Point-of-Care High Accuracy Fracture Risk Prediction

Lead Research Organisation: Cranfield University
Department Name: Cranfield Defence and Security

Abstract

A significant and escalating worldwide health burden is the aging population and its demand for accurate medical diagnostics. Of particular concern are osteo diseases such as osteoporosis as these become significantly more apparent in elderly populations. Unfortunately, current diagnostic methods are poor predictors of pathology outcomes such as fracture risk. The challenge then is to identify and develop enhanced and new approaches to bone quality appraisal that can be employed for accurate prognosis, targeted therapies and therapy assessment.

It has been well demonstrated that 'bone quality' (including characteristics such as collagen/mineral ratio, collagen integrity, mineral crystallite size, microstrain) has a marked affect on a bone's mechanical properties and is probably the 'missing' information required to produce diagnostically predictive models of fracture. Unfortunately there is no current technique for its in vivo determination. However, such information is embodied within conventional X-ray scatter signatures (e.g. X-ray diffraction) although these are weak and present significant measurement difficulties.

We have identified a potential route to in vivo measurement of these clinically valuable but weak signals. The technology has only recently become available through independent innovations for (i) X-ray generation (flat panel/source-on-a-chip) and (ii) obtaining 'amplified' information from scattered X-rays (using 'focal construct technology', FCT). Critically, the multi-emitter flat panel X-ray source will enable us to engineer precisely the analytical X-ray beam required to provide scatter signatures enhanced by several orders of magnitude. The FCT beam topology also enables the simultaneous measurement of the absorbed X-rays (to estimate bone mineral density) and those coherently (and incoherently) scattered. The source-on-a-chip technology is manufactured as a flat-panel device capable of generating X-rays from very low-power sources. It has the additional advantage that it may be fabricated to produce an X-ray source of precisely the geoemetric form required for FCT. Ultimately we envisage these techniques being integrated within a single imaging/DEXA/scatter system to provide a comprehensive diagnostic tool. The nature of the techniques also enables design towards hand portable devices for point-of-patient care. Thus this proposal principally concerns the development of a new instrument that will be subsequently used to examine the possibilities of applying our novel technologies to a number of different areas and therefore it will enable a new and exciting research capability.

Planned Impact

The research programme is the first step towards the development of a new healthcare technology for accurate and robust bone fracture prediction. The technological solution builds upon cutting edge science coupled with highly innovative state-of-the-art engineering. The application of the technology will enable patients with osteoporosis to be accurately diagnosed within GP surgeries and other local points of care. Our approach has the potential for wide spread impact in patient care, N.H.S. cost savings, U.K. industrial development and wealth generation.

1. Patients will be significantly less likely to suffer from factures (or even death following fracture) due to more informed patient management and will have enhanced health care through reduced times to receive the results of tests.

2. Patients receiving therapy for bone disease will have improved care through faster and more accurate diagnostic testing.

3. The N.H.S. spend of >£20 billion per annum on treating hip fractures would be significantly reduced if accurate fracture assessment were possible.

4. Industries in the U.K. will assume a world lead in the technology growth and application underpinning significant potential global R&D investment ultimately contributing to the U.K.'s economic growth.

5. The young scientists employed would be trained within an exciting applied research field providing a springboard for future careers in academia and or industry.

6. In the short term the Universities will benefit directly through an expanded research base, new collaborations and networks.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Arnold EL (2020) The use of µCT and fractal dimension for fracture prediction in osteoporotic individuals. in Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials

publication icon
Dicken A (2014) Validation study of a ray-tracing simulator for focal construct geometry. in Applied radiation and isotopes : including data, instrumentation and methods for use in agriculture, industry and medicine

publication icon
Dicken A. J. (2016) TOWARDS POINT OF CARE INSTRUMENTATION FOR ACCURATE FRACTURE RISK PREDICTION in OSTEOPOROSIS INTERNATIONAL

publication icon
Dicken AJ (2015) X-ray diffraction from bone employing annular and semi-annular beams. in Physics in medicine and biology

 
Description We have been able to show which physico-chemical and architectural features of bone show a measurable change associated with osteoporosis. Further, a new method to measure such features has been demonstrated and a route to production of a prototype instrument produced.
We have, through a new collaboration with 'QBIM' and their FE modelling of osteoporotic bone, managed to show a close correlation with clinically critical mechanical bone properties and the architectural features revealed by CT. A paper is currently in prep.
Exploitation Route The fundamental data indicates how improved fractured prediction may be possible by appropriate in vivo measurements.
Sectors Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description The finding have shown which components of X-ray scatter signatures may be clinically significant. This is currently being considered by Halo X-ray Technologies (HXT) as the basis for development of a prototype instrument. HXT have submitted 2 Innovate UK grants and are a partner on an EPSRC grant (starting July 2018) to develop a working platform instrument based upon the new biomarkers.
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description CRUK Grand Challenge
Amount £19,498,366 (GBP)
Funding ID Precision 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 05/2017 
End 04/2023
 
Description EPSRC Healthcare Partnerships
Amount £750,000 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/R024316/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2018 
End 06/2020
 
Description EPSRC Impact Acceleration Account
Amount £10,000 (GBP)
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2016 
End 03/2017
 
Description EPSRC Institutional Sponsorship Fund
Amount £29,254 (GBP)
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2016 
End 03/2017
 
Description Home Office
Amount £400,000 (GBP)
Funding ID IRC2010 
Organisation Home Office 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2011 
End 01/2014
 
Description Home Office
Amount £400,000 (GBP)
Funding ID IRC2010 
Organisation Home Office 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2011 
End 07/2014
 
Title FCT on Bone 
Description During the course of the research programme, we developed a new approach to the rapid and accurate acquisition of diagnostic information associated with osteo material. This includes both a new absorption imaging modality and a physicochemical probe that act simultaneously. Know collectively as focal construct technology, this was a significant development component of the research programme which successfully delivered data of a precision to enable its usefulness diagnostically. This has been described within several papers, one of which is identified below and the rest in the Publications section. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The impacts have included (a) the tool was essential for the successful application of one component of the CRUK proposal (see Further Funding) (b) the method was applied to the study of a different biological apatite system and this resulted in several extraneous publications (including a Sci Report, 2017) (c) the method has been adopted within a new PhD programme examining species differentiation for the forensic sector (d) the method will be used in a new collaboration with archaeologists at Exeter University where osteoporotic change in ancient civilisations will be explored. 
 
Title Data supporting: 'Association between nanoscale strains and tissue level nanoindentation properties in age-related hip-fractures' 
Description Measurement of the properties of bone as a material can happen in various length scales in its hierarchical and composite structure. The aim of this study was to test the tissue level properties of clinically-relevant human bone samples which were collected from donors belonging to three groups: ageing donors who suffered no fractures (Control); untreated fracture patients (Fx-Untreated) and patient who experienced hip fracture despite being treated with bisphosphonates (Fx-BisTreated). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Data_supporting_Association_between_nanoscale_strains_...
 
Title Data supporting: 'Association between nanoscale strains and tissue level nanoindentation properties in age-related hip-fractures' 
Description Measurement of the properties of bone as a material can happen in various length scales in its hierarchical and composite structure. The aim of this study was to test the tissue level properties of clinically-relevant human bone samples which were collected from donors belonging to three groups: ageing donors who suffered no fractures (Control); untreated fracture patients (Fx-Untreated) and patient who experienced hip fracture despite being treated with bisphosphonates (Fx-BisTreated). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Data_supporting_Association_between_nanoscale_strains_...
 
Title Supporting data: 'Age Related Changes of Rib Cortical Bone Matrix: Application for Age-at-Death Estimation' 
Description This study used autopsy material from 113 rib specimens. A set of 33 parameters were measured by standard bio-mechanical (nanoindentation and microindentation), physical (TGA/DSC, XRD and FTIR) and histomorphometry (porosity-ImageJ) methods. Stepwise regressions were used to create 35 equations that would produce the best 'estimates of age at death' vs real age of the cadavers. Five equations were produced; in the best of cases an equation counting 7 parameters had an R2 = 0.863 and mean absolute error of 4.64 years. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Supporting_data_Age_Related_Changes_of_Rib_Cortical_Bo...
 
Title Supporting data: 'Age Related Changes of Rib Cortical Bone Matrix: Application for Age-at-Death Estimation' 
Description This study used autopsy material from 113 rib specimens. A set of 33 parameters were measured by standard bio-mechanical (nanoindentation and microindentation), physical (TGA/DSC, XRD and FTIR) and histomorphometry (porosity-ImageJ) methods. Stepwise regressions were used to create 35 equations that would produce the best 'estimates of age at death' vs real age of the cadavers. Five equations were produced; in the best of cases an equation counting 7 parameters had an R2 = 0.863 and mean absolute error of 4.64 years. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Supporting_data_Age_Related_Changes_of_Rib_Cortical_Bo...
 
Description Combined Raman and X-ray Scattering 
Organisation University of Exeter
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We are contributing the data, skills and knowledge from the EPSRC grant to a new consortium.
Collaborator Contribution This is a new consortium that has evolved during the past 2 months. It is designed to realise the findings from two EPSRC funded research grants and combine the outputs of both studies into a single progressive grant with significant added value.
Impact The initial output from the consortium will be an EPSRC grant submission due to occur in 2017.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Halo exploitation 
Organisation HALO X-ray Technologies Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We are providing the underpinning scientific expertise and skills required for commercialisation
Collaborator Contribution Halo X-ray are translating the research ideas that arise in response to outcomes from the EPSRC grant from ourselves to a practical and commercial space.
Impact CA
Start Year 2016
 
Description Longitudinal imaging of bone tissue remodeling: a novel platform for probing skeletal adaptation 
Organisation University of Saskatchewan
Department Department of Anatomy and Cell Biology
Country Canada 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The goal of this interdisciplinary research is to advance understanding of the spatio-temporal regulation of cortical bone remodeling. Stated simply, we seek to understand how a BMU plots its course through bone and what factors affect its progression both in terms of its resorptive and formative phases. Our role in the project would be to utilize image data to target post-mortem assessment of ultrastructural properties adjacent to BMUs in both the rabbit and the human bones. The culmination of our partnership will be the development of new computational models that allow integration of complex regulatory mechanisms governing the path and progression of BMUs through existing micro- and ultrastructure.
Collaborator Contribution This collaborative programme resulted in a major applicatio to the presidigeous Human Frontiers Science Programme involving a number of International collaborators. The Partners contributions were to realise the following objectives : 1. Establish a novel in vivo imaging protocol for longitudinal 3D observation of BMUs in the rabbit 2. Perform comparative 3D ex vivo imaging on human materials 3. Incorporate image data within multilevel computational models of BMU regulation for both humans and rabbits.
Impact We have yet to be successful in our efforts to fund this proposal. Further actions will be undertaken over the next 24 months.
Start Year 2016
 
Description NISTA Diagnostics 
Organisation Nista Diagnostics
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Our team is providing a component of the technical support to enable proper interpretation of data.
Collaborator Contribution This is a new collaboration that started in Oct 2019. This new US medical diagnostics company Nista Diagnostics Inc, are attempting to augment the pathological assessment of biological tissues through the use of X-ray scattering to examine a wide range of conditions. Nista made an approach to the Cranfield team as they were aware of the work we had been undertaking on osteoporosis and disease in other tissues. Nista have requested that the Cranfield team undertake all the essential 'up-front' work to commence a small clinical trial within the UK at two Centres and then manage the trials. The networks formed as a component of the EPSRC grant have enabled this to be undertaken quickly and we hope to be starting the trials within 2020.
Impact This is a commercial, multidisciplinary collaboration that is within early gestation stages, hence there are no definitive outputs as yet.
Start Year 2019
 
Description QUBIM - modelling mechanical properties 
Organisation Quibim SL
Country Spain 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We are taking the CT data collected during the EPSRC grant and providing it to Qubim in order to develop models of mechanical properties from FE calculations.
Collaborator Contribution Qubim are a new, start-up company that is using clinical CT data to derive bone mechanical properties from FE calculations. They have agreed on a new collaboration where they exploit data collected from the sample cohorts of fractured and non-fractured bones to assess the mechanical properties and elate these to the physicochemistry.
Impact The CT data is currently being sent to Qubim and therefore we have no outputs to report at this early stage.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Towards Preventing Vertebral Fractures Using Multiscale Biomechanical, Simulation and Imaging Techniques 
Organisation Queensland University of Technology (QUT)
Country Australia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We shall be undertaking nano-scale physicochemical characterisation of bone mineral crystals using X-ray Diffraction and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy. We shall use techniques established in our lab and utilised by Dr Greenwood in the EPSRC project, to establish potential correlations between these chemical biomarkers and both morphological (from micro-CT) and mechanical parameters (from tissue-level testing).
Collaborator Contribution This collaboration is through an ARC grant that will be submitted in March 2017 (hence no financial contributions have been attributed). The partners are planning to 1. Develop an integrated framework of novel imaging and biomechanical testing techniques to capture osteoporotic bone tissue biomechanics and morphology over multiple spatial scales. 2. Apply these techniques to obtain a comprehensive visual illustration and constitutive knowledge of mechanisms by which microfractures accumulate and culminate in vertebral fractures. 3. Design new hierarchical simulation techniques to replicate individualised multi-scale anatomy for a musculoosseoligamentous system, with a focus on the aged osteoporotic spine. 4. Predict trabeculae microfracture (top-down approach) and vertebral compression fracture risk (bottom-up approach) in the osteoporotic spine for simulated loading conditions representing authentic physical activities. 5. Using probabilistic modelling methods, characterise the relative importance of bone architecture, external loading and bone tissue properties in regulating fracture risk in the osteoporotic spine.
Impact No outputs as yet except for a complete grant proposal.
Start Year 2017
 
Company Name HALO X-ray Technologies Ltd 
Description HALO X-ray Technologies is an innovation company developing new and disruptive materials identification systems for aviation security, medical systems and process control applications. The HXT patent portfolio, currently licensed from our academic partners, protects our core IP. Industry-standard lab- and time-bound X-ray analysis techniques are now possible as real-time solutions for multiple industries by implementing new X-ray optics to dramatically improve signal strength. This significantly translates underlying and well-established science into a solution that can solve industrial and commercial applications at speeds required for these markets. As an example, aviation security has historically used technology that typically only estimates if a material is a threat. This leads to false alarms, long delays through checkpoints and frustrated passengers. HXT technology has capability to definitively identify material and for the first time at speeds that will enhance rather than slow checkpoint systems and at a cost point that is well-aligned with our target markets. HXT platform technology can provide medical systems for point-of-care solutions to address an ageing population and process control systems providing definitive and rapid materials analysis to improve efficiency for in-line industrial manufacturing. HXT IP provides platform capability across numerous sectors, realising disruptive and compelling solutions and offering significant business opportunity in all areas of application. The current focus is on aviation and border security and there are a number of opportunities specifically for this sector, such as: - Drugs and currency detection for postal systems. - Personal electronic devices screening (PEDS). - Checkpoint screening system for explosives detection. 
Year Established 2012 
Impact Halo X-ray Technologies Ltd (HXT) has its offices and development facilities based in *BioCity Nottingham. HXT systems offer new opportunities to the aviation security environment and will be potentially deployed in greater locations throughout the airport. The aviation checkpoint will be improved as our technology and systems roll out and new HXT technology will facilitate additional security checks at the departure gate. *BioCity is a private limited company founded by the University of Nottingham and Nottingham Trent University who are each part owners of the business.
Website https://www.haloxray.com/
 
Description Girl Guide Engagement 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Given the research subject, we believed that it was important to address the issues of osteoporosis in audiences of young women. We therefore undertook a series of talks and information sessions through the local girl guiding organisations on a number of occasions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015,2016
 
Description International Centre for Diffraction Data 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact We believed that it was important to engage with a professional organisation in the analytical science sector - especially associated with X-ray diffraction. The International Centre for Diffraction Data (ICDD) based in Philadelphia is pre-eminent as a company within the professional diffraction sector and therefore we approached ICDD and were subsequently invited to Philadelphia to present our work to the Members at Large.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Womens Institute Engagement 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Patients, carers and/or patient groups
Results and Impact As part of the outreach from the study, we undertook a formal engagement with the Women's Institute to disseminate information and findings associated with the study. This was particularly relevant given the nature of the research and the audience. The engagement involved a number of interviews culminating in a talks provided to a number of regional Women's Institute meetings.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015,2016