The safety of pedestrians, cyclists and motor vehicles in highly turbulent urban wind flows

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Civil Engineering

Abstract

In the planning process for high rise buildings, it is common practice to carry out physical or numerical simulations of the wind flow around such buildings, in order to establish the acceptability or otherwise of these wind conditions for a range of pedestrian activities such as sitting, slow walking, rapid walking etc. It is less common to assess the wind conditions in terms of pedestrian safety in high winds, and the safety of cyclists and light high sided vehicles is never usually considered. The need for such considerations has become tragically obvious in a recent incident in Leeds, where a pedestrian was killed after a lorry blew over due to winds around a new high rise structure. When pedestrian safety is considered, this is usually in terms of a simple wind speed criterion that does not take into account human behaviour and does not allow for a proper risk analysis. This project will consider these issues with a view to establishing a robust methodology for calculating the risk of a pedestrian, cyclist or high sided vehicle accident in high wind conditions around high rise building. Full scale measurements will be carried out around a high rise building on the University of Birmingham campus to measure the turbulent nature of the flow around such buildings, since it is these highly turbulent flows that are of relevance to the issue of safety rather than the mean wind flows. Wind tunnel tests and CFD calculations will be carried out of the same building to assess the adequacy of these techniques for predicting the highly turbulent flows of relevance to the problem under discussion. Trials will then be carried out using instrumented volunteers of a range of age and size, who will walk or cycle around the structure during windy periods, and their behaviour will be assessed both quantitatively and qualitatively, in order to develop probability distributions of the wind speed at which incipient instability of pedestrians occurs. In addition measurements will be made of the cross wind forces on scale models of typical high rise vehicles using the University of Birmingham moving model TRAIN rig, with highly turbulent cross wind conditions, again to develop probability distributions of wind speeds for incipient instability. The probability distributions thus obtained will then be used, with wind speed probability distributions, to develop a calculation methodology to determine the variation of accident risk around high rise structures.

Planned Impact

The primary output of the research will be a detailed understanding of the wind flow around high buildings and the effects of such winds on pedestrians, cyclists and large high sided vehicles. This will fill a significant gap in current knowledge and increase public safety significantly. The specific applied benefits to stakeholders will be as follows.

a) Architects and planners - a published methodology for assessing the risk of wind induced accidents around the base of high rise buildings.
b) Civil and Structural Engineering consultants - published guidance on where structural design changes are required to buildings in order to minimise inconvenience to the public and maximise personal safety.
c) Transport planners - published guidance on safe wind conditions for cyclists and high sided vehicles around high rise buildings.
d) Local authorities - published guidance for the assessment of planning applications in order to ensure acceptable wind conditions around buildings.
e) Wind tunnel and CFD consultants - a revised methodology to enable a rational risk based approach to pedestrian, cyclist and vehicle safety to be carried out.
f) It will thus be of indirect benefit to all who live and work within cities, and mitigate against economic losses due to repeated road closures etc.

This impact will be achieved through interaction with the project partners who represent a range of the different stakeholders set out above, the production of academic and technical / professional papers in publications that will be accessible to stakeholders, through regular dissemination seminars and meetings and through a high profile final event at a central London location.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The project is ongoing, with all its major components underway - full scale testing, physical model testing and computational fluid mechanics (CFD) calculations. All findings are thus tentative, but it is nonetheless clear that aspects of current practice in both physical model testing and CFD are not well suited to assessing the effects of very high winds on pedestrians, cyclists and road vehicles, and that there are a number of unstated assumptions in current methodologies. The nature of these will be reported in full later in the project.
Exploitation Route The work will have significant implications for urban planners, wind tunnel operators and CFD specialists. This will be taken forward in the first instance with the project advisory group, and then on an individual basis with specific organisations.
Sectors Construction,Energy,Transport

 
Description The project is ongoing and thus the major impact is still to come. However to date the work funded by this project has been used by a major consultancy firm to assess the safety of high sided road vehicles in windy conditions. As the work is commercial, this cannot be publicised further at present, but will be written up and disseminated in an appropriate manner in future. More such impacts are expected.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Construction,Transport
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Scruton Lecture 2017: Wind engineering for serviceability and resilience 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Scruton lecture is the annual prestigious lecture of the Wind Engineering Society as part of the Institution of Civil Engineers. It is aimed at raising the public profile of Wind Engineering and engaging with a wide audience both in person and online.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.ice.org.uk/eventarchive/scruton-lecture-2017-wind-engineering-for-servicea
 
Description Talk to Wind Engineering Society 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Wind effects on transportation systems
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016