Well-posedness and stability for relativistic Euler equations with free boundaries

Lead Research Organisation: King's College London
Department Name: Mathematics

Abstract

A rigorous mathematical description of a star requires a coupling between two famous systems of partial differential equations: the Euler equations of fluid mechanics and the Einstein equations of general relativity. These systems possess a rich mathematical structure and describe fundamental physical processes, playing an important role in both mathematics and physics. Their coupling gives the so-called Euler-Einstein system, a fundamental model in the analysis of fluid bodies coupled to gravity. One of the most important examples are the stars, idealised as fluid or gas clouds with a moving boundary interface separating them from the vacuum.

The first and basic mathematical question that one can ask about the free boundary Euler-Einstein system is the following: can one develop a rigorous mathematical framework that establishes the existence and uniqueness of solutions to this system given some initial configuration of the star? Can we similarly track down the beahviour and the regularity of the moving vacuum boundary? How do the changes in initial configurations affect the solutions? Such questions are technically termed as problems of well-posedness, and the principal aim of the proposal is to develop a rigorous well-posedness framework for the moving vacuum boundary Euler-Einstein system.

Mathematically, this problem intertwines various difficulties associated with both the free boundary fluids and the Einstein equations. Due to its highly nonlinear nature, it is a priori unclear whether the free vacuum boundary can cause a degeneracy in the model, leading to a potential breakdown of the solutions, even after a very short time. Even in the Newtonian setting, the degenerate nature of the problem was hinted at by John Von Neumann as early as 1949. However, the past few decades have seen striking developments in the rigorous study of the Newtonian free boundary Euler equations on one hand, and in the mathematical general relativity on the other. A satisfactory well-posedness theory for the Newtonian free boundary compressible fluids has been developed in the past 3 years. Similarly, a rigorous mathematical study of relativistic fluids is a rich and broad topic, that has generated a lot of mathematical research over the past decade. As an example, a momentous breakthrough in the study of stable shock formation for relativistic fluids was accomplished by Christodoulou in 2007.

While such works provide an important impetus for this proposal, the complicated, but beautiful interaction between the free boundary geometry and the relativistic geometry, gives rise to new mathematical structures and additional challenges with respect to the existing literature. The proposal explores these structures in detail and develops novel ideas to show the well-posedness of 1) the free vacuum boundary Euler equations on the Minkowski spacetime and 2) the free vacuum boundary Euler-Einstein system. It then uses the thus established framework to address the stability of the well-known Friedmann-Lemaitre- Robertson-Walker solutions, describing an accelerating expanding universe.

Planned Impact

Besides the academic impact that has been described in the "Academic Beneficiaries" section, this multifaceted proposal connects to the broader public in several important ways.

From its conception in the 18th century, the Euler equations of fluid mechanics have represented one of the focal points in the study of partial differential equations. They led to the study of a variety of important phenomena such as the turbulence, formation of shocks, boundary layers etc. Another beautiful theory, the general theory of relativity, offered us a mathematical tool to study phenomena on large scales under the influence of gravity. Not long after its formulation in 1915, equations for fluids interacting with gravity as described by Einstein were formulated and led to an important system of equations that we call the Euler-Einstein system. It embodies the complexities of both the Euler equation and the Einstein equations individually but at the same time their coupling gives rise to exciting new mathematical phenomena. When the fluid that we are describing is contained in a finite bounded region, which is allowed to change its shape in the course of time, then this system becomes a basic mathematical idealisation of a star.

One of my aims is to explain some of the intricate mathematical structures underpinning the free vacuum boundary Euler equations when relativistic effects are present. Notions such as black holes, white dwarves, gravitational collapse etc. easily capture the imagination of the public, yet there exists a significant gap in understanding the mathematical mechanisms behind such phenomena. Many of the necessary tools come from the field of nonlinear PDEs and geometric analysis and my aim is to take steps in bringing some of these ideas closer to the general nonexpert audiences. I will therefore give presentations on the role of mathematical analysis in our description of stars through the outreach programs at King's. Most importantly, I will speak at conferences and events designed for the UK secondary school maths teachers. I will separately give talks to secondary school students with the aim of popularising mathematical analysis and motivating some of the basic analytical tools in a clear and engaging way. I will also present the outlines of the proposed research at international summer schools for undergraduate students with encouraged participation of the UK maths undergraduates. This is part of my long term goal to foster the development of nonlinear mathematical analysis in the UK. I also plan to create lecture notes that will come out of this series of lectures, as a stepping stone for my future supervision of Masters and Ph.D students.

The UK has a longstanding tradition of world leading research in the field of mathematical analysis. Nevertheless, the relative amount of research in the field of nonlinear partial differential equations is small in comparison to the USA and Europe. This proposal will help shrink that gap and contribute to the development of the field in the UK. In line with this expectation, I plan to organise a workshop at King's College London that will bring world leading experts in nonlinear PDEs together. Special resources will be allocated to encourage the participation of Ph.D.-students and junior researchers from the UK.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Guo Y (2020) Continued Gravitational Collapse for Newtonian Stars in Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis

publication icon
Hadzic MH (2017) Dynamics of expanding gases

publication icon
Hadžic M (2021) Stability and Instability of Self-Gravitating Relativistic Matter Distributions in Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis

publication icon
Hadžic M (2019) A Class of Global Solutions to the Euler-Poisson System in Communications in Mathematical Physics

publication icon
Hadžic M (2017) Local Well-Posedness and Global Stability of the Two-Phase Stefan Problem in SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis

publication icon
Hadžic M (2019) A priori estimates for solutions to the relativistic Euler equations with a moving vacuum boundary in Communications in Partial Differential Equations

publication icon
Parmeshwar S (2020) Global expanding solutions of compressible Euler equations with small initial densities in Quarterly of Applied Mathematics

 
Description An overall goal of the research conducted with the support of this grant was to develop new rigorous mathematical tools for the study of physical phenomena such as evolution of stars - inspired by astrophysics or more generally the behaviour of gases in vacuum - inspired by fluid mechanics. In bothe cases one wonders about the effects of merging these classical topics with the Einstein's theory of gravity. Results of our research are trying to develop tools that will set a stage for a rigorous mathematical treatment of these phenomena.---------------------------------------------------------------- 1) Jointly with Steve Shkoller (UC Davis) and Jared Speck (MIT) we have been able to identify a rigorous mathematical framework which allows us to formulate the so-called initial value problem for free boundary fluids in the context of special relativity.
We resolved the problem for "short" times, which is a mathematical statement that the problem is suitably well-posed on a sufficiently small time scale. This is a major step in the development of the theory. In two current works in progress, we hope to be able to extend our ideas to construct examples of gases surrounded by vacuum that expand and exist for "all times". Such gases should be thought of as a basic model of a compact star surrounded by vacuum. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2) Jointly with Juhi Jang (USC) we have discovered a class of global solutions to vacuum free boundary Euler equations. Euler equations remain to the day one of the most challenging examples of partial differential equations. The
wealth of dynamic scenarios associated with Euler flows is linked to phenomena such as turbulence, vortex
filamentation and other types of singular behaviour. It has therefore been very important to identify stable
regimes, wherein solutions are well-behaved for all times.
We made progress in this direction and in our article we proved one of very few global existence and uniqueness statements for three dimensional Euler flows (with or without free boundary). ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3) Compressible Euler-Poisson system is used as the fundamental Newtonian description of a star.
Even though extensively studied in the astrophysics literature, except for some very special examples no global-in-time solutions in were known.
In a joint work with Juhi Jang (USC) we have been the to identify an open class of initial star configurations that leadto global solutions. These solutions correspond to expanding stars, which are a mathematical idealisation of a supernova explosions.------------------------------------------------- 4) We have recently completed a joint work with Zhiwu Lin (Georgia Institute of Technology) and Gerhard Rein (University of Bayreuth) where we develop a general theory that allows us to relate the instability properties of a star or a galaxy to their density at the galactic or stellar centre, respectively. Our fundamental insight is that high central density causes an onset of unstable behaviour and therefore these objects are not physically viable models of steady galaxies or stars.

Change added 11 Mar 2021: One of the previously reported outcomes was reported both in its preprint stage - as well as in the published version. Now there is only the published version. I have removed one outcome which was reported as a work in preparation.
Exploitation Route The use is of conceptual value, as the problem of understanding free boundary fluid problems is a precursor to the understanding of an even more fundamental question of the behaviour of stars, which are described by the coupling of Euler equations to the Einstein field equations of general relativity.
Sectors Education

URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1511.07467
 
Description The outcomes of the work conducted under this award have been used, to varying degrees, to motivate several popular lectures in recent years for predominantly high school students and/or general public. These include lectures at the King's Maths School, King's Factor lecture, popular talks at the Universities of Tuzla and Sarajevo (Bosnia and Herzegovina). These were used as a platform to excite students about maths research - the topic of the award lends itself to a very compelling imagery (evolution, dynamics, stability, and instability of stars), which makes the link possible. In 2021 the Adams Prize was awarded by the University of Cambridge to the grant holder, partly based on the outcomes of this award. The prize in particular recognised the grant holder for their role "in the development and application of new tools to study the existence of global-in-time solutions (such as existence theory of expanding compressible flows) and the formation of finite-time singularities (such as finite-time gravitational collapse of stars)." Within the context of cross-disciplinary work, the work on the existence of stable and unstable galaxy and star configuration gave a clear mathematical proof of a conjecture which famously originates from the field of astrophysics. Such an interaction of disciplines led to a development of new mathematical techniques that are currently finding applications in other problems coming from physics and general relativity. The most important intra- and interdisciplinary long term contribution of the award is the use of geometric ideas (most importantly scaling invariances) to study global dynamics of fluid flows with free boundaries, which provides the link to mathematical analysis and fluid mechanics. Furthermore, within the context of impact generated by intradisciplinary work, the results on the well-posedness of relativistic stars have been recently clearly linked to developments in the field of so-called dispersive equations. This is likely to generate further developments within the mathematical field of partial differential equations and mathematical physics.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Education
Impact Types Policy & public services