Solid Water, Frozen Time, Future Justice: Photography and Mining in the Andean Glaciers

Lead Research Organisation: Royal College of Art
Department Name: School of Art and Humanities

Abstract

Solid Water, Frozen Time, Future Justice (hereafter Frozen Future) is a collaborative visual research project that will document the effects of copper and lithium mining on glacier systems of the Chilean Andes. Extractive industries are encroaching upon these glaciers, and at times of water scarcity, diverting their ice for industrial purposes. The future of glaciers is contested. A water conflict between global mining and local livelihoods is already acute with water rights in Chile stacked in favour of mining interests that may increasingly, perhaps exclusively, depend on solid water supplies. Whilst mining is a global industry, Britain has a particular place in its networks of extraction; London is home to the head offices of the wealthiest corporations which trade in its stock markets. A future of accelerating extractivism is assumed to be inevitable and, most recently, asserted as essential to global economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic. But glacier systems are not simply subject to corporate agency: environmentalists, activists, indigenous and local communities imagine another future of environmental justice. Frozen Future will document how extractivism at glacial sites is contested in the present and projected into the future, prioritising the visibility and the voices of those most affected by mining operations. The research re-thinks the capacity of photography as a means of recording past events and re-directs the camera towards the future.

Visual research at sites of copper and lithium extraction in Andean glaciers will create new documentary photography, drone imagery, audiovisual projections, two and three-dimensional maps as well as written records and textual analysis. In place of the Romantic representations of glaciers as sublime objects of timeless isolation that have disconnected their stores of solid water from local ecologies and global economies, Frozen Future will record the contemporary glacial extractive zones of the Chilean Andes and demonstrate the entanglements of ice and the position of glaciers within global systems. Connections between local sites of mining and global sites of exchange of capitalised mined materials will be mapped and made visible.

The development of a collaborative arts practice will establish de-colonial perspectives from which indigenous ontologies of the life of landscapes as well as concepts of use of natural resources can be recorded. Collaborations with Chilean environmentalists, activists, local communities and museum curators will enable knowledge of the effects of extractivism upon a future stored in solid water, frozen in ice, to be shared with stakeholders, specialist audiences and wider publics, from arts and ecology researchers in universities to corporate shareholders.

Frozen Future research will generate a 'documentary dispositive' composed of a major photographic exhibition, edited into audiovisual screenings for wider distribution. Both forms of dissemination will increase understanding of the effects of extractivist economies upon glacial and global ecologies. Collaborations between researchers and activists at Chilean glacial extractive zones are extended to environmentalist stakeholder groups based in Europe through participation in the different forums accompanying exhibition and screenings facilitating open debate about redressing the material inequalities of mining and achieving forms of future justice. Frozen Future's collaborative documentary will contribute to a critical aesthetic of the Earth's landscapes. A critique of conventional representations of nature and the possibility of de-colonising landscape photography will form academic publications: a monograph, journal articles and conference papers. Thus, the splendid isolation of glacial systems from a global world filled with a myriad of electrical exchanges is re-examined in Frozen Future and landscapes ruptured by mining are are revealed as living spaces.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Igancio Acosta, Louise Purbrick, Xavier Ribas, Trafficking the Earth, Handle of a Shovel, Overburden in collective exhibition Image Ecology, curated by Boaz Levin and Kathrin Schönegg C/O Berlin, 16.09.2023 to18.01.2024 
Description The large scale photographic installation of 336 images and texts, Trafficking the Earth, redisplayed alongside two new works, art books created by Louise Purbrick, entitled The Handle of a Shovel and Overburden. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The redisplay of Trafficking the Earth and exhibition of two new artbooks in a highly respected and much visited contemporary photography gallery in a European capital city brought to wide audience debates about creating new ecological relationships. The curators explain: "By revealing the links and interdependencies of human and nonhuman life around the world, Image Ecology opposes the assumption of a dualistic understanding of nature versus culture. How can the world be more fairly organized given the challenges posed by ecological, economic, and social crises? The exhibition encourages human action and transnational solidarity, opening possibilities for forward-looking ecological photography practices." 
URL https://www.co-berlin.org/en/program/exhibitions/image-ecology
 
Title Ignacio Acosta, Hyiegia Watches Over Us (2022), a photographic installation in Mining Photography exhibition, Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburg, Germany, 15.7.22? to 31.10.22 
Description Hyiegia Watches Over Us (2022) is an installation of forty photographs, arranged in a four-row grid that explore the links between copper production and water consumption. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact This new photographic work displayed in one of a significant German regional museum, contributes to an inter-discipinary art practice that changes public attitudes towards the visual documents of climate change.The curators statement concludes: "Using historical photographs and contemporary artistic positions as well as interviews with restorers, geologists, and climate researchers, the exhibition tells the story of photography as one of industrial production, showing the extent to which the medium has been deeply intertwined with the human change of the environment. By focusing on the ways by which industrial image production has been materially and ideologically implicated in climate change, rather merely using it to depict its consequences, the exhibition employs a radically new perspective towards this subject." 
URL https://www.mkg-hamburg.de/en/exhibitions/mining-photography
 
Title Ignacio Acosta, Into the Deep: Mines of The Future, video installation, Zeppelin Museum Friedrichshafen, Germany, 26.05.2023 to 05.11.2023 
Description A two screen video installation that focusses upon two sites that are key players in the transition to a "green economy": Kiruna, Sweden's northernmost town, 200 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle and Chile's Atacama Desert, one of the most arid places in the world. In both, extreme and fragile environments, industrial colonisation has fragmented their territories with the profits of state-owned mining companies and multinational corporations are prioritised over the rights of native inhabitants: in Kiruna, over Sápmi or Sámi people and in the Atacama Desert, over the Licanantay people. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The new video work Into the Deep (2023) displayed for over five months in a regionally significant public museum in Germany develops an urgnent and emerging debate about the 'green transistion.' It changes public perception about ecological, social and economic long-term damage caused by mining for 'green energy' materials, including the pressure Indigenous peoples and their ancestral territories, usually marginalised from debate. The work argues that a climate strategy without the participation of Indigenous peoples will be ineffective. 
URL https://tracesofnitrate.org/filter/Exhibitions/2023-Zeppelin-Museum-Friedrichshafen-Germany
 
Title Ignacio Acosta, Xavier Ribas, Louise Purbrick, Intersectional Geographies, curated by Jacqueline Ennis-Cole, Martin Parr Foundation, Bristol. 27.01.2022 to 03.04.2022 
Description Ignacio Acosta, Metallic Threads, three photographs, 2016 Louise Purbrick, Broken Ground, text piece, 2022 Xavier Ribas, Twenty-Eight Points, two photographs, 2014, 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The installation of these three Traces of Nitrate works alter perceptions of the remoteness of extractivism in Chile and bring to public attention the local connections of historical mining relationships. The curator states: 'Intersectional Geographies brings together a diverse selection of photographers whose works address inclusion within society at a time of climate crisis, social distancing and human rights violations.?' And a reviewer: 'Intersectional Geographies unpacks and addresses complex and timely ideas from climate and social justice to extractive mining practices and questions of gender through the work of a diverse and international list of photographic voices working across the conceptual and documentary mode.' Alona Pardo, Curator, Barbican Art Gallery. 
URL http://martinparrfoundation.org/exhibitions/intersectional-geographies/
 
Title Xavier Ribas, In A Dim Light, ProjectSD, Barcelona, 19.1.24 to 30.3.2024 
Description In a Dim Light is a photographic exhibitions that includes the new work Dead Ice: Like Air Trapped in their Lungs (2024), an installation of 40 photographs taken at the Juncal Norte glacier in Chile in January 2023, together with four archival images extracted from the 1959 bulletin of the Museo Nacional de Historia Natural in Santiago de Chile, where the scientific studies of the ice mummy of a child, excavated in 1954 from the Andean summit of El Plomo, were first made public. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2024 
Impact The new work Dead Ice (2024) displayed in a public art gallery in a major European regional capital, Barcelona, for over two months brings new visual imagery of fragile glacial landscapes of Chile threatened by global mining activity to public attention, changing perception about the nature of water as an unlimited natural resources. 
URL https://projectesd.com/exhibition/in-a-dim-light/
 
Title Xavier Ribas, Montequari, 2023, an installation in 2023 - Crisis Climática curated by Gloria Sarabia, at Pontificia Universidad católica de Chile, 13.09.2023 to 26.10.2023. 
Description Xavier Ribas, Monturaqui (2023) is comprised of sound, images and text installation. Audio: sound recordings made by Xavier Ribas, Louise Purbrick and Ignacio Acosta (www.tracesofnitrate.org) in a monitoring well in the water extraction works owned by Minera Escondida in Monturaqui, Chile. Sound editing: Sebastián Jatz Rawicz. Print: Map of the Monturaqui water wells overlaid with the names of archaeological artefacts displayed in the exhibition 'Chile Before Chile', at the Chilean Museum of Pre-Columbian Art, Santiago, Chile. Wall text: Text extracts from the exhibition 'Chile Before Chile' at the Chilean Museum of Pre-Columbian Art, Santiago, Chile. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact This new multi-media work displayed in one of the most important university galleries in captial of Chile, Santiago, for was part of a developing exchange between Chilean academics and Chilean publics about water extractivism and the new legacies of colonialism in South America. 
URL https://tracesofnitrate.org/filter/Exhibitions/2023-Crisis-Climatica
 
Title Xavier Ribas, Monturaqui (2023), a sound and image installation in collective exhibition Seismic Mother (2023) curated by Holly Birtles and Charly Blackburn, Hypha Studios, London, 01.09.2023 ti 28.09.2023. 
Description This edition of Xavier Ribas, Monturaqui (2023) is a sound and image installation comprised of: Audio: sound recordings made by Xavier Ribas, Louise Purbrick and Ignacio Acosta (www.tracesofnitrate.org) in a monitoring well in the water extraction works owned by Minera Escondida in Monturaqui, Chile. Sound editing: Sebastián Jatz Rawicz. Print: Map of the Monturaqui water wells overlaid with the names of archaeological artefacts displayed in the exhibition 'Chile Before Chile', at the Chilean Museum of Pre-Columbian Art, Santiago, Chile. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact Importantly, Hypha Studios, bring new artworks and the complex ideas that carry into accessible public spaces. Please see below: "Hypha Studios are open to the public, creating new forms of engagement in the centre of our communities. A condition of being placed in a free studio are the public events that the artist creates to engage local communities. The public program consists of live music/ exhibitions/ceramic classes/life drawings or other workshops. This is to encourage learning and interest of the public and for the creative's practice to reach a much wider audience. We are reimagining our high streets and engaging local communities by working with councils, architects, developers, shopping centres managers, warehouse owners and commercial landlords all over the country. Our public program that is led by the creatives we place will generate new footfall and support existing businesses." 
URL https://hyphastudios.com/seismic-mother-curated-by-holly-birtles-charly-blackburn/
 
Description Solid Water, Frozen Time, Future Justice: Photography and Mining in the Andean Glaciers has created a large body of audiovisual documentation at the extraction of copper in the high Andes, lithium in the Salars and the appropriation of water systems at these sites. The researchers have made visible fragile ecologies that are being degraded through extractive processes. Photography, film and sound artworks that articulate that life and agency of these ecologies as well as indigenous and activists resistance to global mining are being made accessible through public exhibitions and public events.
Exploitation Route Audiovisual documentation of the ecological destruction of extractive zones is being collected and displayed in the museum sector; it is an important tool of environmental education at all levels; the loss of life and livelihood, biodiversity and local incomes, at particular sites of copper and lithium extraction is of urgent concern for those using both metals in the energy storage systems of the batteries of the 'green transition.'
Sectors Creative Economy

Education

Energy

Environment

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

URL http://tracesofnitrate.org
 
Description The findings of Solid Water, Frozen Time, Future Justice: Photography and Mining in the Andean Glaciers have already been the subject of artworks in a series of art galleries, museums and cultural spaces forming part of collective exhibitions or conference agendas that are addressed to the ecological impacts of mining, the climate crisis and the need for Earth Justice. These exhibitions and conferences share the objective of the award: to contribute to new understandings of the global inequalities of extractivism, human and more than human relationships, and the 'rights of nature'.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

Societal

 
Description Alma Feigis, A conversation with Dr. Louise Purbrick about art, extractivism, and the Anthropocene, podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact This podcast will contribute to Alma Feigis' undergraduate studies; it supported her investigation of artistic work that offers criticism of the Anthropocene. It has yet to be widely shared, the timing of which is dependent upon the academic calendar of end of year shows.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://soundcloud.com/user-210039167/art-extractivism-anthropocene?utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=...
 
Description In the Brine, Royal College of Art, London 15 and 16 June 2023. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact In the Brine was development of the collaboration between Traces of Nitrate, Laboratorio de Artes Gráficas del Desierto de Atacama (LAGDA @_lagda) and the OPEN research group at the RCA.

An interdisciplinary panel:
Professor Anna Korre, Environmental Engineer, Royal School of Mines
Dr Andrew Hughes, Groundwater specialist, British Geological Survey
Dr Evi Petavratzi, Mineral commodity specialist, British Geological Survey
Eliza Collin, Wet Zones, Design Researchers, Design Museum
Dr Sarah Cheang, Vanished Rivers and Indentured Labour, RCA.

was followed by LAGDA workshop that led to the creation of a new textile work AGUA, DÓNDE ESTÁS? and its installation of in Hyde Park.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://tracesofnitrate.org/filter/Events/2023-In-the-Brine-Royal-College-of-Art-London
 
Description Interview for an exhibition catalogue 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This 27 page interview is reproduced in a catalogue of the collective exhibition Reassemblage at the Tenerife Espacio de las Artes for the Tenerife Photography Biennale 2021. The catalogue is edited by curator, photographer and critic Teresa Azorena,

Teresa Azorena, Reassemblaje, Tenerife Espacio de las Artes, Tenerife, 2024, ISBN: 978-84-124928-4-2
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://tracesofnitrate.org/2023-Reassemblage
 
Description Open Forum on Art and Activism: Extractivism and the "Green Transition", Project Space, Phoenix Art Space, Brighton 07-11 June 2023 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact The Open Forum grew from a collaboration between the Laboratorio de Artes Gráficas del Desierto de Atacama (LAGDA, @_lagda) and Traces of Nitrate. Desierto Herido/Scorched Earth, an exhibition of works from the Laboratorio de Artes Gráficas del Desierto de Atacama (LAGDA) explores the ecological harm of extractivism and was the setting for a day workshop hosted by the University of Brighton's Centre for Environmental, Spatial and Cultural Politics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://phoenixartspace.org/Events/project-space-desierto-herido-scorched-earth/