GCRF Gender and Violent Extremism Network

Lead Research Organisation: United States International University Africa
Department Name: International Relations

Abstract

This proposal will develop an open, critical and interdisciplinary network on Gender and Responding to Violent Extremism. The project is led by Dr Fatuma Ahmed, the United States International University in Kenya and Dr Sahla Aroussi, the Centre of Trust Peace and Social Relations in collaboration with Ms Pauline Skaper, the Rift Valley Institute in Nairobi. Although there is no international consensus on what constitutes violent extremism, it is acknowledged that this type of violence undermines peace and development not only at the national level but internationally. Violent extremism tends to be approached from a gender essentialist perspective, with men assumed to be perpetrators and women as victims, 'mothers' and 'wives' of recruits or potential recruits. In recent years, the role of women in the prevention of violent extremism and within extremist networks such as Al-Shabaab, the 'Islamic State' and the English Defence League has come to the spotlight particularly following the adoption of the United Nations Security Council resolutions following the adoption of 2242 on Women, Peace and Security in 2015. Yet, research and scholarship in this area remains new and a deeper engagement with gender and the role of norms around masculinities and femininities in violent extremism is still limited in scholarship and policies around terrorism and violent extremism. Hence, our Global Network on Gender and Responding to Violent Extremism (GARVE) is both timely and relevant. Around the globe, there are a number of international networks focused on violent extremism and radicalisation or on gender but there are no international networks that are specifically focused on gender and violent extremism.
Our proposal addresses primarily the Challenge Area of Human Rights, Good Governance and Social Justice but also cuts across the Challenge Area of Equitable Access to Sustainable Development. 'Violent extremism' has significant impact on women and girls' enjoyment of human rights. Because of its impact on security and stability, violent extremism undermines development efforts, and sustains aid dependency. Countries experiencing violent extremism are spending significant portion of their budget on military spending and counter-terrorism operations that could have been invested in services, infrastructure and development projects. As a result, poverty increases and deepens, and the population suffer. Violent extremism also halts development by pushing population to flee and migrate and by the damage that extremist groups do to infrastructure and institution. This project is fully aligned to the UK's international challenges and policy priorities. Tackling violent extremism, gender equality and increasing communities' resilience are all UK aid priorities. Kenya is on the DAC list of countries recipient of ODA funding.
Our network will bring together academics and practitioners from across the globe virtually and physically to discuss, exchange knowledge and expertise, theorise, identify research gaps and highlight best practices and policy failures. The network aims to attract members from diverse disciplines, to promote innovative and critical thinking on violent extremism from a gender perspective and to facilitate shared learning. By adopting an interdisciplinary approach and a multidisciplinary membership this network will allow for new perspective on gender and responding to violent extremism to emerge. Our network will ensure continuous engagement with policymakers in the UK and internationally. The activities of our network include research networking visits, engagement event, conference, roundtables, and webinars. The network deliveries are a network of academic and practitioners working on gender and violent extremism, strong partnership between members of the network, an online library of resources, a special website for the network, 2 academic edited volumes, and research funding proposals for GCRF and other funders.

Planned Impact

This proposal will develop an open, critical and interdisciplinary network on Gender and Responding to Violent Extremism. Gender is generally under-researched in scholarship on violent extremism and overlooked or misunderstood in policies and programmes aimed at its prevention. Around the globe, there are a number of international networks focused on violent extremism and radicalisation or on gender but there are no international networks that are specifically focused on gender and violent extremism. The impact strands of our network are: 1) Sharing knowledge and informing policy and practice; 2) fostering dialogue on gender and violent extremism; 3) enhancing the capacity of researchers from the Global South to apply for funding and to lead on research proposals; 4) enabling the development of new research projects on gender and violent extremism; 5) Building strong partnerships between academics and practitioners beyond the life of the project.
1) Sharing knowledge and informing policy and practice: Through maximising knowledge and evidence sharing based on the research of our network members we are aiming to influence policymakers and practitioners members to approach gender and violent extremism from a different perspective rooted in gender equality, sustainable development and good governance and respect for human rights.
2) Fostering dialogue on gender and violent extremism: our network will bring together academics and practitioners who worked with different groups and understanding of what constitute violent extremists and extremism (ultra-right; foreign fighters; Islamists; Christian rights...). The network also brings together people with different geographical expertise, different disciplinary and theoretical perspectives and areas of expertise. As such the network will foster the emergence of a powerful, timely and unique dialogue on what constitutes violent extremism, how gender operates within different forms of violent extremism and how violent extremism can be addressed from an interdisciplinary perspective.
3) Enhancing the capacity of researchers from the Global South to apply for funding and to lead on research proposals: Our network has capacity building at its core. Through the various activities discussed in the pathways for impact we are aiming to build the abilities of researchers from the Global South including early career to successfully seek funding opportunities and to collaborate on research projects. We are also aiming to support the capacity of early career researchers to publish in academic journals and edited collections.
4) Enabling the development of new research projects on gender and violent extremism: The network will provide opportunities, impetus, and ideas for new research projects on gender and violent extremism to be developed and submitted. These could potentially include GCRF Network Plus grants and other GCRF research focused grants.
5) Building strong partnerships between academics and practitioners: one of the main deliveries of this project is a large network of partners with various degrees of involvement with the network. Among this group we envisage the emergence of a strong Community of Practice to emerge naturally and informally and to continue to work together beyond the life of the project to apply for collaborative funding projects, to conduct collaborative research and to continue to share research findings and best practices. Despite the almost universal relevance of this area of interest, international collaboration in this field is extremely rare; an important aspect of what we will achieve will be fostering these relationships to allow for a greater evidence base and global understanding of gender and violent extremism.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Ahmed Ali F (2021) Black muslim women in security studies in Critical Studies on Security

 
Description The achievement of this network is that we have been able to:
1. Set up a unique platform for sharing best practice on community-based, academic and socially engaged gendered approaches to respond to violent extremism.
2. Generate significant new knowledge on gender in responses to violent extremism through various activities such as roundtables, Webinars, International conference and research collaboration.
3. Identify important research resources that have been uploaded on the Garve Website.
4. Important new research questions have opened up from the Special Issue on "Rethinking Gender in responses to Violent Extremism" to be published in the Journal of British Academy which highlighted the issues of ethics, methodology and race politics in researching violent extremism as an area for theory, practice, and future research directions.
Exploitation Route We envisage that our project outcomes will be taken forward through our website, the Network itself which has created a platform/epistemic community of practitioners, scholars and policy makers working on gender and response to violent extremism and the publication of the Special Issue on "Rethinking Gender in Responses to Violent Extremism" to be published in the Journal of British Academy as part of knowledge production.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Security and Diplomacy

URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/
 
Description Al-Shabaab's Gendered Economy 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Al-Shabaab has an interesting relationship with women, most notably when it comes to its economy. The conservative Islamist group holds deeply patriarchal views as to women's roles in society. Believing that a woman's place is at home, the group formally prohibits women from working or engaging in business - behavior they consider 'un-Islamic'. Women are subject to a strict dress code, they are prohibited from leaving their homes without a male escort and they cannot loiter outside, limiting their involvement in the public sphere.

As such it is surprising that despite its approach to gender, women form a key part of al-Shabaab's war economy. Despite its formal ban on women working, research reveals that women are actively involved in al-Shabaab's financial concerns; running businesses on behalf of the group; moving goods over the borders between al-Shabaab and government territory; and playing a leading role in the group's fundraising operations. The roles that women play are critical to the group's survival, helping al-Shabaab to fund - and therefore to sustain - its insurgency.

Work on Somalia's war economy to date has been gender-blind; unseeing of the roles that are played by women. Given how crucial al-Shabaab's financial endeavours are to its survival, if women are playing a key role, it is vital that this be better understood.

During this meeting, Dr Orly Stern presented the findings from her research, Al-Shabaab's Gendered Economy. Her research examined the apparent contradiction between the group's ideological principles and its use of women. It also assessed the ways in which the group treats different groupings of women, questioning what this tells about al-Shabaab's ideology and operations.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Forum: Women, Peace & Security and Violent Extremism 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Dr. Sahla Aroussi presented her findings from her research - Strange bedfellows: Women, Peace and Security and Countering Violent Extremism in Kenya. The study examines the impact of linking WPS with countering violent extremism on the ground in Kenya. Dr. Aroussi argues that connecting Women Peace and Security agenda with violent extremism has had several damaging consequences for women and their communities. She finds that this new approach has precipitated the redirection of donor funding away from important gender initiatives and towards countering violent extremism, resulting in women's additional stigmatisation, insecurity and exclusion.
The purpose for this discussion was to bring the research findings to a wider audience who are dealing with violent extremism, women, peace and security and to interrogate globally the impact of interlinking these two distinct areas. It also offered a space for comparative analysis on findings from other regions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/episode-2-women-peace-security-and-violent-extremism/
 
Description GARVE Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The website is a space to showcase what the network is producing and engaging in; offer a platform for interaction with various stakeholders; offer a repository for members publications and upcoming events + workshops. The main aim of the project is to bring together a network of academics, practitioners and policy makers to deepen and broaden the understanding of gender and violent extremism from an international perspective. The website is able to draw a variety of actors to interact and exchange ideas and knowledge from their various regional or country perspectives.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL http://www.garve-network.org
 
Description International conference on gender and responding to violent extremism 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact GARVE Network's inaugural conference aimed to explore how attention to gender in P/CVE research and policies has impacted first on responses to violent extremism and second on the women's rights agenda and local communities over the last few years.

Topics explored and discussed in the 2 day conference include:
*women as perpetrators of violence
*CVE, democracy and Human Rights
*Gender, CVE and Afghanistan
*Gender in PCVE policies
*Masculinities & VE
*Race politics, power and ethics in researching VE
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/international-conference-on-gender-and-responding-to-violent-extr...
 
Description Preventing/Countering Violent Extremism and Gender Program and Projects Mapping 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The activity was to carry out a research mapping exercise and to produce a report/document on funding for P/CVE and gender. Questions that the research mapping exercise covered included: What is being funded;What types of projects are they; Is gender taken into consideration; Who are the main funders and where is the funding targeted at in terms of region + recipient countries?
? Mapping also included: Tracing projects funded in the P/CVE and gender space by mapping which projects were funded, by whom (funders) and where (locations that is where the projects is based); Identifying the general profile (for example building resilience of communities at risk), of the projects funded, project implementers (CSOs, NGOs, CBOs, government agencies, research institutions/think tanks/universities, regional organisations etc.) and their focus (whether they were regional, international or national based); Outlining the specific issues and population/target for P/CVE funding. o Providing a list of UN-funded P/CVE and gender projects; Documenting the impact/achievements, challenges, gaps and emerging trends of P/CVE and gender funding.

The purpose of the mapping was to find out who was funding what kind of activity in the region; who was being funded and for how long. This would make it clearer on the areas that had little or no focus and identify research gaps as well. It was also to identify possible areas of partnership, collaboration and linkage between different actors.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
 
Description Roundtable: An Overview of far-right violent extremism and how women are involved 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact This talk provides an overview of far-right violent extremism globally, with particular attention to its growth in the United States and Europe. It will explain its various forms over time and across nations, as well as its ideology, means of communication and networks, strategies and goals, and the spaces through which it seeks to recruit new adherents and motivate supporters to enact violent and terroristic actions. It also focuses on the changing role of women in far-right extremism and far-right terroristic violence.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/episode-5-overview-of-far-right-violent-extremism-and-women/
 
Description Roundtable: Gender & Responding to Violent Extremism 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact This forum explored gender and violent extremism from two perspectives. Judith Gardner presented findings for discussion from the study of Somali women and girls experiences of Al Shaabab. David Duriesmith presented on the growth of interest in masculinities and violence extremism drawing on lessons he collaborated with Noor Huda Ismail on disengagement in South East Asia.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/episode-3-qna-gender-responding-violent-extremism/
 
Description Roundtable: Gender, Violent Extremism & Human Rights 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact This forum looked at the intersectionality of gender, violent extremism and human rights. Prof. Fionnuala Ni Aolain, the UN Special Rapporteur for the Protection and Promotion of Human Rights while countering Terrorism, presented her report - on the human rights impact of policies and practices aimed at preventing and countering violent extremism.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/episode-4-gender-violent-extremism-human-rights/
 
Description Roundtable: Introduction to the GARVE Network by Dr. Fatuma Ahmed Ali. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Dr. Fatuma Ahmed Ali, the Principal Investigator of the GARVE project, introduced the project and network to the public. Marc Sommers presented his latest book - Trust-Based, Qualitative Field Methods: A Manual for Researchers of Violent Extremism, which is a practical guide to conducting high-quality, trust-based, qualitative field research on violent extremism. Marc Sommers is an internationally recognised youth, peace building and conflict expert. An Africanist and anthropologist, he also has expertise on gender, CVE, governance, education, social inclusion, urbanisation, refugee and development issues. Dr. Sommers served for several years as Senior Conflict Advisor for the State Department, where he focused on peace building efforts in Africa. He also worked as Senior Research Advisor for the IGAD Centre of Excellence for Preventing and Countering Violent Extremism in Djibouti (seconded by the State Dept). He is also a member of the UN Advisory Group of Experts for the Progress Study on Youth, Peace and Security.
This roundtable introduced the GARVE network, it's partners, objectives and focus of the network. The roundtable generated discussions on research in this sensitive area including research ethics; how to protect those participating in research especially the local community; how to include other stakeholders especially security actors without risking the local population and how to discern information being received. The audience had various regional research institutions and independent researchers who shared their research methodologies and compared it to what was being presented including community members (represented by 2 community leaders) who discussed how various research had impacted on their communities including interaction with the security sector.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://garve-network.org/podcasts/episode-1-introduction-to-garve/