Reactive Scattering Dynamics at the Gas-Liquid Interface: Bridging the Gap between the Gas-Phase and Solution

Lead Research Organisation: Heriot-Watt University
Department Name: Sch of Engineering and Physical Science

Abstract

Anywhere the gas and liquid phases meet, chemistry occurs at the interface. Examples in the natural world include: respiration in living organisms; atmospheric aerosol particles; the surface of the sea on Earth; hydrocarbon particles in the atmosphere of Saturn's moon Titan. The chemistry of these interfaces is also vital in man-made environments as well: combustion of liquid fuels; industrial processes such as multiphase catalysis, gas sequestration and distillation. However, despite their importance, in comparison to the chemistry of reactions in the gas-phase or in solution, reactions at the gas-liquid interface are much less well understood. This project aims to deepen our fundamental understanding of reactions at liquid surfaces through a combination of cutting-edge experiment and theory.

Consider a gas molecule approaching a liquid surface. The first encounter it makes with the surface will be an isolated event; the gas phase molecule will collide with a single molecule of the liquid surface. At this point the encounter is essentially the same as a gas phase collision between two isolated molecules. In the gas-phase, the molecules will then recoil and the encounter will be over. In some cases, collisions at the liquid surface will also result in the gas-phase molecule rebounding back into the gas-phase. However, it may instead go on to collide with further liquid surface molecules, and may even pass through the surface of the liquid and into solution, before eventually returning to the gas-phase. Reactions at the gas-liquid interface thus share characteristics of both the gas and solution phases, and by studying the dynamics of the reactions we can bridge the gap between them. This complements the intensive on-going effort in these hitherto largely separate areas, providing a unifying picture of molecular scattering dynamics.

We will develop a new apparatus for our experiments, based on our previous experience in gas-liquid interfacial scattering, and combine it with high-resolution laser spectroscopy previously applied to study gas-phase dynamics. We will use this to study the reaction of CN radicals with liquid hydrocarbons, which forms HCN. The dynamics of this benchmark reaction process have been previously studied in the gas and solution phases. This reaction is not only of fundamental interest, as the CN radical is an important reactive species in extra-terrestrial atmospheres (e.g. atmosphere of Titan), and liquid hydrocarbon combustion. Simultaneously with the experiments, we will develop new theoretical models of the forces between the atoms present, and use those in calculations to simulate the dynamics of the reactions under experimental conditions. We will compare and combine the results of the experiments and theory to provide the most-detailed ever description of gas-liquid interfacial reaction dynamics. The fundamental insights into dynamics at the gas-liquid interface provided by this work will inform our understanding and modelling of the processes at gas-liquid interfaces in a wide range of environments vital to our society, e.g. atmospheric aerosols, liquid fuel combustion.

Planned Impact

The proposed work is fundamental in nature and therefore it is expected that the societal and economic benefits deriving from the results will primarily be realised in the longer term. These benefits will follow from the improved understanding and capacity to model interactions at the gas-liquid interface that will be derived from this work. Such interactions have, in general, very broad applicability across many diverse fields, including, e.g. gas separation and multiphase catalysis; heterogeneous chemistry on atmospheric aerosol particles and at the surface of the sea on Earth, and at different gas-liquid interfaces in extra-terrestrial atmospheres (where CN, the specific target of this work, is itself a known species in some cases, such as the atmosphere of Titan); combustion of liquid fuels (where CN reactions are also known to be involved in the combustion of hydrocarbons); through to biological respiration. A refined understanding of the fundamental processes of gas uptake, energy exchange and reactivity will lead to improved numerical models of these environments. The improved predicative capability that this would enable has potential societal benefit through, e.g. informing policy on emissions control to mitigate the effects of environmental pollutants.

The technical development here of a high-resolution, tuneable IR source coupled with frequency-modulated detection has potential applications in other fields. The more obvious candidates include detection of trace-species concentrations and temperatures in gas-phase environments such as the atmosphere or in combustion.

The computational tools developed here will be exploited more widely through being made available in established molecular simulation packages (e.g., CHARMM and TINKER). These packages are used by the wider dynamics community to study a range of chemical systems beyond the G-L interface. This includes the investigation of molecules of biological interest, including peptides, proteins, small molecule ligands, nucleic acids, lipids, and carbohydrates, in a variety of heterogeneous environments, including solution, crystal, and membrane environments.

There will, in addition, be more immediate societal impact from the output of highly trained personnel with either technical skills in the use of modern laser, vacuum, electronic-data capture and data processing technologies, and at the forefront of high-performance computing methods. They will also have well-developed generic and transferable communication, presentation and problem-solving skills. They will be ideally suited to contribute to the growth or creation of high-technology companies, enhancing innovative capacity and consequently increasing business revenues.

We will also continue to enhance public awareness of science by disseminating the aims and results of this work to the wider public, at a suitable level, through available media including lectures, on-line video presentations and websites. The high-performance computational algorithms will be folded in the 'danceroom Spectroscopy' (dS) framework, an interactive molecular dynamics simulation platform at the frontiers of high-performance computing, real-time 3d imaging, and chemical dynamics. dS has been developed by PI2 over the last few years. It has been the subject of innumerable national and international press stories, and toured around major cultural venues across the UK, Europe, and the US. To date, dS has enabled over 100,000 worldwide to literally step into a real-time molecular dynamics simulation.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Liquid surfaces are ubiquitous in nature and common in technological settings, and their interactions with the gas phase species are significant in the chemistry of a very wide range of environments, including planetary atmospheres (such as Earth's troposphere), combustion systems and heterogeneous catalysis. Despite this, experimental studies of molecular collisions at the gas-liquid interface have until recently been very rare, and are still sparse compared to pure gas-phase or gas-solid surface experiments.

In this project we have developed a new apparatus to study the inelastic and reactive collisions of small molecules with inert and reactive liquid surfaces. We have constructed a new high-vacuum system combining a continuously-refreshed liquid surface with a molecular beam source of CN radicals, and including an in-vacuum optical multipass (Herriott) cell. The CN radicals have been made by DC electric discharge, the first time this has been demonstrated as a way to make this radical.

We have coupled two laser systems to this to probe the products of the scattering, in both cases using frequency-modulated absorption spectroscopy. The first laser was an existing near-infrared system that can probe the incident CN radicals in the molecular beam, and any CN that undergoes inelastic scattering from the liquid surface. The second laser system was developed during the grant, and produced frequency-modulated mid-infrared light through difference frequency generation (DFG) between a 1064 nm fixed frequency fibre laser, and a tuneable Ti:Sa ring laser. Frequency modulation in the near-IR of this Ti:Sa laser output is transferred into the mid-IR by the DFG, providing a unique widely tuneable mid-IR single frequency laser source with high-frequency (100 MHz) modulation.

We have used the near-IR laser system to study the inelastic collisions of CN radicals with inert (per-fluoro poly-ether) and reactive (squalane, a long-chain branched saturated hydrocarbon) liquids. We have published the results of the scattering with PFPE, which show significant translation to rotational energy transfer at the surface, with a substantial fraction of the scattered CN having superthermal translational energy distributions, consistent with a dominant impulsive scattering mechanism, in contrast to a thermal desorption mechanism in which the incident molecule equilibrates with the surface. We have also established (currently unpublished) that the CN reacts rapidly at the squalane surface, with less than 20% of the incident CN rebounding into the gas phase. The CN that is observed is also strongly superthermal, suggesting that accommodation with the surface is strongly correlated with reaction.

We have demonstrated that the mid-IR laser system works using CH4 as a test system (as yet unpublished) and are confident that it will provide a methodology to probe the closed-shell molecules that are often a product of radical H-abstraction reactions at liquid surfaces, including HCN as originally proposed. We will take this work forward under the umbrella of our recently awarded Programme grant (EP/T021675/1), including probing the water product of OH reactive scattering at liquid surfaces.

The collaboration with the Glowacki group at the University of Bristol that formed part of this project is reported in detail elsewhere in Researchfish, and resulted in a new dynamics code for modelling reactive and inelastic scattering at gas-liquid interfaces. This code will be taken forward and applied to a variety of systems under our Programme grant, in which we have been awarded significant Tier 2 computing resources for this purpose.
Exploitation Route This is a pure research project, and we expect the outcomes to be used by other academics. We expect this work to be used by both experimentalists and theoreticians. We have demonstrated that it is possible to couple radical scattering at the liquid surface with high-resolution absorption spectroscopy for the first time, which we expect will inspire other experimentalists to broaden their horizons with respect to the systems that it is possible to study. The theoretical developments are very exciting, and provide a methodology to perform reactive and inelastic scattering simulations for interfacial systems at a previously impossible level of accuracy. We therefore expect this to be adopted and further developed by other theoreticians in the future.
Sectors Chemicals,Education,Energy,Environment

 
Description Chemical Structure and Dynamics at the Gas-Liquid Interface
Amount £12,718 (GBP)
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2020 
End 05/2021
 
Description Cirrus funding; MD of hydrocarbon liquid surfaces
Amount £6,389 (GBP)
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2019 
End 02/2020
 
Description James Watt Scholarship
Amount £58,500 (GBP)
Organisation Heriot-Watt University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2017 
End 08/2020
 
Description New Directions in Molecular Scattering
Amount £5,880,172 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/T021675/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2020 
End 05/2025
 
Description Platform Grant
Amount £1,277,251 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/P001459/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2016 
End 08/2021
 
Description Glowacki (Bristol) on gas-liquid dynamics 
Organisation University of Bristol
Department Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We are performing experimental studies of the inelastic and reactive scattering dynamics of diatomic and polyatomic gas-phase molecules at liquid surfaces. This forms the experimental component of a joint experiment-theory collaboration, which is currently funded by two linked EPSRC grants (EP/M021823/1 (HWU) and EP/M022129/1 (UoB)).
Collaborator Contribution Dr David Glowacki and his group at the University of Bristol are developing new methods for scattering calculations of the dynamics of gas-liquid interfacial inelastic and reactive scattering, which will be applied to systems that we are studying experimentally.
Impact Platform grant: EP/P001459/1
Start Year 2015
 
Description Chairman, International Symposium on Molecular Beams 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Organised the 28th edition of the recurrent conference series: International Symposium on Molecular Beams
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://ismbedinburgh2019.eps.hw.ac.uk/index.html
 
Description School Visits 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Multiple visits to schools across Northern England and Scotland, as part of the Public Understanding Outreach programme of the School of Engineering and Physical Sciences. Presentation to penultimate/final year school pupils, called 'How do Chemical Reactions Go?' which incorporates information on and results from our EPSRC funded projects. Question and answer sessions included, as well as discussion with the teaching staff present. Teaching staff generally report subsequent enthusiastic discussion about the topics raised.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016