Evaporative Cooling of Internal Combustion Engines

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sussex
Department Name: Sch of Engineering and Informatics

Abstract

The proposed work will examine an evaporative cooling system for use on modern Internal Combustion (IC) engines. The project aims to assess the impact of surface vibration and dynamics on the heat transfer capabilities and stability of controlled evaporative cooling for typical engine coolant jackets. The approach will include use of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to predict 2-Phase flow for simplified and representative coolant jacket geometries. This CFD work will assist in getting an understanding of the physics of evaporative cooling, that will in turn assist in the development of robust control strategies to handle what is considered to be a very effective but potentially unstable heat transfer mechanism. A pilot control system will be built allowing the effectiveness of robust control in the presence of vibration and agitation to be experimentally assessed and verified. This 3-year project will be of direct benefit to the academic community since it should generate new fundamental knowledge of evaporative cooling, of particular interest to IC engine research, as existing engine cooling systems are nearing their thermal limits because they exploit forced-convection-based heat transfer involving a water/glycol mixture passing through a coolant jacket. This limit in turn, restricts the performance of both (CI) compression ignition (diesel) engines, and spark ignition (SI) gasoline engines, particularly with engine downsizing, where the intended application could be for conventional or parallel hybrid vehicles, or as compact, high power-weight-ratio range extender engines for Extended Range Electric Vehicles. Evaporative cooling is of considerable interest to automotive vehicle manufacturers and suppliers, because many see the great potential of evaporative cooling over conventional convective systems, to achieve improved IC engine fuel economy and reduced CO2 emissions.

Planned Impact

This Evaporative Cooling project will potentially lead to very significant impact in five areas: i) the environment, ii) vehicle user economy, comfort, and safety, iii) improvements in automotive technology, iv) opportunities for manufacturing industries, and v) an expansion of fundamental academic work on extending the thermal limits of internal combustion engines. Apart from the proposed follow-on work to this project, this initiative is expected to motivate research into other areas of importance which are believed to be limiting the thermal capability of internal combustion engines, such as the current coolant medium of water/glycol, albeit its excellence and predominance for the last 40 years. If successful there will be clear impact on academic research, automotive technology, and on the automotive industry, made immediately possible via project partners Ford, Ricardo, and Denso.

The impact on the academic community will include advances in IC engine cooling control and thermal management, heat transfer, and better predictive capability in 2-phase flow.

The impact on automotive technology will be a reduction in automotive CO2 emissions and fuel consumption, also the benefits of faster warm-up, interior heating, and demist, and the associated improvements resulting from better coolant system components for evaporative cooling, such as a smart coolant pump, coolant level sensors, and condenser systems.

The impact on the automotive industry as a whole will be the more powerful approach of evaporative cooling, which if successful, could impact on the design and development of future IC engines globally.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Jafari S (2016) A review of evaporative cooling system concepts for engine thermal management in motor vehicles in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering

publication icon
Jafari S (2018) Control of Spray Evaporative Cooling in Automotive Internal Combustion Engines in Journal of Thermal Science and Engineering Applications

 
Description We have now published 4 journal publications and 2 international conference publications (listed in our outputs section). Three physically different experimental test rigs have been designed, manufactured, and completed, to enable the effectiveness of (spray) evaporative cooling on an IC engine to be established. i.e.: i) a pool boiling rig; ii) a (static) spray evaporative test rig; and iii) a (dynamic) Quarter-Cylinder Head Test Rig, which has a spray evaporatively-cooled Quarter Cylinder Head test-piece dynamically excited by a shaker. These rigs are now generating data that is being stored in our secure data cloud. This data is currently confidential, available only to the partners. This is totally unique data, the first of its kind in the world. Much more data will be added in due course. The data we have shows two things: huge heat fluxes available from spray evaporative cooling, and ii) a definite influence of agitation and vibration on the heat transfer associated with spray evaporative cooling (as might occur in a real engine in a vehicle). The significance of the first finding has great potential impact in two areas. First, in cooling the combustion engines in (HEV) Hybrid Electric Vehicles (which need to be very much lighter and compact than those in existing HEVs); and second, electric vehicle battery management is of considerable significance both for HEV and Electric Vehicles.

The work on the (dynamic) Quarter-Cylinder Head Test Rig is now focused on the ability to robustly control the cooling process under varying load conditions (i.e. transient engine load). We have not reached that point yet but a new Chancellor's-Award-winning PhD student has recently arrived at Sussex University and completely focused on that challenge. The data collected also highlights the need for improved modelling and simulation of spray evaporative cooling, We plan to seek research council funding (in collaboration with another UK university) to undertake both fundamental computational work and experimental verification of model predictive spray evaporative-cooling.

Ricardo PLC (via their Shoreham Technical Centre, UK) has funded a 9-month continuation of the project (from 1st May 2019 to 31st January 2020). This work has produced new findings related to: 1) a spray evaporative cooling correlation suitable for dynamic conditions at various amplitudes and frequencies; 2) a robust spray evaporative cooling control system design approach; and 3/ information relating to robust spray evaporative cooling control of actual hardware under dynamic conditions.

The details are at still confidential but two further journal papers have been published 2020, and several journal publications are in the preparation.
Exploitation Route The research has proved successful, we are looking to take the technology to TRL-4 and beyond. But more than that, we have published a landmark journal paper: J. Thalackottore Jose, A. Sarmadian, J.F. Dunne, C.A. Long, J.-P. Pirault, Cedric Rouaud (2021). An experimentally-verified temperature control simulation model for spray evaporative cooling of vibrating powertrain parts, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 170, 121041. We believe that this journal publication provides an extremely important virtual design tool to enable the automotive industry to create effective and durable thermal management systems suitable for electric vehicle powertrain, motor drives, and power electronics. Two industrial suppliers to the automotive industry are very keen to continue collaborating with Sussex University.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Electronics,Transport

 
Description Three physically different experimental test rigs have been designed, manufactured, and completed, to enable the effectiveness of (spray) evaporative cooling on an IC engine to be established. i.e.: i) a pool boiling rig; ii) a (static) spray evaporative test rig; and iii) a (dynamic) Quarter-Cylinder Head Test Rig, which has a spray evaporatively-cooled Quarter Cylinder Head test-piece dynamically excited by a shaker. These rigs are now generating data that is being stored in our secure data cloud. This data is currently confidential, available only to the partners. This is totally unique data, the first of its kind in the world. Much more data will be added in due course. The data we have shows two things: huge heat fluxes available from spray evaporative cooling, and ii) a definite influence of agitation and vibration on the heat transfer associated with spray evaporative cooling (as might occur in a real engine in a vehicle). The significance of the first finding has great potential impact in two areas. First, in cooling the combustion engines in (HEV) Hybrid Electric Vehicles (which need to be very much lighter and compact than those in existing HEVs); and second, electric vehicle battery management is of considerable significance both for HEV and Electric Vehicles. Impact to the wider community was reported earlier. The findings from the research have for example been used in two non-academic settings: 1/ A British Science Festival presentation to a lay audience; and 2/ to a global team of industrial specialists within the Ford Motor Company (and its associated companies). The first talk, a British Science Festival talk (held in 2017 at the University of Brighton and University of Sussex). The title of the talk was: 'The golden age of the steam (cooled) engine is coming!' This was to highlight that most car engines are currently liquid-cooled using 100-year-old principles. But that liquid cooling has reached the limits needed for the next generation of engines for hybrid electric vehicles. The talk then went on to point out that research at Sussex university is examining the use of steam for engine cooling which offers improved efficiency, reduced CO2 emissions, and improved fuel economy. The talk also required specific points to be addressed like: What are the most exciting advancements coming out of your research area at the moment? Who funds your research? Is your research part of a collaboration? If yes, who with? And do you expect to have any newsworthy research or book publications. The second talk to participant specialists in different parts of the Ford Motor Company across the world. The presentation to an audience of around 40 specifically addressed a number of Evaporative Cooling of Internal Combustion Engines topics. Returning to the specific findings of the project, in summary, this work has produced new technical findings related to: 1) a spray evaporative cooling correlation suitable for dynamic conditions at various amplitudes and frequencies; 2) a robust spray evaporative cooling control system design approach; and 3/ information relating to robust spray evaporative cooling control of actual hardware under dynamic conditions. As of 2021, we now have a total of 11 publications - most in very high quality journals. Ricardo PLC (via their Shoreham Technical Centre, UK), having funded the 9-month continuation of the project (from 1st May 2019 to 31st January 2020), are very keen to continue their collaboration with Sussex University, and, along with other industrial suppliers are actively seeking other sources of funding to exploit the technology to bring it from its current TRL to a point where a practical thermal management system using spray evaporative cooling is closer to commercialisation. The research has therefore proved successful, we are looking to take the technology to TRL-4 and beyond. But more than that, our published journal papers is a 'landmark' in the field i.e.: J. Thalackottore Jose, A. Sarmadian, J.F. Dunne, C.A. Long, J.-P. Pirault, Cedric Rouaud (2021). An experimentally-verified temperature control simulation model for spray evaporative cooling of vibrating powertrain parts, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 170, 121041. We believe that this journal publication provides an extremely important virtual design tool to enable the automotive industry to create effective and durable thermal management systems suitable for electric vehicle powertrain, motor drives, and power electronics. A relevant journal paper has been published in 2021 plus two relevant conference papers presented and published at different conferences. Both conference papers received 'Best paper award' in their category. (For some reason Research Fish would not allow entry of the second conference paper (i.e. A. Sarmadian, J. Thalackottore Jose, J.F. Dunne, C.A. Long, J-P Pirault, and C Rouaud. (2021) The effect of surface to-nozzle distance on the critical heat flux of spray evaporative cooling applied to vibrating surfaces. HEFAT-ATE 2021 Conference)). In terms of further advancement of the technology, a fundamental study of full spray evaporative cooling under dynamic conditions is planned. On the wider subject of Evaporative cooling of vehicles, particularly of battery electric vehicles, a former PhD student aimed to bid in September 2021 for a Royal Academy of Engineering Fellowship (with Ricardo support). However the September 2021 bid had a strict requirement of the applicant formally having PhD before the submission deadline of 21st September 2021. Unfortunately, the student formally received his PhD 3 days after the deadline i.e. on 24th September 2021. Despite this setback, this bid (to be based at Sussex) will go in, at the next Call for Royal Academy of Engineering Fellowships. In September 2022 Kings College London submitted a bid to the Royal Academy of Engineering 2022 Fellowships scheme. Sussex University is named as a collaborator on the project. And in December 2022, former Sussex University Research Fellow Dr Alireza Sarmadian submitted a three-year EPSRC Fellowship with the title 'Re- engineering thermal management systems for safer and greener transport'. This builds on the work done at Sussex under the EPSRC contract, and again names Sussex University as a collaborator.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Title Three experimental rigs. 
Description Three physically different experimental test rigs have been designed manufactured and completed to enable the effectiveness of (spray) evaporative cooling on an IC engine to be established. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Three experimental test rigs have been designed manufactured and completed to enable the effectiveness of (spray) evaporative cooling on an IC engine to be established. All three rigs are now operational and are generating useful data, i.e.: i) a pool boiling rig; ii) a (static) spray evaporative test rig; and iii) a Quarter-Cylinder Head Test Rig, which has a spray evaporatively-cooled Quarter Cylinder Head test piece dynamically excited by a shaker. The purpose of our (static) spray evaporative test rig being to create a workable cooling system (involving sensing, cabling, and piping) using a simple test piece, and to verify temperature and heat flux measurement. The purpose of the Quarter Cylinder Head rig being to demonstrate the ability to achieve stable control under realistic dynamic conditions of a spray evaporatively-cooled test piece with realistic geometry. We have also published a landmark journal paper: J. Thalackottore Jose, A. Sarmadian, J.F. Dunne, C.A. Long, J.-P. Pirault, Cedric Rouaud (2021). An experimentally-verified temperature control simulation model for spray evaporative cooling of vibrating powertrain parts, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 170, 121041. We believe that this journal publication provides an extremely important virtual design tool to enable the automotive industry to create effective and durable thermal management systems suitable for electric vehicle powertrain, motor drives, and power electronics. Two industrial suppliers to the automotive industry are very keen to continue collaborating with Sussex University. 
 
Title Evaporative cooling measured experimental data including video information 
Description Evaporative cooling measured experimental data including video information 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Three experimental rigs to generate evaporative cooling data (relevant to IC engines) have been designed and built at Sussex University. These rigs are now generating data that is being stored in our secure data cloud. This data is currently confidential, available only to the partners. This is totally unique data, the first of it's kind in the world. Much more data will be added in due course. Attempts are underway to undertake a follow-on project to exploit the data and the capability of the experimental rigs. 
 
Description Progress Reports x 7 
Organisation DENSO Italy
Country Italy 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution So far we have had 11 x 2-hour-long quarterly progress meetings (which we cycle between the partner locations and the University of Sussex). We have supplied 11 written progress reports and presented our research findings to them.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have contributed valuable reality checks needed to apply to all aspects of the research, particularly to the experimental developments that we are undertaking. The partners (such as Denso) are also supplying us with small items of hardware. Ford have supplied specific castings for us via Ford Dunton; Ricardo have been giving us detailed operational data.
Impact Our IMechE Journal of Automobile Engineering publication output was reviewed by all the partners. We have generated 11 written research progress reports.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Progress Reports x 7 
Organisation Ford Motor Company
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution So far we have had 11 x 2-hour-long quarterly progress meetings (which we cycle between the partner locations and the University of Sussex). We have supplied 11 written progress reports and presented our research findings to them.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have contributed valuable reality checks needed to apply to all aspects of the research, particularly to the experimental developments that we are undertaking. The partners (such as Denso) are also supplying us with small items of hardware. Ford have supplied specific castings for us via Ford Dunton; Ricardo have been giving us detailed operational data.
Impact Our IMechE Journal of Automobile Engineering publication output was reviewed by all the partners. We have generated 11 written research progress reports.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Progress Reports x 7 
Organisation Research Councils UK (RCUK)
Department Ricardo Consulting Engineer
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution So far we have had 11 x 2-hour-long quarterly progress meetings (which we cycle between the partner locations and the University of Sussex). We have supplied 11 written progress reports and presented our research findings to them.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have contributed valuable reality checks needed to apply to all aspects of the research, particularly to the experimental developments that we are undertaking. The partners (such as Denso) are also supplying us with small items of hardware. Ford have supplied specific castings for us via Ford Dunton; Ricardo have been giving us detailed operational data.
Impact Our IMechE Journal of Automobile Engineering publication output was reviewed by all the partners. We have generated 11 written research progress reports.
Start Year 2015
 
Description This collaboration relates to EP/M005755/1 
Organisation DENSO Italy
Country Italy 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The research team at Sussex University are engaging with the partners in quarterly project meetings by supplying progress reports. So far, three progress reports have been exchanged at three steering meetings.
Collaborator Contribution Ford are supplying measured data Ricardo are supplying expertise Denso are supplying hardware.
Impact The partners have overseen the preparation of a major review article addressing the technology that has now been submitted to a journal for publication (January 2016)
Start Year 2015
 
Description This collaboration relates to EP/M005755/1 
Organisation Ford Motor Company
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The research team at Sussex University are engaging with the partners in quarterly project meetings by supplying progress reports. So far, three progress reports have been exchanged at three steering meetings.
Collaborator Contribution Ford are supplying measured data Ricardo are supplying expertise Denso are supplying hardware.
Impact The partners have overseen the preparation of a major review article addressing the technology that has now been submitted to a journal for publication (January 2016)
Start Year 2015
 
Description This collaboration relates to EP/M005755/1 
Organisation Ricardo UK Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The research team at Sussex University are engaging with the partners in quarterly project meetings by supplying progress reports. So far, three progress reports have been exchanged at three steering meetings.
Collaborator Contribution Ford are supplying measured data Ricardo are supplying expertise Denso are supplying hardware.
Impact The partners have overseen the preparation of a major review article addressing the technology that has now been submitted to a journal for publication (January 2016)
Start Year 2015
 
Description Advanced Propulsion Centre (APC) Future of Technology series events held in London throughout 2018. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Professor Julian Dunne attended all of the Advanced Propulsion Centre (APC) Future of Technology series events held in London throughout 2018. These events included a wide range speakers and stakeholders, such as Jonathan Porritt (eminent writer, broadcaster and commentator on sustainable development) plus eminent speakers from Greenpeace, the WWF, the Financial Times, the Faraday Institution, and the SMMT. The final event: 'Are we on the road to nowhere?' held in November 2018 at The Crystal, London, discussed the likely impact of Brexit on the UK motor industry.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://futureoftechnology.co.uk/watch/
 
Description British Science Festival Lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This was a British Science Festival talk (held in 2017 at the University of Brighton and University of Sussex). The title of the talk was: 'The golden age of the steam (cooled) engine is coming!' This was to highlight that most car engines are currently liquid-cooled using 100-year-old principles but that liquid cooling has reached the limits needed for the next generation of engines for hybrid electric vehicles. The talk then went on to point out that research at Sussex university is examining the use of steam for engine cooling which offers improved efficiency, reduced CO2 emissions, and improved fuel economy. The talk also required specific points to be addressed like: What are the most exciting advancements coming out of your research at the moment? Who funds your research? Is your research part of a collaboration? If yes, who with? And do you expect to have any newsworthy research or book publications? So this was a real opportunity to describe the work and its potential impact to a lay audience of around 60 people (and the media).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Evaporative Cooling of Internal Combustion Engines 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact This was a talk in November 2017 to specialists in different parts of the Ford Motor Company across the world. The presentation, to an audience of around 40 Ford (or associated company) employees, specifically addressed the following Evaporative Cooling of Internal Combustion Engines topics:

1/ Research project overview, aims and objectives; The Team.
2/ High-Level motivation: Vehicle CO2 emissions reduction.
3/ Motivation for improved IC Engine thermal management.
4/ Exploiting the physics of evaporative cooling.
5/ The potential benefits of evaporative cooling of engines.
6/ History of engine evaporative cooling systems.
7/ What are we doing to meet the objectives of the project?
8/ What we have achieved so far? What remains to be done?
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Visit to India with Secretary of State for Business Innovation and Skills and Lecture to Automotive Research Association of India 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact In October 2014 Julian Dunne joined the UK Secretary of State for Business Innovation and Skills (Dr Vince Cable) on a 4-day British High Commission mission to India, where he lectured at the Automotive Research Association of India. This involved both small-scale and much larger social engagements with Indian business leaders in Mumbai. Then a visit to the Tata vehicle manufacturing plant in the city of Pune, followed by a half-day visit and tour of the facilities at the Automotive Research Association of India, also in Pune.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014