Variant antigen profiling: a novel genomic tool for diagnosis and surveillance of animal African trypanosomiasis.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Institute of Infection and Global Health

Abstract

Animal African trypanosomiasis (AAT) is a livestock disease with frequent and devastating effects on animal health and on the development of sub-Saharan nations. This neglected tropical disease is caused by the parasite Trypanosoma congolense, which is spread by biting flies and infects the blood causing chronic anaemia, wastage and ultimately death if untreated. Unlike Human African trypanosomiasis ('sleeping sickness'), which is caused by a related parasite T. brucei, and is declining after successful intervention and much research, AAT remains very common and poorly known. Yet the annual costs of disease and treatment are estimated at ~$4.5 billion across 37 countries. The FAO considers AAT to "lie at the heart of Africa's struggle against poverty", and central to its Millennium Goals. Most research on African trypanosomes is directed at the model organism T. brucei, but given the profound effects of AAT on animals and people, we need research dedicated to the veterinary parasites to determine how parasite variation affects the course and severity of disease.

All African trypanosomes use antigenic variation to avoid the immune response of their host. This involves the replacement of the protein coat covering the parasite surface each time the host produces antibodies to the protein. The protein is called the Variant Surface Glycoprotein (VSG) and is crucial to parasite survival and the severity of disease, determining the length of infection and resistance to innate host defences. The genomes of both T. brucei and T. congolense contain hundreds of VSG genes, of which just one is expressed at a time from a specific expression site. Together, this repertoire of alternative VSG genes is a ubiquitous, but highly variable, feature of trypanosome genomes that constantly changes in response to host immunity. We can use this repertoire to understand how parasites change through space and time, and what effect this has on disease. This project aims to measure variation in VSG repertoire across the T. congolense population, and then produce a novel tool for rapidly predicting the properties of a strain based on its VSG repertoire.

I will produce genome sequences for 40 isolates sampled from T. congolense infections of cows. Until now, analysis of VSG repertoires on a population scale has been avoided because their complexity makes it impossible to use standard tools. Previously, I discovered that T. congolense VSG are divided into distinct types, each defined by unique protein motifs. I will quantify the VSG repertoire in each T. congolense isolate by comparing its VSG to these protein motifs. The relative abundance of the VSG types will produce a 'variant antigen profile' (VAP) for each isolate. To give the VAP some predictive power, I will identify which VSG are actually used in antigenic variation, (and those that might perform some other role), by identifying the active VSG gene present in the specific expression site and expressed on the parasite cell surface. I will also identify significant correlations of VAPs with geography, time, disease severity and parasite relatedness. A tool to generate and interpret a VAP will be accessible online, making it possible to predict the properties of any T. congolense isolate from genome sequence data using variant antigen profiling.

AAT represents an enormous challenge to animal health and economic development in Africa and yet we have no detailed knowledge of how T. congolense varies and how this relates to the kind of disease we see. Such information would improve diagnosis, the efficiency of drug therapy and control measures, lead to earlier and more appropriate treatment for sick animals, and perhaps even identify proteins that could serve as vaccine targets. The time is right to develop a fast and simple approach to making sense of VSG diversity that can unlock the potential of trypanosome genomics for understanding AAT, estimating its risk and mitigating its effects.

Technical Summary

Animal African trypanosomiasis (AAT) is a livestock disease caused by the parasite Trypanosoma congolense, which has a significant negative impact on animal health and productivity across sub-Saharan Africa. Variant Surface Glycoproteins (VSG) are expressed on the parasite surface where they protect against host immunity. The expressed VSG is periodically replaced to evade acquired immune responses through a process of antigenic variation. VSG genes are ubiquitous, highly variable and intimately associated with disease; thus, I aim to develop novel ways of quickly analysing VSG variation and so better understand antigenic variation, parasite transmission and disease phenotypes at the population scale. This project will quantify population variation in VSG repertoire through genome sequencing of 40 T. congolense isolates sampled from natural infections across Africa over a 50-year period. VSG will be extracted from genome sequences based on protein motifs identified previously and typed based on phylogenies revised using these new data. The distribution of total VSG among the various conserved phylotypes will produce a 'variant antigen profile' (VAP) for each strain. How the frequency of individual phylotypes changes through time and space will define specific VSG or VSG clades that are diagnostic of provenance (i.e. particular regions or outbreaks). To confirm which phylotypes encode functional variant antigens, I will characterize VSG expression sites by cloning T. congolense telomeres from ten strains into yeast using the telomere-assisted recombination (TAR) method. I will also identify expressed VSG sequences by mass-spectrometry to confirm that the active VSG is telomerically expressed. This work will result in a method for rapid analysis of VSG repertoire in trypanosome genome sequence data, which is currently lacking, a detailed understanding of VSG variation in T. congolense and of how this diversity relates to parasite populations and disease phenotypes.

Planned Impact

>The UK science research community will benefit from new knowledge and tools relating to parasitology, veterinary science and genetics. These benefits will have an impact on our basic understanding, our ability to analyse highly abundant and variable gene families in diverse genomes on a population scale, and on future African collaborations. These are short term benefits likely to have impact by the end of the project.
>UK research capacity will benefit from the training of postgraduate and postdoctoral researchers and by establishing this laboratory for the high-throughput genomic analysis of parasite populations. This will have impact through the skills in genome analysis that individuals transfer to subsequent positions and through subsequent projects that apply this knowledge to other parasitic diseases in the UK and abroad. These are short term benefits likely to have impact by the end of the project.
>The UK public will benefit through learning about AAT and our efforts to control it. This will have impact by emphasising the generally unrecognized effects of veterinary disease on the prosperity of developing countries. These are short term benefits likely to have impact by the end of the project and ensured through the outreach activities of the IIGH.
>UK society will benefit through the contribution of this research towards the statutory commitment of the UK Government and its agencies towards international development. This will have impact by providing new knowledge that will facilitate African science, and by developing and entrenching collaborations with African research institutes. These are short term benefits likely to have impact by the end of the project.
>UK biotechnology companies could benefit from the commercialization of new tools and by providing diagnostic services to African veterinary sectors. AAT is endemic and the pressure for more livestock production in the coming decades is likely to make prevention of AAT more profitable. This is a long-term benefit, having impact once VAPs are proven and routinely applied.
>African farmers in AAT endemic regions will benefit through improved assessment of risk to their livestock, improved diagnosis of disease and prognosis of illness. This will allow individuals to prevent disease and to manage limited resources for therapy effectively, ultimately resulting in fewer deaths and greater productivity. These are medium term benefits likely to have impact once animal health agencies routinely apply VAPs in disease surveillance.
>African animal health practitioners will benefit through the routine application of VAPs during disease monitoring, providing more precise and data-rich diagnosis of AAT. This will have impact by allowing local researchers to take quicker action to prevent epidemic, to prioritise control measures depending on the nature of the parasite (and its VAP), and to build a population-wide understanding of disease phenotype for the first time. These are medium term benefits likely to have impact once VAPs are routinely using genomics in field surveillance.
>African veterinary policy makers will benefit from routine variant antigen profiling through the new information this provides on parasite population structure, transmission and the relationship between parasite diversity and disease phenotype. This will increase effectiveness of public services, allowing policy makers to assess risk on national scales and prioritize resource use to reduce disease burden. These are long term benefits likely to have impact after the utility of VAPs in disease surveillance is proven.
>African governments and societies will benefit from the precise and data-rich information provided by variant antigen profiling once routinely applied, through greater productivity and efficient land-use resulting from avoidance and prevention of AAT. These are long term benefits likely to have impact after VAPs are routinely used to assess risk and control AAT.
 
Description Using our new method, variant antigen profiling, we have established the global Variant Surface Glycoprotein (VSG) repertoire in Trypanosoma congolense and T. vivax. For T. congolense, this has shown that the species repertoire is defined exhaustively and universally by 15 phylotypes. Discovery of this limited and conserved repertoire opens up the possibilities of improved and more precise disease diagnostics, new avenues to understanding disease outcome, and new multivalent vaccine targets. By experimentally infected tsetse flies with T. congolense, we have discovered that one of these conserved VSG phylotypes is developmentally regulated, that is, only expressed on the surface metacyclic stage parasites, in the fly mouthparts. Along with other parasite proteins exclusively expressed in this part of the life cycle, this VSG is one of our novel candidates for a T. congolense vaccine. We have also characterised the global VSG repertoire in Trypanosoma vivax, the second major cause of Animal African Trypanosomiasis , using variant antigen profiling. In doing so, we discovered that the T. vivax VSG repertoire is limited to ~200 phylotypes that, unlike other parasite species, cannot recombine. This may explain the different disease outcome associated with T. vivax and strongly supports the theory that T. vivax is clonally propagated. Analysis of T. vivax gene expression has also discovered diverse T. vivax-specific cell-surface proteins that are not VSG. We produced a peptide array of these proteins and screened the array with serum from T. vivax-infected cattle from around the world, which identified six proteins as being strongly expressed and naturally immunogenic. These are promising vaccine candidates that have now been expressed in recombinant form and used in immunize mice. Challenge experiments have shown that these proteins are able to provide partial to complete protection against infection. We have made our variant antigen profiling methods available through freely available software (VAPPER).
Exploitation Route We have identified parasite antigens from both T. congolense and T. vivax that can be developed as vaccine candidates. Future studies will also relate the different VSG phylotypes (and their expression profiles) to disease outcome and transmission dynamics to establish how affect virulence. With robust understanding of their diversity, and tools to measure diversity in natural populations, we expect VSG to become valuable epidemiological markers of animal African trypanosomiasis. Proof of this in subsequent studies we are now beginning may lead to new diagnostic tests able to predict, not only infection, but disease prognosis. When applied to experimental infections, our new methods will facilitate a much deeper understanding of VSG expression and how this relates to pathogenesis. Ultimately, more precise knowledge of how pathogens evade the immune system could potentially lead to fundamental new ways to prevent disease.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description We have identified parasite antigens from both T. congolense and T. vivax that have been taken up as vaccine candidates by ourselves (in a subsequent BBSRC project) and by others. This has generated considerable interest in the livestock trypanosome field and efforts are on-going to build a research consortium to exploit these novel proteins for vaccination. I attended a workshop at the Roslin Institute in November 2019 with other academics and representatives of non-academic partner organisations (e.g GALV-med, Gates Foundation) to discuss a proposal for a large research programme to develop novel T. vivax proteins we and our collaborators have discovered into an experimental vaccine.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
Impact Types Societal

 
Description BBSRC Partnering Award
Amount £23,500 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2018 
End 03/2020
 
Description Overseas Development Assistance seed fund
Amount £8,950 (GBP)
Organisation University of Liverpool 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2018 
End 07/2018
 
Description Wellcome Trust Collaborative Award
Amount £2,100,000 (GBP)
Organisation Wellcome Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2018 
End 04/2022
 
Title Variant antigen profiling 
Description We have used our new knowledge of African trypanosome VSG repertoires to establish new methods for rapid extraction and visualisation of VSG repertoires from DNA or RNA sequence data. The metric produced by this approach is called a Variant Antigen Profile, and it can be applied to any strain of T. congolense or T. vivax. We have described this method on our website and we are in the process of publishing a paper describing a software tool (VAPPER). This is in revision as 'Gigascience'. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact We have presented this new approach at multiple recent meetings devoted to animal African trypanosomiasis and it has received considerable interest, since it solves a fundamental problem in trypanosome research - how to accommodate the many thousands of VSG genes in high-throughput genetic screens. To ths end, the method was incorporated into a recent Wellcome Trust Collaborative Award that was funded to explore the physiology of VSG expression. It has also led to new collaborative research projects to apply the method to natural vector infections in Kenya (June 2018) and experimental infections in Brazil (March 2018). 
URL https://github.com/PGB-LIV/VAPPER
 
Title Supporting data for "VAPPER: High-throughput Variant Antigen Profiling in African trypanosomes" 
Description Analysing variant antigen gene families on a population scale is a difficult challenge for conventional methods of read mapping and variant calling due to the great variability in sequence, copy number and genomic loci. In African trypanosomes, hemoparasites of humans and animals, this is complicated by variant antigen repertoires containing hundreds of genes subject to various degrees of sequence recombination.
We introduce Variant Antigen Profiler (VAPPER), a tool that allows automated analysis of the variant surface glycoprotein repertoires of the most prevalent livestock African trypanosomes. VAPPER produces variant antigen profiles for any isolate of the veterinary pathogens Trypanosoma congolense and Trypanosoma vivax from genomic and transcriptomic sequencing data and delivers publication-ready figures that show how the queried isolate compares with a database of existing strains. VAPPER is implemented in Python. It can be installed to a local Galaxy instance from the ToolShed (https://toolshed.g2.bx.psu.edu/) or locally on a Linux platform via the command line (https://github.com/PGB-LIV/VAPPER). The documentation, requirements, examples, and test data are provided in the Github repository.
By establishing two different, yet comparable methodologies, our approach is the first to allow large-scale analysis of African trypanosome variant antigens, large multi-copy gene families that are otherwise refractory to high-throughput analysis. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
 
Description Antigenic variation consortium 
Organisation University of Edinburgh
Department The Roslin Institute
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This consortium is funded by a 4-year Wellcome Trust Collaborative Award to examine VSG expression in diverse experiments. The University of Liverpool is providing all bioinformatic analysis of the data and was central to the application process. Data from our collaborators will come to our laboratory to be analysed and interpreted using the expertise and methods developed during our BBSRC funded project.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners will carry out experiments to manipulate trypanosomes (Glasgow, Edinburgh), then carry out experimental infections in mice and cow (Roslin) using those modified parasites. DNA and RNA from these experiments will be sequenced (Edinburgh) and the data transferred to Liverpool.
Impact None as yet.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Antigenic variation consortium 
Organisation University of Edinburgh
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This consortium is funded by a 4-year Wellcome Trust Collaborative Award to examine VSG expression in diverse experiments. The University of Liverpool is providing all bioinformatic analysis of the data and was central to the application process. Data from our collaborators will come to our laboratory to be analysed and interpreted using the expertise and methods developed during our BBSRC funded project.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners will carry out experiments to manipulate trypanosomes (Glasgow, Edinburgh), then carry out experimental infections in mice and cow (Roslin) using those modified parasites. DNA and RNA from these experiments will be sequenced (Edinburgh) and the data transferred to Liverpool.
Impact None as yet.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Antigenic variation consortium 
Organisation University of Glasgow
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This consortium is funded by a 4-year Wellcome Trust Collaborative Award to examine VSG expression in diverse experiments. The University of Liverpool is providing all bioinformatic analysis of the data and was central to the application process. Data from our collaborators will come to our laboratory to be analysed and interpreted using the expertise and methods developed during our BBSRC funded project.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners will carry out experiments to manipulate trypanosomes (Glasgow, Edinburgh), then carry out experimental infections in mice and cow (Roslin) using those modified parasites. DNA and RNA from these experiments will be sequenced (Edinburgh) and the data transferred to Liverpool.
Impact None as yet.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Brazilian trypanosome genetics 
Organisation Federal University of São Paulo
Country Brazil 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have a collaboration with FUSP to examine genetic diversity among Brazilian trypanosomes. This collaboration has built up over the last five years through mutual exchanges of data and resources, culminating in a BBSRC Partnering Award this year. Young scientists from our lab have travelled to Sao Paulo previously and this award will ensure that students and early-career scientists continue to move between labs over the next two years. In the past, we have assisted the Brazilian group with genomic analysis of trypanosome strains that they have isolated, and we will be hosting Brazilian scientists in Liverpool during 2018 to continue this.
Collaborator Contribution For our part, this collaboration enables us to examine antigenic diversity in Brazil and develop opportunities to develop a vaccine. Brazil is an excellent place to develop a trypanosomiasis vaccine because the parasites are relatively uniform and the disease has a major economic effect that should encourage industrial partners to engage. Our collaborators have provided clinical material for us to assay our antigenic arrays, and genetic material with which to produce antigenic repertoires. Currently, they are providing access to animal research facilities to carry out experimental infections to measure antigenic gene expression.
Impact Manuscripts published, others in preparation. In 2019, a Brazilian postdoctoral researcher visited the University of Liverpool for three months and was trained in Bioinformatics, and subsequently obtained associated employment in Brazil afterwards.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Sequencing approaches to clinical infections in Kenya 
Organisation International Centre of Insect Physiology and Ecology (ICIPE)
Country Kenya 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I and a postdoctoral researcher travelled to Kenya in 2018 to collect material in the field in collaboration with ICIPE staff and students. I am hosting an ICIPE graduate student in my lab for five months in 2019 to analyse the data that have come from these materials. We will publish jointly in 2019.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners at ICIPE hosted us at their field station and provided transportation and basic lab facilities during sample collection. Access to their managed field sites is crucial to our work.
Impact A Kenyan postgraduate researcher obtaining a Wellcome Trust training fellowship, sponsored by Dr Jackson and based at the University of Liverpool, through this collaboration and by exploiting the work described.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Trypanosome vector transcriptomics (Kenya) 
Organisation International Centre of Insect Physiology and Ecology (ICIPE)
Country Kenya 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We will dissect tsetse flies to extract trypanosome parasites before preparing RNA sequencing libraries from infected fly mouthparts. These will be sequenced in Liverpool to test a key outcome of our research relating to VSG expression. The results will provide evidence for subsequent funding applications to develop certain VSG as vaccine candidates. This project will establish a partnership with ICIPE that we intend to expand and elaborate through further funding applications (to study the genomic epidemiology of VSG in naturally infected animals) and through the reciprocal exchange of students and early career researchers. We have signed a memorandum of understanding to this effect.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners at ICIPE will provide access to the their field site in Kenya where we can obtain clinical samples from infected animals, and collect infected flies. ICIPE staff will assist in collecting these samples and in dissecting flies. In future, it may also be possible to collect clinical samples from wild animal reservoirs. These samples are invaluable to the application of new methods developed during our BBSRC grant and ensuring their lasting impact.
Impact A Kenyan postgraduate researcher obtaining a Wellcome Trust training fellowship, sponsored by Dr Jackson and based at the University of Liverpool, through this collaboration and by exploiting the work described.
Start Year 2018
 
Title VAPPER: a tool for quantifying variant antigen repertoire from African trypanosome sequence data 
Description VAPPER combines our scripts for extracting and characterising VSG from trypanosome DNA or RNA sequence data, and visualises the repertoire in comparison with a database of existing parasite strains/experiments in the form of heat maps, principal component analyses and dendrograms. 
Type Of Technology Webtool/Application 
Year Produced 2018 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact The software will be released in June 2018. 
URL https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/492074v1?rss=1