Catalysing 3 routes to C-H Borylation using Earth-abundant Metals
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Chemistry
Abstract
The ability to construct rapidly new molecular architectures is essential across multiple fields. For example, pharmaceutical development requires a library of building blocks to maximise diversity at the early stage of drug discovery. Likewise, materials science is built on the ability to polymerise new building blocks with functional potential. Aryl boronic acids and esters satisfy this need and are some of the most commonly used building blocks. They are air-stable and easy to manipulate with many well-established routes for functionalisation. However, the current routes to form aryl boronic esters rely on inefficient chemistry that is over 50 years old or require the use of toxic and scarce (thus unsustainable and expensive) precious metal catalysts. This proposal seeks to replace these technologies with new methods using Earth-abundant aluminium- and zinc-complexes. More specifically, we will use aluminium and zinc based catalysts to achieve the direct (one step from simple precursors) borylation of simple (early stage) and complex (late stage) molecules.
The use of catalysis is essential in ensuring the sustainability of processes as this minimises the energy input requirements and amount of material needed for each transformation. Catalysis offers the single most applicable method to ensure a sustainable future for chemical synthesis and the use of Earth-abundant metals for catalysis greatly improves this prospect. The use of aluminium and zinc is also driven by their low-toxicity relative to many other catalysts used in direct borylation (e.g. Co, Ir based catalysts). Zinc and aluminium have high daily permitted exposure limits enabling their use late in pharmaceutical manufacturing without the need for exhaustive metal removal required when using precious metal catalysts.
This project will specifically target the borylation of arene C-H bonds. Arenes are commodity chemicals with great structural diversity, but they lack handles for further functionalisation. We will develop aluminium- and zinc catalysts capable of introducing a boronic functional handle to these substrates. Aluminium and zinc benefit from many similar properties including, size, substrate (arene) affinity, electronegativity and, to some extent, coordination preferences, but they differ based on their charge (valency) in compounds (+3 Vs +2). We will utilise both metals within common frameworks to enable the effect of unit charge variation to be studied to determine key structure activity relationships. This deep understanding will enable broad scope borylation of arene C-H bonds to be achieved. The aryl boronic ester products are among the most common synthetic building blocks used by academia and industry so this will ensure the high impact of our developed methods.
We will transfer our initial breakthroughs through to operationally simple processes that can be readily used by the broadest academic and industrial synthetic community. Throughout we will be supported by GSK and Dr Andrew Dominey (GSK Process Chemistry, Stevenage), who as a co-Investigator on this project will be essential to enable the development of a truly useful process. Regular meetings and placements at GSK will be carried out to ensure cohesive progression, technology transfer and imbedding of our new developed methods at GSK. Alongside this, the GSK placements offer a unique chance for real-world testing and benchmarking of our new developed methods. Placements at Stevenage will enable application of our new reaction to specific pharmaceutical targets.
The use of catalysis is essential in ensuring the sustainability of processes as this minimises the energy input requirements and amount of material needed for each transformation. Catalysis offers the single most applicable method to ensure a sustainable future for chemical synthesis and the use of Earth-abundant metals for catalysis greatly improves this prospect. The use of aluminium and zinc is also driven by their low-toxicity relative to many other catalysts used in direct borylation (e.g. Co, Ir based catalysts). Zinc and aluminium have high daily permitted exposure limits enabling their use late in pharmaceutical manufacturing without the need for exhaustive metal removal required when using precious metal catalysts.
This project will specifically target the borylation of arene C-H bonds. Arenes are commodity chemicals with great structural diversity, but they lack handles for further functionalisation. We will develop aluminium- and zinc catalysts capable of introducing a boronic functional handle to these substrates. Aluminium and zinc benefit from many similar properties including, size, substrate (arene) affinity, electronegativity and, to some extent, coordination preferences, but they differ based on their charge (valency) in compounds (+3 Vs +2). We will utilise both metals within common frameworks to enable the effect of unit charge variation to be studied to determine key structure activity relationships. This deep understanding will enable broad scope borylation of arene C-H bonds to be achieved. The aryl boronic ester products are among the most common synthetic building blocks used by academia and industry so this will ensure the high impact of our developed methods.
We will transfer our initial breakthroughs through to operationally simple processes that can be readily used by the broadest academic and industrial synthetic community. Throughout we will be supported by GSK and Dr Andrew Dominey (GSK Process Chemistry, Stevenage), who as a co-Investigator on this project will be essential to enable the development of a truly useful process. Regular meetings and placements at GSK will be carried out to ensure cohesive progression, technology transfer and imbedding of our new developed methods at GSK. Alongside this, the GSK placements offer a unique chance for real-world testing and benchmarking of our new developed methods. Placements at Stevenage will enable application of our new reaction to specific pharmaceutical targets.
Publications
Grundy ME
(2023)
Understanding and Expanding Zinc Cation/Amine Frustrated Lewis Pair Catalyzed C-H Borylation.
in ACS catalysis
Ingleson MJ
(2023)
Main Group Catalyzed Arene Borylation: Challenges and Opportunities.
in ACS catalysis
Kumar Bisai M
(2024)
Transition Metal-Free Catalytic C-H Zincation and Alumination
in Angewandte Chemie
Kumar Bisai M
(2024)
Transition Metal-Free Catalytic C-H Zincation and Alumination.
in Angewandte Chemie (International ed. in English)
| Description | To date we have made significant progress studying 3/4 of the key challenges, as outlined below. Challenge 1: a uni-molecular Zn/Al FLP catalyst that effects broad scope arene C-H metalation Milestone 1 and the overall key goal of this challenge, developing transition metal free processes that can convert C-H bonds directly into C-Al and C-Zn bonds (termed C-H metalation) has been met. We have developed multiple systems that use sub-stoichiometric amount of simple amines (i.e. cheap and easy to handle), such as triethylamine, to effect the direct C-H metalation of a range of heteroarenes (e.g. thiophenes, furans, indoles, pyrroles). This is an unprecedented conversion that generates useful organometallic nucleophiles direct from the parent heteroarene. In addition, we studied the mechanism in detail, experimentally and computationally. This enabled us to generate a set of guidelines that we believe will enable this fundamentally new approach to C-H metalation to be applied to a range of other main group metals and ligand systems. Challenge 2: a cationic metal hydride able to C-H metalate many (hetero)arenes. We have explored a number of systems that fall within this challenge, and to date none effect C-H metalation. This indicates that these electrophilic metal hydrides have insufficient basicity to deprotonate heteroarenes even when the heteroarene is coordinated to a metal centre (this also indicates weak activation of the heteroarene on forming a pi complex with the Al/Zn electrophiles studied to date). Given the other work packages are working well this approach has been deprioritised. Challenge 3: [Al]+/[Zn]+ that bind HB(OR)2 to generate highly electrophilic borenium species. Milestone 3 and the overall key goal of this challenge has been met. Specifically we developed highly electrophilic metal complexes that interact with the oxygen position of commercial boron reagents (e.g. catecholborane). This interaction makes the boron centre sufficiently reactive that it can interact with a range of heteroarenes. In the presence of a base this then effects C-H to C-B conversion while regenerating the starting electrophilic metal complex. This enabled the developed of a zinc catalysed C-H borylation process which has been optimised and published. |
| Exploitation Route | Given the success in the area of Challenge 1, we believe that the development of a fundamentally new way to convert C-H bonds directly into C-M (M = main group metal(loid)) will be used by multiple groups in academia. This methodology should be applicable to other metal and ligands, thereby it is a useful addition to the toolbox to synthesis C-M bonds. Aryl-zinc reagents are particularly ubiquitous due to their utility in the Negishi coupling reaction (and other transformations), therefore we also believe the developments from WP1 can be taken forward to provide routes to these reagents that will be attractive to the wider synthetic community (academia and industry). The latter is one of our key goals for the remainder of this grant. |
| Sectors | Chemicals Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology |
| URL | https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acscatal.2c05995 |
| Description | Collaboration with expert computational group |
| Organisation | University of St Andrews |
| Department | School of Chemistry St Andrews |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Worked with the team of Professor stuart Macgregor, we generated all the experimental work and some computational analysis to underpin detailed computational mechanistic analysis |
| Collaborator Contribution | Led the complex computational study, trained a co-worker at the Univesity of Edinburgh and gave significant intellectual input into the project which complemented the experimental studies. |
| Impact | One publication to date see: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acscatal.2c05995 |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Description | International Conference (France) |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | Milan Bisai spoke on results from this grant at an International Conference in France in July 2023 (Imeboron). Audience ca. 50 people, academics/PDRAs/PHd. students from around the globe. Significant discussion afterwards. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| Description | Presentation at International Conference |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | Milan Bisai presented results from his work funded by this grant at a conference in India (Main-group Molecules to Materials (MMM III) from 09th-11th December 2023 at IIT Hyderabad & University of Hyderabad). Sparked significant questions and discussions afterwards. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| Description | Presentation at Overseas University |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | Michael Ingleson presented work from this grant at a symposium at the University of Laval in Canada. Sparked questions and discussions afterwards. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |