Droplets With Dynamic Size On Smooth Surfaces

Lead Research Organisation: The Open University
Department Name: Faculty of Sci, Tech, Eng & Maths (STEM)

Abstract

Droplets interacting with solid surfaces are found in a wide variety of daily life experiences and natural phenomena. Their study serves as a canonical example of a wetting phenomenon which, despite its simplicity, has been shown to be a remarkably complicated problem. Many theoretical efforts over the last few years have focused their attention on understanding how the properties of the solid surface affect the dynamics of the droplet, with particular emphasis on droplet control and manipulation, which is important for a wide range of technological applications, including the rapidly growing fields of nano- and micro-fluidics.

Quite often the volume of the droplets is subject to external, time-dependent variations - a situation that we refer to as droplets with dynamic size. This occurs, for example, when there is mass exchange through the droplet interface (evaporation/condensation phenomena), or when droplets sit on porous materials so that liquid is absorbed through the pores.

When the volume of a droplet increases or decreases, it is widely accepted that microscopic defects on the surface (either chemical or topographical) induce pinning effects, which block the translational motion of the contact line, i.e. the line where the liquid/gas interface meets the solid surface. As a consequence, droplets exhibit what is known as stick-slip motion, which has crucial effects on, e.g., the way droplets evaporate, but has been proved to be notoriously difficult to predict, and more importantly control. Precisely because of this, the use of smooth, pinning-free surfaces with controllable macroscopic properties/topographies has become a major need in the design of many microfluidic/wetting systems. However, a quantitative understanding of the interplay between the volume changes in droplets and smooth variations on the surface, and how this affects both the dynamics and the shape of the droplet, still elude us.

This project will explore the fundamental interplay between a time-dependent variation of the droplet volume and simple smooth variations on solid surfaces. Using a balanced combination of analytical and computational techniques, we aim to investigate under which conditions a droplet may naturally exhibit lateral motion as its volume changes in time, and to exploit this in applications on droplet control, such as directed motion. We will also investigate whether simple configurations like periodic variations are able to induce complex dynamics, such as random walks and collective phenomena in a multi-droplet system.

The ultimate goal of the proposed research is the systematic and predictive theoretical and computational analysis of the dynamics of droplets with dynamic size on surfaces that have controllable and experimentally amenable properties. As a consequence, the outputs of this project can be used to recommend new design rules, geometries, and operational protocols for improved droplet control and manipulation in technological applications that rely on cooling/heating processes and/or porous-based micro-devices.

Planned Impact

The ultimate goal of the proposed research is the understanding of how solid surfaces can be designed to control and manipulate droplets with dynamic size. This a key aspect in many rapidly developing technologies in the UK's biomedical, printing, and computer hardware industries, to name but a few. The systematic use of state-of-the-art theoretical and computational techniques, as proposed here, can generate valuable insight into many aspects of these systems, and particularly how they can be integrated into a wide variety of functional materials and microfluidic processes at different scales.

To stimulate interaction with industry, the PI will organise a multi-disciplinary workshop at the Open University, in Milton Keynes. This will provide a valuable platform for leading experts from academia and industry to identify promising inter-disciplinary collaborations. One of the aims of this event will be to discuss how the ideas developed in this project, along with other recent advances in the area, can be carried through to implementation in specific industrial applications. In addition to the workshop, the results of this project will be disseminated at several international conferences and through the PI's national and international collaborators.

The UK is currently world-leading in the areas of interfacial fluid mechanics, multiphase flow, and microfluidics. These communities will benefit from the training of one PDRA with an inter-disciplinary outlook that combines analytical and computational skills in fluid mechanics and statistical physics. The PDRA will also benefit from training in scientific writing, networking through attendance to conferences, project management, and public engagement. This project will further establish the UK's reputation in these areas and strengthen links with other research groups, both nationally and internationally.

The problem of droplets with a time-dependent volume interacting with solid surfaces can be used to illustrate how mathematical methods are applied to understand a variety of physical concepts, such as capillarity and wetting, stability, mass transfer, and fluid flow. To make the results of this research accessible to as wide an audience as possible and to inspire others to carry out mathematical research, the PI will promote aspects of the research programme by means of dissemination to non-academics and the general public, including: (i) Teaching-based dissemination, i.e. via incorporating research highlights into module content that is related to the proposed research, (ii) Giving public presentations to students of all levels; and (iii) Social media/outreach activities, where this research will also be featured, such as e.g. the new initiatives #HiddenMaths and #MeetUsMonday at the Open University.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Cucurull B (2022) Lacunarity transition in a chaotic dynamical system in Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical

publication icon
Ewetola M (2021) Control of droplet evaporation on smooth chemical patterns in Physical Review Fluids

publication icon
Hatipogullari M (2019) Contact angle hysteresis in a microchannel: Statics in Physical Review Fluids

publication icon
Haynes M (2022) On the lifetimes of two-dimensional droplets on smooth wetting patterns in Journal of Engineering Mathematics

publication icon
Radhakrishnan ANP (2019) Hydrodynamic Characterization of Phase Separation in Devices with Microfabricated Capillaries. in Langmuir : the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids

publication icon
Wilkinson M (2021) Flooding dynamics of diffusive dispersion in a random potential in Journal of Statistical Physics

 
Description One of the main aims to be addressed in this project is to establish how the motion of a droplet that has a time-dependent volume can be controlled by the properties of the solid surface. We have developed an analytical theory that is able to describe all the equilibrium configurations of a three-dimensional droplet resting on a solid surface with a well-defined chemical pattern. Our results show that the maximum height of the droplet will always be aligned with either: (a) a maximum, (b) a minimum, or (c) a saddle point of the chemical pattern. As the volume changes in time, the droplet will follow a sequence whereby its location will be alternating between these three different states. This also leads to an alternation of the aspect ratio of the droplet contact area, which is in agreement with experiments.

Another finding of this project has been to show how asymmetric chemical patterns are able to force the droplet to move in a preferred direction as the volume of the droplet decreases in time due to evaporation. We have established clear mechanisms for directed motion which have been fully quantified in mathematical terms.

In addition, we have developed a new approach to understand the life times of evaporating droplets. This is based on a combination of static stability analysis and a diffusion model that describes the evaporation rate of the droplet. The findings have been submitted to J. Eng. Maths and should be pubished shortly.

Another development in the project has been to do an analytical study of the bifurcation structures that arise on a droplet that is evaporating on an inclined plane. We have shown how the competition of solid patterning and gravity gives rise to an intricate dynamics of the evaporating droplet. The analytical findings have been compared to computational results using cahn-hilliard and navier-stokes equations.
Exploitation Route The findings of this award can be used to exploit droplet control on solid surfaces. Our theory shows that with well-defined surfaces properties, an evaporating droplet can follow a reproducible path along the surface that can be quantified mathematically in terms of well-knonw bifurcations. This can potentially lead to further studies of surface design/optimisation for droplet manipulation and transport.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Education,Electronics,Environment,Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description The research from this award has been used in various outreach events. In particular, the PI has designed and delivered a Royal Institution masterclass at Bletchley Park (2019), public lectures at the British Science Week (2021) and Maths Week Scotland (2021), and led the development of demonstrations of interfacial flows and chaotic motion at science festivals (Big Bang Fair 2019 and Maths Fest 2020, 2022). Part of the content of these activities was directly taken from the outputs of this award. For example, illustration of the concepts of stability, wetting and mass transfer by using evaporating droplets as a prototype system, and how stability changes (bifurcations) can lead to the emergence of chaotic motion.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Education
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Collaboration with Dr. H. Kusumaatmaja (Durham U.) 
Organisation Durham University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have started a collaboration with the theoretical/computational group led by Dr Halim Kusumaatmaja from Durham University. We have obtained analytical/asymptotic results on the shape and bifurcations of droplets sitting on surfaces with smooth properties as the volume changes by making use of thin film approximations. This is being compared with computational results done by Dr Kusumaatmaja's group.
Collaborator Contribution Computations of energy minimisation of three-dimensional droplets resting on chemical patterns. Use of the numerical methodology developed at Dr Kusumaatmaja's group.
Impact Multi-disciplinary as it involves experiments, computations and analytical methodologies.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Smart Materials & Surfaces Laboratory at Northumbria University 
Organisation Northumbria University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This project involves collaboration with the experimental group led by Gary Wells and Rodrigo Ledesma-Aguilar from Nortumbria University. We have obtained analytical/asymptotic results on the shape and bifurcations of droplets sitting on surfaces with smooth properties as the volume changes. This is being compared with experiments on droplets evaporating on slippery surfaces.
Collaborator Contribution Experiments of evaporating droplets on smooth topographies. A new experimental setup that mimicks a two-dimensional system where droplet is confined between two parallel slippery surfaces, and where the droplet volume is controlled by a pumping system.
Impact Multi-disciplinary as it involves experiments, computations and analytical methodologies.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Maths Week Scotland 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Following on the success of the RI masterclass that I delivered in 2019, I developed a public talk on chaos theory, which I gave during the Maths Week Scotland in September 2020. The audience was a mix of school students and general public and they engaged in discussions on how the mathematical modelling of chaos can be applied to study evolution of biological populations as well as weather and climate prediction.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description RI Masterclass 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Royal Institution Masterclass delivered in November 2019 at Bletchley Park. The audience was around 30 secondary school pupils. The theme of the masterclass was chaos theory and the relation with physical and biological systems, with examples taken from my research on fluid mechanics. Students engaged actively with a variety of activities to learn the mathematical concepts that are used in the modelling of dynamical systems and chaotic motion. The overall feedback was very positive with students remarking how much they enjoyed learning advanced concepts in mathematics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://mcs.open.ac.uk/RI_MasterClasses/bletchley.php