Can Cyclin Dependent Kinase Activity be manipulated to control chromosome pairing and recombination in plants?

Lead Research Organisation: John Innes Centre
Department Name: Crop Genetics

Abstract

Abstracts are not currently available in GtR for all funded research. This is normally because the abstract was not required at the time of proposal submission, but may be because it included sensitive information such as personal details.

Technical Summary

Most related chromosomes of wild relatives of wheat exhibit extensive gene synteny along their chromosome length. The genes on these related chromosomes exhibit more than 95% homology at the sequence level. Despite this level of similarity, there is little recombination between wild relative and wheat chromosomes at meiosis due the presence of the Ph1 locus. Ph1 even reduces (homologous) recombination between chromosomes derived from wheat landraces where they are significantly diverged. Deletion of the Ph1 locus allows the chromosomes to behave more like homologous chromosomes and recombine. Recombination involves the initiation of double strand breaks within genic regions and then repair of these breaks. Recent data indicates that whether Ph1 is present or absent, homoeologues pair and the recombinational machinery is loaded. The final marker for crossing over MLH1 is even loaded, but the process then stalls unless Cdk activity is increased or Ph1 is deleted.

Recently a Ph1 like kinase, CDKG, has been identified in Arabidopsis, and it also affects pairing and recombination. This opens up the possibility of exploiting this system for dissecting the regulation of kinase activity during meiosis, including the development of methodology for modulating its function.

To understand the function of these kinases, we will first produce tools such as specific antibodies that will allow their isolation and manipulation. Using these tools, we will assess the behaviour of these kinases and their molecular function, and their interaction with selected classes of small molecules. Finally, we will develop a reliable and robust system for delivering these compounds into wheat and wheat-wild relative spikes at various stages of meiosis, either in the presence of Ph1 or not, and assessing the promotion of either homologous chromosome pairing in wheat itself or homoeologous pairing in the wheat-wild relative hybrid.

Planned Impact

During the next 30 years, as much wheat grain will be required as has been produced since the beginning of agriculture. This will require a step change in breeding strategies. Breeders will need a combination of strategies including exploiting wild relatives of wheat carrying useful traits. One of the limiting factors highlighted by a number of high-level reviews (including by BBSRC) of such strategies is the ability to regulate chromosome exchange or recombination in wheat. The issue is further complicated by constraints placed on chromosome exchange resulting from the presence of related chromosomes. There are examples where wild relatives have been successfully exploited as a novel source of genetic variation for traits in wheat breeding programmes, e.g., the transfer by Sears of leaf rust resistance of Aegilops umbellulata to common wheat saved the US economy billions of dollars.

However, the introgression of genes from wild relatives into wheat is very time consuming and inefficient and therefore fell out of favour. However, international breeding centres have again started to exploit wild relatives to generate synthetic hexaploid Triticum aestivum, creating a "synthetic wheat" breeding programme. Some 25% of elite lines of wheat generated by CIMMYT are derived from crosses to these synthetic wheat genotypes. Having exploited this approach successfully, many argued that to increase yield production in wheat it is imperative to revisit the exploitation of genetic variation available in the wild relatives in breeding programmes. As a result of this, a number of private sector breeders encouraged the reestablishment of wheat alien introgression in the UK public sector, as part of BBSRC's wheat pre-breeding programme.

To facilitate the transfer of genetic variation via wheat/alien introgression, research is required to increase the speed and enhance the efficiency of the process. In brief, wheat/alien introgression involves hybridisation with a wild relative followed by repeated backcrossing to generate lines of wheat carrying an alien chromosome on which a target gene is located. A series of further crosses to specific genotypes/mutant lines are then required before the chromosome of the alien species can recombine with those of wheat, allowing the transfer of the target gene to wheat without linked deleterious effects.

The expected outcome of this project will be the creation of tools to allow breeders to better exploit the genetic potential of wild wheat relatives as well as enhancing "homologous" recombination between more divergent wheat chromosomes. It will provide an indication of how the level and distribution of recombination may be altered in wheat. The immediate beneficiaries will be those involved directly in wheat pre-breeding. The programme will also allow the development of a skills base, particularly in cytogenetics, a dying art in the UK which can be utilised by the next generation of scientists involved in wheat breeding and the larger wheat breeding community.

This research will make a contribution to food security and sustainable agriculture, key objectives of BBSRC's strategic plan. Wheat has been identified as a key crop by BBSRC and it has financially supported a new pre-breeding programme. Ultimately, the farming industry will benefit by having high-yielding, durable wheat cultivars tailored made to suit particular abiotic and biotic conditions. This in turn will have major societal benefits through the production of reasonably priced food produced in an environmentally sustainable manner.
 
Description We have shown how in a polyploid plants, related chromosomes are sorted from truly homologous chromosomes, thus stabilising meiosis, and giving the plant a level of fertility.
We have shown that on polyploidisation in wheat, ZIP4 3B duplicated along with a segment of heterochromatin, and inserted into a Cdk cluster on 5B, creating the Ph1 locus. The Ph1 locus in hexaploid wheat, increases homologous crossovers, restricts homologous crossovers, and ensures correct pairing of the true homologous chromosomes, rather than homologous chromosomes. We have show exploiting Tilling mutants, and now CRISPR mutants of ZIP4 5B, that it is responsible for increases homologous crossovers, and restricting homoeologous crossovers. ZIP4 5B is also responsible for promoting homologous pairing, rather than homoeologous pairing, this is done by improving the efficiency of pairing homologous pairing during the telomere bouquet. We also have shown that fertiliser and low temperatures can enhance exchange between related chromosomes in ZIP4 mutants. We were able to define the factor in the fertilise as being responsible for the effect. Increased magnesium concentrations increased the level of homoeologous crossovers. the ZIP4 5B may also be responsible for improving the efficiency of homologous pairing. A further study has shown that 56% of the meiocytes show meiotic abnormalities in the CRISPR, with 48% exhibiting univalents and 34% exhibiting multivalents. A mutant ph1b line carrying a 59.3Mb deletion of chromosome 5B covering the ZIP4 5B gene exhibited a similar level of meiocytes with meiotic abnormalities, namely 56%, with 47% exhibiting univalents and 44% exhibiting multivalents (defined as the Roberts et al phenotype). This slight increase in multivalents is likely to be simply due to rearrangements carried by the ph1b deletion line.
It is unclear why the duplicated ZIP4 copy inserted into a cluster of Cdks on chromosome 5B, rather than remaining on chromosome 3B. The Arabidopsis Cdk homologue affects chromosome pairing, and rice Cdk homologues exhibit altered meiotic expression on polyploidisation, antisensing the wheat copies did not result in the Roberts et al phenotype (50% of the meiocytes with meiotic abnormalities). The duplicated ZIP4 copy is responsible for these phenotypes. We published a number of papers based on this. Thus a 60 year old story in wheat genetics has finally been resolved
Exploitation Route The ZIp4 tilling mutants are being exploited within private and public sector breeding programmes, both in the UK and internationally. The exploitation of these mutants combined with Mg treatment allows for increased homologous crossover between related chromosomes.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description The research lead to the characterisation of the Ph1 locus, bringing to 60 old story to a close. The characterisation of this characterisation required the generation of ZIP4 5B mutants and the phenotypic of these mutants. These ZIP4 5B mutants can be exploited in pre-breeding programmes to allow introgression of wild relative DNA segments into hexaploid and tetraploid wheat. The ZIP4 tilling mutants have been requested and distributed to private and public sector breeding companies in the UK, France, India and the US. We have just shown in 2021 that one of the ZIP4 TILLING mutants produces a separation of function phenotype. Its exploitation still allows wild relative DNA segments to be intreated into wheat. However unlike previous mutants, the pairing effect is still functional allowing the mutant to be meiotically stable and set high seed number. The mutant should be be exploited in breeding. We have already requests for this line both nationally and internationally.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Conference organiser of PAG San Diego attracting 3800 plant and animal researchers 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I am on the organising committee of the largest plant and animal ag genomics conference attracting some 3800 researchers, policy makers, industry etc
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity Pre-2006,2006,2007,2008,2009,2010,2011,2012,2013,2014,2015,2016,2017,2018,2019
 
Description Either myself or members of my group have given 6 talks on ZIP4 5B as the major Ph1 gene controlling homologous/homoeologous crossover and pairing in wheat and its hybrids 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Of 6 talks on ZIP4 5B (Ph1) gene given, one was UK graduate students; and 5 at international meetings
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020
 
Description Meeting and presentation to discuss interactions between those international groups involved in meiosis research on wheat and barley in Paris 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The meeting has led to the proposal to hold a much larger meeting on cereal meiosis researchers in 2019 at RRes
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Plenary talk at Genomics in breeding meeting, IPK Gatersleben, Germany 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Gave plenary talk at the main crop institute in Germany.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017