Ultrasonic propagation in complex media: correlated spatial distributions and multiple dispersed phases

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Chemical Engineering

Abstract

Complex fluids are part of our every-day life - these are suspensions of particles, which may be solid or liquid. Foods such as milk and mayonnaise, health-care products like moisturising creams and common chemical products like paints are all examples of particle suspensions. As well as these, industrial processes often include a stage where the material is a suspension of particles, even if the final product is not in this form: drug processing is one example, where crystallisation is used to extract the drug from solution, producing crystalline particles of the pharmaceutical ingredient. Current research is fascinated by the very small: nanoparticles, and what we might be able to do with them; many of these will also be produced as a suspension in a liquid.
In some cases, the particles can clump together to form aggregates. This is certainly a problem with many nanoparticles which stick together because of electrostatic effects. It also causes difficulties for the crystallisation process just mentioned, where the aim is to produce lots of crystals of the same size. In other cases, the aggregation may be intended, and designed to create structure in the material, to give it distinct properties, such as strength or near-solid-like behaviour - some gels are like this. On an industrial scale, aggregates of asphaltene commonly form in petroleum processing, causing problems with clogging. Whatever the cause, we would like to be able to know more about the particles and the aggregation which has occurred.
When an ultrasonic wave (a sound wave at higher pitch than humans can hear) travels through a fluid which has particles or droplets suspended in it, the particles/droplets scatter the wave by sending some of it in other directions. A very similar effect produces a rainbow when sunlight is scattered by water droplets in the air. With ultrasonic waves, which are compressional waves, scattering by the particles can also convert some of the wave into other wave types, namely thermal and shear waves. These processes take energy away from the ultrasonic wave which causes a reduction in its amplitude. By measuring the attenuation (loss in amplitude) and the wave speed for an ultrasonic wave travelling through the suspensions, we can find out the concentration of particles, how big they are, or something about their properties e.g. their density. We know that the attenuation is different when the particles are close together, when they are aggregated. But we currently do not have a way to work out the properties of the particles, or their concentration or size, when there are aggregates in the suspension, nor can we say how big the aggregates are, or how closely packed the particles are in them.
What we need is a way to understand how the sound waves travel through suspensions when the particles are clumped together. At the moment we have a model (a mathematical description of what happens) for well-dispersed suspensions, but not for aggregated ones, nor for suspensions with several different types of particles. In this project we will study this problem by using mathematical models, by using computational simulations and by making experimental measurements. Each of these parts to the project will investigate how sound waves interact with the clumps of particles, or the different types of particles. What we want to achieve in the end is a way to make measurements and use the data to characterise the suspension, to tell us the particle size distribution, the aggregate size, the aggregate structure or other properties. The outcomes of the project will be models and methods that can be used to characterise particle suspensions. This will enable ultrasonics to be used with confidence as a process monitoring technique in a wide range of industrial contexts.

Planned Impact

Online monitoring of suspended particulate systems is an extremely widespread need across many industries, for example food, healthcare, chemical, agrochemical, petrochemical, healthcare, nuclear etc. The process industries have a critical need for accurate and appropriate process analytical technologies (PATs) in order to ensure consistent product quality and characteristics. The development of accurate PATs which are appropriate for inline implementation is of critical importance for effective process control, leading to lower cost production, and higher quality products. In addition there is a need for new monitoring techniques to keep pace with developments in novel material processing such as nanoparticle applications. This project addresses particularly suspensions which have some degree of aggregation or mixed particles types, such as in petroleum processing, drilling mud, in pharmaceutical crystallisation and in nanoparticle production. The project aims to deliver a model appropriate for ultrasonic monitoring of these suspensions, a methodology for interpreting measurements, and a validation of both, through simulation and experiment. Its long-term impact is to enable ultrasonics to be implemented as a PAT in many industrial applications, with the consequent benefits listed above.
The outcomes of the project will also have impact on the use of ultrasonics as a research characterisation technique, enabling its use for structured particle materials e.g. nanoparticle clusters, drug delivery systems etc. New experimental methodologies will be investigated, with potential impact on research users of ultrasonics for characterisation, along with workers in non- destructive testing, and medical applications. The in-depth understanding of ultrasonic propagation achieved and disseminated by the project will impact the more immediate community working with ultrasonics, and acoustic propagation. The development of simulation techniques for particulate systems has relevance in many fields of research, not restricted to ultrasonics, and these developments will produce impact through their application to metamaterial design and novel nano-particle structure design.
The research associates working on the project will have the opportunity to work in a cross-disciplinary environment, with regular interaction with academics from other disciplines. They will receive training appropriate for their research programme, but will be involved in whole-project discussions, broadening their knowledge and skills base.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Finite element modelling has been developed for the interaction of acoustic waves with particles. A rigorous comparison has been made between an analytical model and a finite element model which demonstrates and validates the thermal and shear wave decay regions around the particle (within a micron or so of the particle surface). Further modelling has demonstrated the effect of interactions between particles mediated by thermal and shear effects on the energy absorption in the system which has an impact on the interpretation of ultrasonic attenuation measurements for process monitoring.
Exploitation Route To develop models for acoustic interactions with structures and particles, to develop characterisation techniques for particles, to study particle aggregation, to investigate acoustic particle manipulation for microfluidic techniques.
Sectors Energy,Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description This project was the computational component of a 3-part project led by me, with two other institutions running joint projects on theoretical development and experimental work. The experimental programme at University of Leeds continues to attract industrial partnerships for the investigation of material properties in-line and off-line. The theoretical and computational work was challenging and further mathematical development is needed but has not been successful in securing EPSRC funding. This project has resulted in my becoming a co-organiser of a 6-month programme at the part-EPSRC funded Isaac Newton Institute in Cambridge on Multiple Wave Scattering in Jan-Jun 2023. This involves an international group of mathematicians primarily, but also scientists and engineers, and will involve industrial participants in specifically-targeted workshops.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
 
Title Dataset for Scientific Reports 2019 paper on silica particles different sizes 
Description Dataset for Scientific Reports 2019 paper on silica particles different sizes https://doi.org/10.17028/rd.lboro.7701461.v1 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Not yet known. 
URL https://doi.org/10.17028/rd.lboro.7701461.v1
 
Description New Scientist Live demonstration stand 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact An Acoustics-related stand was presented at the New Scientist Live exhibition in London, September 2018.
Universities involved: Leeds, Loughborough, Manchester.
Lots of visitors, many school children and members of the public.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Organised and chaired UK Acoustics Network Computational Acoustics Group meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact I lead the Computational Acoustics Special Interest Group of the UK Acoustics Network. I organised and chaired the first meeting of the group (following the launch event of the Network as a whole) on 20th February 2018 with 25 attendees. The attendees were a mix of academic researchers and industry users, including auto, aero, simulation companies and acoustic consultants. I presented work from the project, as well as coordinating discussion on challenges in computational acoustics. The event was significant in bringing together industry users with academics, and covered a broad range of computational techniques.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://www.acoustics.ac.uk
 
Description Presentation at a workshop on nanoporous materials 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Acoustics Network one-day research workshop on acoustics of nano-porous materials.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Support for New Scientist Live stand on Acoustics with Acoustics Network 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact An exhibition stand at the large-scale New Scientist Live event in London (Excel), led by the Acoustics Network. A number of demos were provided by the institutions on this projects and the stand was staffed by many members of the project team (Leeds, Loughborough, Manchester and Sheffield).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://live.newscientist.com/exhibitors/university-of-sheffield-1?azletter=A#/