Women in Caribbean Carnival

Lead Research Organisation: Leeds Beckett University
Department Name: Cultural Studies and Humanities

Abstract

The Women in Carnival Research network will be the first international network of carnival scholars and carnival artists focusing on the changing roles of women in carnival (inclusive of anyone who self identifies as a woman).
Its originally also lies in its engagement with both the artistic and academic carnival community and breaking down boundaries between these communities. It will create a cross-disciplinary research group which aims to explore the role of women in carnival in the Caribbean, the US and the UK. Through these workshops, a website and a series of publications, the network will provide a longstanding platform to sustain artistic and academic research on the role of women in carnival culture.
One of the main criticisms aimed at contemporary Caribbean carnivals by traditionalists is that they no longer seek to challenge the power of the establishment but have become a spectacle of the female body. The Women in Carnival research network will explore the role of women in contemporary carnivals through breaking down the traditional masquerade and so-called 'bikini and beads' mas binary in carnival research to examine the many new ways women are participating in carnival; as scholars, artists, performers, traditional mas players, organisers, event curators, designers, calypsonians and steel pan players. In Trinidad carnival 2017 the legendary 80-year-old calypso star Calypso Rose released a hit song entitled 'Leave Me Alone'. Quickly dubbed one of the first feminist calypso songs by the international press, the lyrics warn men to leave women alone on the road and to let them 'free up' and party. The song declares a woman's right to not be harrased by men during Carnival where deeply imbedded patriarchal rules no longer apply and echoes the celebratory freedom of Carnival which is asserted and claimed by women. Calypso Rose's song drew attention a culture of 'victim blaming' amongst Trinidadian politicians and officials in the wake of sexual assaults and the long-standing problem of domestic violence on the island. Following the unsolved murder of a young female Japanese steel pan musician during carnival 2016, who was according to the The Washington Post, found strangled and wearing a yellow bikini, the former mayor of Port of Spain Raymond Tim Kee was reported to have argued that the 'vulgarity and lewdness' of women on the road during carnival was partly to blame for crimes against them. Trinidadian carnival costume designer Anya Ayoung-Chee responded to Calypso Rose's song and the issues highlighted by it by partnering with local artists and activists to design t-shirts, worn by hundreds of Trinidad carnival goers in 2017, emblazoned with the phrases 'Leave Me Alone' - and the Trinidadian English version -'Leave She Alone'. Ayoung-Chee also argues that women out on the streets in large numbers during carnival is an act of political activism in itself; 'coming out in the streets in the tens of thousands, owning your space, owning your freedom [...] what is that besides activism?' (Anya Ayoung-Chee in Powers, The Washington Post, Feb 26 2017). This is just one example of the complex gender and sexual politics at play in the carnival sphere which the network seeks to examine and address. In recent carnivals in Trinidad traditional masquerades such as the 'Baby Doll' mas has been used by social activists to highlights issues of sexual abuse and teenage pregnancy on the island (see Eintou Springer and the Idakeda Group). Carnival offers a space for celebrating and emancipating women but can also replicate deeply patriarchal systems of power imbedded within in its communities. This unique network will connect key carnival collaborators and to gain a profound understanding of the evolving role of women in carnival from a comparative, cross-disciplinary and perspective.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The Women in Caribbean Carnival project PI (Emily Zobel Marshall, Leeds Beckett University) and Co-I (Cathy Thomas, University of California Santa Barbara), with support from project advisor Adeola Dewis (Cardiff University), delivered three international symposiums (Trinidad, Feb 2022, California, May 2022 and Leeds, August 2022) examining the role of women in Caribbean and diasporic carnival following a successful AHRC research networking bid.

The dynamic, collaborative symposiums brought together researchers, artists, performers and other carnival stakeholders in three different diasporic locations; the US, the Caribbean and the UK. The key focus on each workshop was to understand how women in carnival resist oppressive forces through the medium of carnival and to examine the sustainability and future direction of carnival research. The workshops were also focused on bringing academics and artists in conversation with one another to bridge the gap between disciplines and practices.

Each symposium was attended by approximately 50 attendees and we were able to collate feedback from each event which was extremely positive. We discovered that women in these three locations use carnival as a platform to challenge patriarchal ideas about sexuality and femininity. They do this through the medium of dance, costuming, storytelling, music and scholarship. The California and Leeds symposiums were hybrid and recorded with both in-person and online participants from around the world. The Leeds symposium included an art exhibition, a theatre performance and a dance workshop. Dr. Kim Vaz-Deville, who attended from New Orleans and presented on the baby dolls of Madi Gras said:
'The symposium was so thoughtfully organized that students, faculty and scholars from around the world will benefit from the work you, Cathy, and Adeola have undertaken. It was an honour and privilege to present. I look forward to further discussions.' Dance Choreographer and performing artist tweeted that she 'really enjoyed this event, very informative, learned a lot and met good creative professionals that are as passionate as myself for people to strive and keep Caribbean carnival alive and to also interact with new arrivals and different categories. Thank you'.

We have been able to form an active international network of women who are now in regular contact with one another via zoom, whatsaap and email and are working collaboratively on both securing academic funding and on artistic projects, such as securing the funding for the delivery of a Mellon/UNCF funded symposium in Brazil in 2024. This Brazil symposium would be aimed at teaching faculty at UNCF collages run by the Women in Carnival project participants focusing on 'carnival pedagogy.'

As well as running three international workshops, we have collated a database of interviews, photographs and film recordings of participants preparing for carnival, reflecting on their carnival practice and taking part in carnival as well as film footage of each symposium. The project leaders and participants took part in tradition carnival practices in both Leeds and Trinidad (and later, New Orleans Mardi Gras) and were able to reflect on the lived experience of carnival in the symposiums that followed the events. The Women in Carnival website will house the digital materials collected during each research trip, including photographs, audio interviews, interview transcriptions and film. The Women in Carnival website will be hosted by Leeds Beckett University and launched in May 2023 and include a forum space for the network to continue to grow and allow ongoing communication between network members. We are also planning a biannual Women in Carnival newsletter sharing news and opportunities throughout the international network, as well as a tri-annual online meetings and sharing.

Exhibition of Carnival Paintings

We were able to support, with additional funding from the School of Cultural Studies and Humanities QR funds, the creation of a carnival exhibition. 'Danca e Luta', by carnival artist Rhian Kempadoo-Miller draws inspiration from traditional carnival characters such as Baby Doll, Jab Jab, Blue Devil, and La Diablesse. The work provides a social commentary on Caribbean heritage, contemporary politics, feminism and current affairs. It also explores how carnival has historically been used as a vehicle for revolution and change through painting, collage, textiles and digital art. A series of six art prints and original canvases were created by Rhian and displayed as part of the WIC symposium in Leeds. The prints were made into six pull-up stands and are now on permanent display in the student 'Social Learning Space' at the School of Cultural Studies at Leeds Beckett University, Broadcasting Place, Leeds.

Women in Carnival Film

The funding supported the creation of a Women in Carnival film. We commissioned carnival researcher Tola Dabiri to collate interviews, music and mas performances and create, with the support of film editor Josh Hallet, an hour-long film documenting the carnival practices and process of women in carnival in the UK. The film was launched at the August 2022 symposium in Leeds. This helped to centre the Leeds symposium on UK mas makers and carnival artists and increase an understanding in the unique presentation of Caribbean mas in British society. It was also aimed to encourage greater participation in the conference by target audience, UK Carnivalists.

The film, as well as being platformed on the Women in Carnival website, will also be available on the 'Carnival in a Box' website, a online resource site dedicated to archiving and supporting UK carnival arts: https://carnivalinabox.co.uk.

'This is Carnival' Theatre Production

We were are able to provide a platform at the Leeds symposium for the independent Black women-led theatre collective 'Speak Woman Speak' to develop and perform a new play entitled 'This is Carnival', drawing from academic research central to the Women in Carnival network, in consultation with Emily Zobel Marshall. 'Speak Woman Speak' created a bespoke piece which was shared in the Leeds Beckett University theatre space at the Leeds Women in Carnival symposium. This was the result of a partnership between the Women in Carnival network, the 'Speak Woman Speak' theatre collective and the 'The World Reimagined' project, a ground-breaking, national art education project seeking to 'transform how we understand the Transatlantic Slave Trade and its impact on all of us.'

This collaboration was aimed at helping to develop the dissemination of the network and raising the profile of 'Speak Woman Speak' to an international audience, as well as building connections between the network and theatre. The Women in Carnival network and Speak Woman Speak have racial justice and social equality at the heart of what they do and are both focused on the amplification of Black and Brown female voices. 'This is Carnival' has since toured in Scotland and Emily is supporting lead actress and manager Leah Francis to develop her work into a practice-based PhD focused on theatre and carnival as a resource for healing in the Black community.


Key project websites

The women in carnival website test pages - these will be finished and launched in May 2023:

https://www.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/test-pages/dougal/women-in-carnival-research-network/

https://www.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/test-pages/dougal/women-in-carnival-research-network/

Details of the Leeds symposum (August 2022): https://www.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/events/research/women-in-carnival/

Leeds Beckett University blog on Women in Carnival symposium: https://www.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/news/2022/08/leeds-beckett-hosting-special-event-celebrating-the-role-of-women-in-carnivals/

Details of the California symposium (June 2022): https://acgcc.english.ucsb.edu/index.php/women-in-carnival-symposium/.

Youtube recording of the Women in Carnival Symposium in California: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQkiGcyn7eY

Review of California workshop by PhD student Stacey Leigh Ross: https://www.byleigh.com/conference-women-in-carnival/

Kim's Vaz-Deville's keynote presentation in California: https://ladatanews.com/dr-kim-vaz-keynote-speaker-at-women-symposium/

Women in Carnival project in Soca News: https://ladatanews.com/dr-kim-vaz-keynote-speaker-at-women-symposium/

Emily Zobel Marshall Keynote at Oxford Brooks University on Women in carnival: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=qaPhp0-SSaM

Newsday Newspaper article on the Women in Carnival Project in Trinidad (Feb 2022): https://newsday.co.tt/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Newsday-International-Womens-Day-2021.pdf

Emily Zobel Marshall Invited Presentation on Women in Carnival project at the University of Surrey (Oct 2022): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9JIm-nek1E
Exploitation Route The project has helped support the development of researchers in many different stages of their careers and to cultivate creative collaborations between postgraduate, early career and more established researchers who attended the workshops to build enduring academic and artistic partnerships and to promote the importance of interdisciplinary approaches, methods and practices and enable scholarly cross- fertilisation.

The 'Women in Carnival' website will be on ongoing resource for the network and the international carnival and research community. This website will be housed at Leeds Beckett University and launched in May 2023. It will contain images and stories from participants across the globe involved with the Women in Carnival project. It will be aimed engaging both academic and non-academic audiences and form a part of the LBU REF 2026 impact case study and continue discussion and dialogue focused on the role of women in carnival long after the initial workshop activity. Through these medium participants can share ongoing research and activity in the field with network members and the larger artistic and scholarly community established during the workshops.


We are also planning to publish an edited collection of articles and interviews based on research conducted for the project with 'The Caribbean Quarterly' which examines the role of women in carnival today from an artistic and inter-disciplinary perspective. Further plans are for Emily, Cathy and Adeola to publish an pedegogic article in the journal 'Interventions' focusing on the process of trying to 'decolonise' their methodology during the Women in Carnival project reward process.

Another outcome we aim to publish a monograph-length Women in Carnival edited collection with, potential, Duke University Press in 2024. This edited collection will break down class, gender and educational barriers by including a diverse and inclusive range of testimonies, interviews, creative responses and essays by practitioners, artists and academics who form a part of the Women in Carnival network. Through this publication the dissemination of the work of Women in Carnival network will be made available to carnival practitioners, scholars and artists across the globe.
Sectors Creative Economy,Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/test-pages/dougal/women-in-carnival-research-network/
 
Description Cathy Thomas, project Co-I, has been working with Renella Alfred to build the Alfred family a website to profile their contributions to carnival and their unique masquerade. We were able to take scanners and external hard-drives to Trinidad to give to project participants (funded by the University of California) as part of the project. This has supported project participant Eintou Springer to work on her forthcoming poetry collection.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic

 
Description Academic Senate
Amount $12,325 (USD)
Funding ID 8-582401 -19900-7 
Organisation University of California, Santa Barbara 
Sector Academic/University
Country United States
Start 07/2022 
End 07/2023
 
Description Keynote at Oxford Brookes University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Emily Zobel Marshall was invited to deliver her keynote lecture entitled 'Mas Intersections: Women in Carnival' at The 9th International Conference on Carnival Arts and Cultures at Oxford Brookes University on Friday 1 July. You can find our more about the conference here: https://socanews.com/news/oxford-gets-ready-for-carnival-arts-conference
The keynote was recorded and is available on YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=qaPhp0-SSaM
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=qaPhp0-SSaM
 
Description Surrey Black Scholars Lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Surrey Black Scholars Lecture

Emily Zobel Marshall was invited to give a lecture for the Surrey Black Scholars series on 'Carnival and Tricksters of the Black Atlantic' at the University of Surrey. The event was hosted by Dr Gabriele Lazzari and organised by Dr Jay Rowe. The Surrey Black Scholars Speakers initiative is designed to provide Black British students with the 'resources, support and environment necessary to achieve excellence and pursue rich and rewarding careers after graduation.' The talk, which discussed the Women in Carnival project, was well attended by over 50 people and well received. It was recorded an available on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9JIm-nek1E
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9JIm-nek1E