📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

Making Museum Professionals, 1850-the present

Lead Research Organisation: University of Lincoln
Department Name: School of History and Heritage

Abstract

In the museum sector today, many organisations are campaigning for fairer recruitment and career structures. In the UK, Museum Detox highlights the 'systems of inequality' facing people of colour, while Fair Museum Jobs campaign for museum recruitment based on 'fairness, transparency, equity and inclusivity'. This new network will support and develop such campaigns by investigating the historical roots of the museum professions and the structures that supported them, from the birth of the modern museum (c. 1850) to the present day. It asks how a variety of museum professions came into being, and how they acted to produce particular competences and ways of working. It considers how they reflected and produced hierarchies, especially around race, class, gender, sexuality and disability, and how such hierarchies were challenged and negotiated by those excluded and disempowered by museums. The project is based on the principle that modern museums developed and are developing in an increasingly globalised world, and aims to investigate professional development transnationally, recognising that people, training methods and standards were all highly mobile. It understands museums both as part of colonising Western scholarship, and as sites of potential resistance and social justice. Critically, the network also seeks to develop productive links between academics and museum professionals, creating spaces, practices and outputs for dialogue between past, present and future, and to conceptualise historical practice as a tool to improve accessible professionalisation today.
The network will have three strands: 1) it will think about who is included and excluded by barriers to museum work and professional structures. This means understanding boundaries of race, class, gender, sexuality and disability, and how they have been created and maintained, and considering distinctions between amateur and professional, and 'insider' and 'outsider'; 2) it will consider how museum careers have and continue to play out within museums: we will analyse training, promotion, the range of distinct roles open to museum staff, occupational organisations, and the hierarchies between different kinds of professional in the museum, including the curator, designer, conservator, educator and volunteer; 3) it will investigate the effects of transnational forces on museum professionals, including colonialism, 'development' and war: we will consider professionals' mobility (willing or unwilling), networks of patronage and influence, locations for training and transnational bodies, e.g International Council of Museums (ICOM; est. 1946).
The network will support the development of deep, transnational historical scholarship through three international workshops and a special issue journal. It will also produce and disseminate a set of tools through which the museum sector can campaign against barriers to accessible professionalisation. A central network aim is to inform collective ways of working across HE and the museum sector: the workshops will seek to move beyond the delivery of a series of formal papers, prioritising practical engagement with source material and data from historic and contemporary museums, and shared writing and output production. The network is committed to the development and contribution of emerging and early career researchers and practitioners, and marginalised voices from the museum sector, and aims to democratise the process of research itself by making sure a wider range of voices are heard. Based on ongoing project evaluation, co-written outputs will consider the methods, benefits and challenges of collaboration between historians and museum practitioners, and the ways in which historical methods can be used to understand the museum professions and professionalisation. The network aims to offer a model for a scholarly but campaigning understanding of the museum as a historically produced but contemporaneously responsive instititions.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The project brought together around 60 speakers and over 100 attendees over 3 workshops to present and discuss research and initiatives around the past, present and future of museum work. The workshops used various formats including presentations, discussions, responding to historical material, and writing sessions. They were in person, online and hybrid variously, and programmes, abstracts, recordings and blog posts can be found here - https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/
Attendees and speakers came from all over the world, although there was a majority from the UK. Attendees and speakers encompassed museum professionals, campaigners, volunteers, and academics at all levels from masters student to professor. Contributions covered the entirety of the period 1850-the present and interrogated aspects of museum work including volunteering, conservation, front of house work, design, anthropology and art.
Although the network aimed to gather people and their research/practice rather than to undertake research itself, some key emerging points can be noted:
• The development of museum work solidified inequalities based on race, gender, and class. The way these inequalities functioned in wider society beyond the museum impacted significantly on power structures within the museum.
• Museum workers have used a variety of networks as self-help mechanisms to navigate their careers, including professional associations, subject groups, unions, campaign organisations and community groups beyond the museum
• Networks have supported both inclusivity and exclusivity in museum work
• Significant transnational forces and bodies such as colonialism, UNESCO, ICOM have exported a hegemonic sense of museum professionalism emerging from elite museums in Europe and the US:
• However, other models exist in other parts of the world from which much can be learned: indigenous approaches to knowledge, community-led museology
• The credentials which underlie museum professionalisation can serve both to restrict the people and practices allowed into the museum, and to empower museum workers from the global majority who experience assumptions that they are not as good as European/US workers.
Process: we set out to explore how academics and museum professionals could work together, how we might advance the research agenda on museum work, and how we might create a project which offered meaningful development for ECRs (in museums and academia) and those without institutional affiliation.
• Discussion and response sessions included academics and museum professionals; although we uncovered differences in approaches, we also discovered benefits and strengths of working together, and grew our understanding of what questions and outputs each audience wants and needs.
• ECR member of the core team organised and hosted one of the online workshops, and co-wrote our article.
• Unaffiliated participants were supported to attend workshops 1 and 2

Achievements also include the creation of outputs to share what we have learned. Although not yet published, we have an article on methodologies for museum work research under review, and have had a proposal for a Special Issue accepted. We have also produced a resource designed for museum professionals, digesting in short form a number of papers from the project workshops and drawing out their significance through questions for reflection.
Exploitation Route The project showed that although pockets of research are happening, a large comparative research project is needed to understand museum professionalisation across time and space, in order to make it more accessible and equitable. We are developing a major, research-led new project, involving selected participants from the network, to undertake more primary research into the past, present and future of museum work and workers. This follow on project will uncover and generate new data about the historic development of museum work and professional/peer support groups for museum workers, as well as about current museum careers and the perspectives of those who work in the sector. It will take a transnational approach to uncover and amplify different models of professionalisation, which recognise indigenous and community museum work and workers, which might be of benefit to the UK's museum sector.
Sectors Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

URL http://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk
 
Description Our key impact is intended to be on the museum sector, museum workers, and academics working in various fields of museum studies. Our starting principle was that a lot of work is happening in different contexts but different sectors/national contexts are not always able to discover the work. The museums sector in the UK is currently working to understand and improve access to museum careers; we decided that impact needs further primary research, and campaigning work itself was best carried out by campaign groups rather than by us. Our approach to impact for this project was to support and amplify these campaigns, and to add a historical dimension to what we know about museum work. Because museum professionals from many organisations participated in our workshops, knowledge circulated from academia to the museums sector and back. Our project resource designed for professional use has had 500 views in 6 weeks so far according to Google analytics. Moreover our research has fed into two 'best practice', research and resource publications of the Museums Association UK, written by one of the project team: Inclusive Recruitment and Selection (https://www.museumsassociation.org/campaigns/workforce/inclusive-recruitment/) and Pay in Museums (https://www.museumsassociation.org/campaigns/workforce/pay-in-museums/). Our network also heard about research and best practice in training and supporting museum workers, and while we do not yet have any evidence that this has yet influenced training programmes, curricula, etc we will be seeking this out over the next few years.
First Year Of Impact 2024
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

Policy & public services

 
Description Workshop 1 at the British Museum 
Organisation British Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution In our first workshop, participants discussed the historic recruitment and selection processes of the BM, using BM archival material - a blog post on the topic can be found here - https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/2023/10/25/recruiting-and-selecting-curatorial-staff-at-the-british-museum-in-the-19th-and-20th-centuries-civil-servants-and-the-ideal-of-the-classical-education/. The BM archivist confirms that this material has not previously been used by researchers, thus we have enabled the Museum to more fully understand its own history.
Collaborator Contribution 1. room and resources for one day of Workshop 1 - room, digital whiteboard, screen for powerpoint and playing audio files etc, access to archival material for discussion purposes. 2. staff time and expertise - Francesca Hillier, Senior Archivist at BM, facilitated an advance visit by PI and Co-I to explore and select archival material for the workshop, as well as preparing material for use at the workshop and being part of the whole workshop day 2. 3. staff time and expertise - Alice Bourne-May, Research Manager at BM, organised the room booking, facilities (including digital whiteboard recordings) and catering booking/payment.
Impact So far just the blog post - https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/2023/10/25/recruiting-and-selecting-curatorial-staff-at-the-british-museum-in-the-19th-and-20th-centuries-civil-servants-and-the-ideal-of-the-classical-education/
Start Year 2022
 
Description Workshop 3 at Technische Universitaet Berlin 
Organisation Technical University Berlin
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The PI and Co-I along with a core team including Dr Nushelle de Silva and Tamsin Russell brought intellectual and professional expertise to the collaboration in the form of designing workshops, drafting calls for papers, selecting participants, leading discussions, etc. PI, Co-I and de Silva have extensive experience of research and publication in the field of museum history, and Russell is workforce lead for the Museums Association in the UK.
Collaborator Contribution As host of the final workshop, TU Berlin brought its intellectual and practical experience in museum research and its application to practice. At the time of the workshop several other museum research projects were taking place at the university and there was cross-attendance between them; the partner's links to the museum world in Berlin and beyond (including Benin) also facilitated wider participation. World-leading museum scholars from TU Berlin such as Prof. Bénédicte Savoy and Dr Andrea Meyer provided intellectual input. Moreover the workshop benefited from the facilities of the partner; this included photography during the workshop and student helpers providing practical assistance, designing print material, etc.
Impact Resource for professionals. This output is multi-disciplinary - History; Art History; Museum Studies; Anthropology; Design
Start Year 2022
 
Description Resource for museum professionals 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Our resource summarised the research presented at our workshops for a professional audience - that is, it focused on brevity and sharing the most information in the shortest and most engaging way. Each piece of research presented was accompanied by a number of questions to prompt institutional and professional reflection. One major section focused on historical research into museum work and professionalisation and its relevance for museum professionals today. The resource also included summaries of some key campaigning and support organisations for museum professionals, and outlined what evidence suggests works and does not work to help develop the sector. The resource has been viewed online just over 500 times so far and we are intending to print and distribute at e.g. the Museums Association's annual conference in 2025.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2025
URL https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/outputs/
 
Description Workshop 1: Museum Work: Hierarchies and Barriers, Exclusion and Inclusion 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was the first workshop of the network and featured one day of papers and discussion and one more focused day with invited participants from museums and universities. About 45 people attended the first day when 15 papers were presented (programme available through website URL below); the second day was a focused discussion day with 12 invited participants responding to material relating to the past and present of museum recruitment. Participants came from Europe and North America, were practitioners, academics and campaigners, and represented a range of career stages.
Outcomes - the workshop will inform the formal outputs from the Network including a bid to enable more research activity to take place. These will be produced in the next 12 months. There are some blog posts from the workshop on the website (URL below).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/workshops/
 
Description Workshop 2: Navigating Museum Careers 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 95 people attended the Network's second, online, workshop, including museum professionals, and researchers from organisational studies, conservation, museum studies, and history/art history. Career stages included UG, PGT and PGR students, ECR and established. Participants came from Europe, US/Canada, Africa, New Zealand. 18 papers were presented covering historical and contemporary research and practice by academics, practitioners and campaigners. Videos of presentations are available on the project website (see below). Additionally there were 2 discussion sessions.
Outcomes - the workshop will inform the formal outputs from the Network including a bid to enable more research activity to take place. These will be produced in the next 12 months.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/workshop-2-navigating-museum-careers-resources...
 
Description Workshop 3: Transnational forces 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The third workshop of the network took place in hybrid form: online (13 May 2024) and in person (11-12 June 2024, TU Berlin).
At part 1, 9 speakers presented papers, and a roundtable discussion finished the day. 100 people booked to attend the event. Speakers and attendees included academics, museum professionals, consultants and charity organisers.
At part 2, the first day consisted of papers, conversations and discussions from 17 speakers. Around 20 more people attended, including museum professionals, academics and students. The second day was a writing and planning workshop for the core project team of 5 people.
Both parts of the workshop included participants from the US, Europe, Africa, Asia and Australasia, and a variety of career stages and sectors.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://makingmuseumprofessionals.blogs.lincoln.ac.uk/workshop-3/