Chronic bee paralysis virus: The epidemiology, evolution and mitigation of an emerging threat to honey bees

Lead Research Organisation: Newcastle University
Department Name: Sch of Natural Sciences & Env Sciences

Abstract

In the UK, a myriad of pollinating insects contribute significantly to the yield of many agricultural crops and the reproduction of wild plants. Managed Western honey bees (Apis mellifera) offer mobile pollination services to compliment wild pollinators, providing a large proportion of this ecosystem service. Both honey bees and wild pollinators have been in severe decline for the past 30 years in the face of multiple interacting pressures that include land-use intensification, agrochemical exposure and the impact of parasites - which are often shared between pollinator species. These pressures are frequently considered in isolation and rarely together.
Emerging infectious diseases, either newly appearing or rapidly increasing in incidence/geographic range in a population, have a history of causing large impacts on honey bee populations. Here we propose to investigate a rapidly emerging disease in honey bees, known as chronic paralysis, which causes severe symptoms in individual honey bees and often leads to colony loss. UK bee farmers are reporting severe repeated disease outbreaks and the causative RNA virus (Chronic bee paralysis virus [CBPV]), is increasing in prevalence in several countries. The purpose of this project is to advance our understanding of the mechanisms behind the recent emergence of chronic paralysis in honey bees, and work with professional bee farmers to develop new mitigation strategies. We will consider re-emergence as the result of CBPV strain transmissibility, environmental stressors, management practices or co-infection and propose four interlinked objectives, each with clear testable hypotheses, to tackle the problem and deliver management solutions.
First, we will monitor the dynamics of disease spread in individual colonies and apiaries to understand where/when the virus becomes associated with the colony. We will gather new case-control data on stressors associated with chronic paralysis to include the presence of pathogens in adult bees; pesticide exposure in adult bees; weather; local land use; and apiary management. We will use a combination of structural equation and microsimulation modelling to elucidate the pre-requisite stressors for disease to develop, with the aim of highlighting early disease detection protocols and developing apiary management strategies to mitigate disease impact.
Second, we will assess whether the recent emergence of chronic paralysis is the result of shifts in the transmissibility or virulence of modern CBPV strains. We will describe temporal and spatial sequence variation at the genomic level, by sequencing representative historic and recent samples. We will recover infectious historic strains by developing a reverse genetic system for CBPV, and use these reagents to compare the risk posed by past, current and future strains - the latter by generating virus reassortants - where RNAs are exchanged between virus genotypes. Finally, we will assess the risk posed by CBPV to other non-Apis pollinators.
Third, we will investigate co-stressors of chronic paralysis using controlled in vivo challenge tests to include known (lack of foraging due to poor weather and overcrowding) and newly characterised (the gut parasite N. ceranae) co-stressors. We will assess the impact of these factors on transmission and virulence for different genotypic strains.
Fourth, we will work closely with the Bee Farmers' Association (BFA) - who represent professional bee farmers from across the UK - to translate research outcomes into improved professional practices when managing chronic paralysis. We have identified a series of potential knowledge exchange opportunities to explore as data arises from our experiments.
This programme of work will provide a step-change in our understanding of chronic paralysis disease development, virus evolution and pollinator co-stressors, as well as generating the necessary biological data and modelling tools to develop informed management practices.

Technical Summary

We will study the epidemiology and evolution of chronic bee paralysis virus (CBPV) which causes severe disease in honey bee colonies, with the purpose of working with industry to develop mitigation strategies. There are four objectives of this study:

- To gather new data on the disease dynamics using qRT PCR to monitor the temporal and spatial spread of CBPV in colonies and apiaries. We will use structural equation models and microsimulation models on new case-control data with five classes of potential stressor: The presence of pathogens (qPCR/RT PCR); pesticide exposure (using LC/MS-MS and GC/MS); prior weather (EDINA/MO); land use local to apiary; and apiary management (using beekeeper surveys). Where these classes contain multiple attributes, we will use multivariate approaches (Principal Components Analysis) to create composite variables for inclusion in the analysis.

- To investigate the role and importance virus evolution in the recent emergence of CBPV. We will sequence a range of historic and modern isolates using nanopore (MinION) sequencing, and develop reverse genetic systems to create infectious historical isolates and potential future reassortants. Transmissibility and virulence in honey bees and non-Apis pollinators will be assessed using controlled adult cage tests.

- To investigate, co-infection, poor weather and confinement, singularly and in combination as stressors of CBPV-disease. The impact of various combinations of stressors on transmissibility and virulence will be determined for different CBPV genotypes using controlled laboratory cage studies and survival analysis.

- Using data and simulation models, we will work with the BFA to develop and rigorously test management strategies using field trials on BFA apiaries, resulting in the development of a chronic paralysis management toolkit for apiarists.

Planned Impact

Academic groups interested in honey bee health will be informed by the experiments to characterise the virus transmission pathways and the interactions between poor weather and coinfection. Methods developed to monitor shifts in transmission and virulence due to challenge with co-stressors will be useful for other better-studied pollinator diseases, where these data are largely absent. Our proposed work on non-Apis pollinators will extend interest to groups working on wild pollinator health - the interaction between pathogens in managed bees and wild pollinators is a rapidly advancing area of research. More generally, those interested in understanding the drivers behind emerging disease in complex biological systems could benefit from the biostatistical and simulation modelling frameworks developed. Our work will also elucidate the contribution of viral reassortants (for example, with segments derived from different genotypes of the virus) to transmission and virulence. These results will be of great interest to groups studying segmented viruses, which are associated with a wide range of diseases in humans, their livestock or plants. The development of a reverse genetic system for chronic bee paralysis virus will - for the first time - enable the detailed analysis of the structure and function of the bipartite virus genome. This development is, these days, a pre-requisite for the comprehensive analysis of any virus. The majority of the proteins (predicted or known) encoded by CBPV are of unknown function. Through a combination of sequence analysis to highlight conserved functional domains, and the development of strategies giving researchers the ability to 'knock out' proteins (reverse genetics), our studies will have a significant impact on the understanding of this poorly characterised virus.

Our key end-user groups are commercial and hobbyist beekeepers whose honey bee stocks are suffering with dramatically increasing levels of chronic paralysis with no clear intervention strategies to minimise disease impact. Our proposal has been developed in close collaboration with the Bee Farmers' Association (BFA) - who represent professional bee farmers from across the UK - to generate the necessary biological data to develop informed management practices. We will work with the BFA to translate research outcomes into rigorously tested programmes for the early detection and management of chronic paralysis. This 'management toolkit' will be distributed to BFA members and the amateur beekeeping sector through our extensive links with both groups, and through disease management workshops. Honey bee diseases are of considerable interest to the agrichemical companies, both large and small. Our data could highlight the need for new anti-viral interventions that would be of interest to these groups.

Policy makers will be interested to interpret the drivers of chronic paralysis emergence in honey bee populations, to see how our data might inform the delivery of key policies designed to protect pollinator populations. Government sponsored inspection and advisory services will benefit from having new information to share with beekeepers, to improve the impact of their activities and help reduce losses to this damaging disease.

Our results will be of interest to the general public, who keep a watchful eye on developments in pollinator health. The "plight of the honeybee" is regularly in news stories. We will use our experience as science communicators to raise awareness and appreciation of the science underpinning beekeeping and bee diseases, and to help distinguish between the hype and the reality of the current threats to honey bees and other pollinators.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have already confirmed that chronic bee paralysis is an emerging disease with spatial clustering within but not between years. We have found a correlation between disease and honey bee imports. We have now found an interesting interaction with weather and honey bee age which we will confirm this year. .
Exploitation Route We are using this information to direct future experimentation.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description Assessing the pollination efficiency of different species of bees on buzz-pollinated plants of agricultural significance
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 2272183 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2019 
End 04/2023
 
Description Biological modelling of honey bee pests and diseases in the UK (BDI)
Amount £12,000 (GBP)
Organisation Bee Disease Insurance 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2018 
End 09/2021
 
Description Arnia 
Organisation Arnia
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We have purchased some honey bee colony monitoring equipment from Arnia. We have also entered into a data sharing agreement with then for three years that allows us access to honey bee colony health data from many parts of the UK.
Collaborator Contribution St Andrews have also bought some honey bee monitoring equipment.
Impact Nothing yet, but we are exploring the automated detection of chronic bee paralysis using the sensors.
Start Year 2018
 
Description National Bee Unit (APHA) 
Organisation Animal and Plant Health Agency
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We have a data sharing agreement with APHA that allows us to look at the spatial and temporal changes in chronic bee paralysis. Difficult to estimate the value.
Collaborator Contribution Data provision.
Impact Access to these data have allowed us to test whether this disease is emergent - which it is. This is the subject of a Nature Communications paper current in resubmission and a PhD studentship. The impact is science - hence ticking no impact yet......
Start Year 2019
 
Description Annual meeting of British Bee Vets 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I was invited to present the project at this annual event.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Bee Farmer (magazine) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact We have produced multiple articles in this industry magazine to goes out to all 500 UK bee farmers.
These include:

Chronic Bee Paralysis Project - December 2018
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019
 
Description Bee Farmer magazine - extenesion from Nature Comms Paper 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Wrote an article in the Bee Farmers Magazine entitled Chronic bee paralysis: An emerging disease in England and Wales. This article disseminated the research findings form our Nature Comms paper
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://beefarmers.co.uk/the-bee-farmers-association/bee-farmer-magazine
 
Description Bee Farmers Association annual meetings 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I was invited to present the project at the Bee Farmers Annual Meeting and had a slot to talk about the aims of the project and get people engaged with providing disease info and samples.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019
 
Description Presentation to National Bee Unit 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Budge has been invited to present the project findings at this annual national event that convenes industry, policy and practitioners (bee health inspectors).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019
 
Description Presentations at amateur beekeeper meetings (regional national and international) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Budge has been invited to present the project findings at the following:

Ulsters Beekeepers Annual Meeting - Feb 2019
Eastern regional forum - March 2019
Cambridgeshire Beekeepers Convention - May 2019
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Talk to Eastern Region Beekeeping Associations (1 of 2) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Gave an introduction to the work at NU on Chronic bee paralysis virus to introduce Thea Commandeur to speak more about the detailed findings to date.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Talk to Eastern Region Beekeeping Associations (2 of 2) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Gave an introduction to the work at NU on Chronic bee paralysis virus to introduce Thea Commandeur to speak more about the detailed findings to date. This was a repeat to a different audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Various extension activities with beekeepers, bee farmers, bee health policy and government bee inspectors 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Various extension activities with beekeepers and bee farmers talking about the project and the results so far.

Specific talks include:
NBU Conference 03-05/04/2019: NAFIC campus, Sand Hutton (~100 participants);
Central association of beekeepers 29/02/20202: Arkendale community centre (~50 participants);
Ted Hooper Memorial Lecture 21/03/2020: Abbotts Hall Farm, Maldon Road, Great Wigborough, Colchester (~120 participants);
Wakefield beekeepers: The Brig, 1 St Mary's Road, Altofts, Normanton (~50 participants)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020