Precursor Chemistry and the CVD of Transparent Conducting Oxides
Lead Research Organisation:
University College London
Department Name: Chemistry
Abstract
This project will involve the investigation of alternative precursors and deposition technologies in order to improve performance and enable next generation transparent conducting oxide (TCO) films to be developed.
Indium tin oxide (ITO) is the current TCO of choice for most industrial applications but it has many limitations, such as modest conductivity (2000-4000 S/cm), a relatively low work function and some optical absorption in the blue-green spectral region. In addition, indium is expensive since it is in relatively short supply, which presents a significant challenge for larger-scale production of next generation photovolatic technologies and flat panel displays. It is therefore crucial to develop alternative TCO materials with no indium with improved optical and electrical properties. Alternatives to ITO include doped ZnO (ZnO:Al, ZnO:Ga, ZnO:SnO2) and doped SnO2 (SnO2:Sb, SnO2:F, ZnO-SnO2) and many of these have been investigated in their bulk form. However, studies of some of these materials as thin films is limited and for many of the applications thin films are required. An ideal method for preparing thin fims for large scale applications is chemical vapour deposition (CVD) given that films with good uniformity and compositional control, large area growth and step coverage can be achieved. However, for a successful CVD process, a volatile precursor is necessary which is prefereably a liquid or low metling solid for atmospheric pressure CVD or highly soluble for liquid based (aerosol assisted) CVD. Current precursors to TCO materials, particularly indium and zinc still suffer from chemical instability, poor reproducibility in the growth process and less than favourable vapour pressures and reactivity for film growth.
This work aims to develop highly volatile and soluble precursors based on metal ketoiminates. The advantages of using the ketoiminate ligand include:
- reactive complexes can be formed in high yield
- complexes with a hign vapour pressure can be formed as monomeric species are isolated
- thermal stability of the metal complexes can be increased by tuning the groups attached to the nitrogen atoms
- the surface reaction between the metal precursor and the surface of the substrate can be enhanced due to the high chemical reactivity of the complexes.
TCO materials to be investigated include doped-ZnO and doped-SnO2. We have the ability to lay down thin films using a new combinatorial aerosol-assisted (AA)CVD reactor for solution based and also a combinatorial APCVD reactor to make films of graded composition. This new reactor enables upto 400 different compositions to be made on a single plate in one CVD experiment. This is important as it will enable us to rapidly screen composition space make idealised and optimised compositions for TCO applications. This combined approach will enable us to investigate different combinations and go towards achieving the next generation TCO materials.
Indium tin oxide (ITO) is the current TCO of choice for most industrial applications but it has many limitations, such as modest conductivity (2000-4000 S/cm), a relatively low work function and some optical absorption in the blue-green spectral region. In addition, indium is expensive since it is in relatively short supply, which presents a significant challenge for larger-scale production of next generation photovolatic technologies and flat panel displays. It is therefore crucial to develop alternative TCO materials with no indium with improved optical and electrical properties. Alternatives to ITO include doped ZnO (ZnO:Al, ZnO:Ga, ZnO:SnO2) and doped SnO2 (SnO2:Sb, SnO2:F, ZnO-SnO2) and many of these have been investigated in their bulk form. However, studies of some of these materials as thin films is limited and for many of the applications thin films are required. An ideal method for preparing thin fims for large scale applications is chemical vapour deposition (CVD) given that films with good uniformity and compositional control, large area growth and step coverage can be achieved. However, for a successful CVD process, a volatile precursor is necessary which is prefereably a liquid or low metling solid for atmospheric pressure CVD or highly soluble for liquid based (aerosol assisted) CVD. Current precursors to TCO materials, particularly indium and zinc still suffer from chemical instability, poor reproducibility in the growth process and less than favourable vapour pressures and reactivity for film growth.
This work aims to develop highly volatile and soluble precursors based on metal ketoiminates. The advantages of using the ketoiminate ligand include:
- reactive complexes can be formed in high yield
- complexes with a hign vapour pressure can be formed as monomeric species are isolated
- thermal stability of the metal complexes can be increased by tuning the groups attached to the nitrogen atoms
- the surface reaction between the metal precursor and the surface of the substrate can be enhanced due to the high chemical reactivity of the complexes.
TCO materials to be investigated include doped-ZnO and doped-SnO2. We have the ability to lay down thin films using a new combinatorial aerosol-assisted (AA)CVD reactor for solution based and also a combinatorial APCVD reactor to make films of graded composition. This new reactor enables upto 400 different compositions to be made on a single plate in one CVD experiment. This is important as it will enable us to rapidly screen composition space make idealised and optimised compositions for TCO applications. This combined approach will enable us to investigate different combinations and go towards achieving the next generation TCO materials.
Planned Impact
This project will have impact through the development of alternative precursors and deposition of thin films of new transparent conducting oxides (TCOs). Solar energy panels offer alternative solutions for a range of energy requirements, for example, Pilkington TCO glass is used in the manufacture of thin plate panels used in the direct conversion of solar radiation to electricity. The thin film solar market is predicted to grow six-fold over the next 5 years to 2GW by 2015. As such, there is significant pressure to supply large volumes of high quality transparent conducting oxides with a range of properties suitable to meet the differing requirements that thin film solar cell manufacturers demand. Solar energy panels offer alternative solutions for a range of energy requirements, from small-scale domestic applications to large-scale solar power stations, from cloudy northern rooftops to hot sunny deserts. TCO films are a key component of these applications and the development of improved TCO films will benefit the public, for example by supplying electricity with a very low environmental footprint. The reduction of fuel costs and the development of improved TCOs will have significant impact on the public sector. With increasing legislation in place via international agreements to reduce greenhouse gases to acceptable levels the development of alternative energy, such as solar-power is clearly of great importance and will reduce the need for fossil fuels.
Organisations
- University College London (Lead Research Organisation)
- Malvern Instruments (Collaboration)
- Sun Chemical Ltd (Collaboration)
- Plasma Quest (Collaboration)
- Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) (Collaboration)
- Teer Coatings Ltd (Collaboration)
- Pilkington Glass (Collaboration, Project Partner)
- AkzoNobel (Collaboration)
Publications
Dixon S
(2016)
n-Type doped transparent conducting binary oxides: an overview
in Journal of Materials Chemistry C
Kafizas A
(2017)
Water Oxidation Kinetics of Accumulated Holes on the Surface of a TiO 2 Photoanode: A Rate Law Analysis
in ACS Catalysis
Knapp C
(2014)
Aerosol-Assisted Chemical Vapour Deposition of Transparent Zinc Gallate Films
in ChemPlusChem
Knapp CE
(2016)
Solution based CVD of main group materials.
in Chemical Society reviews
Manzi J
(2015)
Aerosol-Assisted Chemical-Vapour Deposition of Zinc Oxide from Single-Source ß-Iminoesterate Precursors
in European Journal of Inorganic Chemistry
Noor N
(2015)
Influencing FTO thin film growth with thin seeding layers: a route to microstructural modification
in Journal of Materials Chemistry C
Ponja S
(2015)
Magnesium Oxide Thin Films with Tunable Crystallographic Preferred Orientation via Aerosol-Assisted CVD
in Chemical Vapor Deposition
Ponja SD
(2015)
Enhanced Bactericidal Activity of Silver Thin Films Deposited via Aerosol-Assisted Chemical Vapor Deposition.
in ACS applied materials & interfaces
Description | In this project precursor development was investigated for their use in depositing high quality transparent conducting oxide films. These materials are used in window coatings, solar powered panels, phones and computers and micro electrode arrays. Good progress was made in developing novel precursors for use in aerosol assisted CVD. Some of the precursors were studied by an industrial partner to evaluate them and a patent had been published. Eight publications have also resulted from this project. |
Exploitation Route | This project led to further funding through the EPSRC grant: EP/L017709/1 (£2,281,220, 'Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxide (TCO) Inks and Thin Films') which was investigating scaled up routes for film deposition. The precursor chemistry developed could be utilitsed by thin film manufacturers as a sustainable method to depositthin films which does not use toxic or pyrophoric reagents. |
Sectors | Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology |
URL | http://google.com/patents/WO2016132100A1?cl=en |
Description | A patent has been granted on the use of a particular type of precursor for the deposition of metal or metal oxide thin films. Precursors developed in the project are currently being investigated by industrial partners for use in sol-gel, inkjet and spray deposition techniques for the formation of functional window coatings. |
First Year Of Impact | 2017 |
Sector | Chemicals,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology |
Impact Types | Economic |
Description | Materially Better Physical Sciences: A Prospectus for the UK Materials Science Community |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Participation in a guidance/advisory committee |
URL | http://www.epsrc.ac.uk/newsevents/pubs/materiallybetterphysicalsciences/ |
Description | Co-doped TCO Films |
Amount | £80,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | University College London |
Department | Department of Chemistry |
Sector | Academic/University |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 08/2013 |
End | 09/2016 |
Description | Porous Complexes for Structural Determination |
Amount | £108,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 08/2014 |
End | 09/2018 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxide (TCO) Inks and Thin Films |
Amount | £2,281,220 (GBP) |
Funding ID | EP/L017709/1 |
Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 03/2014 |
End | 02/2019 |
Description | Zinc Oxide Precursors and Film Deposition |
Amount | £80,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 08/2012 |
End | 09/2015 |
Description | NSG |
Organisation | Pilkington Glass |
Department | Pilkington Technology Centre |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | Identifying precursors for use in thin film deposition of functional materials |
Collaborator Contribution | Testing precursors in scale rigs and completing patent on potentially commercial precursors |
Impact | Patent and publications as well as further investment in grants |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | AkzoNobel |
Department | Research, Development and Innovation |
Country | Netherlands |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | Malvern Instruments |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | Pilkington Glass |
Department | Pilkington Technology Centre |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | Plasma Quest |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | Sun Chemical Ltd |
Country | Canada |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable Manufacturing of Transparent Conducting Oxides |
Organisation | Teer Coatings Ltd |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The project represents a significant collaboration between academia and industrial sector organisations. The collaborators will provide an application context for the developments. We are working closely with industrial partners, particularly NSG (Pilkington) who are the world's largest supplier of TCO glass and have considerable interests in photovoltaic stacks. NSG have collaborated with UCL for ~20 years and have funded CASE awards etc and are well placed to commercialise developments from the project under the appropriate licensing agreements. They have the expertise and equipment to investigate scale-up. We are also working closely with our other industry partners who are interested in the development of nanoceramics for TCOs in photovoltaics as printed inks (e.g. Teer Coatings), in order to ensure that outcomes are regularly disseminated and discussed. |
Collaborator Contribution | All have attended regular quarterly project meetings and provided expert advice. Sun Chemical have provided expert guidance and resources to enable us to develop inks and Malvern are helping with rheology. Beer coatings have taken our sample and sputtered films. NSG provide regular input and help with the design of the scale up system as well as providing samples. |
Impact | Patent has been published on "Deposition process" WO2016132100A1 with Pilkington NSG. Abstract of the patent "A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate." Collaborations continue with NSG investigating hydrophobic coatings (EP/W010798/1 A durable and scalable anti-soiling coating for solar modules) for solar panels and also discussions on scale up AACVD and mist CVD. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Title | DEPOSITION PROCESS |
Description | A process for depositing an inorganic material on a substrate, the process comprising, providing a substrate having a surface, providing a precursor mixture comprising a metal sulfonate, and delivering the precursor mixture to the surface of the substrate, wherein the surface of the substrate is at a substrate temperature of above 450 °C and is sufficient to effect decomposition of the metal sulfonate. The inorganic material may include a metal or a metal oxide. The preferred metal sulfonate is metal triflate. |
IP Reference | WO2016132100 |
Protection | Patent granted |
Year Protection Granted | 2016 |
Licensed | No |
Impact | Precursor have been identified which can be used for the deposition of a range of technologically important metal oxides |