Combinatorics, Probability and Algorithms

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: School of Mathematics

Abstract

The interface of Combinatorics, Probability and its applications (in particular to algorithms) has been developing into an exciting area, with connections and applications, e.g. to Theoretical Computer Science, Statistical Physics and Operations Research. The project will focus on three themes in this area with interrelated objectives:

(i) Randomized Algorithms with a particular focus on randomized property testing:
Property testing aims to infer global structure from local random sampling algorithms. More precisely, given a combinatorial object, we aim to distinguish very quickly if it satisfies some property or if it is far away from satisfying this property. So the main goal is to design randomized algorithms which only consider a tiny part of the input, and then distinguish with high probability between the two above cases.

(ii) Random Discrete Structures:
The study of random graphs is motivated by understanding the typical behaviour of objects. This area has connections to statistical physics (in particular, the study of phase transitions, where small parameter changes give rise to major structural changes) and underpins the average case analysis of algorithms as well as the study of network processes, e.g. of epidemic nature. We will concentrate on the global structure of probability models defined by local constraints as well as on complex networks.

(iii) Randomized Constructions:
This theme is concerned with the use of randomized processes to build combinatorial objects with desired properties, with a focus on longstanding graph decomposition problems. (The main aim in such problems is to split a large object into suitable small pieces, which has applications, e.g. in statistical testing and information theory.)

The aim of the project is to make decisive progress on central questions within these three themes, whose solution relies on the interplay between Combinatorics and Probability. The three themes are connected by several common features. For example, a fundamental paradigm underlying many of the objectives is that of "local-global" structure: how do local patterns influence (typical) global structure? The investigation of this paradigm has been enormously fruitful in the field of Extremal Combinatorics over the last few decades. Within the project we will consider this from a probabilistic perspective. This is particularly relevant for computational problems where the graphs under consideration are large: in "traditional" graph theoretical problems the whole graph is exactly given, but for large networks this is often no longer the case. So we need to infer their global properties from local considerations.

Planned Impact

Large graphs and networks underlie much of modern society and science. Correspondingly, in the past decade, the study of networks has increased dramatically and includes researchers from biology, computer science, economics, engineering, mathematics, physics, sociology, and statistics. Prominent examples of networks are the world wide web, social networks as well as biological networks such as the brain.

All these networks are huge and often constantly evolving. So it is not feasible to have a complete and exact understanding of their structure as well as of precise solutions to the corresponding optimization problems. Probabilistic approaches provide a way out of this dilemma: in particular, randomized property testing has the potential to quickly give an informed guess about the global structure of a network (see Theme RA). Conversely, the study of random graphs (see Theme RS) underpins the average case analysis of algorithms as well as the study of dynamic processes (e.g. epidemics or information distribution).

I believe that I have identified core problems associated with the mathematical foundations of such questions, which are (i) central to the area and (ii) whose solution will yield a body of coherent and broadly useful methods. So part of the long-term impact will be a significantly enhanced toolbox for the probabilistic analysis of large (random) graphs and networks.

Similarly, the project will also establish probabilistic tools for constructing combinatorial objects relevant to design theory (the Erdös conjecture on sparse designs), combinatorial number theory (k-term AP-free process) or extremal combinatorics (the Gyarfas-Lehel conjecture).

The solution of the proposed problems, which either have resisted attack for several decades (e.g. decomposition problems) or else are central in areas arisen much more recently (e.g. from randomized property testing) obviously also has a significant direct impact on the field.

As described in "Academic Beneficiaries", there is a wide range of research groups from several areas (both in the UK and overseas) who would benefit from the proposed research. So as described in "Pathways to Impact", I will be disseminating the results from the project as widely as possible and will organize corresponding activities. Moreover, I will provide the junior researchers on the project with suitable training and guidance. (I believe that I have an excellent track record in these respects.) Finally, I will make use of the opportunities provided by the fellowship to broaden my research by increasing the emphasis on probabilistic and algorithmic aspects. Altogether, this will contribute to the UK being at the forefront of developments in this rapidly developing and influential area.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Balko M (2021) Hypergraph Based Berge Hypergraphs in Graphs and Combinatorics

publication icon
Barber B (2020) Minimalist designs in Random Structures & Algorithms

publication icon
Condon P (2018) A bandwidth theorem for approximate decompositions in Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society

publication icon
Condon P (2020) Dirac's theorem for random regular graphs in Combinatorics, Probability and Computing

publication icon
Condon P (2019) Resilient Degree Sequences with respect to Hamilton Cycles and Matchings in Random Graphs in The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics

publication icon
Ehard S (2020) A rainbow blow-up lemma for almost optimally bounded edge-colourings in Forum of Mathematics, Sigma

publication icon
Ehard S (2020) Pseudorandom hypergraph matchings in Combinatorics, Probability and Computing

publication icon
Espuny Díaz A (2019) Edge Correlations in Random Regular Hypergraphs and Applications to Subgraph Testing in SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics

publication icon
Frankl N (2020) Embedding graphs in Euclidean space in Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series A

publication icon
Frankl P (2022) The Erdos Matching Conjecture and concentration inequalities in Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B

 
Description The aim of the project was to make decisive progress on a range of questions at the interface of Combinatorics and Probability. One area we concentrated on so far is randomized "property testing". The guiding principle is the following: given a huge combinatorial object (e.g. a huge network), we aim to distinguish if it satisfies a certain property or if it is "far away" from satisfying this property. The main goal is to design randomized algorithms which only look at a very small part of the input, and then distinguish with high probability between the two above cases. We have characterized all the hypergraph properties which admit such an algorithm (here a hypergraph consists of hyperedges which each join several vertices of the hypergraph).

The second area we focused on so far is the use of randomized processes for the construction of combinatorial objects satisfying certain conditions. Here are main focus are long-standing problems involving decompositions and designs of graphs and hypergraphs. One example is the so-called Existence conjecture for combinatorial designs, which has its roots in the 19th century. We have given a new proof based on probabilistic (and combinatorial) arguments. Our main result concerns designs in hypergraphs whose clique distribution fulfils certain certain regularity requirements. This enables us to strengthen the results of Keevash as well as to derive a number of new results which go beyond the setting of quasirandom hypergraphs. Answering a question of Keevash, we also completely solved the H-design problem for any arbitrary hypergraph H. This enabled us to prove a conjecture of Chung, Diaconis and Graham on universal sequences for k-element subsets of an n-element set. We also developed a randomized approach to asymptotically confirm a famous conjecture of Erdos on the existence of triangle decompositions which are "locally sparse".

We also considered the problem of decomposing a large dense graph G into sparse (but possibly large) graphs H. In this direction, we have proved an asymptotically best possible degree condition for approximate decompositions into a large family of sparse graphs (namely bounded degree graphs of small bandwidth). We used this as a tool to resolve the longstanding Oberwolfach problem (which was posed by Ringel in 1967) on decompositions of complete graphs into cycle factors for large graphs. (The conjecture can also be phrased in terms of certain scheduling problems.) We actually prove a significantly more general result, which allows for decompositions into more general types of factors. In particular, this also resolves the Hamilton-Waterloo problem for large graphs.

Furthermore, we made progress on three long standing conjectures from the 1960s about path and cycle decompositions of graphs. In particular, we proved the following two conjectures for graphs of linear minimum degree: the conjecture of Gallai on path decompositions as well as the conjecture of Hajos on cycle decompositions.

A further highlight is a proof of the famous Erdos-Faber-Lovasz conjecture (posed in 1972) for large hypergraphs. This conjecture concerns colourings of linear hypergraphs (such colourings have an interpretation in terms of scheduling problems and can also be phrased as a decompositin problem). Such colouring problems are notoriously hard, and the conjecture gives a tight bound on the chromatic index of such hypergraphs (i.e. the number of colours needed to colour the edges of the hypergraph without conflicts).
Exploitation Route There is a wide range of individual researchers and research groups working in the areas considered within the project. I believe that the methods developed within the project will pave the way for follow on research in several directions. In particular, while the existence of combinatorial designs was an open problem for about 150 years, the methods developed for the proof of the Existence conjecture are very general, and thus now related questions suddenly are within reach too. Similarly, the Oberwolfach problem and its variants have attracted the attention of many researchers, resulting in more than 100 previous research papers covering a large number of partial results. I believe that our methods will have further applications to related problems. Likewise, there are several unsolved colouring problems which might now be within reach of the techniques we developed for the Erdos-Faber-Lovasz conjecture.
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)

URL http://web.mat.bham.ac.uk/D.Kuehn/pubdk.html
 
Description interview for popular science article on our work 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The proof of the Erdos-Faber-Lovasz conjecture (https://arxiv.org/abs/2101.04698, still under journal review) reached a large and also non-academic audience.

After interviews with the authors, an article appeared in the popular Mathematics journal Quanta (and was reprinted in wired.com):

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mathematicians-settle-erdos-coloring-conjecture-20210405/
https://www.wired.com/story/mathematicians-settle-the-erdos-coloring-conjecture/

A corresponding tweet was made by the magazine on 21 April 2021 (214,000 followers)
https://mobile.twitter.com/quantamagazine/status/1381661394966343683

There were several further tweets, blogposts, facebook posts, youtube videos (by team members) and articles on the work, e.g.:
Spain: https://institucional.us.es/blogimus/en/2021/04/lll/
Israel: https://gilkalai.wordpress.com/2021/01/14/to-cheer-you-up-in-difficult-times-17-amazing-the-erdos-faber-lovasz-conjecture-for-large-n-was-proved-by-dong-yeap-kang-tom-kelly-daniela-kuhn-abhishek-methuku-and-deryk-osthus/?fbclid=IwAR1CSdRGDKHLR3RYVL9sihYSLp_mOu_CZ9P4deA_CQ_VYj4pazyRlhmCRuM
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.quantamagazine.org/mathematicians-settle-erdos-coloring-conjecture-20210405/