Liquid actuation based on humidity gradients: Hygrotaxis

Lead Research Organisation: Northumbria University
Department Name: Fac of Engineering and Environment

Abstract

We live in a world made of water, and more specifically, water that is constantly melting, freezing, condensing and evaporating. Many important aspects of our lives are determined by how water changes between ice, liquid and vapour.

Evaporation is a seemingly simple process which occurs when a droplet is in contact with a gas that is not saturated with vapour molecules. This is why damp clothes take longer to dry on a rainy day. Droplet evaporation occurs in a wide range of important situations, from the drying of droplets from the surface of a car to the minute workings of cooling systems used in microelectronics.

Moving droplets about is a very appealing solution for problems involving the transfer of mass and heat, and in recent years there have been advances in identifying mechanisms that lead to the self propulsion of droplets. For example, it is possible to use ratchet shaped surfaces or surfaces of changing rigidity to guide the motion of droplets, and by adding surfactants (such as food coloring) it is possible to make droplets chase each other. However, identifying a mechanism for droplet self-propulsion on solid surfaces that does not rely on ratcheting or external agents has remained elusive.

Recently, experimental evidence has emerged indicating that droplets evaporating on solid surfaces in the presence of a non-uniform ambient humidity generate directed flows and even 'bend' towards each other. One may naturally think whether such behaviour can be transformed into the net motion of the droplets. Such a new means for droplet self propulsion is very appealing, as it could lead to advances in heat and mass transfer applications.

In this proposal I will explore the concept of "hygrotaxis". This is a new self-propulsion mechanism for liquids that exploits non-uniform ambient humidities to create fluid flow. Using a combination of computational fluid dynamics simulations and proof-of-principle experiments, I aim to investigate the mechanism of hygrotactic motion for i) single droplets, ii) pairs of droplets, and iii) droplets subject to confinement. The results of this research will set the foundations of hygrotaxis as a new concept in Soft Matter Physics. In collaboration with two industrial partners, I will identify opportunities for further research that can inform technologies which harness hygrotaxis, such heat management systems for microelectronics and self-cleaning surfaces for the automobile industry.

Planned Impact

Industrial Pathways

The scope of the research activities in hygrotaxis falls within the general concept of liquid transport and discharge from solid surfaces over timescales shorter than the timescale of evaporation of the liquid. This principle can be translated into a wide range of applications within industrial Research and Development (R&D).

Heat Transfer Sector - Heat pipes are devices that combine temperature differences with a liquid-gas phase change to mediate the transfer of heat between solid interfaces. The use of heat pipes spans a wide range of applications including cooling systems for microelectronics and spacecraft and as heat-storing elements for energy harvesting. A key feature in heat-exchange technology is the efficiency of heat transfer. More precise management of the liquid-gas phase change, including the spatio-temporal control of liquid structures can lead to optimised devices that increase the net heat transfer between target surfaces. In this proposal I will work with Sustainable Energy Systems (SES), an SME dedicated to R&D in heat exchangers, as an Industrial Partner of the project. The planned activities are focused on identifying surface geometries and operational conditions that exploit hygrotaxis to increase the efficiency of heat transfer devices. The main outcome of this collaboration will be a set of proof-of-principle results (simulations and experiments), which can be developed as a follow-up project focused on heat-exchange applications.

Automotive Sector -- According to the Annual Business Survey of the Office of National Statistics the UK vehicle sector contributed with a £60.6 bn turnover to the UK economy in 2013. Moreover, the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders reported that 158,000 jobs were directly related to vehicle manufacturing industry in 2014. A challenge faced by the automotive sector is how to enhance liquid transport and minimise surface debris upon evaporation from automobile coatings. Current technologies focus on aesthetics, protection against corrosion, durability, the ability for production en masse and cost (Akafuah et al., Coatings 6, 2016). In this project, I will work with Jaguar Land Rover, a UK multinational automotive company. The pathways to impact activities of this collaboration will be aimed at identifying combinations of specific surface geometries, surface properties and operational conditions, which lead a better liquid transport upon evaporation. The result of this collaboration will be a first set of proof-of-principle results that underpin a subsequent collaboration project with JLR specifically aimed at developing new self-cleaning surfaces which exploit hygrotaxis. This can help maintain the current niche capability enjoyed by the UK in the automotive sector.

Public Engagement

Evaporation is a seemingly simple process, and it occurs in a multitude of everyday life situations. Evaporation can be used to illustrate a variety of concepts in Physics, for example capillarity, superhydrophobicity, stability, heat transfer and phase transitions. It also satisfies the fascination we have for slow processes as illustrated by time-lapse videography. In this project I will work with Think Physics, a HEFCE-Catalyst project aimed at encouraging young people, with a particular focus on women, to pursue careers in STEM disciplines, to develop an trial an outreach demonstrator based on evaporation. In collaboration with Nature's Raincoats, an outreach project run by Northumbria, Nottingham Trent and Oxford Universities, I will run this demonstrator in Public Outreach events.

People Development

This project will employ a Post Doctoral Research Fellow, whose expertise will add to the UK's academic skills-base in theoretical and computational Soft Matter Physics. The PDRF will also benefit from training in project management, scientific reporting and networking through attendance to conferences, and in public engagement training.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Armstrong S (2019) Pinning-Free Evaporation of Sessile Droplets of Water from Solid Surfaces. in Langmuir : the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids

publication icon
Barrio-Zhang H (2020) Contact-Angle Hysteresis and Contact-Line Friction on Slippery Liquid-like Surfaces. in Langmuir : the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids

publication icon
Ruiz-Gutiérrez É (2019) Lattice-Boltzmann Simulations of Electrowetting Phenomena. in Langmuir : the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids

publication icon
Wells GG (2018) Snap evaporation of droplets on smooth topographies. in Nature communications

 
Description In this project we are developing a detailed understanding of the conditions in which asymmetries in the ambient humidity can force evaporating droplets to move.

Key Finding 1: We have developed a computational and experimental toolkit to study the evolution of evaporating droplets subject to asymmetry.

Key Finding 2: We have applied our methods to understand the evaporation of a single droplet in contact with a non-planar, but ultra smooth, surface. We have found that on a wavy surface, evaporating droplets shift positions as a consequence of "snap" events, and that, unlike droplets evaporating on ordinary surfaces, their shape and position during evaporation can be predicted with good accuracy.

Key Finding 3: We have carried out a series of experiments on the evaporation of single droplets on a liquid-like surface (a solid coated with small polymer chains) under accurately controlled humidity conditions (using a bespoke experimental setup). We have completed a first study on the effect of evaporation on the wetting properties of the droplets, and are currently testing the effect of a humidity gradient on single and multiple drops as a means to achieve their motion.

Key Finding 4: We have carried out a first study of the motion of liquids inside a capillary tube as a model system to understand evaporation in asymmetric confinement. Our findings show that, in the absence of evaporation, a liquid undergoes a long-crossover dynamics as it invades a capillary tube, challenging long-held assumptions on the motion of liquids in confinement.

Key Finding 5: We have studied the static and dynamic friction of droplets on ultra smooth liquid like surfaces under different ambient humidity conditions. Our results show that on such surfaces, small differences in humidity can lead to significant changes in the surface's wettability. These results are now published in the peer-reviewed journal Langmuir [Langmuir 2020, 36, 49, 15094-15101].

Key Finding 6: We have produced a set of modelling simulations as part of the PhD student match funded by the host institution. The simulations focus on the effect of strong asymmetry in the ambient humidity. We intend to submit these results as a second peer-review publication in 2021.
Exploitation Route From a scientific point of view, our findings are of interest to scientists working on fundamental and applied aspects of evaporation; hence we have presented our results at national and international conferences to maximise their impact. This includes the American Physical Society Division of Fluid Dynamics meeting in Atlanta (2018) and the SIG Meeting on Multiscale Modelling of Wetting Phenomena in Durham in 2018.

In addition to this academic dissemination, we have been in touch with our partners, Jaguar Land Rover and Sustainable Engine Systems, to discuss potential applications of our results. With our partner Sustainable Engine Systems we are looking at the application of our results in the context of cooling devices.
Sectors Electronics,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description In partnership with NUSTEM, we have developed an outreach activity focused on the concept of smart surfaces (linked to the ultra-smooth SLIPS surfaces used in the project) to disseminate to primary and secondary school children. The NUSTEM team have tried the workshop during Northumbria University's Physics Experience week with a group of 13 Year 12 pupils. The workshop lasted an hour and was delivered by the postdoctoral fellow working on the research project. The industrial impact of this project is now being further developed in the context of a Northern Accelerator Award (SOCAL: NA-CCF-51).
Sector Education,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Creating new types of heat pipes 
Organisation Sustainable Engine Systems Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Our work on the behaviour of fluids in confinement undergoing evaporation has a direct relevance to cooling devices, which SES is interested in exporting.
Collaborator Contribution SES have provided industrial advice in order to optimise geometries in our simulations and experiments.
Impact Following our pathways to impact activities plan, we have held industrial advisory board meetings with SES. The first one in October 3 2018 (via Skype) and a second visit to Northumbria University on October 16 2018. We are planning a follow up meeting in March/April 2019.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Surface designs to prevent watermarks on solid surfaces 
Organisation Jaguar Land Rover Automotive PLC
Department Jaguar Land Rover
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Our research on evaporation under asymmetric humidity conditions and on non-planar surfaces is relevant to the design of surfaces that better discharge evaporating water droplets.
Collaborator Contribution Ian Bossons from JLR provided in-kind support during an initial industrial advisory meeting on October 9, 2017.
Impact JLR ended the collaboration in January 2019 citing internal pressures.
Start Year 2017