#BeObjective #BeKind #Be... Journalists' emotional labour in the era of social media

Lead Research Organisation: Middlesex University
Department Name: Faculty of Arts & Creative Industries

Abstract

The suicide of television presenter Caroline Flack in February 2020 raised on the public agenda the issue of abuse on social media, particularly that targeted at public figures, and the neglect of care for wellbeing and mental health of those who are at the receiving end of this abuse. While we are starting to scratch the surface by discussing these issues, and there are political efforts to regulate online harms, journalists are a group of public communicators who are daily active on social media and deserve immediate attention in this regard. This is because their emotional labour (worker's management of emotion which is required based on the requirements of their job or profession) has been historically heavily neglected by both the academia and industry; they are faced with a range of new challenges in social media environments, and continued overlooking of this issue might result in increased degrees of stress, burnout, depression, anxiety and an estrangement from self within the journalism community.

With the embrace of emotion in daily life and the growing awareness of the effects of negativity and abuse on social media, the traditional advice given to journalists to deal with criticism, such as developing 'thick skin', seems outdated and potentially harmful to journalists' mental health. Yet, alternative advice is rare. Emotional education is missing from the curricula and general coping mechanisms are currently largely individual and include actions such as information avoidance and drinking, as there is no systematic or institutionalised support offered to journalists to deal with issues that arise from their job - such as stress, anxiety and depression.

This project aims to fill that gap with the analysis of the forms and effects of emotional labour present in social media journalism and exploration of journalists' perceptions of best practice to deal with negativity on social media and support systems they would welcome in the process. Alongside these research aims, the project aims to develop guidelines for 'emotional education' which would prepare journalists for exposure to challenges and dilemmas brought about by their work, as well as guidelines for development of support systems for coping with negative effects of the job.

The focus of the study is on the analysis of social media behaviour, experiences and opinions of British political journalists. Methodologically, the project draws on the Digital Methods (DM) paradigm, since its aim is to combine DM with traditional techniques of analysis. Specifically, the project applies a multi-method approach by employing digital ethnography, digital media analysis, content analysis and interviews.

The findings from the project will be published in the manuscript Tweeting Brexit and two journal articles, as well as presented at several conferences and research symposium organised by the PI. A range of stakeholders, including journalists, journalist organisations, educators and publishers, regulators and mental health charities, will be engaged in working groups that will draft recommendations for, on the one hand journalists 'emotional education', and on the other hand wellbeing support for ill-effects of work. Through specialist workshops and discussions on emotional education two key non-academic audiences will benefit from this project: journalism (and other content creating) educators and aspiring media professionals (and emerging content creators in general). The project has broader, transformative potential beyond journalism studies with its aim to raise workplace mental health on the public agenda, which will be achieved through a public roundtable on the topic of journalists' mental health and promotion of project's findings by stakeholders, such as the European Federation of Journalists, which will act as a Project Partner.
 
Description While the award is still active, several objectives have already been met. In particular, during the first year of the Fellowship, the data has been collected and analysed relating to journalists' use of social media, ways in which they negotiate this labour, emotional challenges they face and ways in which they manage these (objectives 5,6,7). The findings contribute to wider international research efforts on these topics and serve to evidence the claims about ubiquitousness of challenges that journalists working on social media face, and the negative effects that exposure to online abuse has on journalists and the wider industry. This data has informed several chapters in the book Tweeting Brexit which has been submitted to Routledge and will be published in May 2022. It has also been presented to and discussed with practitioners and journalists' unions in bilateral talks and stakeholder events.

Additionally, significant new knowledge was generated pertaining to two key topics. On the one hand, insights into journalists' perceptions of what would constitute effective support systems for their well-being and mental health were generated. Some of this data has been presented to journalists working across Europe and their unions at the event organised by the European Federation of Journalists in March 2022. Several unions reported wishing to utilise this evidence in arguing for better support systems for journalists in their respective countries. The data will be further discussed with stakeholders from national and international journalist organisations in working groups scheduled for 29 April 2022 with an aim to establish common guidelines for support systems in the industry (objective 4).

On the other hand, the project unveiled risks from digital connectedness, particularly in relation to embeddedness of smartphones and social media in journalists' daily working routines. Here, journalists who were interviewed for the project spoke of a range of disconnection strategies they employ as preventive and coping strategies to safeguard well-being and optimise work. This issue is largely underexplored in journalism studies and lacks acknowledgment in the industry. It opens up important new research questions about the risks from digital connectedness in this, and related industries, as well as organisational and policy responses that can and should support workers in this aspect of labour.

The project is now in the dissemination phase where significant efforts are being made to meet objectives 1 and 2 - raise the issues of journalists' emotional labour and well-being on the agenda of academics and industry and contribute to informed debates about these. The Fellow has already presented findings on these topics at two academic conferences, sparking academics' interest and contributing to establishment of partnerships with new networks which are working on issues of journalists' well-being. For example, the Fellow joined the Journalism Education and Trauma Research Group, and the Happiness Project that connects scholars investigating journalists' well-being. In terms of raising awareness and informing debates, the Fellow has also published a research article and an analysis piece in the industry magazine on the topic of emotional labour journalists experienced in the pandemic, ensuring the data is available to academic audiences, as well as professional practitioners.
Exploitation Route The data and insights generated in the project might be taken forward by both academic and non-academic stakeholders.

Regarding academic routes, the Fellow has established a partnership with Dr Manuel Menke from the University of Copenhagen. They are working on combining their data in a project that would examine best practice in organisational support for journalists' well-being in a comparative perspective. Further, the Fellow is collaborating with the Journalism Education and Trauma Research Group on publishing findings and applying for a new grant that would build on the project by exploring pathways to building resilience in journalism in the Global South. Further, through the Happiness Project, the Fellow has developed new networks with scholars working on issues explored in the project. She has held several bilateral talks involving data and insight exchanges, ensuring projects' findings can be useful in development of other similar projects.

As to non-academic audiences, the European Federation of Journalists has been briefed on project's data and is looking at using it to inform their labour right initiatives. Representatives of several journalists' unions across Europe have expressed interest in using some aspects of data in creating campaign and support mechanisms relating to tackling online abuse in journalism. A range of other stakeholders, including organisations such as UNESCO, Dart Centre and Rory Peck Trust, as well as media companies such as the BBC and Reach, have accepted invitations to participate in a working group on journalists' well-being organised by the Fellow. This will allow these stakeholders to participate in the discussion of project's data and use these in their own efforts.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Government, Democracy and Justice

 
Description The award has just entered its second year and is still active, so the impact initiatives are mostly in their early stages. To enable impact, the Fellow has worked on establishing networks and relationships with research users, managing to engage a range of stakeholders, from media organisations (e.g., BBC, Reach, New Statesman Media Group) to international organisations supporting journalists' safety and well-being (e.g., European Federation of Journalists - EFJ, UNESCO, Dart Centre, Rory Peck Trust). Early evidence of emerging impact is evident in the knowledge exchange activities undertaken with stakeholders. Specifically, briefing has been carried out with the European Federation of Journalists' policy officer who is looking at the ways in which the EFJ can use the findings to inform their labour right initiatives when it comes to remote working and organisational support for journalists' well-being. Conversations are ongoing with EFJ's Chair of the expert group on labour rights. The findings related to online abuse in journalism and support systems for well-being have been presented and discussed with practitioners, unions, and representatives of stakeholder international organisations (e.g., Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, International Federation of Journalists) at the EFJ event in March 2022. Here, representatives of several European journalists' unions have requested further information that might assist them in designing policies and campaigns for fighting online abuse in journalism. Within academia, findings have been used to develop a manuscript focusing on strategies for managing emotional labour and building resilience in journalism, which has been proposed to a prestigious academic publisher. Three reviewers interrogated it and concluded that it is highly innovative and original, instigating a new research-informed pedagogic approach to media work. The manuscript is currently being produced with a prospective publication date in 2023.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Analysis piece published in an industry magazine 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact An analysis piece discussing some of the findings from the study was commissioned by the editor of the Press Gazette, the British media trade magazine dedicated to journalism and the media, and published on magazine website, as well as promoted in its newsletter and via social media channels. Even based on Twitter analytics alone, the information reached more than several thousand people. Importantly, these are practitioners and industry stakeholders who may act based on the findings about negative impact of digital transformations in the industry, although the impact on decision-making is of yet unknown.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://pressgazette.co.uk/digital-transformations-in-pandemic-affected-journalist-wellbeing-job-sat...
 
Description Briefing with European Federation of Journalists 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The Fellow has met with the Policy and Project Officer at the European Federation of Journalists, the largest organisation of journalists in Europe, representing over 320.000 journalists from 45 countries. The EFJ was briefed about the key findings from the project. Ways in which the organisation can use the data from the project in their efforts and campaigns related to gender equality and protection of journalists' labour rights were discussed, as well as opportunities to present and discuss the findings in international stakeholder meetings and events. Plans were made for the data on online abuse in journalism to be presented and discussed at the EFJ conference "How can gender equality and diversity promote trust in the media?"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://europeanjournalists.org/blog/2022/02/17/final-conference-how-can-gender-equality-and-diversi...
 
Description Discussion about online abuse in journalism with journalists' unions 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Fellow participated in the expert panel 'Tackling online abuse' at the "How can gender equality and diversity promote trust in the media?" event organised by the European Federation of Journalists. She reported data from the project pertaining to the scale of, consequences, and possible solutions to the online abuse in journalism. The audience, comprised primarily of journalists and representatives of journalists' unions, requested further information about discussed evidence by posing questions during and after the panel, reportedly in order to inform their own practice and decision-making. Several journalists and unions have tweeted about the findings presented in the talk, hence making the information available to several thousands of their followers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://europeanjournalists.org/blog/2022/02/17/final-conference-how-can-gender-equality-and-diversi...
 
Description Findings presented at the AJE seminar 'Giving emotional flack jackets to journalism students' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Fellow presented the research-informed pedagogic approach to building emotional intelligence and resilience in journalism education to stakeholders - journalism educators, journalists, and representatives of journalist-centred civil society organisations. The presentation received positive evaluations and sparked a lively debate among participants. Journalism educators commented that the proposed pedagogic approach is original, important and user-friendly, and expressed the desire to learn more about it so they can apply it in their teaching. Based on this presentation, the Fellow also established a collaboration with a research group on trauma informed literacy, with which she made plans for future related activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://ajeuk.org/aje-winter-seminar-2020-giving-emotional-flak-jackets-to-journalism-students/
 
Description Presentation of findings at the PSA Media and Politics Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The Fellow presented the findings from the study in a paper presentation titled 'Pride and Anxiety: British journalists' emotional labour in the Covid-19 pandemic' at the international PSA Media and Politics group conference. The audience, comprised of practitioners, scholars researching this field, and students studying it, engaged in a discussion of journalists' mental health and organisational support for journalists' well-being. Following the presentation, the Fellow established connections with several key stakeholders with whom collaborations are being discussed.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.canterbury.ac.uk/events/PSA-Media-and-Politics-Conference.aspx