Using roots to bio-engineer soil

Lead Research Organisation: Cranfield University
Department Name: School of Water, Energy and Environment

Abstract

In order to sustainably increase crop yields to feed the growing world population, and considering the challenges we are facing today due to climate change, we need to carefully manage our soil resources. Promoting measures to manage soils better whilst reducing costs will also help farming businesses remain competitive and profitable. Instead of burning fossil fuels to drag more steel through the ground, this research will harness the power and properties of plant roots to engineer soil for optimised crop growth.

Roots can bio-engineer soil because they can bind soil particles together, providing resistance against soil erosion by water. Roots can also improve soil infiltration and hence prevent runoff. Roots also absorb and release nutrients into the soil, allowing soils to improve their nutrient status and to reduce environmental side effects. Last but not least, roots break up the soil and create pore spaces when they decay. These macro-pores aerate the soil and make its structure more crumbly. So roots can act as a surrogate for machinery and hence reduce the number of tillage operations.

Cover crops are a way for UK growers to address the current Greening Rules that require them to: maintain minimum soil cover, minimise land management to limit erosion and maintain organic matter levels. They are fast growing species, planted between two cash crops, which have the ability to boost soil health and reduce the negative impact of agro-management on the environment. They are usually planted immediately after harvest and left to grow all winter; they cover and protect the soil surface against erosion and die off or are destroyed in early spring to make way for the cash crop. There has been an increasing interest in research to support the application of cover crops. However, current estimates indicate that only 8% of all arable land used for spring cropping in the UK adopts winter cover crops in the rotation. This is because robust science that provides evidence of the multiple benefits of cover crops is lacking.

Past research has successfully linked agronomic productivity to above ground plant traits. More recent studies also investigated root traits and demonstrated their important effect on several single soil functions such as aggregate stability and water availability. No study has looked at the effects of root properties of cover crops to synergistically enhance multiple soil functions and no study has provided a robust methodology to combine complementary root traits in plant communities and to model their effects on multiple soil functions.

The main aim of this study is therefore to develop a novel framework to select and combine complementary root traits in cover crops that prevent soil resource losses and improve crop growth conditions.

To develop the model, root screening will be performed with ten common cover crops (oat, rye, ryegrass, Festulolium, buckwheat, mustard, fodder radish, phacelia, Lucerne and vetch) grown in big soil monoliths, filled with real soil, under laboratory conditions. The plants will be grown in different environments prone to soil degradation. A series of root properties (e.g. rooting depth, root hair density) will be carefully determined, and we will use a DNA technique, qPCR, to determine the proportions of root biomass of each species within a plant community.

The key deliverable of this research will be a novel model that will allow the design of combinations of plant species with complementary root traits that prevent soil erosion, mitigate runoff and improve soil structure and nutrient status for optimised crop growth.

Technical Summary

As a result of pressure on the finite amount of land available for food production, crops are often grown on land that is prone to erosion. With increased rainfall intensities under climate change, significant increases of soil loss are predicted over the coming decades globally. Hence, devising strategies for reducing soil erosion must be a high priority for both food security and preserving the essential ecosystem services provided by soils. One such strategy is to develop cover crops with better root systems for these purposes. To date, there has been little research on combining plant root traits that are beneficial for multiple important soil functions. The concept is that multi-plant interactions with complementary root traits will result in more effective dynamic remediation of degraded soil.
The main aim of this study is therefore to develop a novel methodology to select and combine multiple, complementary root traits in cover crop plant communities to control runoff and erosion, improve soil structure and enhance nutrient availability. To do so, a series of micro- and macro root architectural properties (such as rooting depth or root hair length) will be carefully determined for 10 common cover crops. Experimental assays will be developed to measure soil functions and an advanced multivariate statistical approach will be applied (i) to predict relationships between root traits and functions and (ii) to compute a root functional identity and diversity index per plant. DNA (qPCR) profiling will be performed to quantify root distributions of mixed plant populations. These distributions will then be used as weighing factors to compute the aggregated trait for ten plant mixtures. To model performance of bespoke plant mixtures, the aggregated trait values will serve as input into regression equations predicting the relationship between plant traits and functions. In a last step, the functional performance of the modelled mixtures will be validated in the field.

Planned Impact

This research will deliver new insights into how cover crops species can synergistically work together to protect soils against degradation and to ensure that soils remain a sustainable resource for food production. Current estimates indicate that only 8% of all arable land used for spring cropping in the UK adopts winter cover crops in their rotation. There is thus a huge commercial imperative from a range of businesses for robust data relating to cover crop selection and species/mixture performance. This research could therefore have significant impacts on the agribusiness sector as well as on environmental policy makers as it will build their capacity to promote growing cover crops. Seed companies able to produce and supply cover crop seeds (including breeding novel cultivars), would benefit from further understanding and an expansion of the cover cropped area.
Policy makers and other organisations such as the statutory levy boards, AHDB (Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board) or governmental organisations such as the Environmental Agency or DEFRA (Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs) and the Environmental Agency would benefit from the research as they are concerned about the status of the UK soils and in preventing and remediating soil erosion in order to avoid negative impacts on soil water quality and quantity.

Providing evidence for maintaining ground cover, organic matter levels and minimizing erosion is of particular importance to policy makers in the current political climate, as the negotiations for Brexit, mean new environmental policy documents will need to be written to replace the EU CAP rules. Research that strengthens the benefits of using cover crops will be important to get this agronomic measure written into the new greening rules post Brexit. Although crucial for sustainable food production and soil conservation, most of us don`t know what`s under our feet. Therefore, the broader public and especially children are also beneficiaries of this work and we will target them to disseminate the knowledge gathered in this project. This research will affect all of us indirectly, as when cover crops are shown to deliver multiple benefits to soils they might reduce tillage operation and chemicals and herbicides costs. This will significantly reduce the operating costs for the growers and impact on food prices.

To ensure that all the potential beneficiaries benefit from the research we will engage with them in a variety of ways.

The PI Sarah De Baets will be the project manager and will coordinate and co-deliver all impact activities. The PDRA`s and technicians working on this project will actively be involved in organising and delivering the impact activities, together with the PI. A steering committee comprising representatives from Cranfield University, DEFRA, the Environmental Agency, ADAS, NIAB and Agrii will oversee and guide the research. This will increase its impact and raise levels of awareness amongst key decision makers and organisations, particularly those identified as beneficiaries throughout the business, regulatory and government community.

For academics we will produce publications and attend and present at key conferences. For Industry and policy stakeholders we will present the project results on the steering committee meetings and on the national Agronomists conference, organized by AHDB. For growers and agribusiness we will demonstrate the performance of bespoke cover crop mixtures on field sites at three field demonstration open days. The PI will also participate at a soapbox science of local `World day of Soils` event and make a video for school children to raise awareness for soils and sustainable agriculture.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Cover crop use is a well-established soil conservation technique and has been proven effective for erosion control and soil remediation in many arable systems. It is, however, important to consider the soil functions delivered by different root systems and evidence their effect, in order to increase the uptake of cover crops for sustainable soil and water management.
The following main findings and results were delivered by the study to date:
1. We created a classification of cover crop root systems up to 0.6 m deep based on functional traits. This will allow us to better study their potential role in soil bio-engineering; soil structural improvements for hydrological services and soil resource protection.

2. Root identity was determined from a distinctive combination of root traits and related to 3 soil functional variables, representing soil structural improvement, runoff mitigation and erosion control.

3. Specific benefits were correlated to combinations of root traits which indicates that selecting cover crop species with the right root traits is crucial to improve soil health. this was used to establish mixtures that we would expect to maximise soil improvements

4. A Quantitative PCR test was developed to provide information on the species distribution of roots cover crops when mixtures were applied. For a mixture of 3 species this allowed for partitioning of root biomass. It showed that belowground the partitioning differs substantially from above ground, which will impact on the ability of mixtures to improve soil health.

5. All mixtures were more able to improve infiltration rate than monoculture species and mixtures including Oat had a greater impact on aggregate stability that mixtures include Rye due to a greater dominance of the other tap based root systems in Oat based mixtures.
Exploitation Route Results were presented and discussed at trade shows with stakeholders; follow-up work is conducted together with farmers to enhance impact. Outcomes were presented to the general public through a soap-box presentation. The crop and soil health phenotyping facilities have proven useful for this type of research and promotional material has been produced and is being used to generate further interest amongst stakeholders.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

 
Description The project has demonstrated the impact of root traits of cover crops on various soil processes which attracted large interest as trade shows, including groundswell, as well as presentations directed at stakeholders via visits and seminars organised by the Agri-Tech centres. This has resulted in new discussions about funded project. As the project was the first to demonstrate the capabilities of the Crop Health and Phenotyping Agri-Tech facilities, this resulted in impact. These world-leading facilities allow us to simulate the complex interdependencies between water, soil, tillage, and crops, not just within seasons, but throughout the rotational cycle at representative spatial and temporal scales, whilst controlling soil and weather variability that often complicates interpretation of field trials. The facilities comprise large (1 m3) lysimeters which can be tessellated to form a continuous soil volume upon which tillage operations can be performed mimicking those applied in the field. A phenotyping platform with a suit of remote sensors is used to monitor crop health. The experiments run in this project attracted a large number of visits and numerous promotion videos, leaflets and seminars were made in partnership with the Agri-Tech Centres and aimed at Industry to raise awareness of the benefits these facilities can bring in testing emerging technologies and novel solutions under replicable and realistic conditions which facilitates enhanced uptake by the farmer community. The promotion material enabled us and the Agri-Tech centres to attract further business.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment
Impact Types Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Seeding Catalyst Award
Amount £25,018 (GBP)
Funding ID ISCF-TFP-SA-Cranfield 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2018 
End 02/2019
 
Title Data supporting 'Functional root trait-based classification of cover crops to improve soil physical properties' 
Description Supporting data for the publication "Functional root trait-based classification of cover crops to improve soil physical properties". 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Modelling_Root_Traits_to_Bio-engineer_Soil/13573907/2
 
Title Modelling Root Traits to Bio-engineer Soil 
Description Supporting data for the publication "Functional root trait-based classification of cover crops to improve soil physical properties". 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact data set relates to root traits that are being described in a publication related to the project and can be used by other researchers that seek to select the most suited cover crops to improve soil health. 
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Modelling_Root_Traits_to_Bio-engineer_Soil/13573907
 
Description partnership with CHAP 
Organisation Crop Health and Protection
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The project made use by the growth facilities owned the the Agri-Tech centre CHAP. We have provided presentations to their prospective industrial partners during visits on campus to assist them in generating business as well as made video and photographic material available for leaflet enabling them to promote their business to potential customers.
Collaborator Contribution CHAP on there end provided a film crew and photographer, and support for events related to soil health, and handouts with project descriptions, web-page design and other means to promote the project and the use of their facilities. This has strengthened the relationship and at the early stage of developing business for the facility this had a substantial impact on winning new projects. The partnership is of mutual benefit as projects run in the facilities typically generate research income to both.
Impact out puts are in the form of promotional materials. tangible outputs include the web-page links above as an example
Start Year 2018
 
Description BBSRC study highlights cover crop benefits for soil health 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Creation of a web-page article that describes how Agri-Tech faciltiies belonging to CHAP were used in this project to showcase usefulness of these faciltiies to a broader audience and to stimulate further collaborations
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://chap-solutions.co.uk/projects/bbsrc-study-highlights-cover-crop-benefits-for-soil-health/
 
Description Crop Phenotyping & Soil Health: Bridging the gap between science & practice 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Understanding the interaction of crops and the environment in crop-based agriculture is a crucial first step to improving crop development, productivity, quality and resilience to changing climates. Phenotyping technologies and data analytics provide opportunities to detect, monitor and understand how crop performance is affected by environmental factors such as water availability, nutrients, disease pressure and soil types.

Soils are a key agricultural resource, but we are facing a crisis of increased degradation of health and quality. It is essential to broaden our understanding of our soils and related ecosystems so that we can use and manage them in a productive and sustainable way. Understanding how soil works - and the impact agricultural practices have on soil structure, health and mass - helps to bridge the gap between fundamental science and practical know-how and is a challenge for many soil science researchers. The Phenotyping and Soil Health Facility is designed to meet this need.

Cranfield University's Dr Wilfred Otten, Professor of Soil Biophysics and Dr Toby Waine, Senior Lecturer in Applied Remote Sensing will provide an overview of this world-leading facility including case studies that demonstrate how the complex interdependencies between water, soil, tillage and crops can be simulated, not just within seasons but throughout the rotational cycle, at representative spatial and temporal scales. From tillage, through drilling, plant establishment and crop development, to harvest and post-harvest.

Representatives from CHAP and Agri-EPI will also be on hand to answer questions and facilitate discussion with regards to other soil health issues currently impacting growers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://chap-solutions.co.uk/news/chap-webinar-bridging-the-gap-between-science-and-practice/
 
Description Exhibition at Groundswell Agriculture 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact stand at Groundswell AG 2019 promoting cover crops and project
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://groundswellag.com/exhibitor/
 
Description Farmers weekly Future Farm Technology 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Stand to dispaly research including research on cover crops at Future Farm technology EXpo, plus delivering of a talk to gether with a farmer on the use of technology to improve soils
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.fftexpo.com/en-gb.html
 
Description Groundswell show 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation of key project outcomes at a stanned joined with Reading University aimed at farmers attending the Groundswell meeting.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL http://groundswellag.com
 
Description Soapbox Science event Milton Keynes 30.06.2018 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I participated at the Soapbox Science event in Milton Keynes in 2018. Soapbox Science is a public outreach platform for promoting women scientists and the science they do. It brings science to the shopping mall. This means everyone can access the scientists by engaging with them directly with no middle man, no powerpoint slides and no lecture hall. Just remarkable women in science standing on a soapbox to amaze with their latest discoveries and answer all the science questions people have been burning to ask.On my soapbox I talked about what plant roots can do for soil. I explained how roots help providing soil cohesion and prevent soil erosion by means of a small experiment with surrogate soil particles that become sticky in interaction with a fluid, a model plant and a spray bottle mimicking root exudation. The result of the experiment was a show of a root system that holds soils particles (cfr. rhizosheath) and soil particles sticking together due to the sticky root exudates.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://mksoapboxscience.wordpress.com/2018/07/02/star-quality-at-soapbox-science-mk-2018/
 
Description Talk at Crop Tec 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Proving more information on the benefits cover crops during a seminar entitled 'Rooting for profit provided by cover crops' at the Crop Tec Show for farmers and agri-businesses.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.croptecshow.com/blog-post/using-roots-to-bio-engineer-soil/
 
Description presentation at World Congress for Soil Science 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact An oral presentation was delivered at the world congress for soil science which was held in the UK. The presentation delivered new findings which resulted ion discussion and feedback that enabled us to improve out outcomes. the meeting was attended by >2500, some of these online. Exact numbers cannot be provided. A second outcome is that it raised our profile and that of the UK as research leaders in this field.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022