Canonical Scattering Problems

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Mathematics

Abstract

Scattering problems (or diffraction problems) consist in studying the field resulting from a wave incident upon an obstacle. This can for example be an acoustic or an electromagnetic wave. In general, these are complicated time-dependent problems, but often a justified hypothesis can be made, which allows time considerations to be dismissed. As a consequence, the wave fields encountered in such problems all satisfy the same equation called the Helmholtz equation. The adjective "canonical" in the title of the project derives from studying simple obstacles, generally of infinite size, with particular characteristics such as sharp edges or corners. Although "simple", these canonical geometries can be used to evaluate the scattered field of more complicated finite obstacles subject to high frequency incident waves.

The first such canonical problem to be considered was the problem of diffraction by a semi-infinite half-plane, and it was solved very elegantly by Arnold Sommerfeld in 1896. This was the start of the mathematical theory of diffraction. Since then, some very ingenious mathematical methods have been developed to tackle such problems, the most famous being the Wiener-Hopf and the Sommerfeld-Malyuzhinets techniques. However, despite tremendous efforts in this field, some canonical problems remain open mathematically, in the sense that no clear analytical solution is available for them. In particular, this is the case for two such problems, the three-dimensional problem of diffraction by a quarter-plane and the two-dimensional problem of diffraction by a penetrable wedge. The word penetrable means that waves can propagate inside the wedge region as well as outside, but with dissimilar wave speeds in the two regions.

The aim of this project is to find a mathematical solution to these two problems, and to use these in concrete applications. It is motivated by a need to address environmental and economical issues linked to both climate change and the near future extinction of fossil fuels. In particular, results on the quarter-plane will be used to understand noise generation within a new type of aeroengine (predicted to drastically reduce the fuel consumption of civil aircraft) and underwater propulsors. This will have a significant impact in these fields of engineering, and will help to cement the UK's position as one of the leading countries for aero and underwater propulsor design. Results on the penetrable wedge will be used in collaboration with climate scientists at the University of Manchester to improve current models for quantifying the effect of light diffraction by ice crystals in clouds. This is a particularly important application since, due to the complex shapes of ice crystals, this problem currently represents one of the biggest uncertainties in predicting climate change. Furthermore, both aspects of the project will enhance the UK's reputation for high quality interdisciplinary applied mathematics research.

Planned Impact

This project is motivated by a need to address environmental and economical issues linked to both climate change and the near future extinction of fossil fuels. The first part of the project focuses on the problem of scattering by an ideal quarter-plane with a strong emphasis on the understanding of noise generation by blade-gust interaction. The second part of the project focuses on the problem of scattering by a penetrable wedge, with a strong emphasis on the understanding of light diffraction by ice crystals in clouds.

By shedding some light on noise generation within a new type of aeroengine, the first part of the project will certainly inspire methods to reduce the overall noise level of such engine. This is currently one of the main issues to overcome before its commercial use and will lead to an obvious impact on the environment. Indeed, this engine is predicted to lead to a reduction of fuel consumption by 25-30% compared to current civil aircraft, which would result in lower emissions of polluting gases. Moreover, this noise in itself is a source of a different kind of pollution, a reduction of which will have a very beneficial impact on society (especially people living or working close to airports or air passengers).

The economic impact of this part of the project is also worth noting. Indeed, despite living in a time of economic and environmental crisis, travelling has become an essential part of our life. It is also generally admitted that fossil fuels will continue to be used for the foreseeable future. However, it is known that such resources are running out, leading to inevitable price increases. Hence, reducing the amount of fuel required by civil aircraft would be a major step towards keeping flight-related costs to a low level. A more direct economic impact that will result from this project arises from the collaborative work with the project partner Thales and the understanding of noise generation within water-propulsors. This will lead to a significant advancement in both the understanding and relevance of the theoretical models used in the early design phase of major military systems. As such, it will assist in the development of low Technology Readiness Level (TRL) to high TRL enhancements, with the effect of maintaining science and technology at the forefront of research in support of related UK national defence activities.

The environmental impact of the second part of the project is substantial since its long term aim is to improve prediction tools for global warming. Indeed, due to their complex shapes, the modelling of light diffraction by ice crystals in clouds is currently one of the biggest uncertainties in predicting climate change. Such an improvement will also allow for a better prediction of the beneficial effects resulting from different solutions designed to reduce global warming.
Naturally, this part of the project also has an economic impact. Indeed, not only will climate change have an effect on the environment and on people, but it will also massively affect businesses and the global economy. The current cost of climate change to the world economy is estimated to be almost $1.3 trillion, while predictions for 2030 suggest that the US would spend 2% of its GDP, and China $1.2 trillion, due to natural catastrophes alone.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Abrahams I (2020) High-contrast approximation for penetrable wedge diffraction in IMA Journal of Applied Mathematics

publication icon
Assier R (2023) A contribution to the mathematical theory of diffraction: a note on double fourier integrals in The Quarterly Journal of Mechanics and Applied Mathematics

publication icon
Assier R (2021) A Surprising Observation in the Quarter-Plane Diffraction Problem in SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics

publication icon
Assier R (2019) Diffraction by a quarter-plane. Analytical continuation of spectral functions in The Quarterly Journal of Mechanics and Applied Mathematics

publication icon
Assier R (2016) Spectral study of the Laplace-Beltrami operator arising in the problem of acoustic wave scattering by a quarter-plane in The Quarterly Journal of Mechanics and Applied Mathematics

publication icon
Assier RC (2020) High-frequency homogenization in periodic media with imperfect interfaces. in Proceedings. Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences

publication icon
Assier RC (2021) Analytical continuation of two-dimensional wave fields. in Proceedings. Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences

 
Description The Laplace-Beltrami operator on a sphere with a cut arises when considering the problem of wave scattering by a quarter-plane. Recent methods developed for sound-soft (Dirichlet) and sound-hard (Neumann) quarter-planes rely on an a priori knowledge of the spectrum of the Laplace-Beltrami operator. We have considered this spectral problem for more general , potentially more realistic, boundary conditions, including Dirichlet, Neumann, real and complex impedance, where the value of the impedance varies like A/r, r being the distance from the vertex of the quarter-plane and A being consant, and any combination of these. We analysed the corresponding eigenvalues of the Laplace-Beltrami operator, both theoretically and numerically. We showed in particular that when the operator stops being self-adjoint, its eigenvalues are complex and are contained within a sector of the complex plane, for which we provided analytical bounds.

A second key finding is related to a different type of canonical scattering problem, namely the scattering by a periodic set of inclusions. This problem was not originally part of the proposal, but it was possible to use similar mathematical techniques, which led to a very interesting discovery of a formula giving the homogenized properties of such material in terms of the volume fraction of the inclusions. Such formula is very efficient from a testing point of view since for a given geometry, the work needed is only performed once and can be reused for different volume fraction. This way we do not need many full numerical computations. This work was selected as a finalist for the Lighthill-Thwaites prize 2017.

A third key finding that was one of the main objectives of this grant is contained in a seminal paper with my collaborator A.V. Shanin. It poses the theoretical foundation of effectively using analysis on two complex variables in order to tackle the quarter-plane problem. In particular, we introduced the notion of additive crossing of branch sets in C^2, which appears to be a fundamental characteristic of the unknown in the quarter-plane problem. This has opened up a lot of new research on the links between functions of several complex variables and diffraction theory, including another paper in QJMAM paper illustrating the practical usefulness of the additive crossing, as well as a paper explaining how to perform analytical continuation of 2D wavefields to C^2.

For the quarter-plane problem still, another paper on Radlow's ansatz has been published in the SIAM journal on Applied mathematics. This is re-exploring the Wiener-Hopf method in two complex variables followed by Radlow. The output will be another proof of the incorrectness of Radlow's approach, as well as the explicit emphasis of a correcting term. We will also show that Radlow's approach performs extremely well in the Dirichlet case despite being incorrect.

A follow up paper, discussing a key assumption made in the latter paper has been published in the Roy Soc Proc A, as part of a special issue on the Wiener-Hopf technique.

Regarding the wedge part of the grant, as planned in the proposal, a review paper on analytical methods in perfect wedge scatterings has been published in Wave Motion and is starting to attract attention.

For the penetrable wedge, we found a way of writing the solution as an asymptotic expansion in terms of a high contrast parameter usiong a mixture of the WIener-Hopf and Sommerfeld-Malyuzhinets methods covered in the review paper mentioned above. This work has been published in the IMA Journal of Applied Mathematics, and lead phd student Matt Nethercote (Named on the grant) to be one of the 6 finalists of the Lighthill-Thwaites prize 2019.

Another paper on Wave scattering by periodic inclusions has been published in wave motion, and an other on scattering by periodic structures with imperfect contact has been published in Proc. Roy. Soc. A.

As part of the workshop I organised thanks to the grant, I am the guest editor of a special issue of Wavemotion on Canonical Scattering. The special issue is now complete, with 11 articles from world leaders in my field. It was a lot more work than anticipated, but I am very proud of the content.
Exploitation Route Thanks to this work, we can hope to apply modern techniques in diffraction theory developed recently in the sound-soft and sound-hard quarter-plane framework to more general set of boundary conditions. This represents a big theoretical step forward and should hopefully lead to concrete applications as regard to diffraction by angular treated surfaces. In fact it has already received some attention and was used and cited by one of the leaders of the field Prof. Lyalinov (St. Petersburg). The homogenization work has been cited 15 times since 2017.

My work on several complex variable has attracted attention and I have given a set of 5 lectures on this topic as part of a summer school organised by the Isaac Newton Institute in Cambridge in 2019. I also recently given 3 lectures (online) on this topic at an American Mathematical Society event hosted by Harvard University.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Environment

URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/wave-motion/special-issue/10C0TTWMJNL
 
Description Canonical Scattering Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Canonical Scattering Workshop Nov. 2017. Sole organiser. 14 renowned speakers from Russia,
USA, France, UK and Italy. The purpose of this workshop was to bring together world-leading
researchers in order to review recent advances and remaining challenges in wave scattering theory.
This was an opportunity to exchange and stimulate new ideas and to initiate new collaborations
internationally or within the UK. It was a great success and will result in a special issue of the
journal Wave Motion.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.mwmresearchgroup.org/canonical-scattering-workshop-2017.html