Mathematical foundations of metamaterials: homogenisation, dissipation and operator theory

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bath
Department Name: Mathematical Sciences

Abstract

In order to understand how various physical media behave under specific conditions, for example: a) how the earth surface
is deformed during an earthquake, or b) what image resolution one can achieve with a fibre-optic endoscope, mathematicians write
differential equations (DEs) and study analytical properties of their solutions, which are then interpreted to draw conclusions
about real-life objects. Part of this activity involves analysis of DEs that additionally depend on a parameter. In the above examples
this parameter could be: a) the ratio of the size of the rock-forming crystals to the thickness of layers of rock in the ground, or
b) the thickness-to-length ratio of the endoscope.
The project will develop a new approach to the analysis of solutions of parameter-dependent DEs, based on recent achievements
in the mathematical theory of ``operators'' and their spectra, which could roughly be thought of as the sets of the operator ``values''.
In general, the spectrum of an operator is found in the two-dimensional-plane of ``complex'' numbers. However, for many operators
representing DEs, the spectrum is a subset of a straight line in this plane. It turns out that considering such an operator as a member of a
wider operator family, whose spectra are not necessarily situated on the same line, brings about a lot of technical benefits, in a similar way
analysis in the complex plane helps understanding real numbers. In the last 50 years or so, many elegant mathematical results about
operators (and about DEs as their particular case) have been obtained by using this analogy. We will exploit these results in order to
improve our understanding of the behaviour of families of DEs. As a particular source of such families we will study equations representing
composites, i.e. media that have several simpler constituent parts. Many objects around us are composites, for example, wood, porous
rocks, foams, bubbly liquids, reinforced resins, polycrystal metals. Mathematical statements that we aim at will provide new information
about such real-life objects concerning, for example, their acoustic properties, or the way in which they interact with an electromagnetic
field. From the physics point of view, members of this wider operator family admit some dissipation (i.e. loss of energy) in comparison to
the original ``loss-free'' setup. The project will provide a general mathematical framework for such dissipative extensions in the case of DEs
describing composites, yielding a new analytic approach to the study of their effective properties.

Planned Impact

The proposed research has two aspects in terms of evaluating its future impact. On the one hand, it has a strong
fundamental component: it is situated on the interface between areas of analysis that have become classical in the
course of development of mathematics in the 20th century. The related concepts and questions (the relationship between
miscroscopic and macroscopic properties of physical media around us, their scattering properties, the structure of the
mathematical objects that describe them) emerge at different levels of dissemination of science knowledge.
They have found their place in basic undergraduate and postgraduate courses and also offer many exciting problems at the
cutting edge of basic research. From this perspective our results will have impact on a fairly large community right from the
start of our work. This community will include those who pursue a professional path in areas related to engineering,
materials science, communication. For example, this could be someone involved in manufacturing non-destructive
testing devices, or someone working on internet technologies. Progress in these areas relies on good understanding
of the basics that underpin them, and this project will increase such understanding.
On the other hand, our mathematical results will have impact on the research and development of new real-world
applications in the above areas. This aspect is likely to materialise in the longer run, 7-10 years from the start of the project
onwards. However, the public will be informed about our progress towards these technological advances even before they
happen. We believe it will be of great benefit to all to be able to learn about science ``in the making'', and it will help
us adjusting our research in order to maximise impact. The project will also make an excellent case for the role of fundamental
mathematics research in shaping our life, which is of benefit to those involved in the education process.
 
Description As a result of the work funded through this award, understanding of the link between composite media with certain geometric and material properties and the so-called time-dispersive media, or media with "memory", in continuum mechanics has been achieved.

Prior to the award, time dispersion had only been explored in the context of electromagnetism, where it is due to the particle interaction at the atomic length-scale. Time dispersion manifests itself in the dependence of the material parameters on the frequency. This is a powerful property, which leads, for example, to "negative refraction", when the geometry of the wave propagation does not follow the classical law known from the school physics.

The work carried out though the award has shown that the time dispersive behaviour is a general feature of continuous media, whenever the internal miscrostructure is taken into account (mathematically, whenever their properties are thought of as obtained by an upscaling process). The project has provided a key to obtaining this general understanding by providing powerful mathematical tools for understanding length-scale interactions, thereby deducing the missing memory terms in the macroscopic description of the continuous medium from the analysis of resonances on the microscale. In this way, time-dispersive media (or "metamaterials") are simply identified as composites with "active" resonance features (i.e. in the scaling regimes when the resonances are "activated").
Exploitation Route In general terms, new mathematical tools developed as a result of the award : a) provide qualitative insight into the behaviour of media, materials, and their mathematical structures; b) equip the end-user with quantitative information about materials that are either already in existence or to be designed with specific properties.

The specific work carried out through the award allows one to efficiently proceed beyond the original objectives, namely: a) develop a scattering theory for time-dispersive media (applicable to a variety of physics contexts, for example, electromagnetism, acoustics, piezoelectricity); b) provide a quantitative description of time dispersive effects for acoustic media, thereby introducing a new quantitative predictive methodology to materials science. This, in turn leads to a range of impacts:

(A) Theoretical impact, through the development of new underpinning material theories: here the beneficiaries are the academic communities working on: a) spectral properties of differential operators (mathematical analysis); b) new concepts for advanced materials and structures (engineering); c) unified view of the effect of length-scale interactions on the macroscopic properties of media (physics);

(B) Modelling impact, through new, frequency-dependent, macroscopic formulations for continuous media;

(C) Medium-to-long term industrial impact, through new design recipes for structured media that solve required inverse problems, for example achieving the required frequency response by a smart choice of the microstructure.

The related beneficiary communities have some overlaps, and can roughly be described as follows: pure analysts working on spectral analysis of differential equations, specialists of theoretical mechanics working with composites and theoretical physicists interested in multiscale effects (Impacts A); applied mathematicians and computational physicists working on wave propagation and materials (Impacts B); university commercial units and R&D departments of industrial agents (Impacts C).
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Construction,Electronics,Energy,Environment

URL https://people.bath.ac.uk/kc525/
 
Description The findings of the PRSA paper "On the existence of high-frequency boundary resonances in layered elastic media" have led to filing a patent (PCT International Application No. PCT/GB2016/051124 "Subterranean Design Process", April 2016). Further impact (on the scale 3-7 years) is expected from other parts of the project. This will be reported once it materialises.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction,Education,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Other
Impact Types Economic

 
Title COMPOSITE ELASTIC WAVE WAVEGUIDE 
Description Aspects and embodiments provide a method of selecting physical characteristics of elements forming a composite elastic waveguide structure configurable to propagate an elastic wave and a composite elastic waveguide structure formed from elements having selected physical characteristics. The method comprises: selecting an elastic wave propagation speed within the composite structure; calculating, based on the selected elastic wave propagation speed, a range of values for at least one the physical characteristic of at least one of at least two elements forming the composite structure, such that propagation of the elastic wave through the combined elements of the composite material at the selected elastic wave propagation speed occurs according to a wave mode in which displacement of a surface of the composite material formed from the at least two elements is substantially zero. Aspects recognise that the propagation of elastic waves in a composite material waveguide may differ from the propagation of elastic waves in a homogeneous material waveguide. In particular, in an appropriately designed composite material, an elastic wave of may propagate through the composite structure and leave, for example, the upper surface of the composite structure substantially unmoved. Homogeneous structures do not allow for propagation of elastic waves in such a manner. 
IP Reference WO2016177994 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2016
Licensed No
Impact This patent application has not been supported beyond PCT. The development of impact for the invention will continue, albeit without IP support.