From Ultrastructure to Micromechanics: a New Perspective on Cartilage Function, Mechanotransduction and Ageing

Lead Research Organisation: University of Exeter
Department Name: Engineering

Abstract

The UK is projected to become a hyper-aged society in 2030 with 36% of its population over 55. The early diagnosis and treatment for tissue degeneration are one of the most pressing challenges in healthcare. Osteoarthritis is a form of cartilage degeneration and the most common musculoskeletal disorder. It is affecting nearly one third of adults over 45 years old and causing more than £850 million direct cost in NHS, plus £3.2 billion indirect cost for downtime and community care. By targeting the cartilage, this project will establish a fundamental link between highly sensitive structural biomarkers in tissue degeneration and biomechanical functionality, therefore providing the possibility of identifying new targets for early diagnosis and novel therapies. This will be achieved by combining 1) advanced imaging technique for the subtle structural changes in the cartilage, 2) micromechanical loading to visualise the structural responses under different cartilage conditions, and 3) numerical simulation for analysing the integrity of tissues and the mechanobiological communication of cells at different ages. The outcomes of this project will provide experimental and simulational evidence to inform the clinical translation of the imaging technique for early diagnosis of osteoarthritis, allow quantitative evaluation of the treatment effectiveness of anti-osteoarthritis drugs, and facilitate the development of novel cellular and regenerative therapies. The approach established in this project will lead to a new toolkit of studying biomechanics-centred dysfunctions in a wide range of tissues.

Planned Impact

The UK is fast approaching a hyper-aged social structure, and tissue degeneration is inevitable in the ageing population. Early diagnosis and precision treatment for degeneration are two of the most pressing challenges in healthcare (Industrial Strategy Challenge Fund Wave 3), and it is critical to understand the initiation and progression of this process. This project will establish a fundamental link between highly sensitive structural biomarkers in cartilage degeneration and its biomechanical functionality. Such a link allows the identification of the compromised biomechanical functionality in cartilage induced by early and subtle changes in its ultrastructure, thereby facilitating the clinical diagnosis and development of novel therapies. This project targets articular cartilage in ageing, for its relatively simple structure and severe social and economic impact. As the most common form of cartilage degeneration, osteoarthritis (OA) affects more than 8.75 million people in the UK, and it has the largest patient cohort in all musculoskeletal disorders (Arthritis Research UK, Osteoarthritis in General Practice 2014). Total knee arthroplasty is currently the only solution for its end stage, costing the NHS more than £850 million in 2010, plus £3.2 billion indirect costs (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, Osteoarthritis 2014).

The project outcomes will have significant impacts on three industries, not only providing the scientific insights but also demonstrating the benefits from the advanced imaging technique, micromechanical characterisation and computational simulation framework. It will impact clinical practice by contributing to the quantitative definition and diagnosis of early OA and predictive prognosis of disease progression. It will impact biomedical device companies (e.g. Siemens) by integrating the fundamental knowledge into the development of the diagnostic hardware and the longitudinal monitoring system for diseases and treatments. It will impact the pharmaceutical companies by revealing new targets for anti-OA drug development and providing biomimetic templates for 3D-printed constructs in cellular therapies. The impacts are expected to continue with our current collaborative partners, including Stryker, and new parties to perform proof-of-principle demonstration and trials in future.

Thus, the pathways to impact can be summarised as:
- Publications in high-impact journals of international readership, and presentation of results in prestigious international conferences;
- Visiting the collaborating hospitals and biomedical companies to ensure timely dissemination of the project outcomes and advancements and fostering knowledge transfer partnerships;
- Presenting results in industry conferences, and directly interacting with industrial researchers sharing an interest in developing diagnosis and treatment for OA to maximise their awareness of such advanced framework and knowledge;
- Organising an international symposium under the ImagingBioPro Network to bring together specialists from academia, clinics and industries, to directly deliver impact for these beneficiaries;
- Maximising the impact of this project for wider communities via a dedicated project webpage hosted by the University of Exeter and through multiple social media, to raise the public awareness of the project and its contribution to healthcare;
- Visiting local secondary schools to host an Engineering and Science Day for students and teachers, inspiring and motivating them into the Healthcare discipline by showcasing the research and impact;
- Training a postdoctoral research associate and two PhD students in the emerging field of biomedical engineering, and introducing research-oriented education in both undergraduate and postgraduate courses to promote career interests in this field.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The key findings include
-a revised experimental approach in studying cartilage ultrastructure and mechanics
-a new framework in quantifying the structure variation in cartilage
-new biomarkers identified under the influence of ageing
-a new framework of integrating image-derived features into computational simulation
-a new correlation between the structure parameter and the mechanical properties in cartilage
Exploitation Route Academic output
-the new knowledge on the cartilage structure and its role in mechanics
-a new tool in combining image and simulation to study various physiological, pathological, and therapeutic conditions

Non-academic output
-evidence to support the development of new endoscopic techniques and instruments
-new biomarkers to consider in clinical diagnosis
-new criteria in evaluating new drugs and therapies
Sectors Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description Exeter Biomaterials Optical Characterisation Suite - EBOC
Amount £632,086 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/V034251/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2020 
End 05/2022
 
Title A bi-phasic fibre-reinforced poroelastic model of cartilages incorporated with polarised Second Harmonic Generation microscopy 
Description A Finite Element (FE) method using a newly developed material model was developed to help investigating the constitutive-specific material properties. The materials model composed of a poro-hyperelastic non-fibrillar matrix and an elastic fibrillar matrix, representing the extracellular matrix(ECM) and the collagen respectively. In the ECM, the interaction of proteoglycan and the interstitial fluid was simulated based on the theory of Soil Consolidation. While in the fibrillar matrix, the heterogeneous distributions of the local fibrillar orientation were incorporated by mapping the polarised Second Harmonic Generation (pSHG) microscopy images which provided the pixel-based fibrillar orientation information, in a pixel to element manner. In addition, the effects of the osmotic pressure due to the imbalance ion concentration, were simulated referring to the Donnan swelling pressure gradient. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The adaptation of this new mechanical model can lead to more reliable and precised simulation on a local-specific mechanical behaviour in the articular cartilage, in the scale of either the tissue or cellular level. With current mechanical model, the heterogeneous distributed fibrillar orientation were able to be taken into account during the mechanical simulation, especially when some cartilage regions where the fibrillar network orientated randomly were being investigated. In addition, sensitivity analysis of the influences of fibrillar networks structure on the site-specific mechanical behaviour, such as the region where chondrocyte located, could be performed by adopting the presented model, which would help us to better understand the relation of the ultrastructure and the micro-mechanics. 
 
Description Early Diagnosis of Osteoarthritis 
Organisation Tokyo Medical and Dental University
Country Japan 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The imaging platform and protocol established by my research group are applied to assessing post-traumatic osteoarthritis and monitoring its progression in mouse models.
Collaborator Contribution The research team at TMDU is linking the epigenetics and molecular mechanics to the structural observations made in Exeter.
Impact Two seminars to be held later in 2023
Start Year 2023
 
Description From Ultrastructure to Functionality: a New Paradigm on Cartilage Repair and Regeneration 
Organisation Cardiff University
Department School of Dentistry
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Our imaging platform provides polarisation-dependent second harmonic generation microscopy to examine the hierarchical organisation of collagen fibril at a few hundred nanometres and intrafibrillar organisation at the molecular scale. This technique allows examining both micro- and ultrastructural parameters of the cartilage, which were found highly sensitive to mechanical loading.
Collaborator Contribution We have developed a novel proprietary human 3D cartilage model utilising chondrocyte progenitor cells isolated from mature human articular cartilage to reproducibly generate cartilage discs that display structural properties similar to human cartilage (stratification into zones, matrix composition & biomechanical integrity). Through mechanical stimulation/activation of inflammatory pathways relevant to osteoarthritis, we were able to initiate an osteoarthritis-like state in our cartilage model, which mimics the tissue damage and glycosaminoglycan loss occurring in human osteoarthritis.
Impact The preliminary data and the proof-of-the-concept evidence from this collaboration have led to a successful PhD studentship application at the University of Exeter. This multidisciplinary collaboration involves biochemistry, biophotonics, biomechanics, and computational simulation.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Osteoarthritis induced changed in cartilage ulstrastructure and biomechanical properties 
Organisation Princess Elizabeth Orthopaedic Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution Our research team has established an imaging platform and provided the proof-of-concept data on animal specimens, to continue the investigation on human specimens.
Collaborator Contribution The surgeon team at POEC will be organising and collecting human cartilage specimens from total knee replacement operations. The surgeons will provide patient data to support the research. They will participate in our research seminars and organise seminars at the hospital to disseminate the outcomes.
Impact The collaboration is just being established, and several events including seminars are scheduled. The collaboration arises from a range of multidisciplinary expertise, inlcuding experimental biophysics, computational biomechanics, and orthopaedics.
Start Year 2022