Development of superconducting composite permanent magnets for synchronous motors: an enabling technology for future electric aircraft

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Materials Science & Metallurgy

Abstract

Continued incremental improvements of conventional aircraft, using gas turbines to generate all the thrust, will not be sufficient in the long term to curb the negative environmental impact of air traffic which is growing exponentially. Hybrid electric distributed propulsion is a new solution with the potential to significantly reduce fuel burn and CO2 emissions. In this approach, electrical power is transmitted from gas turbine powered generators to numerous electric fan motors. Superconducting electric motors are likely the only technology capable of achieving the required power densities, greater than 10 kW/kg to make hybrid electric aircraft feasible.
One of the most promising synchronous motor designs for this application uses trapped flux superconducting composite permanent magnets (SCPMs) on the rotor, instead of coils. The increased gap fields this permits can enable high power densities. This project will develop these SCPMs in the form of stacks of second generation high temperature superconducting (HTS) tape. Although designed to carry transport current, pieces of HTS tape can also sustain persistent currents which correspond to trapped magnetic fields. Stacks of HTS tape have been proven by the Applied Superconductivity and Cryoscience Group at the University of Cambridge to trap fields many times higher than produced by rare earth magnets, despite containing less than 2% superconductor by volume. However, there has been almost no previous work on implementing them into a motor, and there are no prototypes in which stacks provide greater gap fields than rare earth magnets. The new SCPM technology has three key advantages over competing superconducting rotor technologies. i) The elimination of current leads reduces thermal leak and simplifies the rotor design compared to coils. ii) Stacks of HTS tape are highly mechanically and thermally stable due to their large metal content, giving them a high mean time to failure. iii) The stacks are almost impossible to quench (uncontrollable loss of supercurrent due to thermal runaway) unlike all superconducting coils, preventing sudden rotor failure in airborne operation.
The project will create stacks using the latest commercial 12 mm and 46 mm wide HTS tape and investigate pulsed field magnetisation for stack geometries suited to a synchronous motor. An existing pulsed field magnetisation system will be used to investigate the properties of the new stacks, in addition to FEM critical state modelling using previously developed frameworks. A major objective will be to study in detail the demagnetising effects on SCPMs due to the oscillating applied fields that can be experienced by rotors. Methods to reduce demagnetising effects to levels acceptable to the aerospace supporting partners will be experimentally investigated.
A 10 kW lab-scale prototype motor will be constructed around a new cryostat to prove the concept of HTS stacks of tape acting as rotor permanent magnets and to study their behaviour in a rotating machine environment. Peak gap fields up to approximately 3 T will be possible when operating the rotor down to 20 K. The stator will include integrated pulsed field magnetisation coils to achieve practical magnetization upon machine start up and will be cooled by liquid nitrogen.
System level design studies will be conducted with partners in the motor and aerospace industries to determine design possibilities for large scale motors that utilise SCPMs based on the results of the project.

Planned Impact

The proposed research project seeks to develop superconducting composite permanent magnets in the form of stacks of high temperature superconducting tape for motor applications. The new permanent magnets have the potential to be one of the enabling technologies for future environmentally friendly hybrid electric aircraft.
In the past decade, most forms of transport have taken a significant shift towards electric power. Electric and hybrid electric road vehicles are a commercial reality, and almost all new large commercial ships are electrically propelled. Electric propulsion for civilian aircraft is at an earlier stage of development but is now gaining serious momentum, attracting design studies from industry and academia. This project can help achieve the very high power densities and efficiencies demanded by the aerospace industry for electric fan motors.
Air traffic worldwide is projected to grow by 5% each year for the foreseeable future. Therefore improving the fuel efficiency of future civilian aircraft is critical to reducing emissions and addressing the long-term rising cost of fossil fuels. Superconducting electric motors are seen as the only class of motors capable of achieving the required specific powers greater than 10 kW/kg. The superconducting composite permanent magnets developed in this project will allow new superconducting rotor designs that have great potential to be used in future aircraft fan motors. It therefore has an impact on the Flightpath 2050 targets set by the EU and the European aviation industry to significantly reduce CO2 emissions and noise by 2050 compared to the 2000 baseline. Reducing the environmental impact of civilian aircraft and the resulting societal benefit is therefore the largest overall impact of the project but also a long-term one. Proving the fundamental feasibility of HTS component technology at an early stage will ensure enabling technologies are ready for application by 2040. The low technology readiness level and disruptive nature of hybrid electric aircraft require partnership with large organisations that have a long-term commitment to Flightpath 2050 targets to enable impact. Partners Airbus Group Innovations UK and Rolls Royce will support the realisation of these long-term goals as well as being beneficiaries through technology transfer. This may contribute to securing the future of the UK aerospace industry, currently the second largest globally. Collaboration with the industrial project partners will allow growth of the research to larger scale prototypes which will be enabled by design studies integrated into the project.
As well as the larger scale economic impact expected from the success of superconducting motor technology for aerospace, other applications may also benefit from the development of high field permanent magnets. These include electrically propelled ships, wind power generators, magnetic separation and small-scale NMR/MRI. The superconducting motor, generator and cable market is expected to grow to £2.2 billion in the UK, with superconducting motors predicted to have the biggest market penetration (> 70%) by 2025. This growth will enable the research to contribute to a low carbon economy and to meeting the UK's carbon reduction targets.
Postdoctoral and student researchers working on the project, will gain significant experience of superconducting motor design and experiments, which translate to valuable skills for the UK aerospace industry and feed the people pipeline needed to grow the UK's emerging electric propulsion activities. The staff of project partners will also gain knowledge of the capability of the latest superconducting materials and specific challenges in applying them to rotating machines. A broad range of transferrable skills will be developed from collaborative work, including commercial awareness for university staff, and also communication skills from reporting results to academic, industrial and student audiences.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Baskys A (2019) Remanent Magnetic Flux Distribution in Superconducting-Ferromagnetic Layered Heterostructures in Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism

publication icon
Campbell A (2017) Demagnetisation by crossed fields in superconductors in Superconductor Science and Technology

publication icon
Climente-Alarcon V (2020) Magnetization and Losses for an Improved Architecture of Trapped-Flux Superconducting Rotor in Journal of Propulsion and Power

publication icon
Climente-Alarcon V (2019) Computation of Superconducting Stacks Magnetization in an Electrical Machine in IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

publication icon
Patel A (2018) A trapped field of 17.7 T in a stack of high temperature superconducting tape in Superconductor Science and Technology

publication icon
Patel A (2017) Magnetic levitation using a stack of high temperature superconducting tape annuli in Superconductor Science and Technology

publication icon
Tomkow L (2019) Distribution of Trapped Magnetic Flux in Superconducting Stacks Magnetised by Angled Field in Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism

 
Description The maximum trapped field between two stacks of high temperature superconducting tape, has been almost doubled during the first 6 months of the project from 7.3 T to 13.4 T, then later increased to 17.7 T. This was achieved using commercial SuperPower tape with a 30 micron substrate combined with 46mm wide tape. The results represents the strongest permanent magnet in the world. The satisfies objective 6 of the project and the overall aim to determine the maximum limits for this new type of permanent magnet. All WP1 tasks have been been successfully completed.
Exploitation Route It shows those in both industry and academia, who are investigating high power density superconducting motors, the suitability of stacks of superconducting tape for motors, the technology proposed in the project.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy

 
Title Trapped field data and analysis for 17.7 T trapped field in a stack of HTS tapes 
Description Data relating to trapped field experiments conducting at the National High Magnetic Field Lab in Florida, USA on stacks of HTS tape. Included is raw data for the 17.7 T trapped field experiment and Hall probe calibration data as well as a summary file for all the data collected. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
 
Description Supply of motor components for test rigs 
Organisation Oswald Elektromotoren GmbH
PI Contribution Design and modelling of superconducting rotors for integration in a fully superconducting motor design. Design, build and testing of test rigs in Cambridge foe superconducting rotors using normal copper conducting stators
Collaborator Contribution Provision of normal copper conducting stator for test rig and custom fabrication of rotor support components which are used by us to construct complete rotors for test rig. Advice on power electronics needed to drive stator and the operating limits of stator
Impact Design of a motor test rig in Cambridge to evaluate magnetisation and demagnetisation of superconducting rotors which is a key goal of the project. The collaboration is multidisciplinary as the supporting partner is an expert in electric motors and drives whereas we are more experts in superconducting materials and their behaviour in magnetic fields. An outcome is sharing knowledge of each of these disciplines which eachother.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Invited seminar (University of Liege) delivered by researcher employed on grant 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact An invited talk was delivered to a group of largely postgraduate students at the University of Liege in the engineering faculty. Some senior faculty members were also present. The vast majority of the audience were not from a superconductivity or motor background so the talk reached a new audience. The talk was on stacks of superconducting tapes for permanent magnet applications. It included a section on electric aircraft and superconducting motors which the audience was not aware of and encouraged questions and discussion after the talk.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017