Controllable model membranes and new quantitative analyses to interrogate light harvesting proteins
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Leeds
Department Name: Physics and Astronomy
Abstract
This proposal will develop new model systems and analysis methods to quantify the biophysical properties of important Light Harvesting (LH) proteins with high spatiotemporal resolution. This will provide insight into the physical basis of photosynthetic processes which are crucial for life on Earth but poorly understood. It will also have wider relevance for the potential use of LH proteins in nanotechnology, photonics and plasmonics. We need to develop a suite of "model membranes" (idealized experimental models of biomembranes) which incorporate LH proteins and offer a balance between complexity, controllability and amenability to tools that can quantify structure and optical properties. We need the ability to manipulate the density of LH proteins within these model membranes. We need to quantify how the organization and optical properties of these LH proteins change in response to important physicochemical stimuli. The proposed project will develop three types of model membranes for studying LH proteins, which progress from mostly synthetic to close-to-natural membranes. These "model membranes" will be manipulated by applying external electric fields to direct the migration of LH proteins within membranes, for the first time. The nanoscale organization and photophysical properties of these LH proteins will be compared in each type of membrane by an advanced microscopy and spectroscopy combined system.
My previous research has demonstrated that the clustering of LH proteins is correlated to energy dissipation (fluorescence quenching) and my expertise with correlative microscopy and spectroscopy tools make me uniquely well-placed for performing quantitative studies of energy transfer processes. In Leeds, we have a new Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscope combined with Atomic Force Microscopy (FLIM+AFM) instrument which will allow unprecedented direct correlation and quantification of optical properties and nanoscale organization (I was co-investigator on the grant acquiring this instrument). This combined microscope is ideal to study LH proteins and gives us a competitive edge. In summary, this project will provide a comparative analysis of the advantages and limitations of new membrane models and, in doing so, quantify the crucial relationship between organization and optical properties of light harvesting proteins. These new models could be applied to bacterial and mammalian membranes of relevance for health and agriculture. Furthermore, knowledge of the important LHCII protein could be relevant for the development of alternative solar nanotechnologies or the production of enhanced crops.
My previous research has demonstrated that the clustering of LH proteins is correlated to energy dissipation (fluorescence quenching) and my expertise with correlative microscopy and spectroscopy tools make me uniquely well-placed for performing quantitative studies of energy transfer processes. In Leeds, we have a new Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscope combined with Atomic Force Microscopy (FLIM+AFM) instrument which will allow unprecedented direct correlation and quantification of optical properties and nanoscale organization (I was co-investigator on the grant acquiring this instrument). This combined microscope is ideal to study LH proteins and gives us a competitive edge. In summary, this project will provide a comparative analysis of the advantages and limitations of new membrane models and, in doing so, quantify the crucial relationship between organization and optical properties of light harvesting proteins. These new models could be applied to bacterial and mammalian membranes of relevance for health and agriculture. Furthermore, knowledge of the important LHCII protein could be relevant for the development of alternative solar nanotechnologies or the production of enhanced crops.
Planned Impact
Who might benefit? Potential economic and societal beneficiaries:
1. New industrial and academic users of our membrane formation methodology and analyses.
2. The scientific microscope technology industry.
3. The alternative solar technology industry.
4. The general public (from increased engagement and understanding and industry).
Beneficiaries #1, #2 and #4 are quite reachable during the 3 year project, whereas #3 is an exciting long-term possibility which will be better defined as we engage with this community.
How might they benefit?:
1. Researchers in academia or industry may use our methodology and benefit from having a more effective method to form and manipulate models of biomembranes and improved analysis routines to gain more quantitative information. For example, once success is demonstrated on naturally-fluorescent LHCII, where its function is easily probed throughout, these approaches could be used to study other membrane systems, i.e., alternative proteins and lipids. The three types of model membrane developed by this research grant (Objectives 1-3) would allow researchers to study the mobility and interactions of other fluorescently-tagged membrane proteins within membranes, manipulating them via electrophoresis, if desired. Use of our analysis routines applying FLIM would allow researchers to quantify protein-protein interactions (e.g. FLIM-based FRET to measure average distances between two proteins). This could lead to future industrial and economic benefit as medically-important membrane proteins are some of the most actively researched.
2. Microscope technology developers and their customers would benefit from the new microscopy sample holder designs (i.e. flow-chambers) which will be developed during this grant which allow combined electrophoresis and microscopy (see section 1.2 in the Case for Support). This could be a new commercialization opportunity. These sample holders would be straightforward to manufacture based on the 3-D CAD specification which would be produced. This would allow other researchers who already have access to AFM or fluorescence microscopes (10,000s globally) the ability to visualize the effect of electric field on their own samples with the use of a simple accessory. For example, this would allow other researchers the ability to easily perform electrophoresis as a separation technique or method to cluster their membrane proteins of interest.
3. The alternative solar technology industry would benefit from the potential that our research could lead to increases in the efficiency of their products. Understanding the biophysics of light harvesting proteins could guide the future exploitation of LH proteins in nanotechnologies, for example, understanding which protein geometries, densities and linkage chemistry promote the effective transfer of energy and/or electrons to conducting solid surfaces. This could assist the field of biophotovoltaics and future development of improved photoeletrochemical devices where LH proteins may be attached to electrodes. Alternatively, an improved understanding of light-harvesting proteins may lead to "bio-inspired" solutions, whereby biological components are not used directly, but instead lead to the construction of new inorganic materials following the design motifs and strategies of the highly efficient biological systems.
4. Adults with an interest in science in the UK and children in local schools will benefit culturally and educationally from our planned public engagement events. We will aim to inspire, increase curiosity and improve understanding of those who attend. The public discourse would be more informed if more members of the public have an increased recognition of the scientific challenges and related environmental issues in solar energy research. This could feed into important debates over sustainability and the economics of alternative energy and challenge conventional wisdom.
1. New industrial and academic users of our membrane formation methodology and analyses.
2. The scientific microscope technology industry.
3. The alternative solar technology industry.
4. The general public (from increased engagement and understanding and industry).
Beneficiaries #1, #2 and #4 are quite reachable during the 3 year project, whereas #3 is an exciting long-term possibility which will be better defined as we engage with this community.
How might they benefit?:
1. Researchers in academia or industry may use our methodology and benefit from having a more effective method to form and manipulate models of biomembranes and improved analysis routines to gain more quantitative information. For example, once success is demonstrated on naturally-fluorescent LHCII, where its function is easily probed throughout, these approaches could be used to study other membrane systems, i.e., alternative proteins and lipids. The three types of model membrane developed by this research grant (Objectives 1-3) would allow researchers to study the mobility and interactions of other fluorescently-tagged membrane proteins within membranes, manipulating them via electrophoresis, if desired. Use of our analysis routines applying FLIM would allow researchers to quantify protein-protein interactions (e.g. FLIM-based FRET to measure average distances between two proteins). This could lead to future industrial and economic benefit as medically-important membrane proteins are some of the most actively researched.
2. Microscope technology developers and their customers would benefit from the new microscopy sample holder designs (i.e. flow-chambers) which will be developed during this grant which allow combined electrophoresis and microscopy (see section 1.2 in the Case for Support). This could be a new commercialization opportunity. These sample holders would be straightforward to manufacture based on the 3-D CAD specification which would be produced. This would allow other researchers who already have access to AFM or fluorescence microscopes (10,000s globally) the ability to visualize the effect of electric field on their own samples with the use of a simple accessory. For example, this would allow other researchers the ability to easily perform electrophoresis as a separation technique or method to cluster their membrane proteins of interest.
3. The alternative solar technology industry would benefit from the potential that our research could lead to increases in the efficiency of their products. Understanding the biophysics of light harvesting proteins could guide the future exploitation of LH proteins in nanotechnologies, for example, understanding which protein geometries, densities and linkage chemistry promote the effective transfer of energy and/or electrons to conducting solid surfaces. This could assist the field of biophotovoltaics and future development of improved photoeletrochemical devices where LH proteins may be attached to electrodes. Alternatively, an improved understanding of light-harvesting proteins may lead to "bio-inspired" solutions, whereby biological components are not used directly, but instead lead to the construction of new inorganic materials following the design motifs and strategies of the highly efficient biological systems.
4. Adults with an interest in science in the UK and children in local schools will benefit culturally and educationally from our planned public engagement events. We will aim to inspire, increase curiosity and improve understanding of those who attend. The public discourse would be more informed if more members of the public have an increased recognition of the scientific challenges and related environmental issues in solar energy research. This could feed into important debates over sustainability and the economics of alternative energy and challenge conventional wisdom.
People |
ORCID iD |
| Peter Adams (Principal Investigator) |
Publications
Hancock AM
(2022)
Enhancing the spectral range of plant and bacterial light-harvesting pigment-protein complexes with various synthetic chromophores incorporated into lipid vesicles.
in Journal of photochemistry and photobiology. B, Biology
Hancock AM
(2021)
Ultrafast energy transfer between lipid-linked chromophores and plant light-harvesting complex II.
in Physical chemistry chemical physics : PCCP
Kondo M
(2025)
Photocurrent Generation by Plant Light-Harvesting Complexes is Enhanced by Lipid-Linked Chromophores in a Self-Assembled Lipid Membrane.
in The journal of physical chemistry. B
Meredith SA
(2024)
Evidence for a transfer-to-trap mechanism of fluorophore concentration quenching in lipid bilayers.
in Biophysical journal
Meredith SA
(2023)
Self-Quenching Behavior of a Fluorescent Probe Incorporated within Lipid Membranes Explored Using Electrophoresis and Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy.
in The journal of physical chemistry. B
Meredith SA
(2021)
Model Lipid Membranes Assembled from Natural Plant Thylakoids into 2D Microarray Patterns as a Platform to Assess the Organization and Photophysics of Light-Harvesting Proteins.
in Small (Weinheim an der Bergstrasse, Germany)
| Description | This project developed several different artificial models of biomembranes that contain light-harvesting (LH) proteins. We developed the supported membrane platform containing the plant protein Light-Harvesting Complex II (LHCII) and applied electrophoresis to induce the migration of these proteins, as planned in the grant (objective 1). We can quantify the relationship between the LHCII protein's concentration and it's level of quenching - a manuscript will soon be prepared from this data. In developing this method, we published one paper on a simpler system of model comprised of lipids and small fluorescent probe molecules as a precursor to studying the LHCII protein - "Self-Quenching Behavior of a Fluorescent Probe Incorporated within Lipid Membranes Explored Using Electrophoresis and Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy". This paper proved that electrophoresis is effective at producing microscale concentration gradients of a molecule-of-interest and that FLIM is an excellent approach to interrogate dynamic changes to molecular interactions via their photophysical state. We also generated "hybrid membranes" that combine natural plant membranes with synthetic lipid vesicles, as planned (objective 3). We published one paper on the development of this model system and characterization with advanced microscopy techniques - "Model Lipid Membranes Assembled from Natural Plant Thylakoids into 2D Microarray Patterns as a Platform to Assess the Organization and Photophysics of Light-Harvesting Proteins". This publication is significant for revealing the distinct advantages of these hybrid membranes when compared to native thylakoids or other model systems as a platform to study the fundamentals of photosynthesis. This worked better than expected therefore we took the decision not work on tethered membrane vesicles as in the original plan (objective 2). Related to this grant, we developed membrane systems where the spectral range of the LH proteins were increased - meaning that there is a greater potential for the system for absorbing a greater fraction of the Sun's energy. One publication showed the flexibility of this approach, (1) "Enhancing the spectral range of plant and bacterial light-harvesting pigment-protein complexes with various synthetic chromophores incorporated into lipid vesicles" - and another paper quantified the timescale of energy transfer from the synthetic chromophores to the LH protein - (2) "Ultrafast energy transfer between lipid-linked chromophores and plant light-harvesting complex II". Overall, these additional studies add great value beyond the original objectives of the project. |
| Exploitation Route | The new method that has been developed may be used by other researchers who study membrane proteins and how the clustering of these proteins affects their function. This could include other photosynthetic proteins or alternatively it could include medically-important proteins. The method of using electrophoresis to control the movement of membrane proteins is applicable to any membrane protein. The analysis protocol of using fluorescence lifetime imaging to assess protein-protein interactions could be applied to any protein that is fluorescently tagged. There are thousand of proteins which oligomerize during their normal functioning, therefore, there is great potential for applying this method to other challenges in bioscience. |
| Sectors | Energy Environment |
| Description | Understanding the role of carotenoids in bacterial light-harvesting proteins |
| Amount | £464,980 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | BB/W004593/1 |
| Organisation | Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 07/2022 |
| End | 01/2025 |
| Title | Analysis of fluroescence concentration quenching by in-membrane electrophoresis and fluorescence lifetime imaging |
| Description | A phenomenon called "fluorescence quenching" occurs when fluorescent probes are present at high concentrations but the mechanisms for quenching are debated and it is difficult to quantify the extent of quenching. We developed a novel method to quantify the amount of fluroescence quenching that is caused by the self-assoication of fluorescent probes. This uses "in-membrane electrophoresis" to generate concentration gradients of fluorophores within a supported lipid bilayer and the amount of quenching is quantified using fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy. This is significant for the many thousands of researchers around the world that use fluorescent probes for bioimaging and assays because our findings highlight that these fluorescent probes must either be used at low concentrations or quenching effects must considered (and corrected for) if concentrations are high. This was first reported in the publication found at this DOI - https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcb.2c07652 |
| Type Of Material | Improvements to research infrastructure |
| Year Produced | 2023 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | One publication and one further in preparation. |
| URL | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcb.2c07652 |
| Title | Dataset for the Study of Evidence for a Transfer-To-Trap Mechanism of Fluorophore Concentration Quenching in Lipid Bilayers |
| Description | This dataset shows the raw data, analysed data and documentation related to figures and tables from the study "Evidence for a transfer-to-trap mechanism of fluorophore concentration quenching in lipid bilayers". This includes: fluorescence microscopy images; fluorescence decay histograms; other graphical analyses; tabulated numerical data. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | Supported the publication "Evidence for a transfer-to-trap mechanism of fluorophore concentration quenching in lipid bilayers" |
| URL | https://archive.researchdata.leeds.ac.uk/1313/ |
| Title | Dataset for the study of "Model Lipid Membranes Assembled from Natural Plant Thylakoids into 2D Microarray Patterns as a Platform to Assess the Organization and Photophysics of Light-Harvesting Proteins" |
| Description | This dataset shows the raw data, analysed data and documentation related to figures and tables from the study "Model Lipid Membranes Assembled from Natural Plant Thylakoids into 2D Microarray Patterns as a Platform to Assess the Organization and Photophysics of Light-Harvesting Proteins". This includes: absorbance and fluorescence spectra; images from Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy (FLIM); images from Atomic Force Microscopy measurements; epifluorescence measurements; analysis of fluorescence data (FLIM); other graphical analyses; tabulated numerical data. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2021 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | Publication in the journal Small that makes use of this data (DOI - 10.1002/smll.202006608) |
| URL | http://archive.researchdata.leeds.ac.uk/824/ |
| Title | Dataset for the study of Enhancing the spectral range of plant and bacterial Light-Harvesting pigment-protein complexes with various synthetic chromophores incorporated into lipid vesicles |
| Description | The Light-Harvesting (LH) pigment-protein complexes found in photosynthetic organisms have the role of absorbing solar energy with high efficiency and transferring it to reaction centre complexes. LH complexes contain a suite of pigments that each absorb light at specific wavelengths, however, the natural combinations of pigments within any one protein complex do not cover the full range of solar radiation. Here, we provide an in-depth comparison of the relative effectiveness of five different organic "dye" molecules (Texas Red, ATTO, Cy7, Dil, DiR) for enhancing the absorption range of two different LH membrane protein complexes (the major LHCII from plants and LH2 from purple phototrophic bacteria). Proteoliposomes were self-assembled from defined mixtures of lipids, proteins and dye molecules and their optical properties were quantified by absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy. Both lipid-linked dyes and alternative lipophilic dyes were found to be effective excitation energy donors to LH protein complexes, without the need for direct chemical or generic modification of the proteins. The Förster theory parameters (e.g., spectral overlap) were compared between each donor-acceptor combination and found to be good predictors of an effective dye-protein combination. At the highest dye-to-protein ratios tested (over 20:1), the effective absorption strength integrated over the full spectral range was increased to ~180% of its natural level for both LH complexes. Lipophilic dyes could be inserted into pre-formed membranes although their effectiveness was found to depend upon favourable physicochemical interactions. Finally, we demonstrated that these dyes can also be effective at increasing the spectral range of surface-supported models of photosynthetic membranes, using fluorescence microscopy. The results of this work provide insight into the utility of self-assembled lipid membranes and the great flexibility of LH complexes for interacting with different dyes. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2022 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | This dataset allows others ti use our spectrscopy and micsropy data for future projects. |
| URL | https://archive.researchdata.leeds.ac.uk/1043/ |
| Title | Dataset for the study of Photocurrent generation by plant light-harvesting complexes is enhanced by lipid-linked chromophores in a self-assembled lipid membrane |
| Description | This dataset shows the raw data, analysed data and documentation related to figures and tables from the study "Photocurrent generation by plant light-harvesting complexes is enhanced by lipid-linked chromophores in a self-assembled lipid membrane". This includes: absorbance spectra, fluorescence decay curves and spectra, analysis of fitting of fluorescence spectroscopy data, photocurrent data, action spetcra. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2025 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | This dataset is a resource that could inform the design of future bio-photovoltaic devices. It supported the publication "Photocurrent generation by plant light-harvesting complexes is enhanced by lipid-linked chromophores in a self-assembled lipid membrane". |
| URL | https://archive.researchdata.leeds.ac.uk/1364/ |
| Title | Dataset for the study of Self-quenching behaviour of a fluorescent probe incorporated within lipid membranes explored using electrophoresis and fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy |
| Description | This dataset shows the raw data, analysed data and documentation related to figures and tables from the study "Self-quenching behaviour of a fluorescent probes incorporated within lipid membranes explored using electrophoresis and fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy". This includes: fluorescence decay curves and spectra; fluorescence microscopy images; analysis of fitting of fluorescence spectroscopy data (FLIM); associated calculations. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2023 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | This dataset is now a resource that can be used by other researchers who want to see example spectra and microscopy images that relate to our new method for quantifying fluorescence concentration quenching. |
| URL | https://archive.researchdata.leeds.ac.uk/1071/ |
| Title | Dataset for the study of Ultrafast energy transfer between lipid-linked chromophores and plant Light-Harvesting Complex II |
| Description | This dataset shows the raw data, analysed data and documentation related to figures and tables from the study "Ultrafast energy transfer between lipid-linked chromophores and plant Light-Harvesting Complex II". This includes: absorbance and fluorescence spectra; molecular dynamics images and associated files; calculations of excitation energy transfer; other graphical analyses; tabulated numerical data. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2021 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | Publication in the journal PCCP (DOI - 10.1039/D1CP01628H). |
| URL | https://archive.researchdata.leeds.ac.uk/885/ |
| Description | Collaboration between Morigaki group in Kobe and Adams-Evans groups in Leeds |
| Organisation | Kobe University |
| Country | Japan |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Securing funding from Royal Society with collaborator Dr Kenichi Morigaki (Univ Kobe) - IEC\R3\183029 - International Exchanges 2018 Cost Share (Japan). Performing research to characterize samples sent from Japan to Leeds: optical spectroscopy and microscopy, atomic force microscopy. Generating new and improved samples in Leeds. Transfer of knowledge and expertise to Kobe. Hosted our collaborators in Leeds for one research visit of and undertaken one research visit to Japan. More planned. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Collaborator is Dr Kenichi Morigaki (Univ Kobe). Jointly securing funding from Royal Society - IEC\R3\183029 - International Exchanges 2018 Cost Share (Japan). Preparing samples in Kobe to send to Leeds. Transfer of knowledge and expertise to Leeds. Reciprocal visits. |
| Impact | Completion of one study that was published in 2021: "Model Lipid Membranes Assembled from Natural Plant Thylakoids into 2D Microarray Patterns as a Platform to Assess the Organization and Photophysics of Light-Harvesting Proteins" (DOI - 10.1002/smll.202006608). Multi-disciplinary between chemistry, biology and physics. |
| Start Year | 2019 |
| Description | Collaboration between Schlau-Cohen group in MIT and Adams group in Leeds |
| Organisation | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Country | United States |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Preparation and analysis of biological samples and shipping these to our collaborators at MIT. Data analysis and discussions. Securing seed funding from our University for travel for our initial visit to Boston. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Performing ultrafast spectroscopy experiments on samples generated in Leeds. Data analysis and discussions. |
| Impact | Completion of one study that was published in 2021: "Ultrafast energy transfer between lipid-linked chromophores and plant light-harvesting complex II" (DOI - 10.1039/D1CP01628H). Multi-disciplinary between chemistry, biology and physics. |
| Start Year | 2019 |
| Description | Be Curious 2022 (Leeds) |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | Regional |
| Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
| Results and Impact | The University of Leeds opened its doors to the general public for a day of free, fun activities desgned to be suitable for all the family. Our group ran 1 of 35 stalls at this event called "Solar-powered racing cars: taking inspiration from plants and physics". Our activity was an interactive exhibit where children and adults used small solar-powered cars to race against each other on a track. They were able to use a torch to shine light at a solar panel to actiate the wheels of the model car! We explained about the basics of sunlight and tried to enthuse our audience about some of the solar-energy research that is done at University of Leeds. Over the course of the day we engaged with many hundred of parents and their children and young adults - estimated as 200 people. The entire event reached approx. 1200 people. This event was coordinated by the brilliant Public Engagement Team at Unviersity of Leeds - special thanks to Dr Alexa Ruppertsberg, Shauni Sanderson and Andy Guy. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://youtu.be/C1rbgBfg7-g |