Linkages between plant functional diversity soil biological communities and ecosystem services in agricultural grassland

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Earth Atmospheric and Env Sciences

Abstract

An increasing human population and the associated need to produce food in a changing world is one of the greatest challenge facing our generation. It is clear that we need to manage our agricultural systems more judiciously to yield benefits from ecosystem services, including biodiversity conservation, carbon and nutrient cycling and greenhouse gas regulation, along with food production. Grasslands are thought to be a key system for provision of these ecosystem services due to their large global coverage, but also because of their potential as reservoirs of biodiversity and nutrients. For instance, in the UK grasslands cover 36% of the land surface and already hold 32% of the UK soil carbon stock, and if managed correctly they could store even more. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change have identified grassland management as having the greatest potential to sequester additional C if managed correctly, and so grasslands are a key system for climate change mitigation. Here we propose that multiple ecosystem services, such as carbon storage, nutrient retention and reduced greenhouse gas emissions in grassland can be enhanced with management of the diversity and composition of the plant community. The reason for this is that plant species differ greatly in their functional characteristics, or traits, and these differences strongly influence the amount and quality of organic inputs to the soil, which in turn stimulates components of the soil microbial community responsible for soil carbon and nitrogen cycling. Moreover, these differences in traits could change the magnitude and direction of ecosystem services such as from net emission of greenhouse gases, towards mitigation via vegetation management. In this study we will characterise the differing traits of key grassland plant species associated with grassland biodiversity restoration, and test their impact on grassland ecosystem services including emissions of the greenhouse gases carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide, soil microbial activity and nutrient cycling and retention. This will provide the first information on the potential for plant diversity to be utilised to manipulate soil nutrient cycling towards greater carbon and nitrogen storage, and lower greenhouse gas emission.

Technical Summary

A key challenge facing agriculture is the need to manage farmland to provide non-market ecosystem services, such as C sequestration and efficient nutrient cycling, along with the maintenance of economically viable production. There is now widespread recognition that in many farming systems the delivery of ecosystem services depends on the maintenance of both above- and below-ground biodiversity, although the mechanisms involved, and the interactions between the two, are poorly understood. This project tests, in agricultural grassland, how variations in plant functional diversity - namely the type, range and relative abundance - influence soil microbial communities, and ultimately rates of soil carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling processes that underpin the delivery of the ecosystem services of C and N retention and greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation. Specifically, we test the overarching hypothesis that soil biogeochemical cycling underpinning ecosystem service delivery can be predicted from plant species' traits, when weighted according to the relative abundance of species, and hence that easily measured plant traits could provide a means to scale-up from the properties of individual species to ecosystem processes in diverse grassland systems. Based on findings from our previous research, we also test the hypothesis that the delivery of these ecosystem services will be maximised in high diversity grassland with plant trait assemblages that promote fungal-dominated decomposer communities, characterised by 'slow' cycling of C and N. In contrast, these services will be minimised and there will be greater emissions of GHGs in low diversity grassland with trait assemblages that promote bacterial-dominated communities associated with 'fast' C and N cycling. This research will provide major advances in our understanding of the importance and nature of interactions between above- and below-ground diversity for multi-functional objectives of grassland agriculture.

Planned Impact

The development of sward management practices to enhance C storage and lower greenhouse gas emission will have a major impact on a range of stakeholder groups and policy makers. There will be enormous benefits to society through the contribution to climate change mitigation, in a way that utilises, or even enhances, biodiversity, informed from better understanding of links between aboveground diversity and belowground functioning. Our proposed stakeholder meetings specific to facilitating communication, will provide a platform for knowledge exchange, and the real opportunity for translating our results into future development of sward management options to address real practical solutions. The main vehicles we will adopt to maximise the impact of our work and raise public awareness include academic publications, presentation at conferences, stakeholder workshops, initiatives with local schools and public scientific forums and lectures. We propose to hold two workshops, for which scientists, policy makers and stakeholders will be invited to participate in dissemination and development of our research activities. These workshops will scope existing policy and stakeholder contexts and perspectives, projected future grassland and agricultural management and policy scenarios, linking plant functional diversity and carbon storage in grassland, will evaluate ecosystem services in grasslands, as well as offering more detailed consideration of stable isotope techniques in terrestrial environments, and modelling of plant-soil interactions in C cycle models. From the greenhouse gas mitigation perspective, we will engage with stakeholders through the UK Nitrous Oxide Focus Group which serves to raise awareness, and propose mitigation solutions. We will also raise public awareness of our science through local and national media interviews, and by presenting at local forums such as Café Scientifique, or delivering public lectures, and organising outreach activities for local schools.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This project aimed to characterise how variations in plant functional diversity influence soil microbial communities and associated biogeochemical cycling, which underpin the provision of ecosystem services in grassland. In light of this we set up several experiments at a range of scales, from a small, greenhouse mesocosm experiment to a large-scale, long-term field study in the Yorkshire Dales. In partnership with Natural England, a large-scale field experiment was established in 2012 within the Ingleborough NNR in Yorkshire. The field experiment consists of a plant diversity manipulation, whereby plant functional groups in the MG3b Geranium syvalticum - Anthoxanthum odoratum grassland - a diverse upland hay meadow community - were sown and transplanted into the existing hay meadow. Over the length of the project, we aimed to determine how different mixtures of plant functional groups affect the soil microbial communities.

Our project has generated a number of key findings that have either recently been published or are being written up for publication in leading journals. Key findings include:

1. Pant traits as predictors of soil functions - This study, which has been accepted for publication in Journal of Ecology (De Long et al. 2019), used a pair of field experiments to test whether relationships between plant traits and soil functions to carbon cycling in monocultures could be scaled to the community-level in mixed grassland communities. Across monocultures of 25 grassland plant species, we detected relationships between some aboveground and belowground traits linked to resource acquisition, and traits predicted soil functions related to carbon cycling, including ecosystem respiration and net ecosystem exchange. However, these relationships were not detected using community-weighted mean traits in field plots that varied in plant species and functional diversity. Our results demonstrate that while plant traits can be used to predict certain soil properties and ecosystem functions in monocultures, they are less effective for predicting how changes in plant species composition influence ecosystem functions in mixed communities.

2. Belowground communities and plant traits - A parallel study, which has been published in the leading microbial ecology journal, The ISME Journal (Leff et al. 2018), was through collaboration with a BBSRC international partnership award. The study tested, in both monocultures and mixed temperate grassland communities, whether plant attributes predict soil communities including taxonomic groups from across the tree of life. The composition of all soil community groups was affected by plant species identity, and plant community composition predicted additional variation in soil community composition beyond what could be predicted from soil abiotic characteristics. However, neither plant phylogeny nor plant traits were strong predictors of soil communities in either experiment. These results demonstrate that grassland plant species form specific associations with soil community members and that information on plant species distributions can improve predictions of soil community composition.

3. A research paper, based on our collaboration, has been published in the leading multidisciplinary journal Science Advances (Semchenko et al. 2018). This study, which builds on that of Leff et al. (2018), showed that the diversity of putative pathogenic, mycorrhizal, and saprotrophic fungi is a primary regulator of plant-soil feedbacks across a broad range of temperate grassland plant species. We showed that plant species with resource-acquisitive traits, such as high shoot nitrogen concentrations and thin roots, attract diverse communities of putative fungal pathogens and specialist saprotrophs, and a lower diversity of mycorrhizal fungi, resulting in strong plant growth suppression on soil occupied by the same species. Moreover, soil properties modulate feedbacks with fertile soils, promoting antagonistic relationships between soil fungi and plants. This study advances our capacity to predict plant-soil feedbacks and vegetation dynamics by revealing fundamental links between soil properties, plant resource acquisition strategies, and the diversity of fungal guilds in soil.

4. Resilience to drought - We tested in the field experiment how plant functional composition influences the resistance and resilience of ecosystem functions under drought, using rain shelters erected in summer 2016. While plant functional diversity species did not have significant impacts on ecosystem functioning, the experimental drought strongly impacted C cycling above and below ground, reducing net ecosystem exchange by up to 50% and ecosystem respiration by up to 25% during the drought. Drought also reduced 13C-CO2 uptake in leaves and 13C transfer to roots, but had no impact 15N-NO3- uptake into root nor leaf biomass. Overall the results indicate that drought has profound impacts on C and N cycling, but that grasslands are generally resistant to extreme events in that C and N cycling processes rapidly recover.

5. Maternal effects (i.e., trans-generational plasticity) and soil legacies - We carried out an additional study to test for the relative importance of legacy effects generated by drought and plant diversity on plant performance and soil nutrient cycling. We used soil and seeds from an existing plant diversity and drought manipulation field experiment in temperate grassland to test maternal, soil drought and diversity legacy effects, and their interactions, on offspring plant performance of two grassland species (Alopecurus pratensis and Holcus lanatus) under contrasting glasshouse conditions. Our results showed that maternal effects on plant biomass were eclipsed by drought soil legacy. Drought soil legacy effects were attributed to changes in both abiotic (i.e., nutrient availability) and biotic properties (i.e., microbial carbon, enzyme activity). These findings demonstrate that while maternal effects resulting from drought occur in grasslands, their impacts on plant performance are likely minor relative to drought legacy effects on soil abiotic and biotic properties. This suggests that soil drought legacy effects could become increasingly important drivers of plant community dynamics and ecosystem functioning as extreme weather events become more frequent and intense with climate change. This work was published in the leading ecological journal Functional Ecology (De Long et al. 2019).
Exploitation Route Our findings will be of direct relevance to land managers, famers and policy makers with interests in managing grasslands for ecosystem services. We are still completing analyses of data so this is yet to be realised, but we are currently seeking funds to apply the ideas developed in this project to land management decisions on grassland restoration for multiple ecosystem services, for instance via GCRF.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

 
Description The research is completed and we are currently writing the work up for publication. However, research staff and PI's have been involved in engagement activities with a range of stakeholders at the focal field site, which have been organised jointly with Natural England who own the land (2013 and 2015), and RDB presented results at various public events and conferences, as have the two PDRAs working on the project.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Title Data availability.xlsx 
Description Data availability for the manuscript entitled 'Defoliation and fertilisation differentially moderate root trait effects on soil abiotic and biotic properties'. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://figshare.com/articles/dataset/Data_availability_xlsx/21394965/1
 
Title Data availability.xlsx 
Description Data availability for the manuscript entitled 'Defoliation and fertilisation differentially moderate root trait effects on soil abiotic and biotic properties'. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://figshare.com/articles/dataset/Data_availability_xlsx/21394965
 
Description Cafe Scientific Bath, Unseen Majority, Jan 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Richard Bardgett gave Cafe Scientific presentation at the Bath Science Cafe, January 2016, discussing the functional importance of belowground life, with reference to BBSRC and NERC funded research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://bathsciencecafe.org
 
Description Earth Matters: How Soil Underpins Civilization 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact After dinner speech on the importance of soils for food production at "Essential Soil and Water Conference", Allerton Project, Game and Wildlife Trust, Feb 2018
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.gwct.org.uk/news/news/2018/january/engaging-soil-and-water-conference-upcoming-at-the-al...
 
Description LIfe in Soil: does it matter? Royal Society Edinburgh Event, Feb 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Richard Bardgett Guest speaker at Royal Society Edinburgh Event, 24th February 2016, Life in Soil: does in matter? The event was organised to raise awareness of the importance of soil life along the general public, policy makers and practitioners, and landonwers and farmers. Talks were followed by a lively panel discussion.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL https://www.royalsoced.org.uk/events/event.php?id=420
 
Description Online presentation on Zoom into Soil: Regenerative Agriculture, BSSS/BES Webinar, Jan 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Online presentation at British Soil Science Society/British Ecological Society workshop "Zoom into Soil: Regenerative Agriculture", Webinar, Jan 2022. Audience mainly practitioners and scientists, and online YouTube video produced from the workshop has been watched by >1300 viewers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RggdJPe6nio
 
Description Plenary Lecture British Ecological Society Annual Meeting, Belfast, 2019. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Plenary Lecture, The hidden majority: soil biodiversity, ecosystem processes, and global change. Celebrating Global Ecology, British Ecological Society Annual Meeting, Belfast, Dec 2019. The talk generated discussions and debate, and helped to raise awareness of the importance of soil biodiversity for ecological processes.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Public Meeting on Soil Biodiversity, Rothamsted Research, July 2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Richard Bardgett guest speaker at public meeting on soil biodiversity: how to explore and utilise life in soil, July 2015.

Belowground biodiversity is largely out of sight and mind, but there is mounting evidence to show that the vast diversity of microorganisms and animals that live belowground contribute significantly to shaping the structure and function of terrestrial ecosystems. This talk will consider new insights into the distribution and ecological roles of belowground biodiversity, and consider some of consequences of changing soil biodiversity under future environmental change.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.rothamsted.ac.uk/events/soil-biodiversity
 
Description Stakeholder Science Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Workshop held at Colt Park National Nature Reserve with scientists and practitioners from Natural England to discuss outcomes of BBSRC and Defra funded research done on Ingleborough National Nature Reserve. The audience included staff from Natural England, collaborators from the US (Colorado and Yale), and research scientists at Manchester, Aberdeen, and Lancaster University and CEH Lancaster.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Talk on biodiversity for sustainable soils, BASE Annual Conference, Nottingham, Feb 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited talk at the BASE (biodiversity, agriculture, soils, environment) AGM and conference on Biodiversity for Sustainable Soils, Nottingham, Feb 2022. The talk considered to contribution of biodiversity to soil health and was delivered to an audience of farmers, land managers, and policymakers. The talk generated discussion and debate, and served to raise awareness of the science base behind soil biodiversity and its contribution to soil health.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://base-uk.co.uk/news-article.asp?id=107
 
Description Time Travel Through Soil 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation at public event at the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences, Amsterdam
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL https://knaw.nl/en/news/calendar/time-travel-through-soil