Not Only Dressed but Dressing: Clothing, Childhood, Creativity
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Sussex
Department Name: Sch of Media, Arts and Humanities
Abstract
A vibrant and lucrative part of the global fashion industry, children's dress is also harnessed extensively in museums, schools and heritage sites to bring histories, ideas and artefacts to life. The vociferous popular debates which regularly erupt in relation to specific outfits, practices, occasions or marketing decisions indicate that children's dress today is being taken more seriously than ever before. What children wear reveals fundamental adult assumptions about what children need or deserve, as well as key insights into children's lived experiences and attitudes.
Despite this, scholars and curators to date have given little sustained attention to children's dress and to how dress is used to communicate with children in museum settings. By bringing together academics, curators and creative practitioners at a series of three workshops, this network will galvanise understanding of both clothing and childhood. The workshops will explore:
1. Communication and Usage: How can children's dress be interpreted in fresh ways and used to stimulate creativity in museum and heritage settings?
2. Agency and Intergenerational Control: Across time, what have been the power dynamics between children and adults in relation to dress?
3. Creativity and Play: How can different dress-based practices enable children's self-expression and individuation?
This network has a distinctive focus on the relationship between children's clothing, design, agency and creativity, moving beyond the socio-historical evidence provided by children's dress. It not only brings together UK-based and international scholars from a range of disciplinary backgrounds (including art and design, history, law, literary studies, sociology, and theatre and performance) with expertise in childhood and/or dress, but also seeks to foster dialogue between university researchers, museum professionals and artists in order to forge new methodologies.
Network participants will explore childhood and dress in relation to a range of concerns including gender and sexualisation, race and national identity, children's rights, and activism (e.g. climate protests against fast fashion). Taking place within or showcasing leading collections of children's costume at the V&A Museum of Childhood, the Worthing Museum and Art Gallery, and the Musée du textile et de la mode in Cholet, France, the workshops will explore (specific) garments as a key source but will also position these within and alongside a diverse range of textual, visual and other material sources including memoirs, oral histories, children's books, photographs, paintings, newspaper and magazine coverage, trade items, and ephemera. Network activity aims to generate subsequent collaborative research projects between participants, as well as new creative works inspired by children's clothing.
'Childhood, Clothing, Creativity' responds to changes at the V&A Museum of Childhood, which is currently seeking to redeploy its collection of children's costume as it aims to become the world's leading museum of design and creativity for children, families and young people, and to inspire curiosity and build creative confidence in future generations. Network findings and discussions are planned eventually to feed into education and/or display in the Museum's three new permanent galleries, slated to open in 2022.
The network also engages children collaboratively in the research. Network activity will begin with a collection visit at Worthing Museum where children respond to the clothing on display in creative ways (e.g. writing, drawing, video making), as well as to reflect on their own experiences of clothing. At the three network workshops, the children's responses will underpin the discussion. A final event, held after the grant's conclusion, will launch a section of the project website that archives the children's thoughts and creative work, allowing the children to see how their ideas shaped workshop discussion.
Despite this, scholars and curators to date have given little sustained attention to children's dress and to how dress is used to communicate with children in museum settings. By bringing together academics, curators and creative practitioners at a series of three workshops, this network will galvanise understanding of both clothing and childhood. The workshops will explore:
1. Communication and Usage: How can children's dress be interpreted in fresh ways and used to stimulate creativity in museum and heritage settings?
2. Agency and Intergenerational Control: Across time, what have been the power dynamics between children and adults in relation to dress?
3. Creativity and Play: How can different dress-based practices enable children's self-expression and individuation?
This network has a distinctive focus on the relationship between children's clothing, design, agency and creativity, moving beyond the socio-historical evidence provided by children's dress. It not only brings together UK-based and international scholars from a range of disciplinary backgrounds (including art and design, history, law, literary studies, sociology, and theatre and performance) with expertise in childhood and/or dress, but also seeks to foster dialogue between university researchers, museum professionals and artists in order to forge new methodologies.
Network participants will explore childhood and dress in relation to a range of concerns including gender and sexualisation, race and national identity, children's rights, and activism (e.g. climate protests against fast fashion). Taking place within or showcasing leading collections of children's costume at the V&A Museum of Childhood, the Worthing Museum and Art Gallery, and the Musée du textile et de la mode in Cholet, France, the workshops will explore (specific) garments as a key source but will also position these within and alongside a diverse range of textual, visual and other material sources including memoirs, oral histories, children's books, photographs, paintings, newspaper and magazine coverage, trade items, and ephemera. Network activity aims to generate subsequent collaborative research projects between participants, as well as new creative works inspired by children's clothing.
'Childhood, Clothing, Creativity' responds to changes at the V&A Museum of Childhood, which is currently seeking to redeploy its collection of children's costume as it aims to become the world's leading museum of design and creativity for children, families and young people, and to inspire curiosity and build creative confidence in future generations. Network findings and discussions are planned eventually to feed into education and/or display in the Museum's three new permanent galleries, slated to open in 2022.
The network also engages children collaboratively in the research. Network activity will begin with a collection visit at Worthing Museum where children respond to the clothing on display in creative ways (e.g. writing, drawing, video making), as well as to reflect on their own experiences of clothing. At the three network workshops, the children's responses will underpin the discussion. A final event, held after the grant's conclusion, will launch a section of the project website that archives the children's thoughts and creative work, allowing the children to see how their ideas shaped workshop discussion.
Planned Impact
This network responds not only to scholarly concerns and preoccupations but also to pressing needs and debates issuing from beyond academia. It is designed to benefit the following key groups:
Practitioners in the museum and the heritage sector
The network aims to engage the dozens of UK museums with collections of children's costume. In addition to the collections in museums and galleries dedicated to childhood (e.g. V&A Museum of Childhood, Edinburgh Museum of Childhood) or fashion (e.g. Platt Hall), numerous regional museums have such collections, including considerable holdings that are not currently on show--in part because of the complex questions of display and interpretation that are the subject of this network. An even greater number of museums use costume and dress in their education programmes. The project partners have been selected for representing different museological contexts for children's dress: museums of childhood (V&A Museum of Childhood) and of fashion (Musée du textile choletais), and regional museums with significant costume collections (Worthing).
To impact museum and heritage organisations, the network will bring nationally and internationally renowned scholars, curators and artists to network events at project partners; involve curators as central network participants; and work closely with project partners to shape the parameters for the workshops. In addition to a specific workshop focused on innovative redisplay, all workshops will incorporate activities designed to engage with this issue. In particular, network activity responds to the planned redevelopment of the V&A Museum of Childhood and the methodological shift this redevelopment models, from a socio-historical model of childhood to a theoretical and practical engagement with children's creative potential and how this can be harnessed through dress/material culture.
Artists who take inspiration from children's dress
The particular interest in creativity aims to enhance the practice of artists whose work engages children's dress as a resource and point of inspiration (see Visual Evidence). This will take place through hands-on archival work in collections of children's costume but also through the dialogue established between participants who are creative practitioners, and those who are scholars or curators working in this area. The network hopes to inspire the artist participants to produce work engaging with the museum collections they visit; these works will be documented on the project website.
Children and their parents
In addition to being co-producers of knowledge about dress via the network, children and their parents are proposed beneficiaries of this research. This is intended to happen as insights from network discussions reshape how material culture is displayed and interpreted for children, and feed into museum learning aimed at children. The children who attend the initial event will be still more directly impacted, as their voices and testimony will both reshape the understandings of childhood, creativity and dress arising from this project, and influence the curatorial strategies of the heritage organisations involved in the network.
Policy-makers
Governmental interest in children's dress often focuses on commercialisation and sexualisation, as in the Bailey Review completed in 2011. The network seeks to change the policy discussion so that it considers children's dress not only through this (of course important) negative lens but also as a positive part of childhood experiences and a crucial tool for engaging children with heritage and design processes. Dissemination of the research findings to policy-makers will occur through established channels in the two interdisciplinary research centres to which the PI and Co-I belong: the Centre for Innovation and Research in Childhood and Youth (CIRCY) at Sussex, and the Centre for Childhood Cultures at Queen Mary/the V&A Museum of Childhood.
Practitioners in the museum and the heritage sector
The network aims to engage the dozens of UK museums with collections of children's costume. In addition to the collections in museums and galleries dedicated to childhood (e.g. V&A Museum of Childhood, Edinburgh Museum of Childhood) or fashion (e.g. Platt Hall), numerous regional museums have such collections, including considerable holdings that are not currently on show--in part because of the complex questions of display and interpretation that are the subject of this network. An even greater number of museums use costume and dress in their education programmes. The project partners have been selected for representing different museological contexts for children's dress: museums of childhood (V&A Museum of Childhood) and of fashion (Musée du textile choletais), and regional museums with significant costume collections (Worthing).
To impact museum and heritage organisations, the network will bring nationally and internationally renowned scholars, curators and artists to network events at project partners; involve curators as central network participants; and work closely with project partners to shape the parameters for the workshops. In addition to a specific workshop focused on innovative redisplay, all workshops will incorporate activities designed to engage with this issue. In particular, network activity responds to the planned redevelopment of the V&A Museum of Childhood and the methodological shift this redevelopment models, from a socio-historical model of childhood to a theoretical and practical engagement with children's creative potential and how this can be harnessed through dress/material culture.
Artists who take inspiration from children's dress
The particular interest in creativity aims to enhance the practice of artists whose work engages children's dress as a resource and point of inspiration (see Visual Evidence). This will take place through hands-on archival work in collections of children's costume but also through the dialogue established between participants who are creative practitioners, and those who are scholars or curators working in this area. The network hopes to inspire the artist participants to produce work engaging with the museum collections they visit; these works will be documented on the project website.
Children and their parents
In addition to being co-producers of knowledge about dress via the network, children and their parents are proposed beneficiaries of this research. This is intended to happen as insights from network discussions reshape how material culture is displayed and interpreted for children, and feed into museum learning aimed at children. The children who attend the initial event will be still more directly impacted, as their voices and testimony will both reshape the understandings of childhood, creativity and dress arising from this project, and influence the curatorial strategies of the heritage organisations involved in the network.
Policy-makers
Governmental interest in children's dress often focuses on commercialisation and sexualisation, as in the Bailey Review completed in 2011. The network seeks to change the policy discussion so that it considers children's dress not only through this (of course important) negative lens but also as a positive part of childhood experiences and a crucial tool for engaging children with heritage and design processes. Dissemination of the research findings to policy-makers will occur through established channels in the two interdisciplinary research centres to which the PI and Co-I belong: the Centre for Innovation and Research in Childhood and Youth (CIRCY) at Sussex, and the Centre for Childhood Cultures at Queen Mary/the V&A Museum of Childhood.
Publications
Carroll J
(2023)
Katy Keene as a Ludic Site for Fashion and Self-Fashioning
in Jeunesse: Young People, Texts, Cultures
Field H
(2023)
Special Issue Introduction - Not Only Dressed but Dressing: Childhood, Clothing, and Play
in Jeunesse: Young People, Texts, Cultures
Field H
(2023)
Puzzles, Kits, and Knits: An Interview with Maija Nygren
in Jeunesse: Young People, Texts, Cultures
Pollen A
(2023)
"Indignities Imposed by Arbitrary Adult Rule?" Children's Dress (and Undress) in Progressive Schools in Interwar England
in Jeunesse: Young People, Texts, Cultures
Sage A
(2023)
Fantasies and Realities of Children's Stage Costume: Madame Behenna's Juvenile Jollities, 1925-26
in Jeunesse: Young People, Texts, Cultures
| Description | Our events confirmed the multiple reasons that children's dress is a fascinating area of study. These include approaches to the (physical and digital) display and interpretation of children's clothing, its continued status as a poor relation within fashion and costume history, and its range of reference and context (fancy dress versus everyday wear, not to mention segmentation by age group). Network activities confirmed the need for a scholarly approach which combines analysis of garments alongside and within print materials and other sources and forms of cultural production. They also positioned children and young people as active participants in fashion with a keen sense of personal style and sartorial expertise, thus reflecting children's agency. They confirmed that, though children's dress is often playful, it nonetheless merits serious attention as a fully integrated and intrinsic aspect of childhood studies and of costume history and display. |
| Exploitation Route | The outcomes will be taken forward in at least two ways: 1) In a special issue of the peer-reviewed journal Jeunesse: Young People, Cultures, Texts https://www.utpjournals.press/loi/jeunesse. This contains an introduction by the grant investigators; articles by network participants Jane Suzanne Carroll, Annebella Pollen, and Alice Sage; and an interview with network participant Maija Nygren. It is scheduled for publication in June 2024. 2) In a planned application for Follow-on Funding to enable the investigators to develop an exhibition and engagement programme about childhood and performance, with particular attention to children's costume. |
| Sectors | Creative Economy Culture Heritage Museums and Collections Retail |
| Description | Our project is bringing childhood clothing to a range of new publics and making it a viable and attractive area for museums in the UK and beyond. Key evidence of this is exhibitions that have already taken place (Hancocks exhibition at Worthing Museum) and planned future exhibitions (Cholet). The project has significantly raised the profile of this field across a range of disciplines and beyond the UK, as shown by an upcoming conference in Frankfurt. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2022 |
| Sector | Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Retail |
| Impact Types | Cultural |
| Description | Collaboration between network member and network partner institution |
| Organisation | Worthing Museum |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Charity/Non Profit |
| PI Contribution | We facilitated the event in September 2022 that led to this partnership (one of our network events). |
| Collaborator Contribution | Artist Helen Hancocks exhibited a series of her illustrations at Worthing Museum. The exhibition was called 'Why Do We Wear Clothes?', and it was accompanied by a series of public engagement events, including workshops for children and an artist's talk. |
| Impact | Helen Hancocks exhibition 'Why Do We Wear Clothes?', Worthing Museum and Art Gallery, May-October 2023. |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Description | 'Agency and Control' workshop, V&A |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
| Results and Impact | At this workshop, scholars, curators, and fashion designers examined: what are the power dynamics between children and adults in relation to dress? How can we uncover intergenerational relations, including in past eras? How do the answers to these questions depend on children's ages, social and cultural backgrounds, and other factors? Speakers and participants included: Tamsin Ace (London College of Fashion); Julie Blanchard-Emmerson (University for the Creative Arts); Katy Canales (Young V&A); Nuno Ferreira and Maria Moscati (University of Sussex); Jennifer Farley Gordon (Iowa State University); Ben Hinson (V&A); Jane Pilcher (Nottingham Trent University); Clare Rose; Annamari Vänskä (Aalto University); Ryan Mario Yasin (Petit Pli). Talks were all recorded and are available at the link below. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://www.notonlydressed.com/workshop-2 |
| Description | 'Creativity and Play' workshop, Worthing Museum |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
| Results and Impact | This workshop, held on 8 April 2022, brought together network participants (scholars, curators, and creative practitioners) to investigate the following questions: what is the place of dress in children's lives? How do clothes enable self-expression and foster children's aesthetic sense? Where does clothing intersect with other childhood possessions and obsessions? Speakers included: Jane Suzanne Carroll (Trinity College Dublin), Gerry Connolly and Jojo Lance (Worthing Museum), Nicola Miles (University of Brighton), Maija Nygren (Almaborealis), Alice Sage (Hill Top), Ben Wild (Manchester Fashion Institute), Verity Wilson. Three of the papers presented are forthcoming in the journal special issue that is an output of the network. All of the papers were recorded and are available at the url below. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://www.notonlydressed.com/workshop-1 |
| Description | 'Display and Usage' workshop, Musée du textile et de la mode, Cholet, France |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
| Results and Impact | At this workshop, scholars, curators, and creative practitioners examined: how do children interact with museum dress collections? What models for engagement with costume and fancy dress have been developed by creative practitioners? Speakers and participants included: Gerry Connolly (Worthing Museum); Helen Hancocks; Rachel Hann (Northumbria University); Anne-Charlotte Hartmann (Studio Abi); Aude Le Guennec (Glasgow School of Art); Nicola Miles (University of Brighton); Annebella Pollen (University of Brighton); Josephine Rout (V&A); Tony Rutherford (National Theatre); Dominique Zarini (Musée du Textile et de la Mode de Cholet). One of the papers presented is forthcoming in the journal special issue that is an output of the network. Talks were all recorded and are available at the link below. This event also led to the collaboration between artist Helen Hancocks and Worthing Museum. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://www.notonlydressed.com/workshop-3 |
| Description | Children's workshop, Worthing Museum |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | Local |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | PI Hannah Field participated in a workshop designed by Anna Twinam-Cauchi, the Education Officer at Worthing Museum. The workshop, called 'Dress Up Grow Up', was set up by Anna in response to the themes of the Not Only Dressed network. Twelve children, aged 4 to 9, participated, along with their parents and caregivers (total attendees approx. 30). The workshop modelled how children can engage with museum fashion collections and be encouraged to create their own clothes and fashion-inspired artworks. The children and their caregivers reported the 'fantastic' event changed the way they thought about making objects. The children's artworks will be showcased on the project website and discussed at the workshops for adult network delegates. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| Description | Project website |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
| Results and Impact | We have built the project website and populated it with details about the network, including the project team, participants, and events. There is also now an annotated bibliography and gallery, produced with support from a University of Sussex/University of Chicago Junior Research Associate placement in summer 2021. The website has been designed to be public-facing and user-friendly. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021,2022 |
| URL | http://www.notonlydressed.com |
