Pulsed laser deposited carbon electrodes for diamond radiation sensors

Lead Research Organisation: University of Surrey
Department Name: Nuclear and Radiation Physics

Abstract

This project will explore and optimise pulsed laser deposition (PLD) low resistivity amorphous carbon coatings as electrode material for radiation sensors based on high purity, high resistivity synthetic diamond produced by chemical vapour deposition (CVD). It will be the first time that the PLD technique is used for this purpose and it offers flexible deposition parameters to optimise the amorphous carbon based electrode properties with a technology that is compatible with conventional lithography.Electronic grade synthetic single crystal diamond is of interest for a large variety of electronic devices, such as high frequency components, transistors, high power diodes and more. High quality diamond bulk properties are ideally suited for a wide range of radiation detector applications ranging from X-ray and neutron sensors to deep UV detection, particle timing and spectroscopy. However, the current limitation to diamond sensor technology is a lack of understanding and reproducibility of contact depositions to the bulk material. This project will focus on the characterisation and optimisation of diamond sensor performance in medical dosimetry and X-ray beam monitoring applications, where diamond with metal-free pure amorphous carbon electrodes uniquely fulfils the requirements placed on X-ray sensors by the current progress in these areas. The nature and quality of the electrical interface determines the stability and performance of diamond radiation detector devices. The project will exploit the flexibility of PLD which allows the investigators to deposit pure carbon layers under a variety of deposition conditions to control and adjust the structural and electronic contact layer properties. PLD will allow them to optimise the deposition parameters of the contact layers according to the radiation sensor performance during the first phase of the project. This will improve the understanding of the influence of the contact properties on the charge transport across the diamond/electrode interface.In the second phase, pad and position sensitive radiation sensors based on the results of the first phase of the investigation will be produced. The sensor performance, including the spatial variation of the response will be studied. The spatial resolution of the prototype position sensor will be investigated to estimate the potential of this development for future X-ray imaging and monitoring devices. The application of the contacting techniques developed is not limited to radiation sensing and every electronic application involving diamond, which can operate at temperatures up to several hundred Celsius and in challenging chemical environments, will benefit from an improved understanding of the processes affecting charge transport across electrode interfaces.

Planned Impact

Element Six Ltd (e6) with its research facilities based in Ascot, is the world leader in the synthesis of high purity electronic grade bulk diamond. Diamond Detectors Limited (DDL) based in Poole(UK) was set up as an e6 venture in 2007, dedicated to the commercial exploitation of this material in radiation sensing applications. Since the end of 2008, BAE Systems has held 50% of the company investing up to 2M, which demonstrates the rising interest in diamond sensors in recent years. It is expected that the UK will continue to be world leading in diamond synthesis and fabrication for commercial diamond based radiation sensors. The experience and location of the Radiation and Medical Physics Group in Surrey, which has a good working relationship with DDL, is ideally suited to complement and support this commercial UK activity. DDL will support this project with technical input and access to their facilities. This connection will ensure timely and professional considerations of any potential commercial exploitations resulting from the project. The main two areas benefitting directly are: 1) X-ray beam diagnostics: There is a need for diamond sensors in the X-ray diagnostic community, particularly for high intensity sources (i.e. synchrotrons and free electron lasers). The Surrey group has a good relationship with synchrotron scientists involved in instrumentation and detector development in several laboratories, including the Diamond Light source (DLS), the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF) and DESY - host to the European free electron laser (XFEL).The DLS is a world class national UK synchrotron facility that has been established during the last decade and demands a UK commitment to synchrotron science for the future in order to optimise the benefit of this large investment. This work will continue to develop in discussion and liaison with colleagues at the light sources who have expressed their support for this project in the attached letters. They have a direct interest in obtaining usable beam diagnostic devices to improve their facilities for the benefit of all users; in this way, our work will support research programmes carried out at synchrotrons that span a large variety of science and engineering topics. 2) Medical dosimetry: This project can lead to the development of medical dosimetry devices, particularly for treatment planning and quality control of radiotherapy treatment delivery, where the trend is increasingly moving to higher resolution spatially defined irradiation fields. These will improve the accuracy of cancer treatment, reduce unwanted side effects and thus benefit health care. Results will be discussed with colleagues in the Medical Physics department of the Royal Surrey County Hospital who support this project and significant progress will be presented at medical physics workshops and conferences. In particular, the Surrey Physics department is part of the Radiation Instrumentation Theme of the SEPnet (South East Physics Network) consortium that is planning to hold focused workshops on detector developments for medical applications. Amorphous carbon electrode diamond sensors also open avenues to additional detector applications that benefit from diamonds material properties: a) Single particle sensitive sensors for biological and medical research that require non-toxic devices: The EPSRC Ion Beam Centre hosted by the University of Surrey is a world leading facility in targeted single cell irradiation which can benefit from thin position sensitive transmission detectors. b) Solar blind UV imaging devices for deep UV photolithography: Deep UV sources and their characterisation are required to reduce feature and thus device sizes in semiconductor industry. c) Radiation hard neutron detectors with low gamma sensitivity: Neutron detectors with these characteristics will benefit security applications as well as the renaissance of power generation by nuclear fission in the UK.
 
Description The project investigated the suitability of pulsed laser deposition carbon based coatings as an alternative electrode material to traditional metal layers for diamond based radiation sensors, particularly with respect to X-ray sensing.

The first objective was to study the correlation between the properties of the carbon coating and the conduction mechanism - initial deposition trials with pulsed laser deposition of pure Carbon and Carbon/Nickel mixtures on low cost thermal grade oxygen passivated polycrystalline diamond were promising in terms of the X-ray sensor performance achieved. As metal-free electrodes are the preferred option for medical and high intensity/low energy X-ray beam monitors, subsequent efforts focused on the optimisation of pure Carbon layers with varying laser deposition parameters on electronic grade polycrystalline diamond. Achieving sufficient adhesion of the carbon layers to the diamond was a major challenge, which made this part of the study take more time than originally envisaged. Carbon based electrodes could only be realised in the laser pulse energy range of 2.3 to 3.6 J cm^(-2)) and for carbon layer thicknesses of approximately 20 nm maximum. Adhesion stability could be slightly improved through a subsequent annealing procedure, which reduced stress and sp3 content in the electrode films. However, Raman studies on the annealed films suggest that differences in the amorphous carbon structure following the annealing procedure are negligible within the laser pulse energy range realised. Similarly, no systematic variation of the electronic performance of the prototype devices produced with deposition laser pulse energy could be found and all prototype sandwich devices (one side carbon electrode, one side Aluminium) showed very similar electronic diode like characteristics, indicating that the deposition process was well controlled and reproducible.

The second objective - to produce and characterise a pure carbon electrode X-ray sensor made of electronic single crystal diamond - was achieved. The device showed lower dark currents and superior signal to noise ratio and time response under X-ray illumination compared to the electronic grade polycrystalline samples (normalised to active area/volume), which - combined with the sublinear relationship between X-ray dose rate and signal current suggests that the carbon electrodes act as blocking contacts that do not allow charge injection and hence reducing signal as well as dark currents, which led to a significantly improved signal to noise ratio, which satisfies the IAEA recommendations for medical dosimetry.

The final objective - producing and evaluating a position sensitive sensor based on the developed technology could not be realised throughout the duration of the project due to the delays caused by the challenge to overcome the limited adhesion of amorphous carbon layers during the earlier parts of the project, which took more time than initially planned. However, the work on diamond X-ray dosimetry is currently being continued through PhD student project (self-funded).
Exploitation Route Graphitic electrodes fabricated by laser illumination in diamond to produce 3D structures is a topic of ongoing research, including groups at Manchester University.

At Surrey, a PhD project (funded by an overseas government) studying the effect of dose enhancement on medical devices and electrode performance is currently being continued.
Sectors Electronics,Energy,Healthcare

 
Description Development of Diamond based X-ray dosimeters
Amount £80,000 (GBP)
Organisation Government of Saudi Arabia 
Sector Public
Country Saudi Arabia
Start 10/2012 
End 09/2016
 
Description Tissue Equivalent Dosimeters Based on CVD Diamond with Graphite Electrodes For Radiotherapy Applications 
Organisation King Abdulaziz University
Country Saudi Arabia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution A. Lohstroh has been named as a consultant for a research proposal for a 6 month project submitted by H. Al-Barakaty to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Ministry of Higher Education King Abdulaziz University. The project focuses on the development and characterisation of a prototype tissue equivalent dosimeter based on synthetic single crystal diamond with graphitic elecrodes
Start Year 2013
 
Description Participate in Soapbox Science 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Talk/Discussion with members of the public in Bristol Pedestrian Zone for 1 hour as part of Soapbox Science
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://soapboxscience.org/
 
Description Radiation detectors based on synthetic diamond 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Invited seminar presentation at the Physics department of the University of Leicester.

Consider future collaborations with the academic at Leicester who is now working in Sussex, subsequent discussions for joint projects have taken place.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013