p_ART_icipate - Participatory Art, Design and Facilitation for Social Connectedness

Lead Research Organisation: University of Roehampton
Department Name: School of Arts

Abstract

Through the impact of Covid-19, societal needs for new tools for public interconnectedness, became evident. Research by key UK funding institutions (AHRC, UKRI, ACE) led to a deeper understanding of how participatory art contributes to greater mental wellbeing, but urgent questions remain about effective art facilitation strategies online. p_ART_icipate, a research team of artistic practitioners and Arts & Health professionals, examines the effect of online participatory art on social connectedness, devising clear guidelines for the online facilitation thereof.

Leading researchers (Dr Gingrich, Prof. Havsteen-Franklin, Dr Grant, Dr Tymoszuk), practitioners (Analema Group, NeuroCreate, Noise Abatement Society, Joy of Sound), cultural institutions (Brunel, QMUL, National Gallery), and social and health organizations (NHS, Royal National Institute of the Blind), investigate if and how participatory media art can contribute to perceived social connectedness online. Four artworks explore the potential for collaborative, multi-sensory experiences to increase mental well-being for the general public, as well as disproportionately affected groups. These are:

KIMA: Colour, an immersive art project developed for the National Gallery, interprets classic masterpieces of The National Gallery's collection as 360 sound and video experience. In collaboration with RNIB, Northern Ireland, we investigate whether participatory art can contribute to a sense of perceived closeness, through multi-sensory experiences among partially-sighted and colour-blind people using a wedge stepped model (N=15).

Zeitgeist consists of an interface for real-time visual representation of Flow mental states, measured by EEG headbands. Participants co-create music remotely, while observing visual indicators of their own creative stimulation. Working with Central & North West London NHS Trust Foundation, we assess scales of social closeness (IOS-scale), and wellbeing. Using focus groups, standardized scales (IOS, sWEMWBS), observation and interviews, we gather evidence on effects of participatory art among healthcare workers (N=12), immediately deployable in the Arts & Health context (workshops, team engagements).

KIMA: Voice explores harmonies between participants' voices. Voice frequency, amplitude and harmonies are visually represented, offering an interface for collaboration to participants in remote locations. Working with Joy of Sound, a charity specializing in participatory art for groups with motor-sensory difficulties, we create practice-based work with individuals in care homes unable to express themselves verbally. Building on a pilot with the Centre for Performance Science, we assess whether creative engagement through participatory art correlates with perceived closeness and mental well-being. This N-of-1 study design will apply a triangulation of methods (survey, observation, interviews), on a small sample of 3-5 individuals and their care-workers, recruited via Joy of Sound.

KIMA: Noise focuses on effects of urban noise on health in recreational areas. Building on previous research at Tate Modern with scientist, Prof. Stansfeld (QMUL), this new artwork sonifies noise in urban parks as an interactive, site-specific installation. The audience designs their own soundscapes, be it on site, or from home. This research measures mental wellbeing and social connectedness, in the context of working-from-home professionals (N=60). Recruitment is conducted via BU's public engagement team and includes MA and PhD students.

A larger, quantitative longitudinal study (IOS, sWEMWBS) encompassing all four artworks, assesses social connectedness and wellbeing in the wider public (N=200). All four artworks will be accessible for audiences, regardless of sensory disabilities or age. The research leads to immediately deployable outputs such as publications, exhibition of new artworks, a research report, and a whitepaper to inform future practitioners.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title KIMA Colour (Monet) - guided facilitation video 
Description Developed in co-creation workshops with RNIB, this facilitation video provides context to the 360 artwork KIMA: Colour by the Analema Group produced for the National Gallery. The idea is to interpret an existing artwork and to provide context and accessibility through a purposefully created facilitation video that makes the artwork accessible for sight impaired audiences. mI 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact - A cohort of 8-12 RNIB participants with varying degrees of sight impairments noticed significant change in their experience of artworks. - Findings are being published and shared 
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSijNLuwV
 
Title KIMA Colour - Van Eyck Facilitation Video 
Description The artwork KIMA Colour Van Eyck by the Analema Group had originally been commissioned by National Gallery in 2020. This development forming part of the p_ART_icipate research project resulted in a new facilitation video that revisits the original artwork by providing context and accessibility for the seeing impaired. This new facilitation video was created in collaboration and co-creation workshops with RNIB participants. now provides additional layers to the artwork experience. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The newly created facilitation video now provides context and accessibility to the seeing impaired and recontextualises the original artwork KIMA: Colour Van Eyck by the Analema Group. In addition to the facilitation video, the Analema Group led by Dr. Alain Renaud created a How To video, that would enable Seeing Impaired to experience the artwork while wearing a Woojer belt, a subwoofer wearable, that translates deep sound frequencies in vibrations that can be felt on the body. This add-on co-created with RNIB participants 
URL https://youtu.be/y1Cy_FoJ3xY
 
Title KIMA Colour - Van Gogh - with Narration 
Description While the other two artworks KIMA: Colour Van Eyck and KIMA: Colour Monet remained unchanged, the Analema Group created a new reinterpretation of the original artwork KIMA Colour Van Gogh in collaboration with RNIB. The new artwork includes a narrative layer, letters sent by Vincent Van Gogh to his brother, describing the colours that the 360 sound and video artwork relates to. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact - 8-12 participants of the RNIB p_ART_icipate workshop noticed significant change in experiencing the new artwork. - Findings will be published publically in 2023 
URL https://youtu.be/GSlhzoQUJKo
 
Title KIMA: Colour Van Gogh - Guided Facilitation Video 
Description This new facilitation video co-created in design and co-creation workshops with RNIB, NHS experts and visually impaired and blind participants provides new context to the experience of the artwork KIMA: Colour Van Gogh. Providing historic insights into the creation of the artwork 'A Wheatfield with Cypresses' by Vincent Van Gogh as well as an onboarding introduction into the 360 artwork KIMA: Colour - Van Gogh by the Analema Group commissioned by The National Gallery (2020), this new guided facilitation video is designed to create a more holistic experience, that involves participants by taking them on an emotional journey. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The artwork has been made more accessible to blind and partially sighted people, but also the general public. Feedback by the RNIB members attested the new-gained suitability of the artwork for partially sighted and blind audiences. 
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tAt9KXc8SQ&t=12s
 
Title KIMA: Voice development 
Description The original artwork KIMA: Voice was created for on-site and site specific installations in 2019. KIMA Voice visualise harmonies between human voices as geometric shapes, turning the artwork into a visual tuner. With this new development led by the Analema Group and their programmers Marc David and Gaelle Berton, the artwork is now available online: https://kima-voice.pages.dev (please try logging in with two computers and use your voices to aim to achieve harmonies between your voices). The artwork has been publically premiered at Barbican in November 2022. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The artwork development will allow for the p_ART_icipate user study and co-creation workshops with Joy of Sound in Spring 2023 
URL https://kima-voice.pages.dev
 
Title p_ART_icipate Logic Model 
Description Our wellbeing and mental health services are characterised by discrete interventions based on normalisation and diagnostic change. This leaves gaps in participatory, collective and cultural change for communities, societies and teams, ultimately impacting on social health and wellbeing. Further to this, many communities and teams are not able to meet in person and for various reasons engage more effectively with digital arts, where the main mode of conduct is verbal and usually face-to-face. participatory digital arts exist in discourse with community health frameworks initiated in 2019 and the development of integrated community recovery, medical and psychosocial approaches. Evidence for using digital arts in the UK to change collective wellbeing is still in early stages of development. 
Type Of Material Model of mechanisms or symptoms - human 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The research team is currently refining the logic model and writing it up for publication to be published with Arts & Health impact factor journal in 2023. 
 
Description National Gallery X 
Organisation National Gallery, London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution National Gallery X invited the research team for a research and impact workshop at National Gallery X. National Gallery X, a collaboration between The National Gallery and King's College is a physical space that provides opportunities for artists exploring arts and technology. The research and impact workshop connected researchers of the p_ART_icipate advisory board with external researchers at Greenwich University, NHS CNWL Foundation Trust, RNIB Northern Ireland, the Arts Council England, as well as external researchers such as the artist Natasha Trotman (Royal College of Art, Somerset House) as well as Holly Adams, Pratt Institute, and was moderated by Dr. Ali Hossaini, Director of National Gallery X / King's College London.
Collaborator Contribution p_ART_icipate research collaborators attended the symposium and provided input on impact of participatory art, as well as critical factors in devising best practices in online facilitations. In particular, we presented the research of the first p_ART_icipate case study KIMA Colour to the panel, and received feedback from the attendants.
Impact An article on the findings from the KIMA: Colour case study co-authored by the PI, and Co-Is as well as our RNIB Northern Ireland partners is being written, with a planned conference submission to EVA London Conference in January 2023. We are also refining our pathway to impact for the p_ART_icipate research project based on the findings from this impact workshop.
Start Year 2022
 
Description RNIB 
Organisation Royal National Institute for Blind People
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The development of the collaborative artwork KIMA Colour with participation by The Analema Group as well as the research team including Dr. Oliver Gingrich (PI), Claire Grant (CoI / NHS) and Prof. Havsteen-Franklin (Brunel)
Collaborator Contribution A series of participatory workshops held in September 2022 online between 8-12 members of RNIB chaired by RNIB's Fiona Joyce and Olive Rogers
Impact Presentation of research findings at Transformations Event at National Gallery X with research advisoryboard
Start Year 2022
 
Title KIMA: Voice 
Description KIMA Voice is an artwork developed by The Analema Group. The new web application has been developed by team members Marc David and Gaelle Berton under supervision by Dr. Alain Renaud and Oliver Gingrich. The artwork compares frequencies in two incoming vocal signatures using javascript webaudio API resulting in a server-side interface for sound and music co-creation. Harmonies between two voices result in meaningful shapes, thereby encouraging users to harmonise with each other. The artwork can be experienced anywhere around the globe. 
Type Of Technology Webtool/Application 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact - New software development - Case study with charity Joy of Sound forming part of the p_ART_icipate research will lead to tangible impact 
URL https://kima-voice.pages.dev
 
Description KIMA Voice Public Prototype Presentation at Radical Embodiment event at Barbican 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The new prototype development of KIMA Voice, one of the four case studies of the p_ART_icipate research was publically presented in form of a participatory live demo/performance at the Barbican Centre's Cinema 2. The event was sold out to an audience of 130 guests and featured several films and live performances around the topic of media arts. The demonstration was facilitated by voice performers Victoria Couper and Wynter James and the Analema Group.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL http://www.artinfluxlondon.com/radical-embodiment.html
 
Description KIMA Voice presentation at Extended Senses Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Extended Senses symposium brought together practitioners, academics and researchers to discuss the use of new technology in the arts to extend our senses at University of Greenwich. The festival organised by University of Creative Arts and University of Greenwich was accompanied by an exhibition. The PI and the Analema Group presented the KIMA: Voice development and the paper presentation will lead to the publication in Virtual Creativity Vol 12 / 1 - a peer reviewed journal published by Intellect. The publication has been accepted after peer-review.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.extendedsenses22.co.uk/
 
Description Kick Off Event - Roehampton University 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact This Kick-off event provided all research collaborators with an overview of the activities planned across the 2 year research project period.

We provided a framework for discussion of methodologies, impact, milestones and research outputs, as well as the opportunity for all partners to get to know each other.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://participateresearch.co.uk/events
 
Description National Gallery X impact workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The impact workshop at National Gallery X provided an opportunity for research group participants to align on questions around impact, and outcomes for the activity.

Prompts relating to the four artworks being developed sparked discussions around key themes including accessibility, methodology, facilitation, participation and impact.

The activity was hybrid involving partners in Northern Ireland (RNIB) as well as third parties (Pratt Institute, Royal College of Art, Arts Council of England), and research group participants (NHS CNWL, University of Greenwich, Brunel University, National Gallery, Analema Group).

The workshop took place as part of the Transformations exhibition at National Gallery X, providing us with the opportunity to exhibit all artworks that form part of the p_ART_icipate research project, and to share these developments with the public and a cohort of undergraduate students too.

The exhibition's evening event was live streamed via YouTube.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.artinfluxlondon.com/transformations-ngx.html
 
Description Zeitgeist presentation as part of CARE project at Royal College of Nursing 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Patients, carers and/or patient groups
Results and Impact The CaRE Project: NHS Team Development Celebration and Exhibition invited practitioners, carers, doctors and nurses for an exhibition showcasing the potential for the arts within public care and the NHS. The p_ART_icipate project Zeitgeist forming part of one of our four case studies was exhibited and facilitated to attending carers, doctors and nurses. The research team PI Olive Gingrich and Co-Is Claire Grant and Prof. Havsteen-Franklin were supported by the Zeitgeist team Dr. Shama Rahman (NeuroCreate) and an assistant.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.cnwl.nhs.uk/professionals/cnwl-arts-psychotherapies-service/CNWL-team-care-project-creat...
 
Description p_ART_icipate Development workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was a 2 day workshop at Somerset House with Dr. Alain Renaud / Analema Group, Dr Tom Davis (Bournemouth University), Ghislaine Boddington (University of Greenwich), Prof. Havsteen-Franklin (CoI / Brunel University), Claire Grant (NHS), the PI (Dr. Oliver Gingrich / University of Greenwich) as well as the developer for KIMA: Noise Marc David.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL http://www.participateresearch.co.uk