Understanding the role of nitric oxide synthase in biosynthetic nitration

Lead Research Organisation: King's College London
Department Name: Chemistry

Abstract

The aim of this proposal is to gain a molecular understanding of the role of a nitric oxide synthase (NOS) and its product, nitric oxide, in biosynthetic nitration. NOSs catalyse the sequential oxidation of L-arginine to produce nitric oxide (NO). Nitric oxide synthase encoding genes have been identified in large numbers of aerobic bacteria, however, only a handful have been biochemically characterised.
The nitric oxide synthase, TxtD, has been shown to produce NO as a biosynthetic precursor of thaxtomin A, a natural product phytotoxin produced by the plant pathogen Streptomyces scabies. In this biosynthetic pathway, NO is used by the unusual cytochrome P450, TxtE, in a regiospecific nitration reaction to produce L-4-nitrotryptophan, a key building block in thaxtomin A biosynthesis. Recently, other cytochrome P450s, from different Streptomyces strains, have also been shown to nitrate tryptophan. These enzymes produce a different regioisomer, 5-nitrotryptophan. This combination of NOS and cytochrome P450 appears to be an important nitration method in natural product biosynthesis, but one which is still poorly understood.
Investigations into enzymatic nitration thus far, have focused on the nitrating cytochrome P450s e.g. TxtE and use a synthetic NO donor to provide NO during the nitration reaction. In order to understand more about this biochemistry, we are interested in investigating the catalytic combination of NOS and cytochrome P450 in vitro. Thus we have overexpressed and purified the biosynthetic nitric oxide synthase, TxtD, and for the first time, used TxtD to provide NO to cytochrome P450 to facilitate nitrotryptophan synthesis. Our exciting initial studies give us an excellent opportunity to further investigate this fascinating and biologically important transformation and understand how these enzymes function together.
This process is of interest as regioselective nitration is a synthetically challenging reaction. Nitro groups are key functional groups in the synthesis of complex molecules such as pharmaceuticals. However synthetic methods for nitration remain non-selective, often requiring harsh conditions. The discovery of regioselective nitrating enzymes creates the exciting possibility of developing nitrating biocatalysts.
In this project we aim to build on our initial success and fully characterise the NOS/CYP nitrating system. This project will produce important information about natural product biosynthetic pathways which will be of interest in the field of synthetic biology. We will generate insight into the biochemistry of bacterial NOS which are poorly understood but have been implicated in important processes such as antimicrobial resistance, plant-microbe interactions and biodegradation. Further understanding of these enzymes will have an impact on biotechnology, health and agriculture.
Due to our knowledge of this system and our significant preliminary data we will quickly generate high impact publishable data. We have also proposed public engagement activities in order to communicate this fundamental science to the public. This proposal is relevant to BBSRC strategic priorities in "synthetic biology" and "new strategic approaches to industrial biotechnology".

Technical Summary

Recently, for the first time, used a nitric oxide synthase (NOS), recombinant TxtD, to provide nitric oxide (NO) to two different NO dependent nitrating cytochrome P450s (CYP), TxtE and 5-NTSlav, to facilitate regiospecific nitration of L-tryptophan.
TxtD and TxtE are involved in the biosynthetic pathway of the natural product thaxtomin A in Streptomyces scabies. Together, they are responsible for producing the key biosynthetic precursor, L-4-nitrotryptophan. 5-NTSlav was recently discovered to nitrate L-Trp at the 5 position. 5-NTSlav is encoded in the biosynthetic gene cluster of an as yet, unknown natural product, in Streptomyces lavendulae.
This combination of NOS and CYP appears to be an important nitration method in natural product biosynthesis, but is still poorly understood. Investigations into enzymatic nitration thus far, have focused on P450s and use a synthetic NO donor to provide NO during the nitration reaction. Our exciting initial studies, which fully reconstitute the in vivo reaction, give us an excellent opportunity to investigate this fascinating transformation and understand how NOS and CYPs function together. The aims of this proposal are 1) to fully characterise the NOS, TxtD; 2) to understand how NOS and CYPs work together to catalyse nitration; 3) to understand how the proteins react to nitration conditions which can result in nitrosylation and radical nitration of protein residues.
Regioselective nitrating enzymes open up the possibility of developing nitrating biocatalysts. Nitro groups are key functional groups in synthetic chemistry. However synthetic methods for nitration remain non-selective. The results from this work will generate insight into natural product biosynthetic pathways and bacterial NOS biochemistry. NOSs have been implicated in processes from antimicrobial resistance to plant-microbe interactions. Further understanding of these enzymes will thus have an impact on biotechnology, health and agriculture.

Planned Impact

The impacts of this work extend from immediate academic impact in a range of disciplines to ultimately industrial; societal and economic benefit. This proposal focuses on investigating the role of nitric oxide synthases and nitric oxide in bacteria. Particularly in natural product biosynthesis. Due to its multidisciplinarity, this work will impact and advance many fields of research, including but not limited to biochemistry, microbiology and synthetic biology. Research results will be disseminated through presentations at national and international conferences by the PI and the PDRA and ultimately through publication in high impact peer reviewed journals which will be open access.
The economic benefit and applications resulting from this project will likely be in the medium to long term. The knowledge we gain on bacterial nitric oxide synthase dependent nitration will be of interest to the biotechnology sector. We will foster links with industry through membership of networks such as BBSRC funded Network in biotechnology and bioenergy (NIBB): Natural Products Discovery and Bioengineering Network; BIOCATNET and the EPSRC funded Dial-a-molecule network thus enabling the development of promising aspects of the project. These partnerships will be entered into with the help of the highly experienced team in the King's Commercialisation Institute which facilitates and accelerates innovation and commercialisation of research within King's College London. More broadly, this work will further the knowledge economy through the training of an excellent postdoctoral scientist and the further understanding of enzymes involved in biosynthetic transformations and how they may be used to facilitate synthetic biology. UK economic competitiveness relies significantly on the development of biotechnology including the use of synthetic biology approaches or the synthesis of bulk chemicals and complex high value compounds such as pharmaceuticals. Thus a fundamental understanding of microbial biochemistry is of vital importance.
The PDRA who is employed to work on this project will benefit from a multidisciplinary training. King's College London provides extensive courses in researcher training and development for transferable skills training for researchers. Furthermore the collaborative nature of the chemistry department at KCL means the PDRA will be exposed to a variety of disciplines from around the college from physics to the biomedical sciences. I am active in my support of undergraduates as future researchers and have hosted undergraduates in summer research fellowships funded by for example the Royal Society of Chemistry and the KCL Experience programme. My group have been extensively involved in public engagement and outreach activities. We will carry on these regular activities over the course of this grant and I will encourage the PDRA to participate in outreach. Specifically we have requested funds to organise a workshop featuring aspects of our research at KCL Science Festival which is open to members of the public as part of National Science Week. Secondly we would like to use the world class facilities of the Nikon Imaging Centre at KCL to generate images of Streptomyces bacteria which are the source of the enzymes in this proposal, for use on our website and for posters, talks and public engagement activity.
 
Description Significant new knowledge generated and New or improved research methods or skills developed: This project focuses on two enzymes that work in concert in several bacterial pathways to facilitate the formation of an unusual and in fact toxic metabolite(nitric oxide) that is then used to create more complex natural product molecules. This system is involved in the production of phytotoxins in plant pathogenic bacteria and also in the production of an antibiotic with activity against tuberculosis. Our study of these enzymes is an attempt to understand not just their activity but also the impact their activity might have on the proteins themselves but also the bacterial cell as one of the products produced is potentially toxic.
1)We have found that the enzyme partners from different pathways can be mixed and matched and that this can impact the product profile of the reaction. We could in fact use even partners from mammalian systems instead of bacterial. We are preparing this for publication along with point 4.
2) We have found that the nitric oxide synthases studied all produce NO at low levels (making it extremely difficult to measure). This may be an artifact of in vitro conditions however we believe it may also be a protective measure.
3)The toxic product NO has been found to impact on the proteins themselves by reacting with them(work done in collaboration with Claire Eyers in Liverpool). This is of interest from a biological context as it implies the enzymes themselves are damaged during the reaction, however it may also explain why the enzymes that produce NO appear to do so at such low levels. This in itself maybe a protective measure.
4)We have also identified a potential mechanism in one bacterium by which the bacterium might overcome the toxicity of one of the products. This is being carried on by a PhD student following the end of the grant. We are preparing this for publication.
5) We investigated if the enzymes of interest interacted with each other to form a complex as we believed this might protect the bacterial cell from toxic intermediates. While we found no direct evidence of this under the conditions of study we did have some indirect evidence. We did find that when mixed partners from different pathways, in one case found the outcome of the reaction changed. Due to what is known about the factors that influence the reaction we believe that protein - protein interaction is a likely factor. While we cant prove it directly (despite many efforts) this is a significant result and one we are preparing for publication.
6) we have developed an analytical method for identifying and monitoring the products formed in this system in collaboration with Dr. Andrew Surman (KCL)
7) we found that several proteins were much more stable and contained more of their important constituents required for activity if they were fused to the so call "SUMO" protein . A mammalian protein which is very soluble and stable. This has been a game changer for the production of many proteins in the lab but particularly nitric oxide synthases which are thermally unstable.
8) we produced the NOS from rufomycin biosynthetic pathway (an antituberculosis nitrated natural product), which proved to be more thermally stable and easier to work with than the homologue TxtD. Interestingly despite this it does not produce NO at a greater rate. This enzyme was of interest as it gave us a nitric oxide synthase from a completely different pathway to determine if it would have any effect on the partner P450. in vivo, this enzyme produces NO for an enzyme which acts on a different substrate. When we partnered them however we didnt see any effect on the product distribution . Thus the systems appear to be interchangable.

Significant negative results and/or research paths closed off:
1)We made mutants of one of our enzymes as planned. This data in most cases resulted in insoluble or inactive/reduced activity enzymes. This data gave insight into what residues are important but in general it seemed that the enzymes were unstable to many changes.
2) measurement of NO production by chemiluminescence. We found this technique challenging for enzymatic assays as the data was not reproducible despite repeated attempts. instead we turned to a new analytical method as above to achieve the desired outcome.

Increased research capability generated from training delivered in specialist skills:
Both the PDRAs who worked on the project were trained in the use of specialist high resolution mass spectrometry, HPLC (preparative and analytical), trouble shooting protein production, new molecular biology techniques e.g. site directed mutagenesis and gateway cloning all of which been extremely beneficial to the group in general and to them personally in terms of improving their skill set.
PDRA 1 also learned how to use a nitric oxide analyser , a new piece of equipment in our group/department.
PDRA 2 learned fluorescence microscopy at the Nikon Imaging centre at KCL, to detect nitric oxide production (part of our pathways to impact plan) in bacteria , a PhD student is now taking this aspect of the project forward.
Both PDRAs presented their work locally at group meetings and nationally/internationally at scientific conferences . Further travel was curtailed due to COVID. However PDRA 2 did present at an online conference.

SN and GPO supervised undergraduate project students in the lab and SN also wrote an application and successfully gained funding through the RESEARCH EXPERIENCE PLACEMENT from the BBSRC Lido DTP for a summer student from a non-research intensive university. The student gained experience in a research lab and SN gained valuable experience in proposal writing and supervision.

Overall this award has enabled us to take an in depth look at the use by bacteria of nitric oxide as a biosynthetic precursor. After this grant was awarded a new system in which this process occurred was identified (rufomycin) and so we also incorporated this system into some of our investigations and it proved to be a valuable resource. It also further demonstrated the importance of this system. Furthermore we have been able to show the off target effects of nitric oxide even on the proteins involved in producing and utilising it. Furthermore we have shown somewhat surprisingly that it is freely produced in cells which can be visualised using microscopy and a publication on this has just beed accepted. Finally all members of the group has benefited from the PDRAs who brought or developed a wealth new skills and techniques to the lab which are now standard even after they have left. This project has helped to seed further projects and collaborations related generally to metalloenzymes and specifically cytochrome P450s.
Exploitation Route The research outcomes while fundamental at this stage will ultimately have an impact in how the particular pathways in question function and also the role of a small but biochemically fascinating small molecule nitric oxide, in bacteriology in general. It is anticipated that this will spur others to further academic research into the role of nitric oxide in bacterial biochemistry which is a poorly understood area. This has implications not just for soil bacteria , of interest to those in environmental microbiology, and their interactions in microbial communities and plants which will also be on interest to agricultural sector, but also more broadly for those interested in bacteria in microbiome as well as pathogens.
Secondly the data have potential to be taken forward by industrial biotechnology i.e. to use the enzymes in question as a source of precursor for certain chemical reactions to generate more sustainable and greener bio-catalytic processes. Also in biotechnology processes where bacteria are fermented to produce high value chemicals for example , nitric oxide should be looked at as another form of oxidative stress in bacteria during the fermentation process.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description The expertise generated during this project has facilitated several collaborations. One of these has resulted in an iCASE PhD studentship with a biotechnology company in the area of biocatalysis. This work has resulted in a publication (just accepted) on the use of enzymes generated by the company to develop new methodology. The development of skill sets in our lab supported by this award, enabled us to support this project and have led to two additional projects involving biotech or pharmaceutical companies which are in early stages. The PDRA employed on this grant moved into a science related path in patent law. It is hugely important that such attorneys are science literate at a high level. This award thus supported a young scientist to develop both the scientific and transferable skills to move to a new career. They gained a multidisciplinary training which will enable them to comprehend applications from diverse areas and as this award was part focused on biotechnology (a growing sector in the UK) this person is in a strong position to both understand and faclitate new patents of economic importance. Finally, I continue to engage in widening participation activities K+ programme & Realising Opportunities https://www.realisingopportunities.ac.uk/. I have had excellent feedback from students on these programmes and since running lectures these for the first time in 2019 on bacterial secondary metabolism, I have been asked to participate each year since. Both programmes promote social mobility and aim to provide access to university to under represented groups. This is something that is hugely important to me.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description A Chemoenzymatic Approach to Late Stage Functionalisation of Peptide Antibiotics
Amount £10,000 (GBP)
Funding ID E21-2982458970 
Organisation Royal Society of Chemistry 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2021 
End 09/2022
 
Description BBSRC LIDO ( DTP) RESEARCH EXPERIENCE PLACEMENT
Amount £2,500 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2019 
End 08/2019
 
Description BBSRC Lido DTP PhD studentship
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2021 
End 09/2024
 
Description Isothermal titration calorimetry instrumentation for structural biology, biological mechanisms and drug discovery
Amount £193,698 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/T01752X/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2020 
End 06/2021
 
Description LiDo BBSRC DTP PhD student
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2020 
End 09/2023
 
Description LiDo BBSRC DTP Rotation student
Amount £6,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2021 
End 06/2021
 
Description LiDo BBSRC DTP rotation student
Amount £6,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2019 
End 01/2020
 
Description cycloprobio
Amount € 120,000 (EUR)
Organisation Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Global
Start 01/2022 
End 01/2024
 
Description Chemoenzymatic 
Organisation King's College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have begun a collaboration with Daniele Castagnolo a former Kings academic now a UCL academic on bacterial enzymes towards developing biocatalysts. Our input is on the molecular biology/protein side particularly in investigating and understanding the enzymes (e.g. structure, function and substarte interactions) we have trained researchers from the Castagnolo lab in moelcular biology and the production and characterisation of proteins as well as enzymology. This is now very much highly effective partnership and we expect to produce several outputs in the near future.
Collaborator Contribution The Castagnolo lab is has expertise in develoing biocatalytic reactions and has been helpful in helping us develop ideas in this space and engaging with industrial partners to develop these reactions and drive the chemical application of the enzymes. Currently we are partnered with GSK and ALMAC
Impact We recently hosted a BBSRC LiDo rotation student in our labs. (reported in funding section) This project now has a full BBSRC Lido student (see funding section) A GSK funded iCASE award (see funding section) A Marie Curie Fellowship (see funding section) The collabroation is multidisciplinary as it integrates synthetic chemistry, analytical chemistry, molecular microbiology and protein biochemistry
Start Year 2018
 
Description antibiotic peptides 
Organisation University College London
Department School of Pharmacy
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The project involves disovering new antibiotic peptides and investigating their biosynthesis. Our contribution is the molecular microbiology and expertis in the production of proteins and assay of enzymes. We also have expertise in the cultivation of microbes and isolation of natural products.
Collaborator Contribution This project originated with the partner at UCL and they sought our expertise . Rachael Dickman is an expert in peptide synthesis and elucidating peptide structure . She has done extensive work on the RIPP family of natural product peptides.
Impact This is a relativeley new collaboration. The BBSRC Lido PhD student involved is just 6 months into her project (the collaboration started when we wrote the project which was submitted to the DTP in 2020).
Start Year 2020
 
Description mass spectrometry of nitrated proteins 
Organisation University of Liverpool
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution we provided the samples to be analysed. As part of one of our objectives we were interested in the modification of amino acid residues in enzymes in our reactions. To detect these we reached out to an expert in this area Claire Eyers (expert in PTM modification detection by mass spectrometry)
Collaborator Contribution Claire Eyers and her team analysed samples we sent by protein digestion and used mass spectrometry to idenfity specific points of modification in the proteins. This enabled the identification of specific residues in the proteins that were modified during the reactions.
Impact While, we have not yet published work associated with this collaboration, the outcomes as noted above were that we could identify sites of modification of the enzyme by the natural precursors. this has both biological implications and implications for any use of these enzymes as biocatalytic entities.
Start Year 2020
 
Description new analytical methodology 
Organisation King's College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We were in need of an analytical method to detect and separate various amino acid products from an enzymatic method to help us fully follow the reaction . Thus we provided the problem that needed to be solved and the question, is there an analytical method for this? While various companies provide different columns for amino acid separation, we found these didnt work for our problem.
Collaborator Contribution To solve the problem we collaborated with Dr. Andrew Surman in the department of chemistry. He is an expert in analytical chemistry and the separation of complex mixtures as well as simple derivatisation techniques. He thus helped us develop an in line derivatisation method to observe and separate all the products of the reaction. This transformed this data for us and solved the problem.
Impact The outcome is that it has resulted in new methodology for this system to enable further study. The collaboration however has also facilitated other projects in other areas which will produce further benefits. It is multidisciplinary in that it involves analytical chemistry and biochemistry
Start Year 2021
 
Description Careers podcast - careers in your ears 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact The podcast is an interview with me , tracking my career trajectory and particulaly my interest at the interface of chemistry and biology.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://anchor.fm/careersinyourears/episodes/International-Womens-Day-with-Dr-Sarah-Barry-e3d7f6
 
Description Hosted work experience students 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Hosted work experience student from in2science programme which aims to widen university participation .
The student shadowed the postdoc on this grant for 1 week.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2008
URL http://in2scienceuk.org/
 
Description Participation in K+ Summer School event (KCL widening participation initiative) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact K+ is a widening participation programme. it is a two-year programme of events, activities and academic workshops created to help support your university application and provide the skills students need to reach their potential as an undergraduate student. Students who successfully complete the programme are eligible for the K+ reduced offer to study at King's worth up to two A-level grades lower than the standard offer (excluding medicine and dentistry). Alongside this, all students who successfully complete the K+ programme will receive the K+ start up bursary of up to £1000 in their first year of university.K+ is run by King's College London. As part of the summer programme I gave a talks to a groups of students: entitled "What is antibiotic resistance and how do we tackle it?" I also emphasised the importance of interdisciplinarity in modern scientific research. I consider it a success that my participation has been requested 3 year. I have been asked back in 2023 .
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Participation in K+ Summer School event (KCL widening participation initiative) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact K+ is a widening participation programme. it is a two-year programme of events, activities and academic workshops created to help support your university application and provide the skills students need to reach their potential as an undergraduate student. Students who successfully complete the programme are eligible for the K+ reduced offer to study at King's worth up to two A-level grades lower than the standard offer (excluding medicine and dentistry). Alongside this, all students who successfully complete the K+ programme will receive the K+ start up bursary of up to £1000 in their first year of university.K+ is run by King's College London.
As part of the summer programme I gave a talks to a groups of students: In 2020 the talk was entitled "How and why do microbes make antibiotics?" and discussed where antibiotics come from and how and why bacteria use secondary metabolites as part of adaptation to their environmental niche. I also emphasised the importance of interdisciplinarity in modern scientific research. The event was online (due to covid). In 2021 the talk entitled "what is antibiotic resistance and how do we tackle it?" was again online due to COVID. I have now been asked back again this year and will give an in person talk in 2022. I consider it a success that my participation has been requested 3 years in a row.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://kplus.london/
 
Description Realising Opportunities, academic skills module (Widening Participation Event) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Realising Opportunities (RO) is a unique collaboration of leading, research intensive universities, working together to promote fair access and social mobility of students from groups underrepresented in higher education.
This talk was part of their academic skills module. There were approximately 80 A level students attending this webinar (this would have course normally have been in person but due to Covid was converted to a webinar). The talk was entitled "How and why do microbes make antibiotics?" and discussed where antibiotics come from and how and why bacteria use secondary metabolites as part of adaptation to their environmental niche. I also emphasised the importance of interdisciplinarity in modern scientific research. Anonymous feedback indicated that it was received positively (see below). The Q and A was very lively indicating that students found the talk engaging.
K+ Academic Day student feedback:

1. The first lecture I watched was by Sarah Barry about Antibiotics which was very informative for me and fully captured me. It was my favourite lecture today especially learning about antibiotics resistance and how it affects us. I especially like the live event where we could ask questions and it was answered very detailed.

2. Dr.Barry made an interesting link between chemistry and biology and how both are used constantly for the benefit of medicine and new interventions. It reinforces the reasons we have to take both biology and chemistry at A-Levels. It was interesting.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL http://www.realisingopportunities.ac.uk/
 
Description Widening participation summer school of students in science 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Our department runs a week long summer school aimed at students from schools which have low university participation particularly in the sciences and have poor lab facilities. The aim of my talk was to put the lab work they have done in a broader research context and discuss my own route to university. The goal of this school is to widen participation at univeristy at some of our local schools.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.kcl.ac.uk/chemistry/outreach/summer-schools