Resilient rail infrastructure: dissipation driven fracture analysis of concrete support systems

Lead Research Organisation: Durham University
Department Name: Engineering

Abstract

The UK's rail infrastructure currently supports 1.3 billion passenger journeys and 100 million tonnes of freight each year. The freight transport alone contributes £870 million to the UK economy. The sector has seen 40% and 60% increases in passengers and freight over the last 10 years, respectively, and it is expected that passenger numbers will double and freight increase by 140% over the next 30 years. As the network has developed the magnitude and frequency of loads applied to the rail support systems have increased significantly, even over the last 10 years. It is estimated that between 2009 and 2014, the UK's rail operator, Network Rail (NR), will invest £3.75bn in track to maintain the network. The vast majority of this 32,000km of rail infrastructure is supported by pre-stressed concrete sleepers (PCSs) and crossing bearers (CBs). These concrete members provide lateral restraint and vertical support to the running steel rails. The PCSs and CBs are in turn supported on three sides by track ballast; crushed stone 30-50mm in diameter. Since their introduction in the 1950s, PCSs have superseded traditional wooden sleepers in new track and NR replaces approximately 200,000 timber sleepers each year with PCSs. However, despite the reliance of the UK's rail network on these concrete structures, and the simplicity of their geometry, surprisingly their structural behaviour is poorly understood. NR's CP5 delivery plan estimated that the used life of the sleepers supporting the network for the 2013/14 period is 60.9% and that 5,918 track failures would occur during the same timeframe. There are concerns that the development of fractures in concrete supporting members is undermining the rail network. In order to maintain a safe, reliable and resilient rail network it is essential to understand how the concrete support systems can be designed to future proof them against ever increasing structural demands.

The proposed research is concerned with three-dimensional dynamic analysis to assess the structural robustness of PCSs and CBs using a novel computational mechanics framework and associated numerical analysis technique. If successful, this research will provide a transformative, complete and consistent framework for modelling fracture in a variety of engineering materials. The creativity of this proposal lies in the application of up-to-the-minute ideas in constitutive modelling, fracture mechanics and numerical analysis techniques to a poorly understood yet critical component of the UK's rail infrastructure. It will provide a framework within which to develop new resilient rail-support system fastening methods.

Planned Impact

This research will provide a new fracture simulation approach. It will also provide a framework within which to develop new resilient rail-support system fastening methods. Existing links between the PI and the UK's only pre-stressed concrete sleeper (PCS) and crossing bearer (CB) manufacturer will provide a pathway for this research to impact on the development of rail infrastructure. This impact can be split into a number of areas, namely:
(i) development of robust and resilient PCS/CB-rail securement methods;
(ii) safer railways and increased service performance;
(iii) reduction of produced C02 and operational costs through increased service life; and
(iv) understanding of the impact of higher speed (such as HS2) and load traffic on the existing ageing infrastructure (that is, will the sleepers fail through fracture).

The proposed research will bring together, currently separate, ideas within computational mechanics within a new analysis framework and could subsequently be applied to a number of other areas outside of the scope of this project.

The project will also develop the skills of a Post-Doctoral Research Assistant in constitutive modelling, fracture prediction and in computational modelling.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Background: The UK's rail infrastructure currently supports 1.3 billion passenger journeys and 100 million tonnes of freight each year. The freight transport alone contributes £870 million to the UK economy. The sector has seen 40% and 60% increases in passengers and freight over the last 10 years, respectively, and it is expected that passenger numbers will double and freight increase by 140% over the next 30 years. As the network has developed the magnitude and frequency of loads applied to the rail support systems have increased significantly, even over the last 10 years. It is estimated that between 2009 and 2014, the UK's rail operator, Network Rail (NR), will invest £3.75bn in track to maintain the network. The vast majority of this 32,000km of rail infrastructure is supported by pre-stressed concrete sleepers (PCSs) and crossing bearers (CBs). These concrete members provide lateral restraint and vertical support to the running steel rails. The PCSs and CBs are in turn supported on three sides by track ballast; crushed stone 30-50mm in diameter. Since their introduction in the 1950s, PCSs have superseded traditional wooden sleepers in new track and NR replaces approximately 200,000 timber sleepers each year with PCSs. However, despite the reliance of the UK's rail network on these concrete structures, and the simplicity of their geometry, surprisingly their structural behaviour is poorly understood. NR's CP5 delivery plan estimated that the used life of the sleepers supporting the network for the 2013/14 period is 60.9% and that 5,918 track failures would occur during the same timeframe. There are concerns that the development of fractures in concrete supporting members is undermining the rail network. In order to maintain a safe, reliable and resilient rail network it is essential to understand how the concrete support systems can be designed to future proof them against ever increasing structural demands.
Findings: Cast-in-place plastic sockets have the potential to initiate fractures when used in concrete railway sleepers and bearers which can lead to a loss of rail restraint. These fractures are particularly likely if the plastic sockets are placed in close proximity and the sleeper/bearer is subjected at excessive pre-stress loads.
Exploitation Route Technical research findings: taken up by others working in the material point method as the developed method has significant advantages, in terms of accuracy and stability, than other material point methods. Industrial findings: highlighted the issues associated with using plastic cast-in-place sockets in pre-stressed rail components prompting alternative fastening methods to be developed.
Sectors Transport

 
Description The PI has strong links with the rail industry through CEMEX and the findings from this research are shaping changes to the manufacturing processes used in the UK for prestressed concrete railway sleepers and bearers. CEMEX is the leading UK manufacturer of concrete railway bearers and sleepers with products being exclusively used by UK Rail authorities (such as Network Rail). Those authorities identified an issue with cracking in prestressed concrete bearers and became very concerned with the root cause and the effects on long-term durability. The issues identified during the research created a change in thinking of the manufacturing process at one of CEMEX's locations. The key impact of this research has been the fundamental redesign and deployment of rail-sleeper/beaer fixing methods in the UK through the use of high fidelity, bespoke finite element analysis and constitutive modelling techniques developed by Coombs at DU. This has included: 1. Identification of the dangers associated with using a drill and fix solution for CBs due to the likelihood of the technique leading to the development of longitudinal fractures in the concrete CBs caused by excessive transverse tensile stresses induced by pre-stressing loads; 2. The risks associated with using cast-in-place plastic sockets (Vossloh dowels, Hostaform Inserts) with very low stiffness compared to the surrounding concrete in both crossing bearers and sleepers, specifically the stress concentration caused by the very low stiffness of the plastic relative to the surrounding concrete and the potential for this to induce fractures in the concrete sleepers/bearers; and 3. Analysis of the suitability of the use of new anchoring systems to replace existing methods in CBs and new PCSs designs with a particular focus on fracture susceptibility of the concrete members in both Network Rail and London Underground assets. The research conducted at DU has shown that due to the plastic inserts and resin being soft relative to the surrounding concrete (10-40 times lower stiffness); they create local tensile stress concentrations in the transverse direction that are exaggerated by high longitudinal pre-stressing. It was also shown that these concentrations, along with destructive installation methods, have the potential to initiate longitudinal fractures in the concrete sleepers/bearers. CBs that have been stored without seeing rail traffic loading have also failed, confirming that the root cause of fracture is pre-stressing, rather than in-service loads (as indicated by the numerical analysis). In addition to the manufacturing changes outlined above, the research findings have led to Network Rail and London Underground changing the technical standard for sleepers and bearers, NR/L2/TRK/030 and T0404, to no longer allow the drill and fix fastening method to be used.
First Year Of Impact 2014
Sector Transport
Impact Types Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Title Isogeometric MPM 
Description Development of a new numerical technique based on the material point method. The new method provides significant improvements in terms of accuracy and convergence. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Allows the material point method to be used on problems not previously accessible due to the inaccuracy of the method. 
 
Title Open-source code for researcher development 
Description AMPLE was developed to address the severe learning curve for researchers wishing to understand, and start using, the material point method. The software was developed at Durham University between 2014 and 2018 by Dr Will Coombs as a platform to test our new research ideas and understand the impact of adopting different material point variants. AMPLE was first released in January 2019 at the 2nd International Conference on the Material Point Method held at Cambridge University, UK. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Too early to measure. 
URL https://wmcoombs.github.io/
 
Title NAF NURBS data 
Description NURBS plasticity: non-associated plastic flow (publication data). This paper extends the non-uniform rational basis spline (NURBS) plasticity frame- work of Coombs et al. [11] and Coombs and Ghaffari Motlagh [10] to include non-associated plastic flow. The NURBS plasticity approach allows any smooth isotropic yield envelope to be represented by a NURBS surface whilst the numerical algorithm (and code) remains unchanged. This paper provides the full theoretical and algorithmic basis of the non- a 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None to date, published in March 2018. 
 
Title Isogemetric material point method 
Description Isogeometric implementation of the material point method including high order basis functions to reduce instabilities and improve accuracy. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact None to date. Software not made available yet as awaiting publication of research paper. 
 
Title Open source code for researcher development 
Description AMPLE was developed to address the severe learning curve for researchers wishing to understand, and start using, the material point method. The software was developed at Durham University between 2014 and 2018 by Dr Will Coombs as a platform to test our new research ideas and understand the impact of adopting different material point variants. AMPLE was first released in January 2019 at the 2nd International Conference on the Material Point Method held at Cambridge University, UK. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2019 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact Too early to measure 
URL https://wmcoombs.github.io/