DIVERSIFICATION OF VERTEBRATE T-CELL FACTOR (TCF) STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION IN EVOLUTION AND DEVELOPMENT

Lead Research Organisation: University of St Andrews
Department Name: Biology

Abstract

Abstracts are not currently available in GtR for all funded research. This is normally because the abstract was not required at the time of proposal submission, but may be because it included sensitive information such as personal details.

Technical Summary

We aim to provide insight into the origins and molecular bases for the diversity of TCF functions downstream of Wnt signalling in vertebrate development. Wnt/beta catenin/TCF signalling mediates diverse roles in embryonic development, stem-cell-mediated regeneration and human disease. While the upstream Wnt/beta-catenin pathway is remarkably conserved; the diversity of functions in vertebrates clearly correlates with increased diversity of TCF transcription factors expressed from vertebrate genomes. In this interdisciplinary collaboration we will investigate how this step change in TCF diversity contributes to diversification of Wnt function in vertebrates. We will test the hypothesis that whole-genome duplications led to diversification of vertebrate TCF genes and possibly increased isoform-coding, which then enabled acquisition of redundancy, as well as, segregated (sub-functionalisation) and novel functions (neo-functionalisation) in vertebrates.

We will particularly investigate whether the vertebrate TCF7E isoform retains functions of the invertebrate TCF and explore whether the TCF diversity is particularly important for embryonic development of the vertebrate CNS. We will meticulously compare gene structure and synteny of TCF genes in genomes of different vertebrates with those of the most closely related invertebrates, the chordates Ciona and amphioxus. We will determine the embryonic expression of TCF genes and isoforms, and assay their function in the Xenopus vertebrate model and in the chordate invertebrate Ciona. We will be able to carry out exciting cross-species TCF swap experiments to assess the extent to which ancestral functions are retained in vertebrate TCF orthologs and in vertebrate embryos. This project will produce a comprehensive understanding of the origin of the diversity of vertebrate TCF structure and the functional impacts in vertebrates, with far-reaching implications for the understanding of Wnt signalling in human disease biology.

Planned Impact

This project represents fundamental research with immediate academic impact and potential for future impact on biotechnology and health services.

ACADEMIC IMPACT: This will be achieved through open access publications in high-impact, peer-reviewed international journals. Impact will also be promoted by attendance by the applicants and supported post-doctoral researchers at international conferences to present the project results. Meetings targeted will include international Wnt conferences and developmental biology conferences such as those of the British, American and International Societies of Developmental Biology and the European and Pan-American Evolutionary Developmental Biology Societies. Academic beneficiaries will primarily be developmental biologists, particularly those working on Wnt signalling function and mechanisms and those interested in the evolution of developmental processes. Additional academic beneficiaries that are reached, particularly through the Wnt meetings, will include biomedical, cancer and diabetes researchers. The post-doctoral researchers on this project will also directly benefit from career development and skills training in an interdisciplinary and collaborative research environment.

PUBLIC UNDERSTANDING OF SCIENCE IMPACT: The general public are also interested in both the evolution of biological diversity on this planet and the causes of human disease. Impact on the general public will be pursued through press releases from our University press offices. We will also expand the Tcf/Lef family Wikipedia web-page, since this is often the first port-of-call for most people when trying to find out about a topic. This Wikipedia page is currently very sparse. We will also contribute to public outreach and widening access events, including Science Week (e.g. with a display of amphioxus and Ciona adults alongside Xenopus tadpoles), with posters and scientists on hand to discuss use of these animals in a comparative fashion to help understand human biology and disease. School visits to our Universities (e.g. via the First Chances widening access program at St Andrews) are another avenue for us to introduce our study species to school children and explain the concept of model systems to study medically relevant biology. We will also run a student summer internship program (USTAN). We will also extend David Ferrier's existing link to the St Andrews public aquarium (60,000 visitors per year), producing a display of Ciona and Xenopus alongside a poster explaining their usefulness in studying fundamental biology relevant to human development and disease. A similar exhibit will also be produced in the new public outreach space in the redeveloped Gatty Laboratory, which faces onto the Fife coastal path and East Sands beach, with over 55,000 users of the coastal path alone each year.

IMPACT ON FUTURE RESEARCH: This research project will have direct impact on the two collaborating research groups and their Universities. This project provides the strong foundation for addressing further research questions with future investigations of specific functions of vertebrate TCF genes and of the regulatory mechanisms controlling alternative isoform expression, such as tissue-specific alternative splicing regulators. We are also keen to expand our analysis of TCF isoform expression and function to cancer genomes and gene expression data from cancer biopsy samples.

IMPACT ON BIOTECHNOLOGY: Our connection with Nanopore will improve application of their technology for studying alternative mRNA expression. As a follow-up to this project, we plan the development of isoform-specific antibody tools with biotech companies. Such isoform-specific antibody tools could become useful for diagnosis of specific subtypes of colorectal cancer.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The overall aim of the project was to provide novel insight into the evolutionary origins and molecular foundations for TCF functional diversity in vertebrates, to help explain the origins of derived vertebrate traits and ultimately inform roles in human disease biology. There were three specific objectives:
1) Determine diversity of Tcf genes and potential transcript isoforms via comprehensive comparative genomics analysis of chordates, to understand molecular foundations for any functional differences.
2) Comparative analysis of differential expression of Tcf genes and isoforms in experimental models of selected vertebrate and invertebrate chordates, to determine conserved and divergent expression patterns to help interpret functional experiments.
3) Experimental analysis of TCF protein function in Xenopus and Ciona embryos with loss- and gain-of-function experiments to deduce conserved and redundant versus divergent gene- and isoform-specific innovations.

The first objective was completed and published in (Torres-Aquila. et al., 2022, doi: 10.1111/dgd.12771). This involved the description of a new model for the ancestral chordate and vertebrate Tcf genes and much more robust description of the chordate and vertebrate lineage-specific motifs and domains across the various Tcf sub-families. This provides an excellent new foundation for future experiments and interpretations of Tcf gene function in the chordates.

For objective (2), new long-read transcriptome datasets for the tunicate Ciona intestinalis, the lamprey Lampetra planeri, and the frog Xenopus laevis have been produced, which are about to be deposited in Genbank as part of submitting a manuscript for publication that describes these results.
Further data addressing this objective has been produced and additional data is in the pipeline in connection with ongoing RT-PCR experiments and in situ hybridisation experiments in both Ciona and Xenopus, as part of the joint award between the University of St Andrews (this award BB/S016856/1, now completed) and the University of Aberdeen (BBS018190/1, ongoing), and a new PhD student at the University of St Andrews. This further data relevant to objective (2) will be published collectively with the functional genetics experiments of objective (3).

From our new transcriptome data produced within objective (2), we have discovered that there is a dramatic step-change in the isoform diversity of Tcf genes at the invertebrate-to-vertebrate transition, which is significantly elevated above the background levels of isoform diversity across the general transcriptomes of each species. This raises the likelihood that the TCF proteins have been a key node for the increase in diverse functionality of the Wnt-Tcf signalling pathway in vertebrate evolution and development.

To address objective (3) we have completed dominant negative knock-downs of Tcf function in the Ciona nervous system and 'rescue' experiments using full-length Tcf coding sequences from several chordates, and characterised the phenotypes via morphological analyses, target genes in situ hybridisations, and differential gene expression analyses from long molecule transcriptome sequencing. These results will be published alongside the ongoing Xenopus experiments being completed in the Aberdeen part of the joint award. These experiments are allowing us to tease apart some of the different functionalities of the various parts of TCF across chordate evolution and development.

outputs can be seen at,
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dgd.12771
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fevo.2021.703163/full
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TCF/LEF_family
Exploitation Route This research is ongoing with the part of the joint award to the University of Aberdeen, particularly focused on the Xenopus laevis experiments. We also have a new PhD student pursuing further analyses in Ciona intestinalis, to better understand the functions of Tcf in this system. More generally, it is clear that our results are of widespread interest to a diverse array of scientific stakeholders. Our publication on the diversity of chordate Tcf gene structures and domain compositions is already picking up citations from researchers in biomedicine (specifically neural disorders), alongside its obvious interest to cell and developmental biologists interested in Wnt signalling and evolutionary biologists interested in chordate evolution as well as transitions in genetic complexity linked to vertebrate origins and diversification.
Sectors Education,Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

URL https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dgd.12771
 
Description As a blue skies project, the aim was not for the results to have immediate impact in the realms of industry, policy or health. These impacts are expected to materialise further in the future. The likelihood of this is real, as the Tcf/Lef genes studied in this project are known to be involved in a variety of human diseases (including various cancers). Since we have been able to significantly revise the model of the ancestral state (or basic structure) of this gene family for chordates and vertebrates, highlighting various lineage-specific protein motifs and domains, then this will provide an essential framework for future work on the functions of these motifs and how data from diverse non-human study species can be robustly related to comparable (homologous) motifs in the human proteins, with the consequent implications for how these functions operate or fail in disease contexts. We are studying the functions of some of these motifs ourselves in current joint projects as well as new ongoing experiments, and this new model for the Tcf/Lef family is already being cited and used by the wider research community. Additional and more immediate impacts have also been in the education and training of new young researchers, via summer internships, as well as use of the results in university teaching. The project has also led to a new PhD student project, and the PDRA from this grant has successfully transitioned to a competitive fellowship held in Spain to further progress her research career. To help disseminate our results to the widest possible array of people we have extensively revised the Wikipedia pages on Tcf/Lef genes, as these pages tend to be one of the main first 'ports of call' for anyone looking for information on any particular topic.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Education
Impact Types Societal

 
Description BBSRC EASTBIO
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2023 
End 09/2027
 
Description Control of the ParaHox genes in chordate evolution and development
Amount £96,500 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2020 
End 09/2024
 
Description Regulation of the ParaHox genes in chordates.
Amount £62,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of St Andrews 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2022 
End 09/2025
 
Description Dr Sebastian Shimeld 
Organisation University of Oxford
Department Department of Zoology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Bioinformatic analysis of unpublished transcriptome data from the partner (Dr Sebastian Shimeld, University of Oxford) to resolve the number of TCF gene sequences that are present in the lamprey.
Collaborator Contribution The partner (Dr Sebastian Shimeld, University of Oxford) has supplied us with unpublished transcriptome data from the lamprey.
Impact New TCF gene sequences have been detected. These will be followed-up in this project with attempts to obtain lamprey expression data and further bioinformatic analyses by ourselves to resolve the precise relationships to other vertebrate TCF genes. All of this data is likely to be included in future publications stemming from this project.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Science Discovery Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Science Discovery Day outreach event covering the activities of the University of St Andrews science departments, open to the general public. Individuals provide exhibits or stalls with material and activities that promote engagement with members of the public, along with the engagement of undergraduate and postgraduate assistant on the exhibits. Over 3,000 people attended.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description TCF/LEF gene Wikipedia page 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We are updating and extending the Wikipedia page dedicated to the TCF/LEF genes that our project is focused on. These revisions will be ongoing throughout the project. Since Wikipedia is now established as one of the main reference sources for anyone connected to the internet then the global reach of ensuring that this information is both accurate and informative will be profound. Wikipedia pages on specific scientific subjects such as gene families are widely used by students at all levels of their education, as well as academics and professional scientists needing a quick reminder or basic introduction to the topic. The wider general public and media often use Wikipedia to help understand technical subjects, and one could envisage seeing mention of the TCF/LEF genes in connection with something like some associated disease biology leading to a member of th general public accessing the information on these Wikipedia pages.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
URL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TCF/LEF_family