'PROCESS DESIGN FOR NEXT-GENERATION MASS FINISHING TECHNOLOGIES'

Lead Research Organisation: Liverpool John Moores University
Department Name: General Engineering Research Institute

Abstract

Summary
Mass finishing [MF] describes the numerous range of processes used to modify and enhance the surfaces of engineered parts by immersion in a fluidized circulatory flow of loose abrasive media. There are many different types of MF operations in use including: vibratory, tumbling and centrifugal disk which are responsible for material removal and the range of finishing actions from surface cleaning to deburring, often imparting a smooth, lustrous finish. The MF process is particularly suitable for irregular shaped parts and/or large batch sizes and is gaining widespread acceptance as a critical operation for super-finishing components in the fields of aerospace, auto-sport, biomedical and space industry engineering.
However, the process has attracted only little research and as a result the potential of the process is far from being fully exploited and current design practices tend to be empirical, strongly reliant on user experience and expertise. The aim of this study is to improve: (i) understanding of particle kinematics, (ii) process performance and capability, and (iii) evolution of surface finish thus adding a scientific basis, presently lacking.
This proposed research will be the first to include study of the highly efficient Drag finishing regime wherein a part is 'dragged' through static media at high speed. A major feature of the work will be the discrete element modelling programme, the outcomes of which will have strong generic relevance to the wider areas of fluidized and bulk particle/ granular flows.
Given the absence of any major UK or European research effort in this field, a key aim will to be to establish, at LJMU, a unit of expertise in MF that will act as a knowledge warehouse and a conduit for dissemination of best practice and which and will seek to contribute to regional and national strategic planning aimed at promoting and sustaining economic growth in manufacturing industry.
The aims of this research are as follows:
to secure and deliver to industry the necessary scientific grounding required to advance and exploit the MF process
to gain new understanding of impact, wear and surface evolution phenomenon in MF processes
to develop a tribological based abrasion model for mass finishing
to found a 3-D DEM capability for simulation of vibratory-fluidized flows
to establish at LJMU a demonstrator facility directed at key application areas
To achieve these goals a world class partnership of experts are brought together coupling manufacturing knowledge with academic and technical expertise including the high value manufacturing catapult, the MTC, and the rapidly progressing joint initiative: MTC@LJMU. Funding support from EPSRC will help ensure that UK industry and academia lead the world in this rapidly developing and important technology. The planned outreach programme will strengthen this action of dissemination to, and engagement with, industry, and serve to coordinate the knowledge transfer.

Planned Impact

Immediate benefits: The immediate impact will be enhanced manufacturing capability resulting in UK wealth creation. The knowledge gleaned will aid production performance and provide for increased commercial competitiveness in MF, achieved, for example, through reduced cycle time, improved media performance, greener and more efficient machining eg. jig-aided.

Longer term benefits: It is anticipated that global impacts will result shortly after project completion when we will see a wider range of components being finished, exploiting advances secured within the project.
This project will result in new optimisation methodologies and procedures that may be exploited commercially bringing further economic benefit. The work will strengthen our ability to create new systems that develop from current MF technologies. This is expected to include novel location systems and/or adaptive-controlled systems.
Value added will come through the industrial partnerships, engagement with the UK MTC and the developing 'MTC@LJMU'initiative. This is due to the extensive industrial network that is presently extending and includes regional and national SME's as well as more established globals.

The glass technology research will benefit operator health, consumption of finite resources and reduce environmental damage. The researchers will work closely with industry, developing their research and professional skills relevant to the employment sectors of our partners. It is of note that many of our researchers are recruited by our sponsors following project completion - recognition of their acquired skills and expertise.

The growing interest in the MF technology is evidenced through the numerous directed enquiries coming to the group. Outreach will feature strongly (ref. 'pathways to impact' and CoS) and the establishment of a national resource, coupled with support of experienced outreach administrative staff (https://www.ljmu.ac.uk/about-us/faculties/faculty-of-technology-and-environment/general-engineering-research-institute/outreach-project ) -will help ensure we target and reach extensively. Our Advisory Board will strengthen activities directed toward the commercial private sector who will benefit from the research. This project addresses the fact that no current research in this field is taking place in the UK and that technological guidance and advancement is simply not available. The need therefore, for a national presence is evidence based, and validated through the industrial partners supporting this proposal. The research programmes have strong academic content and the contribution to knowledge will be a major intellectual impact. There is significant fundamental research in an area presently lacking in knowledge. The PI has a strong record of delivering high impact outcomes of generic benefit which can be evidenced through the REF2014 'Case'-visit (http://impact.ref.ac.uk/CaseStudies/Results.aspx?HEI=64 ).

This proposal is the culmination of many years of industry collaboration, government and industry funding and university research infrastructure support. The resources needed to deliver the stated impact are principally associated with technical and administrator costs and a low cost item of equipment. We will measure how effective we are in achieving impact in a number of ways. The principal means will be to establish quantitative evidence of performance improvements and provide a foundation upon which we can drive our dissemination to the global community. Secondly, we will monitor engagement with new industry through the outreach unit and determine how many of these contacts can be developed to stronger partnerships. Thirdly we will monitor access to the knowledge warehouse and to the proposed dissemination / outreach events - this data will give reasonable measures on the value of the outcomes. The pathways to impact have been carefully considered to ensure maximum exploitation of outcomes and knowledge.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Jamal M (2017) A digital process optimization, process design and process informatics system for high-energy abrasive mass finishing in The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology

publication icon
Jamal M (2017) Materials characterization part I: contact area of the Berkovich indenter for nanoindentation tests in The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology

publication icon
Jamal M (2017) Materials characterisation part II: tip geometry of the Vickers indenter for microindentation tests in The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology

publication icon
Wang S (2023) Novel contact force measurement in vibratory finishing in Powder Technology

 
Description This new research delivered a novel 3-D simulation based on the Discrete Element Modelling (DEM) method of the granular fluidized flow systems associated with mass finishing processes. This generic solution provides a capability for realistic and representative exploration of the physical processes responsible for surface evolution including particle interactions and flow phenomena in abrasive MF. A new FEA simulation model was coupled to the advanced DEM model and gave insight into the consequent surface and sub-surface stress conditions, particularly important for highly fatigued or cyclically loaded engineering parts. These findings are important to the engineering finishing community and to the manufacturer of mass finishing equipment enabling each to evaluate the effect of new designs or design revisions to the machine on the finishing performance, hence saving costs and time on hitherto expensive evaluations.

A new digital-based optimisation system was designed and validated with industry that was proven to reduce costs and enhance the efficiency of abrasive mass finishing processes. The system converged to an optimized machining solution employing optimisation methods and convergence theory. The system could support use as a cycle design tool, production decision support tool or as a process cost model. It has a potentially wide application across multiple sectors.

The design, fabrication and evaluation (including FEM Structural analyses) of a new jig arrangement system for vibratory mass finishing has been completed. The arrangement is designed to hold the part in the horizontal position and allow free rotation with the media. The system has been shown to remove or reduce the risk of work-surface and machine damage associated with the processing of large components and negate the requirement for workholding via large fixtures. This is an important finding for the finish processing of large components, particularly those of high added value and susceptible to damage.

It has been demonstrated with industrial applications that mass finishing processes are able to deliver high-quality surface finishes with additive manufactured parts possessing a relatively complex geometry (both internal features and external facets) under select conditions. This is an important finding for the metal additive manufacturing community who presently meet with significant challenges related to the as-built condition of the parts. It is necessary to impart a toleranced finish on many of the surfaces to satisfy most applications and this work provides an important step in helping to understand how this can best be achieved whilst meeting production time and cost target criteria.

Novel methods have been developed to gain understanding and insight of particle trajectories and motion within mass finishing processes. This included a dynamic wireless-based transducer coupled with particle image velocimetry for trajectory measurement, a static high-resolution force measurement methodology for impact phenomena, a high-resolution wireless methodology for dynamic force measurements, X-ray method for trajectory measurement and a coupled RecurDyn / EDFEM technique. These systems have captured new data that is providing industry with previously inaccessible knowledge, and are being used to support the design of novel machining concepts including robot-assisted finishing. This has added to existing knowledge and is important for the advancement of the processing technology and the next generation of vibratory mass finishing machines.
Exploitation Route The immediate beneficiaries of this work are the consortium partners.
The outcomes and findings were validated and demonstrated with, industrial applications.
The dissemination of this research is continuing as the network of industrial partners develops.
The post-doctoral researcher appointed to the project has now secured FT employment with LJMU and continues to pursue this field of research. Further projects with the PI and this new staff member are being scoped.

A major EPSRC project that progresses the findings from this research has recently been submitted (09/2019) [EPSRC/ W2927308. A multi-discipline approach to optimise the functional surfaces of additive manufactured medical implants]. The proposed project expands the research domain and embraces a cross-discipline, multi-university programme.

Outcomes of the abrasive glass research and prior associated Innovate UK project [TSB 101275] and extended within this project featured within the MTC as an exemplary Case Study and were reported in a PhD thesis, MPhil thesis, EuroEng thesis, numerous MSc theses, international journal articles and conference papers, and company literature. The research was promoted at an international manufacturing exhibition held in the NW region attracting new business contacts and applications.

The "granularised" multi-particle DEM approach conceived at LJMU has been adopted by the MTC and interfaced with other allied physics modelling tools to support their industry collaborative programmes. This has permitted investigation of domains and processes previously inaccessible via computer simulation.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description This project continued from a prior Innovate UK project [TSB 101275], 'Thermally Treated Recycled Glass as a Vibratory Finishing Abrasive' in partnership with MTC, Vibraglaz, Potters-Ballotini, Fintek, GTS and Rolls-Royce - in which a new abrasive tool based wholly on thermally treated recycled glass was developed for the mass finishing industry. The tool was highly innovate and potentially a disruptive technology for the sector. The product has strong environmental credentials: recycling of a landfill material, recyclable, reduced consumption of finite materials and lower energy usage in its manufacture, has been subject to rigorous and independent evaluation under external supervision in the USA and Europe, and has proven capability. This EPSRC project featured the new tool within its experimental programmes. This work contributed to the building in the UK (Barnsley, Yorks) of a £2.5M factory for high volume production of the product within a sector of value circa $300M/annum, immediately creating 6 new manufacturing jobs. The new product has led to improved production efficiencies, a wider product offering and increased sales revenue, estimated to have a value of £1.2M in the first two years of production. The product offers a method of finishing that is cleaner and more environmentally sensitive than any other available process technology and it is reasoned that a cost-saving due to legislative compliance, waste management and tool economics, per tonne of media approaches 40 percent. SEM partners, Sharmic and Fintek, have introduced the glass product to their range of abrasive media, resulting in new business and interest. The company Repclif Chemical Services Ltd has invested in the design and development of new formulations specific to the glass product and are presently marketing these in partnership with Potters-Ballotini. This fundamental research has been instrumental in the realisation of an expanding portfolio of collaborative industry-externally funded research programmes with sources including Innovate UK [IUK - 132873], Metal AM Process Informatics for Improved Surface Finish of Complex Parts, in partnership with MTC, Croft Additive Manufacturing Ltd and Fintek, British Council, the MTC [MTC_CRP, Design Process Control for Improved Surface Finish of Complex parts][ MTC_IMP 'Next Generation Finishing Technologies to Enhance Residual Stress And Surface Condition (NGFin)], Industry and the EU, in addition to internal University funding.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Economic

 
Description IUK AM Strategy Steering Group
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact Additive Manufacturing is enabling the transformation of existing sectors and providing completely new and disruptive business opportunities. The UK is amongst the global leaders in both the development of knowledge and successful application of AM technology. However, there are gaps in the supply chain (materials supply, equipment, post processing and validation). Therefore, industry leaders and initiatives, such as the Foresight Report [5], are recommending the urgent development of a UK National Strategy on AM. (membership lapsed)
URL https://am-uk.org/about-am-uk/am-strategy/
 
Description IUK Croft
Amount £150,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 132873 
Organisation Innovate UK 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2017 
End 07/2018
 
Description KE & I
Amount £12,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 276002S0001920TRI 
Organisation Liverpool John Moores University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2018 
End 05/2018
 
Description LJMU RIS
Amount £15,000 (GBP)
Funding ID AH -147 
Organisation Liverpool John Moores University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2017 
End 07/2017
 
Description MTC CRP1
Amount £105,000 (GBP)
Funding ID TAB - CRP - 2016 -10 
Organisation Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2016 
End 02/2017
 
Description Next Generation Finishing Technologies To Enhance Residual Stress And Surface Condition (NGFin)
Amount £120,000 (GBP)
Funding ID MTC_IMP 
Organisation Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2018 
End 07/2019
 
Description Uplift Project
Amount £3,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 276002S0001923TRI 
Organisation Liverpool John Moores University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2018 
End 04/2018
 
Description BAE AM 
Organisation BAE Systems
Department BAE Systems Military Air & Information
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We have cooperated with BASE in the finishing of Additive manufactured parts. This has provided BAE with new insight into the potential of mass finishing for their products. It has laid the foundation for future collaborative engagements with LJMU.
Collaborator Contribution BAE have provide new AM products to LJMU for us to explore under the MF process. This will help broaden our experience and knowledge with this emerging technology. It will also provide data that we can use to populate our knowledge warehouse (a scheduled outcome of the project). It will also provide a platform upon which we can build a future strategic collaborative partnership.
Impact Outcomes rea presently associated with surface finish data on alloyed additive manufactured parts.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Qualkem; http://www.qualkem.com/ 
Organisation Qualkem
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Qualkem have been invited to join the consortium as an Associate Partner. They have been invited to participate in Quarterly Project Meetings and to offer their advice throughout the course of the project.They are party to progress and dissemination activities
Collaborator Contribution They have wide experience in the formulation of chemical compounds for industry in a wide range of applications. They have particular expertise in chemical formulations for the newly developed glass media used in mass finishing. They bring valued technical knowledge and industry networks to the project. They have particular insight and understanding of chemical formulations used in the experimental studies associated with this project.
Impact Reference to EPSRC project on the company website is presently being prepared
Start Year 2017
 
Description Sharmic Engineering Ltd. https://sharmic.co.uk/ 
Organisation Sharmic Engineering Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Sharmic have been invited to join the consortium as an Associate Partner. They have been invited to participate in Quarterly Project Meetings and to offer their advice throughout the course of the project.They are party to progress and dissemination activities.
Collaborator Contribution They have wide experience in the Mass Finishing industry and are providers of machine tools, abrasive media and fluid compounds. They bring valued technical knowledge and industry networks to the project. They have particular insight and understanding of jig arrangements and MF challenges that we are addressing within the project.
Impact Reference to EPSRC project on the company website is presently being prepared.
Start Year 2017
 
Company Name Abraglaz Ltd 
Description The company has been established to help exploit the potential of a thermally treated recycled glass product that has, at its foundation, the thermally treated glass product developed for abrasive mass finishing (Ref. Innovate UK 101275; 2013-2015) . This new product will differ from the previous product in that it will possess porosity. The significance of this introduced quality will be the potential to act as an abrasive grinding wheel. The challenge is to identify a material that will satisfy environmental, cost, health and performance criteria and provide the necessary porosity whilst subject to a high-temperature cycle. If this can be achieved there is a £80M / year annual market open for its introduction. The early / foundation works for this development were supported by the LJMU (RIS - AH 147 ref. Further Funding section). The second phase is now underway (March 2018; 3 months project, KE&I 276002 S0001 920TRI; ref. Further Funding section), again supported by the LJMU in partnership with the inventor (Abraglaz Ltd). 
Year Established 2017 
Impact None at this time.
 
Description Aerospace Manufacturing Magazine 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The article reported on outcomes of the collaboration between LJMU, MTC and industry partners. It was associated with metal additive manufacturing and aerospace materials.
The research had two aims. First, reduce the variability and overall surface roughness of an AM part by optimising the build parameters and so make mass surface finishing more effective and quicker. Second, improve mass surface finishing techniques to suit the increased part complexity. Capturing process informatics from build and finishing, along with mechanical properties measured at key stages have been vital to providing data for developing a process optimisation system (POSY).

As a software tool, POSY is a tangible outcome from the project that is being designed and developed by MTC. This will help AM manufactures to predict and set the best build parameters to achieve near net shape while maintaining tensile strength and also reducing initial surface roughness. In addition, it will help AM part design teams to allow for the tolerances required by further post processing using mass finishing. Meeting these two objectives will enable AM parts to achieve a comparable surface smoothness to a subtractively engineered component.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://www.aero-mag.com/additive-manufacturing-innovate-uk-fintek
 
Description ManLive2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The ManufacturingLive2017 was a leading industry event, The Manufacturer Live, was held in Liverpool and was made up of a series of interlocking events which helped form the Digital Manufacturing Week, SMEs had opportunity to meet over 4,000 of the UK's high-growth manufacturers, key manufacturing OEM's, industrial accelerators, hardware-startups, finance and 4IR solution providers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://lcr4.uk/events/manufacturer-live-2017/