Reducing risk through uncertainty quantification for past, present and future generations of nuclear power plants

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

To ensure national resilience and productivity in an uncertain world, the UK needs a safe, reliable energy supply. Electricity generated by domestic nuclear fission plant creates an important contribution to this, currently generating around one sixth of the UK's requirements. Future fusion-powered plant provide a vision of lower waste, higher safety energy generation from essentially limitless fuel.

However, poor public perception of nuclear safety is limiting uptake, whilst poor understanding of the behaviour of critical nuclear materials exposed to thermal, mechanical and radiation loading increases engineering uncertainty, hence escalating design risk and operational cost.

This programme of research uses a multi-scale, multi-technique approach, combining high performance computer models with imaging analysis, to build a deeper understanding of the mechanical behaviour of several vital engineering materials subject to such stresses:
* silicon ceramics used for the containment of historic nuclear waste,
* graphite used for moderating reactions in the current generation of nuclear plant,
* beryllium and tungsten used to line containment vessels for future fusion generation.

Developing better, experimentally-validated models of the structural integrity of such vital components will enable increased accuracy in design, hence reducing the cost of build and operation of power generation and waste storage facilities and giving greater public confidence in the industry.

The research combines the strengths of two computational approaches:
* Fully physically-based materials models, which are well-developed, but are not yet applicable to large and complex engineering systems;
* Empirical engineering models, which are useful in the domain for which they have been calibrated, but currently have limited transferability;
along with rigorous error analysis, to create an approach that is transferable across length scales, enabling the tracking of fundamental physical mechanisms through to engineering application.

The experimental elements of the programme, using X-ray tomography to create 3D images of strain and damage inside samples and Digital Image Correlation to track real-time crack propagation, will provide new insight into the behaviour of these critical materials under stress and observational parameters to inform the modelling.

The project will draw from the strengths of the interdisciplinary team to develop experts of the future. It will involve and inform industrial partners and other key stakeholders, from regulators to plant workers, to ensure results are relevant to and taken up by UK energy generation and other strategically important industries.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We successfully simulated the uncertainty associated with failure of some nuclear materials
Exploitation Route This will pave the way towards a probabilistic safety case in nuclear industry
Sectors Energy

 
Title CAFE modelling of statistical distribution in fracture toughness 
Description A cellular automata finite element model is being developed which can capture the statistical distribution of fracture toughness of nuclear materials. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This is a new publication (See publication section) and is yet to attract the attention of researchers. An updated version of its impact will be given in the next ResearchFish submission. 
 
Description Probabilistic nuclear structural integrity collaboration with Rolls Royce 
Organisation EDF Energy
Department EDF Energy Nuclear Generation
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution A brief presentation of the preliminary work carried out in this project at the steering committee attracted the attention of representative from Roll Royce plc. Discussions about the expansion of work was had and it was agreed that "Probabilistic nuclear structural integrity" is an area of shared interest. It was agreed that the best way forward to expand the collaboration is to make joint application for funding. This is now currently underway as part of the Department of Business, Energy, and Industrial Strategy's Phase II call for Nuclear innovation programme: advanced manufacturing and materials competition, Phase 2.
Collaborator Contribution University of Bristol (UoB) and Rolls Royce plc (RR) have both joined a consortium led by EDF Energy to apply for funding from Nuclear innovation programme: advanced manufacturing and materials competition, Phase 2. The core of the joint UoB-RR shared work package is to apply the probabilistic structural integrity to Gen IV nuclear reactors. This is an application and expansion of the work carried out in this EPSRC project for capture the uncertainty in degradation of nuclear materials. The outcome of the application and the result of the collaboration will be given in more detail in future ResearchFish submission given the early stages of the work.
Impact - the output of the application to BEIS will be given in the next ResearchFish submission.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Probabilistic nuclear structural integrity collaboration with Rolls Royce 
Organisation Rolls Royce Group Plc
Department Rolls-Royce Civil Nuclear
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution A brief presentation of the preliminary work carried out in this project at the steering committee attracted the attention of representative from Roll Royce plc. Discussions about the expansion of work was had and it was agreed that "Probabilistic nuclear structural integrity" is an area of shared interest. It was agreed that the best way forward to expand the collaboration is to make joint application for funding. This is now currently underway as part of the Department of Business, Energy, and Industrial Strategy's Phase II call for Nuclear innovation programme: advanced manufacturing and materials competition, Phase 2.
Collaborator Contribution University of Bristol (UoB) and Rolls Royce plc (RR) have both joined a consortium led by EDF Energy to apply for funding from Nuclear innovation programme: advanced manufacturing and materials competition, Phase 2. The core of the joint UoB-RR shared work package is to apply the probabilistic structural integrity to Gen IV nuclear reactors. This is an application and expansion of the work carried out in this EPSRC project for capture the uncertainty in degradation of nuclear materials. The outcome of the application and the result of the collaboration will be given in more detail in future ResearchFish submission given the early stages of the work.
Impact - the output of the application to BEIS will be given in the next ResearchFish submission.
Start Year 2019
 
Description UKAEA 
Organisation Culham Centre for Fusion Energy
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration with UKAEA within this project initiated a Royal Academy of Engineering Research Chair programme
Collaborator Contribution UKAEA continued in kind and cash support for expanding this research programme to a Royal Academy of Engineering Research Chair
Impact This programme is contributing to UKAEA materials roadmap
Start Year 2019