Arable - Are chitin amendments to soil a means to control potato cyst nematodes?
Lead Research Organisation:
James Hutton Institute
Department Name: Cell & Molecular Sciences
Abstract
Summary:
Plant parasitic nematodes cause an estimated $80 billion of annual damage to global agriculture and threaten food security in many regions. The potato cyst nematode (PCN) is a plant parasitic nematode that infects solanaceous species and causes significant damage, primarily to potato crops. In the UK alone, PCN causes more than £31 million in damage annually. Historically, PCN has been managed by using nematicides. However, due to potential environmental concerns, these chemicals have become tightly regulated. Currently there is only one granular nematicide left on the UK market and this has an uncertain future with an upcoming regulation review in 2024. Scotland is a large producer and exporter of seed potatoes. Current regulations state that if PCN has been detected in a field, that field can no longer be used for seed potato production. PCN is spreading in seed growing areas and recent predictions suggest that without improved PCN management tools this industry will collapse by 2050.
Chitin is an abundant biomolecule which is found in insects, fungi and shellfish. Chitin is also present in PCN eggshells where it protects the developing juvenile by providing the eggshell with rigidity and tensile strength. Chitinous soil amendments have previously been proposed for control of plant parasitic nematodes. Addition of chitin to soils may help select for chitin-degrading microbial populations, naturally raising the prevalence of these organisms in that environment. The microbes may subsequently use sources of chitin already present in the soil, such as PCN eggshells, as an energy source, allowing the suppression of PCN numbers to a level where they are no longer a threat to the potato crop.
We currently do not know if chitinous soil amendments are suitable for Scottish growing conditions or the impact they have on beneficial, chitin-containing, soil organisms. In this work we will investigate whether chitinous soil amendments control PCN in UK soils and how this control is achieved. Soil samples from field plots treated either with or without chitinous soil amendments will be collected. These samples will be used to identify the presence of different fungal, bacterial and free-living nematode populations and to quantify PCN numbers and chitin degrading activity. Comparing treated and untreated samples will allow understanding of changes in PCN populations, which microorganisms are responsible and if there is a negative impact on wider soil biodiversity. Testing in a controlled greenhouse environment will confirm whether the chitin within the soil amendment has a positive effect towards reducing PCN populations through eggshell degradation and will confirm which microorganisms are responsible.
The project outcomes will include identifying differences in microbial and nematode populations in field samples treated with or without a chitin-rich soil amendment. Analysis of the increased presence of chitinase, the enzyme responsible for chitin degradation, in soil samples will confirm the pathway utilised to degrade PCN eggshells. Additionally, structural investigation of PCN eggshells will validate whether eggshells are degraded sufficiently to prevent PCN hatching. Populations of potentially beneficial free-living nematodes will be identified in treated and untreated samples to survey for potential wider nematocidal effects of chitin-based soil amendments.
Plant parasitic nematodes cause an estimated $80 billion of annual damage to global agriculture and threaten food security in many regions. The potato cyst nematode (PCN) is a plant parasitic nematode that infects solanaceous species and causes significant damage, primarily to potato crops. In the UK alone, PCN causes more than £31 million in damage annually. Historically, PCN has been managed by using nematicides. However, due to potential environmental concerns, these chemicals have become tightly regulated. Currently there is only one granular nematicide left on the UK market and this has an uncertain future with an upcoming regulation review in 2024. Scotland is a large producer and exporter of seed potatoes. Current regulations state that if PCN has been detected in a field, that field can no longer be used for seed potato production. PCN is spreading in seed growing areas and recent predictions suggest that without improved PCN management tools this industry will collapse by 2050.
Chitin is an abundant biomolecule which is found in insects, fungi and shellfish. Chitin is also present in PCN eggshells where it protects the developing juvenile by providing the eggshell with rigidity and tensile strength. Chitinous soil amendments have previously been proposed for control of plant parasitic nematodes. Addition of chitin to soils may help select for chitin-degrading microbial populations, naturally raising the prevalence of these organisms in that environment. The microbes may subsequently use sources of chitin already present in the soil, such as PCN eggshells, as an energy source, allowing the suppression of PCN numbers to a level where they are no longer a threat to the potato crop.
We currently do not know if chitinous soil amendments are suitable for Scottish growing conditions or the impact they have on beneficial, chitin-containing, soil organisms. In this work we will investigate whether chitinous soil amendments control PCN in UK soils and how this control is achieved. Soil samples from field plots treated either with or without chitinous soil amendments will be collected. These samples will be used to identify the presence of different fungal, bacterial and free-living nematode populations and to quantify PCN numbers and chitin degrading activity. Comparing treated and untreated samples will allow understanding of changes in PCN populations, which microorganisms are responsible and if there is a negative impact on wider soil biodiversity. Testing in a controlled greenhouse environment will confirm whether the chitin within the soil amendment has a positive effect towards reducing PCN populations through eggshell degradation and will confirm which microorganisms are responsible.
The project outcomes will include identifying differences in microbial and nematode populations in field samples treated with or without a chitin-rich soil amendment. Analysis of the increased presence of chitinase, the enzyme responsible for chitin degradation, in soil samples will confirm the pathway utilised to degrade PCN eggshells. Additionally, structural investigation of PCN eggshells will validate whether eggshells are degraded sufficiently to prevent PCN hatching. Populations of potentially beneficial free-living nematodes will be identified in treated and untreated samples to survey for potential wider nematocidal effects of chitin-based soil amendments.
Technical Summary
Technical Summary:
Chitin-containing soil amendments have been proposed as tools for control of soil-borne pathogens, including plant-parasitic nematodes such as potato cyst nematodes (PCN), but information on the efficacy of these products and their mode of action is lacking. We will use a combination of field and controlled environment trials to examine the impact of these amendments on PCN viability and populations of microbial agents that may provide the control of PCN. We will characterise the prokaryotic and eukaryotic communities in field and controlled environment soils using next generation sequencing of 16SrRNA, 18SrRNA and ITS amplicon libraries. We will quantify the abundance and range of chitin degraders in response to soil amendments using quantitative PCR on the chiA gene. To address the concern that chitin-containing soil amendments could impact beneficial free-living nematodes, we will characterise these nematode communities through a combination of metagenetic analysis and visual identification. Viability assays will be used to quantify the degradation of PCN eggs. We will employ a range of univariate and multivariate statistical techniques to test the links between microbial community structure, chitinase levels and PCN numbers. These experiments will address the overarching hypothesis that the addition of chitin-containing soil amendments will increase the selection for specific chitin degraders and increase levels of chitinase production which will lead to a breakdown of PCN eggshells and an increase in PCN mortality. The alpha diversity of fungi and free-living nematodes will not be reduced by the increase in chitinase production.
Chitin-containing soil amendments have been proposed as tools for control of soil-borne pathogens, including plant-parasitic nematodes such as potato cyst nematodes (PCN), but information on the efficacy of these products and their mode of action is lacking. We will use a combination of field and controlled environment trials to examine the impact of these amendments on PCN viability and populations of microbial agents that may provide the control of PCN. We will characterise the prokaryotic and eukaryotic communities in field and controlled environment soils using next generation sequencing of 16SrRNA, 18SrRNA and ITS amplicon libraries. We will quantify the abundance and range of chitin degraders in response to soil amendments using quantitative PCR on the chiA gene. To address the concern that chitin-containing soil amendments could impact beneficial free-living nematodes, we will characterise these nematode communities through a combination of metagenetic analysis and visual identification. Viability assays will be used to quantify the degradation of PCN eggs. We will employ a range of univariate and multivariate statistical techniques to test the links between microbial community structure, chitinase levels and PCN numbers. These experiments will address the overarching hypothesis that the addition of chitin-containing soil amendments will increase the selection for specific chitin degraders and increase levels of chitinase production which will lead to a breakdown of PCN eggshells and an increase in PCN mortality. The alpha diversity of fungi and free-living nematodes will not be reduced by the increase in chitinase production.
| Description | This proposal connected industry-based experts and researchers to identify whether chitin-containing soil amendments could control potato cyst nematodes (PCN) . Chitin-rich amendments, such as the one produced by Angus Horticulture, could offer a novel strategy to increase the natural decline rates of PCN between potato rotations. Theoretically, increasing chitin as a carbon source in soils will help promote the selection of chitin-degrading microorganisms. Chitin is a key component of PCN eggshells and could consequently be digested by these microorganisms. When the natural PCN hatching process is disrupted PCN will no longer hatch in response to their host plant. There is an urgent need to validate products such as this chitin-rich soil amendment to help assist protection of the rapidly deteriorating GB potato industry. The overall aim of the project was; To identify whether the addition of chitin-containing soil amendments to PCN infected soil has the potential to reduce PCN abundance through promotion of chitin-degrading microorganisms, while maintaining beneficial organisms. With an Overarching hypothesis of: Addition of chitin-containing soil amendments will increase both selection for specific chitin degraders and levels of chitinase production leading to a breakdown of PCN eggshells and increased PCN mortality. Alpha diversity of fungi and free-living nematodes will not be reduced by increased chitinase production. We addressed this through the following two project objectives; O1: Assess whether addition of chitin containing soil amendments reduces PCN populations under field conditions and identify which chitin degraders are drivers of increased chitinase production. Determine if selection for chitinase degraders negatively impacts soil biodiversity and FLN diversity. O2: Determine whether there is a link between chitin addition, chitinase levels and degradation of PCN eggs. The most significant achievement from this award was the assessment of the efficacy and potential impacts of a ready to commercialise chitin amendment product. We were able to highlight that further testing of the product was needed to confirm whether it could impact PCN population numbers. While we saw no affect of the product on PCN populations there were high chitinase enzyme levels in the product itself. This enzymatic activity was likely reflected in the visible eggshell degradation seen using scanning electron microscopy. However, many results from this work remain statistically insignificant. Sampling from an older field trial (2021) was not suitable and future work should sample from freshly established trial sites or only within microcosms. It is clear that sampling time affects measurable chitinase activity. Chitinase activity should be measured regularly and over a longer period of time. Field plots need to be distinctly separated. Unlike nematodes, microbial communities spread faster and further in soils. Non-significant data from field samples is likely due to poor field trial planning. Movement of microbial communities between treated and untreated plots would explain lack of significant data. Therefore further testing of application timings and levels is needed to fully understand the impacts of this product. |
| Exploitation Route | These results can be taken forward by industry, policy and the wider research community. We have assessed a ready to commercialise chitin soil amendment product but have been unable to entirely confirm its beneficial effects. We have however identified the need for further testing that can be taken forward both by the company looking to market the product and the wider research community. This includes expanded field trials with more explicit temporal sampling and testing the product at a range of application levels. The tested soil amendment product was high in both chitinase enzyme activity and fungi (a group known to be key to chitin degradation) so testing soils directly after soil amendments may be key to determining the efficacy of this product as there appeared to be no longer term effects. These findings are also relevant to policy as they highlight the need for further development and testing of non- synthetic chemical PCN management products to replace the looming loss of synthetic alternatives. This project was able to show that chitin is potentially a good route for PCN management as the findings in our study showed no negative impacts on non-target nematode and fungal groups but did find high chitinase activity in the product itself. This enzymatic activity was likely reflected in the visible eggshell degradation seen using scanning electron microscopy. |
| Sectors | Agriculture Food and Drink Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology |
| Description | Interest in the results from this work has been highlighted from the Scottish Government-funded PCN working group. The group wishes to include the chitin-rich soil amendment into their IPM management work package so that it can be included in their grower-focussed decision support system. However, the group recognises that there is additional work needed including more detailed field trials. It is also worth noting that until current policy on using food waste products on agricultural land changes then products like this one will not be saleable. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2023 |
| Sector | Agriculture, Food and Drink,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology |
| Impact Types | Economic Policy & public services |
| Title | 16s & ITS sequences for pot and field experiments |
| Description | 16s & ITS sequences for pot and field experiments have been uploaded to EBI under the Project accession - PRJEB73872 |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | n/a |
| Description | Field open day (Barnyards, Forfar), presentation about PCN resistance and tolerance for growers, agronomists & seed producers |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | Approximately 100 growers, seed producers, land owners and agronomists relating to potato production were invited to a field trial open day at a site heavily infected with PCN. I was invited to present the importance of resistance against PCN and differentiate between resistance and tolerance. An additional session was conducted on novel technologies such as the use of chitin-rich soil amendments. Growers appreciated being able to talk directly to someone with a scientific knowledge of the topic and were welcomed to ask questions throughout the day. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.pcnhub.ac.uk/previous-events |
| Description | Potatoes in Practice stand |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
| Results and Impact | Hosting the PCN action Scotland stand at Potatoes in Practice. An opportunity to display various aspects of PCN work coordinated with the JHI CMS tent. RKN work was also presented on a poster. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.hutton.ac.uk/events/potatoes-practice-2023 |
| Description | SSCR winter meeting 2025 |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
| Results and Impact | Invited to speak at the SSCR winter meeting 2025 presenting PCN work at JHI and whether we are in control of PCN management strategies or not. There was decent audience participation and follow on discussions. The presentation covered work from several projects. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2025 |
| Description | Talk given at EAPR Pathology and Pests Section Meeting (Arras, France) |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | Invited as keynote speaker to present current PCN work. New contacts have been made following this activity. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.eapr-pathology2023.com/about-Arras-and-access |