📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

Haunting Issues: Children, Spectrality and Culture

Lead Research Organisation: University of Worcester
Department Name: School of Humanities

Abstract

The present moment is in many respects a traumatic time to be a child. Children exist at the intersection of the Covid-19 pandemic which has restricted access to family, friends and education; armed conflicts which are displacing them from their homes; and a climate emergency which is threatening their future. At the same time, the years 2021 and 2022 bring significant landmarks for global thinking on the child. 2022 marks the twentieth anniversary of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child coming into force in the UK, while 2021 saw the launch of 'Children's Commission' on 'the future of childhood'. As such, this timely project, which has the potential to feed into the commission's findings, comes at a moment when the status of the child is both evidently on the international social and political agenda and subject to a variety of threats and destabilisations.

Contemporary culture has for some decades interrogated the precarious nature of modern childhood, an interrogation which frequently registers a specific anxiety about the missing, displaced or otherwise 'spectral' child - the child who is, like a ghost, simultaneously absent and present. These concerns have reached a particular pitch in contemporary culture in recent years. However, to grasp their implications for the ways in which children are understood not only culturally, but socially is an interdisciplinary challenge within and beyond the UK. We propose that by instigating a humanities-orientated approach to areas of contention which are more conventionally considered in terms of social and political science it becomes possible to see the imaginative engagements which have always played a central role in shaping the policies and structures - educational, clinical, familial - which have had the effect of rendering multiple groups of children spectral subjects granted only a haunting presence within public and political discourse. These ghosts can be sensed across a diverse range of sources, including literature, cinema, and folklore, and demand analysis by humanities scholars skilled in drawing out the interplay between cultural constructions of the child and their real-world counterparts.

The research network seeks to address three key questions provoked by the motif of the spectral child. The first of these concerns the child at the boundary of life and death. The second asks how, at a time when the political union of the United Kingdom appears increasingly fragile, conceptions of nationality are generative of certain kinds of spectral children. Finally, in the wake of the Irish Mother and Baby Homes Commission report (2021), the third interrogates the responsibility for care which exists between the State and the child, asking how particular modes of care-giving might occlude, compromise or otherwise allow the child to 'go missing'. To address these questions, the network brings together scholars from the fields of literature, film, history, sociology, and philosophy, to investigate the intersection between childhood states and states of spectrality as registered in imaginative or creative texts. This investigation will take place through three workshops, each taking as their opening session a contribution from a professional outside of arts and humanities scholarship. Three strands of engagement activity (a visual arts project with refugee and asylum-seeking children, a film festival, and a creative writing initiative with children in hard-to-reach constituencies) will run alongside these nodal points in the network's lifespan. The interdisciplinary approach proposed here facilitates a broader understanding of shifting attitudes to the figure of the child, both as emblematic of a previous state of being and as a problematic receptacle for various visions of futurity. In doing so, the network engages with the wider 'Care for the Future' theme, asking what failures of care, broadly understood, might generate such 'haunting issues'.
 
Description Across the duration of its activity, the 'Haunting Issues: Children, Spectrality and Culture' Research Network, through academic dialogue and collaborations with non-academic partnerships, achieved the following:
1) An understanding that cultural representations of the experiences of children and young people engaged in numerous kinds of border crossing have a capacity to highlight the ways in which the politico-legal frameworks which surround such crossings frequently act to deny the presence of the child at the border, and the specificity of their experiences there, frequently with traumatic or deadly consequences to the children involved. Such cultural analysis acts to rebut dominant political narratives around provision for migrant children, and the research emerging from this analysis will be published in a special issue of the journal Children's Geographies in 2026.
2) The establishment of the possibilities of interdisciplinary discourse across the humanities and clinical/therapeutic disciplines for more fully understanding the complexities of grief and mourning in cases of infant loss, miscarriage and infertility, particularly in finding a shared vocabulary for these experiences which might be of use to families navigating these kinds of losses. The establishment of a 'Psychoanalysis, Culture and the Child' discussion group, in collaboration with the Northern School of Child and Adolescent Psychotherapy are ongoing.
3) The potential for the creation of narratives of haunting by children and young people to act as a process through which experiences of marginalisation and social exclusion can be explored and rebutted, and the privileged quality of the genre of the ghost story in particular for achieving this work.
4) The cultural significance of the figure of the neurodivergent child within narratives of the anthropocene and climate collapse, and their function there as correctives to the exploitation of the futural child to come within political discourse on arresting the progress of climate change. A chapter mapping this cultural motif is forthcoming in Dr Arnold's monograph 'Little Strangers: The Spectral Child in Contemporary Literature'
Exploitation Route 1) The finding of the network of the rich potential for the process of creating and telling ghost stories to be productive for providing an accessible space where the experiences of marginalised cohorts can be given voice. This model could be used across the education, arts, culture and heritage sectors with reference to a wide range of demographics experiencing social exclusion.
2) The network's interdisciplinary discussions with clinical colleagues at the Northern School of Child and Adolescent Psychotherapy points towards the ways in which using cultural narratives of haunting (which frequently explore the kinds of losses and traumas colleagues in clinical and therapeutic contexts are addressing) might provide a common vocabulary for working with certain cohorts of patients and clients whose experiences make conventional clinical and theoretical frameworks challenging or distancing.
3) The network's research on the borderised child as spectralised has the potential to be put to work by charitable organisations, and policy makers working with migrant children, with cultural analysis acting as an engine through which policy and practice can be informed to be meaningfully reflective of the experiences of the border crossing child, rather than erasing or homogenising it.
Sectors Creative Economy

Education

Healthcare

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

 
Description The outcomes of our collaboration with New Writing North have resulted in the organisation wishing to take forward the model of academic input into their work with schools and expand it to a number of new cohorts, thus expanding the potential for the impact of the initiative on the young people participating. Senior Programme Manager, Tess Denman-Cleaver stated the following when asked about the impact of the findings on the organisation: This process and the work it has produced is a brilliant example of the potential of how our model of engaging young people can be partnered with academic research to enhance creative experiences for young people.
First Year Of Impact 2024
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

Societal

 
Description The Spectral Child and the Archive 
Organisation University of Leeds
Department University of Leeds Special Collections
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I proposed, organised and chaired the 'Spectral Child and the Archive' event in collaboration with colleagues in the Special Collections department at the University of Leeds, and poets Liz Berry and Kimberly Campanello. The event, which was open to the public, explored the ways in which the poetic form might offer renewed presence and place to such cohorts of children, and the possibilities which arise in the interactions between poet and archive. Professor Kimberly Campanello's MOTHERBABYHOME (2019) and Liz Berry's The Home Child (2023) both constitute long form poetic works which engage closely with the archive in their evocation of the lives of children denied, erased or forgotten by the functioning of various state systems of care, whether the UK's 'Home Child' initiative or the mother and baby homes run by religious orders in the Republic of Ireland. The event opened with a short performance of an extract from MOTHERBABYHOME by Professor Campanello, and which included a number of readings from The Home Child, and discussion ranged across the ethical questions posed by engagement with archival fragments which attest to the lost lives of children removed from their families by the state, the ways in which certain kinds of mourning for these specific losses might be enacted through the creation of literary work, and the connections between the historical events which underpin the work of both poets and contemporary instances of coercive state action towards the child and the family.
Collaborator Contribution Sarah Prescott (Literary Archivist, Special Collections, Leeds University Library) contributed to the organisation of the event, facilitating the use of archival holdings within the event itself, liaising with colleagues in conservation. Liz Berry and Kimberly Campanello contributed their experience of archival research and creative practice to the discussion, in addition to performances of their own work relating to the topics at hand.
Impact This was a multidisciplinary collaboration bringing together literary studies, archive studies, and creative writing.
Start Year 2023
 
Description The Spectral Child and the Law 
Organisation Trinity College Dublin
Country Ireland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I proposed, co-organised and chaired the roundtable event 'The Spectral Child and the Law', hosted by the School of Law at TCD. Other contributions included liaising with the interdisciplinary range of speakers and promoting the discussion to members of relevant academic communities. The roundtable drew together a cohort of creative writers, cultural commentators, clinicians and legal scholars for a discussion on where the child might be understood to be 'missing' in Irish law, both historically and in the contemporary moment. The conversation reflected on how literature might articulate the silences, questions and tensions which exist in Irish law around the figure of the child and of the foetus, in relation to the provision of reproductive healthcare, miscarriage, child loss and infertility, among other issues, particularly in the wake of the 'Repeal the 8th' movement, and the constitutional change which followed it. The event asked how creative work might respond to these absences and the questions they generate in a way which is impactful and meaningful to an audience beyond the legal and medical profession, and the potential of literature to play a vital role in helping societies navigate issues that have historically been highly polarising.
Collaborator Contribution Dr Andrea Mulligan (Associate Lecturer in Law, Trinity College Dublin) acted as discussant and co-organiser for this event, contributing her knowledge of bioethics and Irish reproductive and family law to the discussion. Ms Julika Hudson (doctoral candidate in Law, Trinity College Dublin) spoke on the intersections of her work as a midwife and her PhD project concerning consent and birth trauma, while Ms Jessica Traynor (author of 'Pit Lullabies') and Ms Alice Kinsella (author of 'Milk: On Motherhood and Madness) contributed to a wider discussion on the ability of creative work to articulate socio-legal and ethical complexity in a way that academic discourse may struggle to. Ms Kinsella has since joined the network as an associate member.
Impact This was a multidisciplinary collaboration, bringing together the disciplines of law, medicine, literature and creative writing.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Haunting Issues Blog and Twitter/X Account @HauntingIssues 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The 'Haunting Issues: Children, Spectrality and Culture' blog was established in 2023 and continues to be populated by network members. Due to the platform used to host the site it is not possible to disaggregate views of individual blogs from views of the site as a whole, however, these currently exceed 250. The blog is pitched to general audiences and is promoted via the 'Haunting Issues' Twitter/X account, which also has an international following.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023,2024
URL https://sway.cloud.microsoft/GDltIdiqxke4eZ2c?ref=Link
 
Description New Writing North Ghost Stories Project 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The PI produced materials around the literary ghost story and the ghost story as mode of communication to support the work of a creative writing facilitator working in Excelsior Academy, Newcastle, specifically with pupils from the Roma community. Over a series of weeks, the facilitator used the prompt materials to help pupils generate their own oral, visual and textual ghost stories, creating a large collage style work and a short film based on this work has been commissioned.
The PI is in conversation with New Writing North regarding an ongoing collaboration which would see her produce further material inspired by academic research into ghost stories, the gothic and speculative fiction which has the potential to underpin future creative writing projects with communities of hard to reach children and young people. Longitudinally, it is hoped that this collaboration would see the PI working with New Writing North to generate new models for collaboration between the organisation and academics working in the humanities.
The below is a statement on the impact of the activity for the cohort and the collaborating organisation, written by Tess Denman-Cleaver (Senior Programme Manager - Young People and Communities):

The partnership fitted perfectly with our programme and approach. It offered our team a brief that is informed by literary history, connected to academic research, and engaging for young people. The openness of the brief and the collaborative nature of the partnership allowed us to tailor the project to the young people we felt would best engage with it and get the most out of it. This meant we were able to pair the brief regarding ghost stories and youth voice with an ongoing programme for young Roma people in the west end of Newcastle and use the activity as a vehicle for them to share their own experiences and cultural background, whilst learning narrative tools and improving their confidence with reading and writing as pupils who have been removed from mainstream classrooms due to low literacy, behavioural issues and SEN.

It was an incredibly fruitful partnership in that it led to the young people developing an idea for a short film they would like to make, which we were then - due to our ongoing partnership in the school - able to commission. The group are now in the process of producing this film, which allows them to develop practical, creative and technical skills and will give them a public platform for their voices as artists and young people from a minoritised background, living in area of major disadvantage in the North East of England.

The fact that their work connects directly to ongoing, current academic research is of huge value to these young people, who struggle to engage with mainstream curriculum teaching and which society does not encourage to believe higher education is for them, or that their voices are of note.

This process and the work it has produced is a brilliant example of the potential of how our model of engaging young people can be partnered with academic research to enhance creative experiences for young people.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
 
Description Put me in the Picture: A Visual Art Engagement Project 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Between the 25th and 28th of July 2024, the 'Haunting Issues: Children, Spectrality and Culture' research network collaborated with Midlands-based artist Naziah Angel, the Brushstrokes Community Project (Sandwell) and the New Art Gallery Walsall, on a bespoke visual arts project working with refugee and asylum-seeking children in the West Midlands area. The project emerged as a response to the lack of visibility of the experiences of these cohorts and a desire to offer an opportunity to fold the experiences of children currently seeking asylum in the Midlands into the narratives of their local communities.

The participants who were eventually recruited to the project were a family group who had come to the UK after fleeing political persecution, and comprised three boys aged between 12 and 6 years old. The oldest boy had been sent on ahead of the rest of the family as soon as he was old enough to be allowed to fly on his own, with his mother, younger brother and cousin following as soon as this became possible nine months later. At the time of the project the younger boys had only been in the country for a month and had not been able to attend school due to having their accommodation frequently changed and being moved a long distance away from their initial school site.

Angel worked with the family to produce images and text (in both English and Cantonese) which reflected their sense of themselves and their journey from Hong Kong to the West Midlands. These large-scale images were transferred to sheets of canvas and highlighted with UV and glow-in-the-dark paint to allow different aspects of the piece to come to light in different conditions. The work was entirely participant-led.

The work was subsequently displayed in a public sharing session at the New Art Gallery Walsall, where members of the public were invited to respond to the work and reflect on their own journeys into their local community, and feelings of identity and belonging. One particularly striking set of responses came from a group of adolescent boys who engaged with both the work and myself and Angel, producing brief sketches which reflected their own hybrid cultural identities and sharing images of things which were important to them. One attendee spoke about the importance of his Moroccan and French heritage, and his recent visits to Marrakesh while another spoke about his family's origins in India and Burma.

While the initial reach of the project was small, the outcomes were significant, both for the specific family involved and for the project partners, who are looking to roll out similar initiatives in the future. Discussions are ongoing between the New Art Gallery Walsall and other project partners on the possibility of displaying the work produced by the participants on a semi-permanent basis. The creation of such moments of meaningful and mutual visibility in their new communities, for cohorts of children whose voices may not otherwise be heard, however initially small in scope, was central to the vision for this project, and the qualitative data collected, including the works produced by the participants themselves, attest that this has been successfully achieved.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://sway.cloud.microsoft/GDltIdiqxke4eZ2c?ref=Link
 
Description The Spectral Child and the Archive 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact I proposed, organised and chaired the 'Spectral Child and the Archive' event in collaboration with colleagues in the Special Collections department at the University of Leeds, and poets Liz Berry and Kimberly Campanello. The event, which was open to the public, explored the ways in which the poetic form might offer renewed presence and place to such cohorts of children, and the possibilities which arise in the interactions between poet and archive. Professor Kimberly Campanello's MOTHERBABYHOME (2019) and Liz Berry's The Home Child (2023) both constitute long form poetic works which engage closely with the archive in their evocation of the lives of children denied, erased or forgotten by the functioning of various state systems of care, whether the UK's 'Home Child' initiative or the mother and baby homes run by religious orders in the Republic of Ireland. The event opened with a short performance of an extract from MOTHERBABYHOME by Professor Campanello, and which included a number of readings from The Home Child, and discussion ranged across the ethical questions posed by engagement with archival fragments which attest to the lost lives of children removed from their families by the state, the ways in which certain kinds of mourning for these specific losses might be enacted through the creation of literary work, and the connections between the historical events which underpin the work of both poets and contemporary instances of coercive state action towards the child and the family.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://sway.cloud.microsoft/GDltIdiqxke4eZ2c?ref=Link