Variability and the latent ageing process in life histories

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Statistics

Abstract

How do we age as individuals? What are the hidden trajectories each of us follow as we grow old? How much of that process is genetic and how much is it the reflection of our experiences and chosen lifestyles? Complex questions such as these will be in the forefront of our proposed research. To answer them we need to combine complicated datasets with novel statistical methods. The datasets already exist, in the form of longitudinal studies. The methods still need to be developed, either from first principles or as adaptations of existing tools. In this multifaceted project, we will be both developing the methodological foundation to answer such questions as well as testing them on existing data.

Longitudinal studies, such as the British Birth Cohorts, are rich, carefully curated datasets with great potential. Collected through the decades, these large datasets have been used to provide us with snapshots of the lives we lead. In a topic as complex as ageing however, a snapshot is simply not enough. We live varied lives, have different experiences and different genetic endowments, and as such we age differently. To study our life trajectories we need to exploit the available datasets to their full extent. The primary limiting factor to such exploitation is the lack of appropriate statistical tools. For this project, we propose to design a suite of statistical tools, together with relevant user-friendly software, that will make the exploration of these elaborate datasets more efficient.

Our statistical tools build on the intuition that beneath all the ups and downs of an individual life there is a clock that measures the individual rate of ageing. Does everyone's clock tick at the same rate? Is the rate predetermined or driven by random exigencies? We call this hidden clock that drives all the observable phenomena of ageing a "latent process". The challenge is to work backward from what is observable to estimate the latent process. Although until now their usage has been mostly limited to medical applications, modern computational tools make it feasible to apply such methods to complex datasets, such as longitudinal studies.

Our aim is to work on three fronts:
1. Develop relevant methodology, with appropriate diagnostic tools and performance metrics, that can be used to answer a large range of scientific questions that focus on life histories and individual trajectories. We intend to make these tools available to researchers together with easy to follow tutorials and appropriate software.
2. Apply these tools to the complex topic of ageing. Using human and model organism datasets (such as guppies), we will test our developed methodology, and interpret the findings within the context of modern evolutionary theory. Our findings will then be disseminated both through scientific publications, through popular science press to the general public and relevant charities.
3. Use these tools to develop our understanding of genetic heritability and its variability as organisms senesce. Through the combination of phenotypic and genetic datasets we can estimate how the genetic impact of a particular character changes through a lifetime.

Technical Summary

Our goal is to operationalise core models, the "latent Markov process" models, from the mathematical theory of ageing by means of novel statistical methodologies. We also plan to develop statistical tools to help testing and calibrating the mutation-selection models central to the theory of ageing.
A key element of many theoretical treatments of ageing is a hidden "senescence" that determines characters such as an organism's response to shocks and challenges, or its likelihood of reproducing. We aim to use sequential Monte Carlo methods to estimate this for individuals from complex data. The main objectives are:
1. To parcel out the variability in senescence among time-scales and population scales. In principle, individuals may differ in their initial condition, their inherent rate of ageing, the random shocks from which they suffer, and the age-related deterioration that they accumulate. Appropriate statistical models allow us to distinguish these different kinds of variation.
2. Filtering: We can distil complex longitudinal data into model-based estimates of simple senescence trajectories, that can be used as the basis for optimal prediction, or as phenotypes for genomic investigations.
3. To produce an accessible software package that will enable a wide range of researchers to fit latent-process models in their research.
4. To apply this software to problems of individual choice and population-level screening design.
Standard theories of the evolution of ageing depend on persistent genetic heterogeneity whose effect varies by age. It is difficult to identify such variants, much less to assess their overall contribution to the genetic load. We aim to meld a variety of standard survival models with random-effects models for heritability estimation to define age-dependent heritability and derive estimates. These methods will be applied to a variety ofdata, such as guppies, through our collaboration with the Guppy Project, and human longitudinal datasets.

Planned Impact

The study of ageing through the use of longitudinal surveys, such as the British Birth Cohorts, can have both direct and indirect societal and economic impacts. In this work, we propose the development of appropriate tools, through which such studies can be made possible, as well as their application to complex human datasets with particular focus on defining underlying senescence patterns.

A primary source of direct societal impact for the current proposal is through public engagement. Building on Prof Steinsaltz's extensive experience on science communication, we intend to use a combination of popular science writing, online tutorials, and public lectures. These aim to enhance understanding both on the core science of ageing, the developed analytical tools, and on the datasets available for scientific enquiry and their access procedures. Our target audience would vary, from interested members of the public to think-tank members. Since part of the proposed research is the application of the developed tools to European and North American retirement surveys, we anticipate gaining insight on a variety of changes in ageing patterns correlated to lifestyle, health, and environmental factors. These findings will be disseminated to the general public through specialised blog posts, and will be used in consultations with charities in order to assist their decision-making and resource allocation process. Associated to the development of mathematical methodology for the study of ageing, we intend to develop computer tools with linked accessible tutorials. These will promote a straightforward exploration of our proposed methodology by interested parties, such as policy makers and charity workers. Together with our online guides, we plan a summer school that will train participants not only in the use of our analytical tools, but also on the background theory and available resources to interested parties.

Finally, an indirect but crucial impact of our work is that by designing tools to exploit the longitudinal surveys, that have been carefully collected and curated through decades of hard work, we help to make them available to their full potential for a wide range of research questions, from health policy making to initiative development for an ageing population.
 
Title Perceptions of ageing - Colouring sheets 
Description As part of the sci-art workshops, we produced 3 colouring sheets illustrating oak leaves for participants to work on as a warm up exercise. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact All workshop participants used at least one of the sheets as part of the warm up exercise, with some focusing on only those for the duration of the workshop. 
 
Description Much of our work is still in progress. Other developments are of a purely statistics-technical nature. Major results so far:
1. In cleaning up and preparing one of the human longitudinal studies that we are using for our work. As part of the data-preparation work we investigated the relationship between reported fertility-related events -- in particular, births and terminations -- and dropout from the study. We found both that these events -- most especially terminations -- were underreported, but also that women who remained in the study generally reported fewer births in early adulthood, suggesting either biased underreporting or an interaction between having children and dropping out of the study. We also found that age at menarche was correlated with women dropping out of the study.
2. As planned, we have developed a statistical tool for using longitudinal ecological data to estimate features of the population, and thus to predict population growth and changes in the population age structure over time, and its response to environmental changes. We have so far applied it only to theoretical (simulated) data and to one small real data set, but we have already identified areas where the traditional methods fail, or are likely to fail, and to provide misleading results.
3. While this award is very much focussed on biological ageing, the methods we are still developing for tracking the progression of ageing has attracted interest from researchers in population health. A 4-year grant has been obtained from NIHR for applying a version of the same algorithms and software to track the progression of complex diseases.
4. The theoretical side of our work on the heritability of ageing has produced more general insights into heritability, in the form of a surprising result about the conditions under which heritability -- usually assumed to be positive essentially by definition -- can actually be negative. This work, a collaboration with a demographer and geneticist in the US, has been published in the journal Genetics.
5. The novel statistical methodology for detecting genetic links to ageing, using local genealogies, has produced demonstrably improved techniques for detecting relevant genetic loci and measuring heritability. One paper, applying neural networks to prediction of individual survival, will be presented at the 25th International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics. A series of other papers on the genomic and statistical methods have either been published as preprints, or will appear shortly. Work to connect the two is now ongoing.
Exploitation Route The genomic methodology that we have developed and are in the process of publishing improves on current tools for identifying genomic sites linked to complex traits, particularly in ethnically mixed populations. If our results are confirmed by others, this can help a wide range of researchers in genomics, and clinical researchers developing applications to individualised medicine.
Dr Hamish Patten, who was hired in July 2019 for this project, identified the possibility of applying some of the same statistical technology that he was developing for the ageing project to the difficult problem of tracking and predicting the return of internally displaced persons. We solicited an EPSRC impact acceleration grant that paid for 50% of his effort for a period of time to develop that application in parallel. A leading international NGO in the field has plans to use the software we developed, and to develop it further for their purposes.
Together with a consortium of researchers in clinical medicine and in engineering, an NIHR grant has been procured to extend our biological-age-trajectory methodology to tracking the progression of complex diseases, using clinical records.
Sectors Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology,Other

URL https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.13.20022012v1
 
Description CoMPuTE: Complex Multimorbidity Phenotypes, Trends, and Endpoints
Amount £80,000 (GBP)
Organisation National Institute for Health Research 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2021 
End 08/2021
 
Description Complex Multiple long-term conditions (MLTC) Phenotypes, Trends, and Endpoints (CoMPuTE)
Amount £2,611,897 (GBP)
Funding ID NIHR202625 
Organisation National Institute for Health Research 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 05/2023 
End 05/2028
 
Description ESRC Impact Acceleration Fund - Festival of Social Sciences Call - Perceptions of Ageing
Amount £997 (GBP)
Funding ID 1906-FOSS-466 - Christodoulou 
Organisation Economic and Social Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 05/2019 
End 11/2019
 
Description IAA: Estimation of Displaced Populations Post-Disaster: a Question of Data and Demography
Amount £39,769 (GBP)
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2020 
End 03/2021
 
Description IDMC 
Organisation UN Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre
Country Switzerland 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The overlap of statistical methodology between our work and the needs of predicting flows of internally displaced individuals led to a collaboration -- funded by a separate EPSRC impact acceleration grant -- to develop a software package specifically for this application. The work was done entirely by my research group, but with considerable consultation with IDMC all along the way, and predicated on our unfettered access to their data base.
Collaborator Contribution They provided access to their data base of internal displacement events, as well as technical assistance. (I have set the value of the data contribution at £1000, though comparable resources can come with charges ranging from 0 to many thousands of pounds.)
Impact The main outcome is a software package ODDRIN that is currently being tested by organisations including the United Nations Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR) and IFRC.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Nuffield School of Primary Care Health Science 
Organisation University of Oxford
Department Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We are providing the core statistical methodology on which the project is based. It is an adaptation of the methods we have been developing for the present award, and uses some of the same software code.
Collaborator Contribution This is a multidisciplinary collaboration, involving multiple specialists in medicine, public health, and engineering.
Impact As a result of our outreach efforts over this award, we found the possibility of extending our work from the biological to the medical realm, and partnered with a group at the Nuffield School of Public Health interested in applying novel statistical methods in clinical medicine. This led to an NIHR pilot grant for AI and Multimorbidity, the CoMPuTE: Complex Multimorbidity Phenotypes, Trends, and Endpoints grant.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Perceptions of ageing - Sci-art Workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Developed and delivered two Sci-art works with visual artist Immy Smith. We aimed to engage a general audience to examine how individuals perceived the concept of biological ageing, and the social constructs surrounding it, by contrasting human senescence to that of other organisms. Due to the success of the original two workshops in November 2019, we were invited to host a workshop in March 2020 for British Science Week 2020.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020
URL https://www.immysmith.net/#/most-recent-work/
 
Description Randomness in art and science 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A publicly available podcast with visual artist Dr Immy Smith, on the concept of randomness and its use in science and art.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.patreon.com/posts/december-2018-in-23450458
 
Description Share your failures more openly: Meet Maria Christodoulou 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Q&A interview published in the Soapbox Science blog, aiming to showcase women in STEMM.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://soapboxscience.org/2019/05/20/share-your-failures-more-openly-meet-maria-christodoulou/
 
Description Soapbox Science 2019 - Reading 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Soapbox Science is a public event aiming to increase the visibility of female scientists and the science they do (more here: http://soapboxscience.org/). We participated in the 2019 event, in Reading town centre, discussing ageing with the general public. The audience engaged well and asked a wide range of questions on ageing research, and demography.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.mpls.ox.ac.uk/news/three-oxford-scientists-join-soapbox-science-in-reading-this-summer
 
Description Soapbox Science Reading 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Dr Christodoulou spoke about our research at a public event ("Soapbox Science") in Reading at which members of the public could come up to ask questions about research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://soapboxscience.org/soapbox-science-2019-reading/