demonstrating our already existing relationship upon which the project will build.
2. A travelling exhibition on 'The Romantic Ridiculous and the Romantic Child' produced in collaboration with North West secondary school students and displayed initially at Windermere Jetty: Museum of Boats, Steam and Stories.
3. A series of workshops called 'Table Talks' on new approaches to Romantic Studies

Planned Impact

The project will benefit the following non-academic partners or interest groups:

1. Secondary school students in the North West
Secondary school students study Romantic poetry as part of the National Curriculum. The Romantic Ridiculous aims to change perspectives on the Romantic period by re-describing its preoccupations under new aesthetic principles. The project will engage students in co-producing a travelling exhibition on the Romantic Ridiculous and the Romantic Child, working with holdings at The Wordsworth Trust and Windermere Jetty to engage students in thinking about how Romantic writers represented childhood and the legacies of the Romantic period in contemporary children's literature. Students' views of Romanticism will be both challenged and juxtaposed with more familiar literature, in the form of children's fiction, in order to change their understanding of the period and its literature. The project will work with between 10-30 A-level students, in the first instance, developing links with 2 local schools in order to mitigate the risk of a school dropping out of the project.

2. Secondary school teachers
The project will also engage secondary school teachers in new approaches to Romantic poetry as part of the travelling exhibition and accompanying workshops, exploring alternative activities and interpretations of Romantic writing, involving the teachers in the collaborative activities undertaken by the students. The project will begin by engaging with secondary schools in the local area which already have links with Edge Hill, including St Mary's Catholic High School in Leigh and Rainford High School in Rainford. Teachers will be invited to one of the Table Talks, focusing on Teaching Romanticism. This workshop will discuss how to develop the Impact of the project on a broader scale in future. Two teachers involved in the project will also act as members of the Impact Steering Committee associated with the project, overseeing and guiding the Impact activities associated with it.

3. Partner museums and cultural heritage organizations
The Atkinson museum (including gallery space, a theatre, and library) has dedicated exhibition space for a collaborative project on laughter in the nineteenth century, undertaken by Edge Hill's nineteenth-century research group, and including material inspired by The Romantic Ridiculous. This exhibition will be launched before the beginning of the AHRC-sponsored fellowship. It is included here to demonstrate existing, non-academic interest in the project, and could be used as a location for the travelling exhibition later in the project. Windermere Jetty, as principal partner, and The Wordsworth Trust at Grasmere have dedicated exhibition spaces to display a travelling exhibition co-produced between me, them, and secondary school students, inspired by the themes of The Romantic Ridiculous, particularly the representation of childhood in the Romantic period and responses to this Romantic Child in nineteenth-century and later children's literature. The project will benefit these partner institutions by supporting them to deliver objectives in bringing their work to wider audiences and co-producing knowledge. The exhibition will finally be hosted by Tate Exchange as part of Edge Hill's memorandum of understanding with the Tate.

4. Tourists, visitors, and locals in the Lake District
Tourists, visitors, and locals in the Lake District will be engaged by the travelling exhibition, which will present information on childhood and the Romantic period in innovative and interactive ways, initially with students presenting on their independent research. The exhibition will engage students outside of the Lake District in thinking about the Romantic heritage of the area and will attract their families and others to the area, as well as engaging tourists and locals in the area.

Further information on Impact is provided in the Pathways to Impact statement.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Ridiculous Romantic Portraits / Landscapes 
Description These were joint exhibitions at Windermere Jetty and Wordsworth Grasmere exploring the funny side of Romanticism with a focus on landscapes at the former and portraits at the latter. The PI and postdoc worked with school students and museum curators to develop artistic responses to these themes and put them on display. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact Museums rethought how to engage with the theme of the sublime and how to work with students to develop creative work. 
 
Description The Romantic Ridiculous has both uncovered 'the ridiculous' as a period-specific aesthetic category for thinking about humour and collaboration in there period and theorises 'the ridiculous' as a transhistorical category enabling critical work today by combining established queer and postcolonial paradigms including 'silly theory', 'low theory', and 'vulnerable reading'. Both PI and the postdoctoral researcher associated with the award produced outputs using 'ridiculous theory' both singly and collaboratively (with some of these outputs, including our duograph, forthcoming. The project culminated in two exhibitions exploring ridiculousness in the Lake District, showing a funny side to Romantic preoccupations with the individual and the landscape in displays of Ridiculous Romantic Portraits and Landscapes: these exhibitions demonstrated the creative possibilities of ridiculousness.
Exploitation Route We used 'ridiculous theory' to explore not only Romantic texts but multimedia texts including the 2020 film EMMA., the BBC sitcom Ghosts, and the pop star. Taylor Swift. We propose ridiculousness as a useful lens through which to explore contemporary culture.
Sectors Creative Economy

Education

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

URL https://romanticridiculous.wordpress.com
 
Description An impact case study on the AHRC funded project 'The Romantic Ridiculous' (2020-2022) might begin with local reach with some significance to the North West with the potential for an ICS to be expanded into a broader analysis of the impact of my research tentatively entitled 'Rethinking Romanticism' (after a Radio 3 Free Thinking episode of this title in which I starred as the senior expert in the field). 'The Romantic Ridiculous' has local reach, working with curators at two Lake District museums (both of which have local, national, and international significance) and two North West schools based in areas of some deprivation. There is a rational for starting local in the significance of the Lake District to Romanticism and in trialling schools based material 'rethinking Romanticism' which might have further impact over the rest of the current REF cycle. Curators at Windermere Jetty and Wordsworth Trust commented on how the exhibitions at their museums impacted their own practice in terms of 1) considering how to engage school and family audiences and 2) how to display material innovatively and engagingly. Curators also provided information on how many visitors would have engaged with both exhibitions - ca 10,000 in total. Rita and I were also invited to present on Wordsworth Grasmere's podcast, with our podcast on 'The Romantic Ridiculous' project and exhibitions achieving the most sign ups and highest audience figures of 2022. Wordsworth Grasmere also used imagery from the exhibition for their corporate Christmas card, sending out information on the project to their mailbase. Staff at both schools commented on how the research impacted both the students and themselves in terms of 1) using humour to engage with seemingly solemn literary periods and 2) inspiring joy in themselves and their students through this process. Students at both schools commented on how the research had deepened their understanding of Romanticism and how humour can be used to engage with school subjects. As a case study for how the Impact activities changed student, teacher, and museum staff views of both Romanticism and ridiculousness, I will focus on the development of the James Gillray display for Wordsworth Grasmere's 'Portraits' exhibition. For the group of students who worked on the James Gillray display, we provided a brief explanation of his career as a graphic satirist attacking figures from across the political spectrum in Britain and representing the horrors of the French revolution as a grotesque phantasmagoria. We also provided prints of images including a self-portrait of Gillray in front of a display of his cartoons and famous cartoons like 'New Morality'. Because we were working at Wordsworth Grasmere, the students were also able to view originals of his work. Students from this group were inspired by the current display of local responses to the river Duddon and used the 3D woollen sculptures as inspiration for their work. Instead of a conventional portrait, the James Gillray group produced a 3D graphic satire of their own comprising two goldfish bowls, with contemporary figures transfigured into various fish in the larger bowl threatening a smaller bowl around which they swam. The fish caricatures represented a range of politicians and celebrities, dead and alive, who threatened the stability of the world's ecosystems because of their climate change denialism and/or their xenophobic policies towards refugees. Their sculpture is therefore considerably detached from Gillray's life and work, although the object perhaps shares some characteristics of the 'New Morality' print, with the Duke of Norfolk transfigured into a leviathan bearing with him radicals and revolutionaries transformed into a bestiary of donkeys, frogs, and crocodiles (maybe there is even a pun on Gillray in there somewhere?). All of the Wordsworth Grasmere students provided rationales for their work which were abbreviated for display. The Gillray group's rationale is worth quoting at length: As we were given the cartoonist James Gillray for our piece, we decided to take inspiration from his satirical portrayals of key political figures - in which he created grotesque caricatures of prominent people of his time, attempting to challenge their power. A central principle of the Romanic movement is the idea of sublime natural beauty - as seen in works by Byron, Shelley, and Keats. Instead of thinking about the Romantics as 'ridiculous', we recreated the organic world using a range of man-made materials to show our own ridiculousness. We used materials such as: netting, wire, and plastic to focus on the destruction caused by capitalism and over-consumption. As plastics mainly find themselves in the ocean - with an estimated 8 million tons entering our waters each year - an inspiration for many Romantic poets is soured by the 'ridiculous' elements of modern life. George, a student working on the 'Portraits' exhibition, commented on the experience: Visiting Wordsworth Grasmere felt like stepping into the past, The exhibition of Dove Cottage especially. Walking through the meticulously crafted hallways and rooms, each packed with references of Wordsworth's work and life was a brilliant experience. The Cottage and museum surrounding it gave an English student who only views "Romantic" literature through paper and PowerPoint a real taste of what it was like to be alive at such a different time in history and being able to contribute to the exhibit with my own interpretation of some of the most famous authors of that time is something I am extremely excited about and won't long forget. Staff from the school said: Our Year 12 and 13 students have literally had the most enlightening time visiting the museum, learning more about the Romantics and, more importantly, creating their own artefacts and seeing them on display in such a highly regarded museum. Their understanding was greatly enhanced by the visit to Grasmere which enabled them to have a better grasp of context. Learning about the Romantics has made the students more creative and enabled them to be more imaginative. They used their individual ideas to satirise current affairs and politics... Our students got more involved with, even immersed in, the connections between the present and aspects of the Romantic era. Our Year 12 and 13 students have many works of literature pre-chosen for them in their studies. The exhibition and their contributions to it both empowered and enriched them. Like George, who privileges experience over analysis in Wordsworthian manner, his teachers similarly emphasize Romantic ideals we have inherited: creativity, imagination, self-realisation. Their focus on 'the connections between the present and aspects of the Romantic era' speaks more directly to Reading the Romantic Ridiculous's interest in Romantic legacies, from independent film and TV sitcom to contemporary responses to the climate crisis. We find the teachers' closing words on empowerment moving - really, we had selected a range of texts for the students to choose from, but that small act of selection alone viewed as enriching compared to the narrowness of the current A-level curriculum. Jeff Cowton at Wordsworth Grasmere said: [I]t was a very colourful exhibition, humorous and serious all at once, which attracted our visitors' attention. Our front of house team reported people who were interested and amused by it. It worked well with the webinar, attended by 98 people (though more will have been attending through screen sharing), our highest attendance of the year so far. In addition, 3,500 people saw the exhibition in the 6 weeks it was on. The image from Stephen Collins will be our Xmas card for 2022 - so its impact will carry on until the end of the year. The other school were less involved in the final development of the display due to timing constrainst after Covid. However, students from the school, in this case Katy and Katie, had a chance to reflect upon their experience of visiting the museum and brainstorming exhibition plans and said: 'The Romantic Project has allowed me to understand how poetry can teach fantastic lessons to the youth of today. The opportunity to be part of this project has been riveting and has broadened my knowledge of Romanticism. Thank you so much for allowing me to participate!' - Katy 'Delving deeper into the Romantic literary canon with Andy has completely enthralled me. The project has been extremely helpful during my own studies of the Romantics at A Level. The quirky aspects of the poets that I have learnt about through this opportunity has added a humorous element to the serious societal commentaries of the Romantics.' - Katie Like commentators from the other school, Katy sees the project's strengths lying in the connections between the period and the 'fantastic lessons' it can teach 'the youth of today', although she is unfortunately reticent about these lessons. Katie, like Jeff at Wordsworth Grasmere, connects with the combination of humour and seriousness in the project, linking canonicity with social commentary. Sophie Terrett, Collection Curator with Lakeland Arts, comments on the significance of bringing the students to the site of Windermere Jetty, allowing them 'to meaningfully interact with the collection and pick out the things which mattered to them', adding 'Thanks to the preparatory work done by the academics at Edge Hill University, they were ready to see the collection and the wider lakeshore site through a specific lens and their unique perspectives were very refreshing'. Sophie sees the students' engagement with landscape aesthetics as shaping their engagement with both the location on Lake Windermere and with the museum's collection of boats, Lakeside leisure memorabilia, and paintings. Sophie continues: Regarding the specific theme of the sublime, this way of looking at Windermere is only briefly touched upon in the existing museum interpretation. The primary focus of the main interpretation is the social history of boats on Windermere and their stories of technological development. We really appreciated the opportunity to draw out those links to the sublime in a way that felt natural to the visiting students and encouraged them to view the collection in harmony with its surrounding landscape. The unique nature of the site as a way for young people to access the water is something which the Participation and Learning Team hope to incorporate into future engagement programming. Sophie's focus on the sublime, rather than the ridiculous, emphasizes the gap between public and academic understandings of the Romantic period. Although the sublime is much commented upon in academic writing, it remains a criterion which needs to be re-introduced to foster public engagement with a significant element of Romantic and later responses to the Lake District. Adding the ridiculous to this work of public engagement may have been a step too far? Sophie confirms that 'There were 6564 visitors to the museum during the period the display was in the Wet Dock and, as it was positioned prominently on the main visitor route, we envisage most of those 6564 people should have seen it.'
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description School field trips to Lake District Museums + follow-up workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 50 students visited Windermere Jetty to develop exhibition material on 'Ridiculous Romantics', learning about Romanticism and the process of curation.
30 students visited Wordsworth Grasmere to develop exhibition material etc.
100 students attended follow-up workshops finalising exhibition material.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://romanticridiculous.wordpress.com/2021/10/22/brace-for-impact/
 
Description Table Talk 1: New Approaches to Romanticism and the Natural World - interactive workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact 60 audience members attended, comprising academics, early career researchers, and post and undergraduate students, to participate in a workshop on new approaches to Romanticism and the natural world. My invited speaker recommended we aim to make a record of the Table Talk in the form of a brochure linked to the 'Ridiculous Romantics' travelling exhibition, and work has started on this document.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://youtu.be/QZwLl4KBaqA
 
Description Table Talks II: New Approaches to Romantic Studies and Society 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interactive workshop involving ECRs presenting their work to a mixed academic / non-academic audience
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://romanticridiculous.wordpress.com/2021/06/21/table-talks-ii-new-approaches-to-romantic-studie...
 
Description Table Talks III: New Approaches to Romantic Studies and Childhood 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Workshop involving ECRs presenting their work to a general and specialist audience
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://romanticridiculous.wordpress.com/2021/12/20/table-talks-iii-recording-and-review/