EnDOW Community. Public engagement in orphan works clearance to unlock access to UK film archives

Lead Research Organisation: Bournemouth University
Department Name: Faculty of Media and Communication

Abstract

EnDOW Community is a follow-on project designed to increase public engagement around EnDOW ("Enhancing access to 20th Century cultural heritage through Distributed Orphan Works Clearance"), a 3-years collaborative project funded by AHRC under the Joint Programme Initiative in Cultural Heritage and Global Change (2014-2018). The underpinning EnDOW project has developed an online resource--the Diligent Search Tool (available at http://diligentsearch.eu)--that helps libraries, museums and archives in the complex task of clearing rights in their 'orphan works'. These are works in which copyright still subsists but whose rights holders are unknown or cannot be located. In order to lawfully digitize and make such material available to the public, the holding institutions must prove they have carried out an unsuccessful 'diligent search' of the copyright owners. While this requirement frequently results in a burdensome process, for which many cultural institutions lack resources and expertise, the EnDOW Diligent Search Tool facilitates this task and makes it feasible also to users with no specialized knowledge of copyright law.

Building on the resource created by the underpinning research project, EnDOW Community explores an innovative way of using the EnDOW Diligent Search Tool. This online resource will be used as a crowd-sourcing platform for copyright clearance in the UK film archive sector. In collaboration with the British Film Institute (BFI), this follow-on project will engage a community of volunteers in the task of clearing rights on a large amounts of films and audio-visual works that are potentially orphan works within BFI and other national and regional film archives. This is an untapped and potentially immense wealth of material that may become available to the public as diligent search is systematically carried out on it.

To achieve its goal, EnDOW Community will create a community of volunteers with the skills to clear the rights of audio-visual copyright works by engaging identified cultural institutions (national and regional film archives) to use the online Diligent Search Tool. A dedicated recruitment campaign will be launched across the main UK film festivals and events. Online resources will be activated to assist the volunteers with the performance of diligent searches on a number of titles selected by BFI and the national and regional film archives, including video tutorials, webcasts and discussion forum. As a result of such engagement, the project will deliver a collection of about 300 right-cleared orphan works (films) that the hosting cultural institutions will be able to lawfully exploit and share online. The engagement and expertise generated by this one-year project has the potential to be extended to a wider range of archival material, so that cultural heritage institutions across all sectors can make the most of existing legislation on orphan works and cultural preservation.

Planned Impact

EnDOW Community will create a volunteer base to crowd-source the copyright clearance of a collection of films under the supervision of the British Film Institute (BFI). The project has both immediate and mid-/long-term outcomes. By the end of the one-year project, it will register as 'orphans' 150 to 300 films, which will be immediately available for online dissemination according to current copyright legislation (UK Orphan Works Regulations 2014 and EU Orphan Works Directive 2012). In the longer run, the EnDOW community project will develop the sensibilization of user communities, voluntary groups and the public at large to the problem of orphan works, which need to be 'cleared' of their rights before being digitised and re-used. As a plus, EnDOW Community is a pilot experiment to that create a blueprint for the right clearance of other types of artefacts (music, books, etc.) for which the EnDOW Diligent Search Tool is already equipped.

Strategic dissemination and recruitment of volunteers include intervention at 11 film festivals, with the projection of an explanatory and motivational video, illustrating the orphan works problem and the way users can help and collaborate. The film festivals targeted by the project typically include the projection of older, classical films, which are more likely to be affected by the orphan works legislation.

Moreover, the network of cultural heritage institutions created by the underpinning EnDOW Project will be exploited to illustrate the progress and outcomes of EnDOW Community.

Finally, the EnDOW community will be advertised through a number of blogposts on various websites: the BFI web site; the CIPPM research blog; the BU Research Blog; the Kluwer IP Blog; the IP Kat; the CREATe Research blog, as well as social media such as the BFI Twitter account (819,000 followers). Direct notification on the project and its progress will be circulated among academics and researchers, cultural heritage institutions, EU MPs, EU executives, members of Civil Rights organizations, university students, and practitioners.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Diligent Search Tutorial 1 - An Introduction to Diligent Search 
Description What is a diligent search? And why is it important to digitize orphan works owned by cultural institutions? 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Tutorial video for diligent search exercise on BFI films 
URL https://youtu.be/YbYEvjFb76Q
 
Title Diligent Search Tutorial 2 
Description This tutorial shows how to perform a diligent search on the films listed in the BFI Films List 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Tutorial video for diligent search exercise on BFI films 
URL https://youtu.be/_XWyjE3mE6Y
 
Title Diligent Search Tutorial 3 
Description This tutorial explains how to use the Diligent Search Tool 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The tutorial is being used by users od the diligentsearch tool 
URL https://youtu.be/fV4aWYiTaWk
 
Title Unlocking Orphan Films 
Description Video explaining the orphan works problem and how to help BFI to clear copyrights. Voice over by Mark Cousins. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The video has been launched at the EnDOW Commuty event in November 2020. 
URL https://youtu.be/QjEm1d48ZYY
 
Description The AHRC Follow-on Funding for Impact and Engagement Scheme (FOF) provides funds to support innovative and creative engagements with new audiences and user communities which stimulate pathways to impact. This includes public engagement, active dissemination and commercialisation activities that arise unforeseeably during the lifespan of or following an AHRC-funded project. This scheme does not support continuation of research activities. Since this project does involve any research activity, it did not produce new research findings, but an enhanced impact of the previosly-funded project (EnDOW).
Exploitation Route The resource created to enalble online participation to copyiright cleareance (currently used by BFI) can be used by other cultural heritage institutions. The project team has been approached by some UK institutions interested in taking forward the resource.
Sectors Creative Economy

URL https://diligentsearch.eu/these-films-need-rights-clearance/
 
Description The original EnDOW project main objective is crowdsourcing the right clearance of copyright works. To this end, it heavily relies on the recruitment of volunteers to clear the copyright of works included in the collections of cultural institutions so that they can digitize and publish them, according to the terms of the law. These volunteers, in the EnDOW Community project, were to be recruited mainly at specifically targeted film festivals, where most of the attendees will be classic films lovers, likely interested in volunteering to help with the main goal of the project. 11 Film Festivals have been selected as an ideal recruitment pool, throughout the United Kingdom. Festival organisers all agreed to have the EnDOW team to communicate the goals of the Community project, and to encourage their public to contribute, as volunteers. Because of COVID19 pandemics, all film festivals have been cancelled. They confirmed their support for the EnDOW project and some of them anticipated the possibility of an online edition of the festival. Unfortunately, to date, no online edition is available of any of the 11 selected Film Festivals. No "live" or online recruitment is therefore possible. The EnDOW team has therefore transferred the recruitment campaign entirely on the virtual scene, through social media and online events. All EnDOW social media (Twitter and Facebook) have been animated and enriched. A very successful online Launch Event has been organised on the 18th of November (see Engagement Activities). Several volunteers have been engaged, but of course not as many as originally forecasted. The project team is eager to resume the original recruitment campaign plan whenever film festivals will be accessible in person again.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Collaboration with the British Film Institute 
Organisation British Film Institute (BFI)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The British Film Institute (BFI) used the EnDOW platform to carry out diligent searches for films as part of the BFI's Unlocking Film Heritage which saw 10,000 films from the UK digitised and made available to the UK public via https://player.bfi.org.uk/britain-on-film. This is declared in a letter of support. Here is an excerpt: "The BFI strongly supports this bid in collaboration with the University of Bournemouth. The BFI was an associate partner for the first EnDOW project and Annabelle Shaw, BFI Rights Database Manager, was on the advisory board. The BFI used the EnDOW platform to carry out diligent searches for films as part of the BFI's Unlocking Film Heritage which saw 10,000 films from the UK digitised and made available to the UK public via https://player.bfi.org.uk/britain-on-film. The BFI also supplied film data to the EnDOW project for diligent search testing. In 2017, the BFI published it's Orphan Works on You Tube; https://www.bfi.org.uk/sites/bfi.org.uk/files/downloads/bfi-press-release-orphans-home-christmas-2017-12-20-v1.pdf .
Collaborator Contribution For the EnDOW Community Project the BFI will work with Bournemouth University to build on work to date by identifying a collection and/or titles for rights research and clearance using the EnDOW platform, creating a dataset of rights-cleared orphan works that will be able to be published on one or more of the BFI's online platforms. The BFI will seek engagement across the wider film archive sector, especially its partner National and Regional film archives and through the wider network of Film Archives UK Copyright Group for inclusion of additional film collections and to develop a crowd-clearing community and to provide an example for other cultural heritage organisations on how to use the platform. Using real-life examples of collections/titles will enable the capturing of the challenges of the Diligent Search process. The BFI will reach out on social media and other sector networks to raise awareness of the project and the incentives for engagement with crowdsourcing.
Impact As integral part of the EnDOW Community project, a list of films is published and the public can help with clearing ther rights (e.g. looking for their rights holder). https://diligentsearch.eu/these-films-need-rights-clearance/
Start Year 2015
 
Description EnDOW Community Launch Event - Online 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A virtual launch event was held on Wednesday 18th November from 4 pm.

EnDOW is a project launched in 2015 to help cultural institutions digitise "orphan works". These are works protected by copyright, but whose rights holders are unknown or cannot be located. A huge wealth of cultural artifacts (writings, films, sound recordings etc.) that can only be lawfully digitised and made available to the public after a "diligent search" of the copyright owners has been performed. A burdensome process, for which many cultural institutions lack resources and expertise.

To help cultural institutions, EnDOW has developed the Diligent Search Tool (http://diligentsearch.eu): a public and freely accessible resource that facilitates the task and allows users with no specialized knowledge of copyright to participate in the diligent search process. By engaging users, cultural institutions can reduce the costs of diligent search by up to 200%.

EnDOW Community and the BFI

The aim of EnDOW Community is to engage an online community of volunteers to perform diligent searches on audio-visual works held by the BFI and other UK Regional film archives. Film lovers of any age and background can take part in this project. Thanks to this army of volunteers, at the end of the project a new collection of audio-visual works will be included in the UK Orphan Works Register and it will become available on the website and YouTube channel of the holding institution.

Lastly, the knowledge acquired by clearing the rights of films owned by BFI and other UK Regional film archives will give the chance to extend the use of the Diligent Search Tool to other cultural artefacts, in a potentially infinite process of freedom of artefacts belonging to different cultural heritage sectors.

77 participants atended this event
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://microsites.bournemouth.ac.uk/cippm/2020/03/25/endow-community/